View Poll Results: A poll
Voters: 73. You may not vote on this poll
Bridi XLT vs Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
#1
Bridi XLT vs Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
Hello all!
I am interrested in some history here.
I am asking for anyone with intimate knowledge (this doesn't mean you need have flown them, but at least competed against or viewed in competition settings) of either aircraft to share their insight, experience, and opinions on any facet of these airplanes. Of particular interrests to me are experiences in competition, opinions on design, and opinions in set up. How did these airplanes stack up to others in their day? But anything is welcome.
Please share any photographs, anything related would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Brian Lundberg
p.s.
I have read on RCU that Bill Cunningham was going to give all the mods for the Escape he could remember giving to Joe Bridi, but I don't think that ever transpired. If so, I'd like to find them...
I am interrested in some history here.
I am asking for anyone with intimate knowledge (this doesn't mean you need have flown them, but at least competed against or viewed in competition settings) of either aircraft to share their insight, experience, and opinions on any facet of these airplanes. Of particular interrests to me are experiences in competition, opinions on design, and opinions in set up. How did these airplanes stack up to others in their day? But anything is welcome.
Please share any photographs, anything related would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Brian Lundberg
p.s.
I have read on RCU that Bill Cunningham was going to give all the mods for the Escape he could remember giving to Joe Bridi, but I don't think that ever transpired. If so, I'd like to find them...
#2
Senior Member
My Feedback: (24)
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Endicott,
NY
Posts: 782
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
I flew an Escape in competition in 1988 or 89. It wasn't planned but in short order I lost my Avanti (shot down) and Joker (dumb thumbs) and felt this was the quickest way to get another model ready and I was also short on funds to go out and get a new glass/foam kit. The top models of the time were the Aurora, Atlanta, LA-1, Summit, etc...yet where I flew in the Southeast there were still some incredible fliers (older guys) winning contests in Expert and Masters with Arrows and Tipos! Keep in mind these were the days when the only "turnaround" style sequence was FAI so every other class could fly out and build up a head of steam for the one centered manuever each pass.
Anyway, in short I loved the way the Escape flew. I substitued 1/16" contest balsa for the wing skins, I think the kit had 3/32" heavy balsa, and made a few tweaks I had read about in the NSRCA newsletter but nothing major. Finished mine with glass cloth and K&B paint and used an OS RF pumped 61 & Hatori pipe; was also a taildragger with MK retracts. I was only flying Sportsman (would be Intermediate today as back then there was a Novice class) and didn't feel the airplane had any bad traits. I flew pattern because I enjoyed the competition, liked the models flown at the time, and enjoyed hanging out with a good group of people but I was only going to be a mid-pack finisher regardless of which airplane I flew. I dont feel the Escape was a hindrance in the lower few classes, and probably good through Expert but I think I only saw 1 other flown in competition. They were past their prime already and had no 'pizzaz' points; lets face it, compared to an Aurora it was pretty dorky looking. Certainly did fly well though.
Anyway, in short I loved the way the Escape flew. I substitued 1/16" contest balsa for the wing skins, I think the kit had 3/32" heavy balsa, and made a few tweaks I had read about in the NSRCA newsletter but nothing major. Finished mine with glass cloth and K&B paint and used an OS RF pumped 61 & Hatori pipe; was also a taildragger with MK retracts. I was only flying Sportsman (would be Intermediate today as back then there was a Novice class) and didn't feel the airplane had any bad traits. I flew pattern because I enjoyed the competition, liked the models flown at the time, and enjoyed hanging out with a good group of people but I was only going to be a mid-pack finisher regardless of which airplane I flew. I dont feel the Escape was a hindrance in the lower few classes, and probably good through Expert but I think I only saw 1 other flown in competition. They were past their prime already and had no 'pizzaz' points; lets face it, compared to an Aurora it was pretty dorky looking. Certainly did fly well though.
#3
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
The top models of the time were the Aurora, Atlanta, LA-1, Summit, etc...
was also a taildragger with MK retracts.
