Lead acid vs ni-cd's
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: , UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 319
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Lead acid vs ni-cd's
Can i ask what would be the best option for my boat
im new to electrics... err and boats!
i want to power a boat but im not after a speed boat
im not even sure on motor sizes yet(but thats probably a different post!)probably a 400 -500 size
im after a good run time rather than breaking the water speed record and wondered what options i have for batterys
i was looking at a 6 cell 7.2 pack either ni-cd or ni-mh but not sure on the difference between the 2
then someone suggested lead acid as its a boat(fairly large 25-30" long)
ive seen some lead acid 6v batterys but what difference does the amps make?
i.e a 6v 1.3 amp lasts lets say 1 hr ish
would a 6v 7amp last 5hrs ish
or doesnt it work like that?
many thanks for any advice
Graham
im new to electrics... err and boats!
i want to power a boat but im not after a speed boat
im not even sure on motor sizes yet(but thats probably a different post!)probably a 400 -500 size
im after a good run time rather than breaking the water speed record and wondered what options i have for batterys
i was looking at a 6 cell 7.2 pack either ni-cd or ni-mh but not sure on the difference between the 2
then someone suggested lead acid as its a boat(fairly large 25-30" long)
ive seen some lead acid 6v batterys but what difference does the amps make?
i.e a 6v 1.3 amp lasts lets say 1 hr ish
would a 6v 7amp last 5hrs ish
or doesnt it work like that?
many thanks for any advice
Graham
#2
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Bastrop,
TX
Posts: 20
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Lead acid vs ni-cd's
what difference does the amps make?
i.e a 6v 1.3 amp lasts lets say 1 hr ish
would a 6v 7amp last 5hrs ish
or doesnt it work like that?
Yes, the more amp hours a battery has, the longer it will last. A 7 amp battery should keep it running for a long time. As to whether a lead acid battery is appropriate for a boat, I have no idea as I have no experience with boats.
i.e a 6v 1.3 amp lasts lets say 1 hr ish
would a 6v 7amp last 5hrs ish
or doesnt it work like that?
Yes, the more amp hours a battery has, the longer it will last. A 7 amp battery should keep it running for a long time. As to whether a lead acid battery is appropriate for a boat, I have no idea as I have no experience with boats.
#3
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: antipolo, PHILIPPINES
Posts: 523
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Lead acid vs ni-cd's
lead acid usually provide plenty of run time. like you said, more ah = more runtime. the only downside is that its a bit heavy. but if its a scale boat, it should be ok. also there is a big difference as sealed lead acid are mostly 6v and nicd or nimh packs are mostly 7.2v.
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: London, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 658
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Lead acid vs ni-cd's
A lead acid battery that is 7ah will last one hour if 7 amps are used. Or 2 hours if 3.5 amps are needed.
Lead acid batterys are not capable of outputting a lot of power - eg the one I have infront of me is 68 Watts. This means that the maximum output it can give is 68 Watts. To calculate Watts, you need voltage * Current. As the voltage is 12V, the current is 5.6A.
This means my Lead acid battery can give out 5.6Amps max.
Ni-cads have MUCH shorter run times - eg a 1700mah (milliamps) will last only 14 mins (i think) with a 7 amp current draw. But, Ni-cads can give out huge amounts of current - over 20 Amps, so this is good in a speed boat. Lead acid batterys are heavy and slow, but good for scale boats.
Lead acid batterys are not capable of outputting a lot of power - eg the one I have infront of me is 68 Watts. This means that the maximum output it can give is 68 Watts. To calculate Watts, you need voltage * Current. As the voltage is 12V, the current is 5.6A.
This means my Lead acid battery can give out 5.6Amps max.
Ni-cads have MUCH shorter run times - eg a 1700mah (milliamps) will last only 14 mins (i think) with a 7 amp current draw. But, Ni-cads can give out huge amounts of current - over 20 Amps, so this is good in a speed boat. Lead acid batterys are heavy and slow, but good for scale boats.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Fresno, CA
Posts: 1,180
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Lead acid vs ni-cd's
Lead acid and NiCd batteries also differ in how they discharge over time. The voltage of a lead acid battery decreases linearly over time, while a NiCd will retain a fairly high, constant voltage then drop rapidly at the end of the discharge cycle.