Design Contest?
#52
Senior Member
My Feedback: (3)
Andrew, if Bruce enters we could set the due date for 2020...?
There once was a design / engineering contest, [I think it was held at MIT] where the teams of contestants were handed a grocery bag full of building materials and given a simple task for their machine to perform while being measured against time, distance, or even "sparring" against another team's machine. Inside the bag would be an electric motor, batteries, string, rubber bands, chopsticks, scrap wood, cardboard, glue, tape, empty spools, toy wheels, ping pong balls...etc. I haven't seen coverage of this event in many years, but it was very interesting to see some very clever contraptions built and then made to perform under pressure.
There once was a design / engineering contest, [I think it was held at MIT] where the teams of contestants were handed a grocery bag full of building materials and given a simple task for their machine to perform while being measured against time, distance, or even "sparring" against another team's machine. Inside the bag would be an electric motor, batteries, string, rubber bands, chopsticks, scrap wood, cardboard, glue, tape, empty spools, toy wheels, ping pong balls...etc. I haven't seen coverage of this event in many years, but it was very interesting to see some very clever contraptions built and then made to perform under pressure.
#53
My Feedback: (18)
Sorry, but; why to limit the contest to those engines? I've several own designs (and built) to show...
Besides; who flyies .049 or .15 today? everyone goes electrics!!!
I guess that the real challenge here is to find someone REALLY designing and building nowadays, besides of plane's power. Unfortunately, everyone buys and by just putting a battery on a plane they think they have the right to say "I built"!!!!
Just a thought, Kill me or love me... It's what I think.
Cheers
Besides; who flyies .049 or .15 today? everyone goes electrics!!!
I guess that the real challenge here is to find someone REALLY designing and building nowadays, besides of plane's power. Unfortunately, everyone buys and by just putting a battery on a plane they think they have the right to say "I built"!!!!
Just a thought, Kill me or love me... It's what I think.
Cheers
It takes a certain type of person to come on to a message board devoted to 1/2A & 1/8A glow powered aircraft and imply that no one flies them. Maybe no one flies them in Italy, but I assure you that 1/2A in particular and small glow planes in general are still plenty popular in the USA!
Personally I vote for a glow only contest. Isn't that what this message board is all about?
Let the electric guys do their own thing.
#54
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Chilliwack, BC, CANADA
Posts: 12,425
Likes: 0
Received 22 Likes
on
19 Posts
OK, I know I've lived up.... er.... down to that in the past. But still............ that's just looooooooowwwww......
It'll soon be summer and I know that a lot of folks will have summer things to do. So let's be fairly generous and put it to something like Oct 1?
And I've got a project in mind. It's a doodle that I did a few years back that I think needs to see the light of day. Chuck won't like it because it'll have more in common with a Lazy Bee than one of his screamin' snarlin' rockets....
#56
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Oakville,
ON, CANADA
Posts: 248
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hi All,
I'm in. For me, any due date, is just a reason to 'get it done'...
I've started by finding my nice pencils, and 'European' curves.
(French curves I have sanded the 'knicks' out of !)
Picking up fresh 1/4in. Graph pads and a nice big 'Gummy' erasor tommorrow...
Found my palm orbital sander, to make a CP 'UltiSonic' cleaner for 'the Cox.049s'...Need the right size jar...
This is going to be fun !
Blank paper and ideas, are very cool,
Then make it fly.
Cheers,
Dave'crosscheck'Fallowfield
And a good excuse to learn how to post photos here !
I'm in. For me, any due date, is just a reason to 'get it done'...
I've started by finding my nice pencils, and 'European' curves.
(French curves I have sanded the 'knicks' out of !)
Picking up fresh 1/4in. Graph pads and a nice big 'Gummy' erasor tommorrow...
Found my palm orbital sander, to make a CP 'UltiSonic' cleaner for 'the Cox.049s'...Need the right size jar...
This is going to be fun !
Blank paper and ideas, are very cool,
Then make it fly.
