ACE foam wings
#1
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Orangeville, ON, CANADA
Posts: 8,658
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
ACE foam wings
Hi y'all,
I've measured up the one set of constant chord wings I have, or had, and also the root of the tapered wing panels in this kit here. I am trying to reproduce the ACE constant chord airfoil as closely as possible. I thought it was designed as a NACA 2415, but if you add 3/8x1 TE to it, which fits nicely and follows the contours nicely, it ends up working out a little thicker. Of course, foam is not a precision medium.. I understand this well. My main goal is to be able to draw a wing saddle that fits them in to a design or two you see. I did measure the pair I had that I used in the Squirt, but they were grossly different and I don't trust the info. I think the one I used was normal though.
My question and a favor to ask: does any of you have an ACE kit with a full size side view? And if so, what is the chance of you checking out the wing saddle, or even better scanning it? Or failing that scanning the root itself? I'd like to see what they draw in for the saddle profile, including TE stock etc. I have a Simple 400 that I finished about a month ago, but seems I chucked the plans, can't find them anywhere.
Thanks in advance if you can help! If not, then you can look at this photo and suffer envy. Or just look at it - my buddy made the fatal mistake today of reminding me he's been hoarding this for years. It's mine now, ha ha ha ha ha ha..... [>:]
Which engine do you think?
I'll tackle it later this season.
MJD
MJD
I've measured up the one set of constant chord wings I have, or had, and also the root of the tapered wing panels in this kit here. I am trying to reproduce the ACE constant chord airfoil as closely as possible. I thought it was designed as a NACA 2415, but if you add 3/8x1 TE to it, which fits nicely and follows the contours nicely, it ends up working out a little thicker. Of course, foam is not a precision medium.. I understand this well. My main goal is to be able to draw a wing saddle that fits them in to a design or two you see. I did measure the pair I had that I used in the Squirt, but they were grossly different and I don't trust the info. I think the one I used was normal though.
My question and a favor to ask: does any of you have an ACE kit with a full size side view? And if so, what is the chance of you checking out the wing saddle, or even better scanning it? Or failing that scanning the root itself? I'd like to see what they draw in for the saddle profile, including TE stock etc. I have a Simple 400 that I finished about a month ago, but seems I chucked the plans, can't find them anywhere.
Thanks in advance if you can help! If not, then you can look at this photo and suffer envy. Or just look at it - my buddy made the fatal mistake today of reminding me he's been hoarding this for years. It's mine now, ha ha ha ha ha ha..... [>:]
Which engine do you think?
I'll tackle it later this season.
MJD
MJD
#3
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Orangeville, ON, CANADA
Posts: 8,658
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: ACE foam wings
That's fine - I can interpolate the odd wobble with a french curve. I'll print it and measure up. I had one wonky panel, but the other data I've gathered to date is all in fairly close agreement.
The fundamental reason I am doing this is so that if I design something and someone else wants to build it, they will fit. In addition, if I was to do a built-up, I'd want it to fit saddles meant for the foam wing.
Please nobody make a career over this request, but a quick trace or scan helps me average out the data.
Thanks,
MJD
The fundamental reason I am doing this is so that if I design something and someone else wants to build it, they will fit. In addition, if I was to do a built-up, I'd want it to fit saddles meant for the foam wing.
Please nobody make a career over this request, but a quick trace or scan helps me average out the data.
Thanks,
MJD
#5
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Orangeville, ON, CANADA
Posts: 8,658
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: Silvaire
What are those two engines?
I can't quite tell, but perhaps an Anderson Spitfire and a VA Mk1 ???
It so, a SERIOUSLY apple/orange consideration...
What are those two engines?
I can't quite tell, but perhaps an Anderson Spitfire and a VA Mk1 ???
It so, a SERIOUSLY apple/orange consideration...
MJD
#8
RE: ACE foam wings
I have the ACE aifroil in Tile Print. I also have a plan that I drew up for a built up ACE wing.
I used it on my 1/2A Stik. http://donatelli.net/12astik/12AStikLdg.mpg
I used it on my 1/2A Stik. http://donatelli.net/12astik/12AStikLdg.mpg
#9
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Orangeville, ON, CANADA
Posts: 8,658
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: Bipe Flyer
I have the ACE aifroil in Tile Print. I also have a plan that I drew up for a built up ACE wing.
I used it on my 1/2A Stik. http://donatelli.net/12astik/12AStikLdg.mpg
I have the ACE aifroil in Tile Print. I also have a plan that I drew up for a built up ACE wing.
I used it on my 1/2A Stik. http://donatelli.net/12astik/12AStikLdg.mpg
MJD
#11
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Orangeville, ON, CANADA
Posts: 8,658
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: Bipe Flyer
The wing is in Turbocad. If you want a copy in Turbocad, DXF or high rez GIF, I'll upload it to my website and post a link.
The wing is in Turbocad. If you want a copy in Turbocad, DXF or high rez GIF, I'll upload it to my website and post a link.
Thanks BF.
MJD
#12
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: MJD
...with the possible exception of the only antique I have, an Atom .09...
MJD
...with the possible exception of the only antique I have, an Atom .09...
MJD
George
#13
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Orangeville, ON, CANADA
Posts: 8,658
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: gcb
Since that Spitfire was produced around 1950, I would consider it an antique too.
George
ORIGINAL: MJD
...with the possible exception of the only antique I have, an Atom .09...
MJD
...with the possible exception of the only antique I have, an Atom .09...