Anyway, in short I loved the way the Escape flew....and didn't feel the airplane had any bad traits.
...compared to an Aurora, it was pretty dorky looking. Certainly did fly well though.
s. wallace, I appreciate your post and hope to hear more follow up posts as well. Thank you sir. This does help and it is exactly what I'm looking for.
Brian
#4
My Feedback: (69)
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
I had a Dirty Birdy in the late 70's I built from a kit. Then went on to a Typo and finally a Phoenix 8. The P8 was the best flying once it was trimmed out. The Typo was a very close second. Both used Super Tiger for power. A little less power, but they lasted alot longer between rebuilds. Not to mention a very stable needle valve setting. Never did build an Escape though.
Dave
Dave
#7
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
ORIGINAL: roadtripessentials
The Great Escape was designed for the .90 class four strokes. The fuse was 5 1/2 '' longer aft of the wing saddle.
I think all other dimensions were the same.
Tony
The Great Escape was designed for the .90 class four strokes. The fuse was 5 1/2 '' longer aft of the wing saddle.
I think all other dimensions were the same.
Tony
I was thinking- a Bridi Great Escape with a new YS 115... Wow!
I'm almost finished with a Great Escape will be rossi powered
Thanks for the replies. Keep 'em coming!!!!
Brian
#8
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
ORIGINAL: roadtripessentials
The Great Escape was designed for the .90 class four strokes. The fuse was 5 1/2 '' longer aft of the wing saddle.
I think all other dimensions were the same.
Tony
The Great Escape was designed for the .90 class four strokes. The fuse was 5 1/2 '' longer aft of the wing saddle.
I think all other dimensions were the same.
Tony
Brian
#10
My Feedback: (3)
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Montreal,
QC, CANADA
Posts: 5,200
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
Brian,
there's a thread discussing the various changes that were made to produce the Great Escape. David Wood was involved in the drafting of those changes based on the designers input. I believe it involved more that just a stretch of the fuse. Spinner size was changed, vertical tail section was quite different. The fuse overall required different parts to produce it - it couldn't be built from an Escape kit alone.
I'll see when I can get to those core templates.
David.
there's a thread discussing the various changes that were made to produce the Great Escape. David Wood was involved in the drafting of those changes based on the designers input. I believe it involved more that just a stretch of the fuse. Spinner size was changed, vertical tail section was quite different. The fuse overall required different parts to produce it - it couldn't be built from an Escape kit alone.
I'll see when I can get to those core templates.
David.
#11
Senior Member
My Feedback: (24)
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Endicott,
NY
Posts: 782
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
ORIGINAL: Ilikebipes
This being the case, the Escape was relatively new in 1988, was it not? I get the impression you felt it may not have been very competitive with these aircraft? Or was it just cosmetics?
The top models of the time were the Aurora, Atlanta, LA-1, Summit, etc...
Remember in the late 80's we had MK and Yoshioka balsa kits and glass/foam Atlanta's, PA-2 (Aurora clone), Summit, Cursor, LA-1, Mistress, Conquest, Avanti, Brushfire, Tipo's, litterally dozens of good choices and very few guys flew a design more than a year or so old. Airplanes came and went fairly quickly as the 'in' thing. Everyone on this forum loves the Atlanta (and it does look great), but as far as I saw (speaking strictly the Southeast) they were popular among the top guys for a very short timeframe before they were on to something else.
Would an Escape fly the higher classes? Sure, I had a friend (former Masters flier) fly my Escape several times and he said it handled well enough to fly the manuevers well, but being 'draggier' had to work harder on some of the taller manuevers. I think it was a very forgiving design and ideally suited for a low time pattern flier of the day...guys with more experience just naturally seemed to want the prettier designs.
I never built a Great Escape, but I do very much recall Joe Bridi displaying them as 'new' at the Byron Expo in 1988. The Great Escape as I remember included the mods Bill Cunningham made to the Escape back when he did so well at the Nats with his. It stuck with me all these years that Joe came all the way to Iowa to display his line of kits at a giant scale event, but this also tells me the Escape had to be from the early 80s.