Cheers,
Dave'crosscheck'Fallowfield
And a good excuse to learn how to post photos here !
#58
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Oakville,
ON, CANADA
Posts: 248
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hi CP,
I allways build two wings. A left and right one !
I have two .25 coro WW1 Combat planes. (D-7 and an Albatross)
They will be 'going down' in combat before 2018. !
Stupidest combat ever ! But fun towing streamers!
People at 'scale ralleys', don't get combat...
My hands hurt. Sharpened axe/spade 5 times, getting the hopp garden thinned out... Ouch !
Wicked roots, last year there were 'Bonsai' hopps, it was so rootbound.
Cheers,
Dave'crosscheck'Fallowfield
I allways build two wings. A left and right one !
I have two .25 coro WW1 Combat planes. (D-7 and an Albatross)
They will be 'going down' in combat before 2018. !
Stupidest combat ever ! But fun towing streamers!
People at 'scale ralleys', don't get combat...
My hands hurt. Sharpened axe/spade 5 times, getting the hopp garden thinned out... Ouch !
Wicked roots, last year there were 'Bonsai' hopps, it was so rootbound.
Cheers,
Dave'crosscheck'Fallowfield
#59
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Chilliwack, BC, CANADA
Posts: 12,425
Likes: 0
Received 22 Likes
on
19 Posts
..... I'm sticking with rubber power for free flight from now on......
But like I said. The shop renos are done, I've hung up the racing leathers and I'm looking skyward.
#60
Senior Member
My Feedback: (3)
RC? That would be, I hate to admit, the rudder only model you saw me flying a few years ago. More recently though I finished up a long running 1/2A free flight power model last summer. It lasted a total of 12 seconds worth of air time over two flights.
..... I'm sticking with rubber power for free flight from now on......
.
..... I'm sticking with rubber power for free flight from now on......
.
Your mention of building a slow model for the contest got me to thinking......that it would be a real challenge to build a Wright Flyer complete with chain driven props off of a single petrol burning .049.
#61
Thread Starter
Guille-
It takes a certain type of person to come on to a message board devoted to 1/2A & 1/8A glow powered aircraft and imply that no one flies them. Maybe no one flies them in Italy, but I assure you that 1/2A in particular and small glow planes in general are still plenty popular in the USA!
Personally I vote for a glow only contest. Isn't that what this message board is all about?
Let the electric guys do their own thing.
It takes a certain type of person to come on to a message board devoted to 1/2A & 1/8A glow powered aircraft and imply that no one flies them. Maybe no one flies them in Italy, but I assure you that 1/2A in particular and small glow planes in general are still plenty popular in the USA!
Personally I vote for a glow only contest. Isn't that what this message board is all about?
Let the electric guys do their own thing.
Guille,
I'm sure you have some nice designs, but the contest is about creating a new design, not showing one you've already built.
So, let's break out the pencils, balsa and CA and get building.
#62
Thread Starter
Should I start a new thread with the rules on the first post that Bruce can sticky, or should we continue with this one? We could all link our build threads there and follow along. I'll get a new contest site set up soon and we can upload photos there as well.
#63
I have always hoped that another Design Contest would get underway. I still have my unfinished 2004 "Sky Terrier" entry; I can finish and fly it for the 2015 contest, right? This is the vacuum bagged carbon fiber model with plug in, hot wired polypropylene wings.
#68
Thread Starter
In the beginning there wasn't any voting mechanism on RC Universe and we wanted to keep all the contest entries together so they were easy to find and vote on. Try finding them on RCU now - not easy. Think of it this way. We're having a contest and using RCU to discuss it.
The ISP which hosted the original contest site went out of business and closed up one night and I didn't have access to the data anymore. Unfortunately I hadn't backed 2004 since early on in the contest that year, so most of that was lost. I'm trying to rebuild it from the Wayback Machine archives, but it's a fair bit of work.
Edit:
A lot of 2004 now restored.
I noticed that most of the pictures from 2006 are missing. I'm working on it.
