Receiver quandary
Any experiences to share with the Spektrum AR6115e receivers? I need a compact end pin receiver for a 1/2A, and this seems my only choice from Spektrum.
Bad idea? Okay? This is for the Blink in the other thread. There is rather limited radio gear space. Previously I used 72mHz on a Berg 4L Rx, with the antenna routed internally around the perimeter of the airframe. I would much prefer to go 2.4 this time around. |
I flew one in a flat foamie for quite some time with no problems at all - until I "parked" the foamie in the top of an 80' tall tree.. it took a thunderstorm to knock the plane out of the tree. Even after a couple of days up in the tree, the ESC, servos, and RX are still working fine. I managed to see the plane just after it came out of the tree, so it didn't get too much rain on it.
Too bad you don't have room for the little AR400 - I loaned mine to a buddy for his "fun fighter" electric corsair and he's having great luck with it, too. |
Have you seen the Orange receivers from HK. The are end pin, and quite cheap. I got a few that I will try soon, and they get smaller and lighter if the case is removed. $6.
|
Mike -
You might want to look into the Lemon RX. I've been using the Orange RX from Hobbyking, but the Lemon RX is a different offering and produced by another manufacturing unit. There is a 100 page thread in RCG about this receiver and it is one of the most complimentary threads I've read. Good performance, good customer support. Pricing is 5 RXs for $26 USD (or 1 for $5.75) and the performance is on par or better than the Spectrum brand RX. These are available in several configurations - end pin, vertical pin, no pin. Lemon thread Lemon On-line Store |
Cool - thanks all.
Update - very interesting thread! For the price I took the risk and ordered some, plus a 3-pack of 40A speed controllers. If they work reliably with a 33k rpm glow engine buzzing the crap out of an 8oz Blink delta, then I'll give them my blessing FWIW. |
I use lemonRX and orange rx from HK. I would never spend that kinda money on REAL spektrum stuff.
|
For a while I thought a $39.95 receiver was a bargain.
|
Originally Posted by MJD
(Post 11619253)
If they work reliably with a 33k rpm glow engine buzzing the crap out of an 8oz Blink delta, then I'll give them my blessing FWIW. |
It can probably handle about 1/8" of padding at best. Very tight in there! We'll see once I get those receivers.
|
I have flown a few of the orange receivers in foamys but wouldn't fly one in anything I had more than an hour of my time in building or more than $50 invested in.. Not worth it..
|
Reports are pretty positive on these Lemon Rx. Unless it's a case of bargain fever.
But really, Is it so difficult choose brand names that actually appeal to Westerners? Or at least won't end up at the wrong end of a smart comment? :) |
Originally Posted by MJD
(Post 11619732)
But really, Is it so difficult choose brand names that actually appeal to Westerners? Or at least won't end up at the wrong end of a smart comment? :)
|
Originally Posted by 2walla
(Post 11619670)
I have flown a few of the orange receivers in foamys but wouldn't fly one in anything I had more than an hour of my time in building or more than $50 invested in.. Not worth it..
|
Almost all receivers, motors and radios are made in Asia. The bigger names support them better. Mostly the same components are used. If you want support, go with a brand name, If you buy two extra and it still costs less than the big names, that is you choice. (mine usually) I would be wary of using the Oraange or Lemon receivers on anything over a .40, just because of the size, not the manufacturer. Maybe that is just me though.
|
Originally Posted by forsakenrider
(Post 11619939)
Why do you say that? have you have issues with them? I've had more issues with name-brand spektrum then I have with the others. .......
That being said, the RCG thread on the Lemon brand seems to indicate that the Lemon is being fabricated to higher QC standards and that the company is very responsive to customer needs and requests --- something that Orange is not. Based on human nature, if the Lemon were sub-par, there would be a lot of folks griping about it. The Lemon site has a short video on the manufacturing process involved --- for those interested, it's a good view. |
This pricing more accurately reflects the relative cost of production without the cost of Western-oriented fancy retail packaging, import, warehousing, distributor/retailer margins, marketing, bla bla..
There is natural skepticism when products we are familiar with are sold for what we perceive as bargain basement prices, but there is no reason it could not be good quality despite the sticker price. If it works as people say, then that is about all there is to it. I'll find out soon enough I guess! |
Originally Posted by MJD
(Post 11620088)
This pricing more accurately reflects the relative cost of production without the cost of Western-oriented fancy retail packaging, import, warehousing, distributor/retailer margins, marketing, bla bla..
! |
So far according to the thread linked above, they have scored well in the development and product support category, looks like they've turned around new configurations in short order based on direct input from consumers. I might not like the stuff once I get it.. but at the moment I am optimistic that I will be satisfied with the value.
Tossing out a defective $6 receiver costs me less money and aggravation than trying to get a replacement for a $40 receiver purchased locally. It is an hour drive to any LHS from here, and generally they say to send it to the manufacturer anyway. One of the perks of warranty coverage (and promotional deals) for the manufacturer is the relatively low percentage of redemption. I have had more problems with receivers marketed by North American distributors/retailers than anything else anyhow - FMA M5, Berg 4L are particular examples, each one has cost me a model while other examples are fine. No trouble with any Spektrum stuff so far, knock on wood. |
Originally Posted by MJD
(Post 11619188)
Any experiences to share with the Spektrum AR6115e receivers? I need a compact end pin receiver for a 1/2A, and this seems my only choice from Spektrum.
Bad idea? Okay? This is for the Blink in the other thread. There is rather limited radio gear space. Previously I used 72mHz on a Berg 4L Rx, with the antenna routed internally around the perimeter of the airframe. I would much prefer to go 2.4 this time around. Hogflyer |
And I regularly fly parkies with park flier receivers out to vision limits. I'm sure I am comfortable with the range even if the aircraft needs a little bigger park than most. I think what worries me is the harsh environment. I would think physical construction and component durability would be similar.
So what is it that makes this "designed for park flyers" only, is it strictly range or other characteristics? I'm not sure I really know, considering the cost associated to likes of the Lemon RX and other mail order imports. Are we saving a few grams in payment for range? I guess so. |
I just got my paws on a AR400 4-ch full range receiver. It's physically smaller than the AR6115e, the pins are vertical, not end pins like the AR6115e. I know guys flying them in Quickie's and sport planes say they have been as reliable as the AR600. Price through Hobby Town where the one I have came from is $29.99.
Hogflyer |
Originally Posted by hogflyer
(Post 11621504)
I just got my paws on a AR400 4-ch full range receiver. It's physically smaller than the AR6115e, the pins are vertical, not end pins like the AR6115e. I know guys flying them in Quickie's and sport planes say they have been as reliable as the AR600. Price through Hobby Town where the one I have came from is $29.99.
Hogflyer |
Have your receivers come in yet? I ordered a 5 pack some time after your's were ordered, but have not gotten them in.
|
Nothing yet..
|
Mine took 22 days. Got them in July from HK with an AP .15, a couple LiFe batteries and a step up voltage regulator. First purchase from them, I was worried with all the bad publicity it gets, but I thought 3 weeks was goodish.
|
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:57 AM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.