MJD
George
#14
My Feedback: (1)
RE: ACE foam wings
I would like to make a comment about the Ace wing. It does fly well but It has a bad tendancy to snap out inverted. I actually do not like this aspect but it is a lot of fun when you know how to use it. If I were designing a small plane\airfoil, I would either go symmetrical or less camber than the Ace airfoil to give better inverted flight. I have been out flying my simple ultimate all afternoon and it is a good example of this. It does not like to outside loop unless you keep the speed up and are gentle with the elevator. It was intetresting because I had just flown my Kaos and then the Ultimate. Big difference! The Kaos just has a better section I believe. At least for my tastes.
#15
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: vertical grimmace
I would like to make a comment about the Ace wing. It does fly well but It has a bad tendancy to snap out inverted. I actually do not like this aspect but it is a lot of fun when you know how to use it. If I were designing a small plane\airfoil, I would either go symmetrical or less camber than the Ace airfoil to give better inverted flight. I have been out flying my simple ultimate all afternoon and it is a good example of this. It does not like to outside loop unless you keep the speed up and are gentle with the elevator. It was intetresting because I had just flown my Kaos and then the Ultimate. Big difference! The Kaos just has a better section I believe. At least for my tastes.
I would like to make a comment about the Ace wing. It does fly well but It has a bad tendancy to snap out inverted. I actually do not like this aspect but it is a lot of fun when you know how to use it. If I were designing a small plane\airfoil, I would either go symmetrical or less camber than the Ace airfoil to give better inverted flight. I have been out flying my simple ultimate all afternoon and it is a good example of this. It does not like to outside loop unless you keep the speed up and are gentle with the elevator. It was intetresting because I had just flown my Kaos and then the Ultimate. Big difference! The Kaos just has a better section I believe. At least for my tastes.
Part of the reason for the ACE wings snapping out is because most or their planes are overweight. However, I don't use that wing for anything anymore. For really small stuff in the .010/.020 size I use a Clark-Y and for anything larger I use a fully symmetrical like an NACA 0013.
#16
My Feedback: (1)
RE: ACE foam wings
An NACA0013 would be a great airfoil on that little Ultimate. I guess the key aspect of a good design with a fully symmetrical airfoil is wing loading. It is imperative to keep them light and then they really come alive. The main bonus of the Ace wing though is how easy they are to build. They would certainly do a little better if they had a spar installed as well. they are just not stiff enough to be precise.
#17
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: vertical grimmace
An NACA0013 would be a great airfoil on that little Ultimate. I guess the key aspect of a good design with a fully symmetrical airfoil is wing loading. It is imperative to keep them light and then they really come alive. The main bonus of the Ace wing though is how easy they are to build. They would certainly do a little better if they had a spar installed as well. they are just not stiff enough to be precise.
An NACA0013 would be a great airfoil on that little Ultimate. I guess the key aspect of a good design with a fully symmetrical airfoil is wing loading. It is imperative to keep them light and then they really come alive. The main bonus of the Ace wing though is how easy they are to build. They would certainly do a little better if they had a spar installed as well. they are just not stiff enough to be precise.
I build foam wings for almost all of my models. They key is to not expect the foam to do any thing but hold the airfoil shape. The ACE foam is way to heavy IMO. I use the lightest foam possible and sheet it with carefully selected balsa - no spars, no LE, just the sheeting and a TE.
#18
RE: ACE foam wings
Here's a link to the wing plan in DXF, DWG and TCW format. I also included the airfoil in DAT format for those who have a foam cutter.
It should be fairly close, I traced it from the ACE Simple Ultimate plans.
http://www.donatelli.net/downloads/B...p-ACE-wing.zip
It should be fairly close, I traced it from the ACE Simple Ultimate plans.
http://www.donatelli.net/downloads/B...p-ACE-wing.zip
#19
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: cpc625
This is from the Whizard plan.
Charlie
This is from the Whizard plan.
Charlie
It sure brought back memories, although I was surprised how tame this model is.
The model uses a built-up wing and is covered with laminating film.
The NACA 3315 airfoil is the closest I could find to the one shown on the Whizard plan.
The attached picture is of rib template I used (Planking is 1/16").
#20
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Orangeville, ON, CANADA
Posts: 8,658
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: ACE foam wings
Thanks to all! I think I have more data than I can digest now - not that I am complaining .
I have the mid '60's RCMs with the press releases and a write up in my collection, I need to find them. But I do recall the mention of Owen Kampen's use of the 2415, and I suspect any differences between a computer plot and the real thing are production tolerance related.
Thanks again.. MJD
I have the mid '60's RCMs with the press releases and a write up in my collection, I need to find them. But I do recall the mention of Owen Kampen's use of the 2415, and I suspect any differences between a computer plot and the real thing are production tolerance related.
Thanks again.. MJD
#21
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Orangeville, ON, CANADA
Posts: 8,658
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: ACE foam wings
ORIGINAL: vertical grimmace
An NACA0013 would be a great airfoil on that little Ultimate. I guess the key aspect of a good design with a fully symmetrical airfoil is wing loading. It is imperative to keep them light and then they really come alive. The main bonus of the Ace wing though is how easy they are to build. They would certainly do a little better if they had a spar installed as well. they are just not stiff enough to be precise.
An NACA0013 would be a great airfoil on that little Ultimate. I guess the key aspect of a good design with a fully symmetrical airfoil is wing loading. It is imperative to keep them light and then they really come alive. The main bonus of the Ace wing though is how easy they are to build. They would certainly do a little better if they had a spar installed as well. they are just not stiff enough to be precise.
But yeah, they are not the lightest option by any means, only convenient. But they work for knock-about sport models. Nor is the 2415 maybe the best airfoil for small models either, too thick IMHO.
Vertical Bearded Grin - here's an overlay of the 2415 and 1415 for giggles. Not much saddle filler needed to adapt.
MJD