Last edited by Bipe Flyer; 05-06-2015 at 10:27 PM.
#69
Thread Starter
OK, here is a link to the design contest rules thread.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/1-2-...ial-rules.html
Bruce, if you could sticky it, that would be great.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/1-2-...ial-rules.html
Bruce, if you could sticky it, that would be great.
#70
Thread Starter
Only if you finish it this time. lol
#71
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Chilliwack, BC, CANADA
Posts: 12,425
Likes: 0
Received 22 Likes
on
19 Posts
OK, here is a link to the design contest rules thread.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/1-2-...ial-rules.html
Bruce, if you could sticky it, that would be great.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/1-2-...ial-rules.html
Bruce, if you could sticky it, that would be great.
By all means put it on your site as well but I'd like to see a build thread for each entry. Links to each thread can be put into the stickied thread as a "one stop shopping" point.
This pretty much mimics what we had in the past anyway.
#73
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: MaranelloModena, ITALY
Posts: 646
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The forum is 1/2A andd1/8A planes. I don't think his statement was intended to be as much of a slight as it sounded and the truth is that there are a lot of electrics out there. The great thing is that the radio gear is so small and light now that 1/2A engines can really be put to good use. Lets all just show each other our design skills and go from there. There's a category for everyone and I'm planning on building an entry for more than one.
Guille,
I'm sure you have some nice designs, but the contest is about creating a new design, not showing one you've already built.
So, let's break out the pencils, balsa and CA and get building.
Guille,
I'm sure you have some nice designs, but the contest is about creating a new design, not showing one you've already built.
So, let's break out the pencils, balsa and CA and get building.
Actually I do fly what I built and I build what I design; namely: one F3A plane (5Kg, 2x2), one 1,5m-220g glider and its electric motorglider version and a sport aerobatic one.
I'm eager to show what I did / do for many reasons... and to promote my skills or my laser cutting machine is not one of those. I want to demostrate that today is still fun to build; to show that to fly something that you really built is twice satisfactory than putting a batt on a foamy (which I personally hate, no exception) and to show other modellers that today is easier for buiilding thhan it was 20 years ago.
I hope you all undertand that my cause is in pro of the "home built" airmodels; just tell: how many hours of TV are you sparing for a kid? How much a kid can learn by building an airplane? We all know the answer...
Cheers;
G.
#74
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: MaranelloModena, ITALY
Posts: 646
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The forum is 1/2A andd1/8A planes. I don't think his statement was intended to be as much of a slight as it sounded and the truth is that there are a lot of electrics out there. The great thing is that the radio gear is so small and light now that 1/2A engines can really be put to good use. Lets all just show each other our design skills and go from there. There's a category for everyone and I'm planning on building an entry for more than one.
Guille,
I'm sure you have some nice designs, but the contest is about creating a new design, not showing one you've already built.
So, let's break out the pencils, balsa and CA and get building.
Guille,
I'm sure you have some nice designs, but the contest is about creating a new design, not showing one you've already built.
So, let's break out the pencils, balsa and CA and get building.
Actually I do fly what I built and I build what I design; namely: one F3A plane (5Kg, 2x2), one 1,5m-220g glider and its electric motorglider version and a sport aerobatic one.
Check one: http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/rc-g...w-concept.html
I'm eager to show what I did / do for many reasons... and to promote my skills or my laser cutting machine is not one of those. I want to demostrate that today is still fun to build; to show that to fly something that you really built is twice satisfactory than putting a batt on a foamy (which I personally hate, no exception) and to show other modellers that today is easier for buiilding thhan it was 20 years ago.
I hope you all undertand that my cause is in pro of the "home built" airmodels; just tell: how many hours of TV are you sparing for a kid? How much a kid can learn by building an airplane? We all know the answer...
Cheers;
G.
#75
Thread Starter
I have no doubts that you're a skilled designer and builder. What I was trying to say was that you need to design something new for the contest, not just a link to a plane you've already designed and built In the past.