Scott
#12
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
David,
It is very kind of you to draw up templates for me. I appreciate it a lot. I cannot build another aircraft for a while, as I am deep into my Super Kaos build at the moment, and need to finish off my "Ultra Sport-rare." So I am not in a rush for the templates. However, I know nothing about these last designs of Bridi except the minimal information I have read in other threads and what we are discussing here.
Just info gathering for now...
I am curious as to what people were powering their escapes and great escapes with. It seems with typical pattern power of the time. The Rossi would be nice.
It also seems as though Joe stuck with his thick stab idea to the end. Did this hurt his designs in the end?
Brian
It is very kind of you to draw up templates for me. I appreciate it a lot. I cannot build another aircraft for a while, as I am deep into my Super Kaos build at the moment, and need to finish off my "Ultra Sport-rare." So I am not in a rush for the templates. However, I know nothing about these last designs of Bridi except the minimal information I have read in other threads and what we are discussing here.
Just info gathering for now...
I am curious as to what people were powering their escapes and great escapes with. It seems with typical pattern power of the time. The Rossi would be nice.
It also seems as though Joe stuck with his thick stab idea to the end. Did this hurt his designs in the end?
Brian
#15
My Feedback: (2)
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: China Spring,
TX
Posts: 138
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
I had an Escape in the late 1980's. I participated in pattern in the Texas/Oklahoma area and had several conversations with Bill Cunningham regarding the evolution of the Escape. As I recall, the foundation for theEscape was the XLT. It was shortened and made slightly smaller. I remember modifying an XLT to Bill's early specs, but it was still a large and heavy plane even with Rossi power.The Escape Ihadas I recall was built withBill's updated mods and was paintedwith automotive lacquer and clear coated with enamel. I used a YS 60RE for power after experimenting with an OPS earlier, in fact in Bill's contest in Oklahoma with mixed results, hence the YS was installed. I had some success inFAI with it. If I can find a picture, I will post.
Prior to the XLT/Escape I competed with the MK Arrow with both OS and Rossi for power. Very fast and effective in ballistic patternthrough Masters. The XLT and Escape were slower and fit the FAI turnaround pattern of that era. MK Jokers came after the Escape. Good luck with your Escape.
Energyman
Prior to the XLT/Escape I competed with the MK Arrow with both OS and Rossi for power. Very fast and effective in ballistic patternthrough Masters. The XLT and Escape were slower and fit the FAI turnaround pattern of that era. MK Jokers came after the Escape. Good luck with your Escape.
Energyman
#16
Member
My Feedback: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Orangevale,
CA
Posts: 79
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
the great escape plan shows a date of december 1990.
incidentely if you have a copy of the escape plan it will give you the date.
according to Joe Bridi the plan number is the month and year it was drawn, hence the great esape plan is #1290.
the great escape is more of a mid wing and i believe the escape was lower. plus the fuselage was longer as has been noted by others.
Dave.
#17
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
energyman,
What is you opinion of the Escape against the competition of the time when you were using it? You said it was slower... Was this a good thing?
klhoard's Bluejay XLT build thread shows the use of carbon fiber composites in his construction. Using that and being judicious with the wood, I'm guessing the weight issue could be rectified a lot easier today?
Anyone with experience at the sticks of a Great Escape, especially in the early 90's until the end of the world as you knew it?
Brian
What is you opinion of the Escape against the competition of the time when you were using it? You said it was slower... Was this a good thing?
klhoard's Bluejay XLT build thread shows the use of carbon fiber composites in his construction. Using that and being judicious with the wood, I'm guessing the weight issue could be rectified a lot easier today?
Anyone with experience at the sticks of a Great Escape, especially in the early 90's until the end of the world as you knew it?
Brian
#18
My Feedback: (121)
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
The last iteration of the Escape was a design called the Malibu by Bill Cunningham. I believe he used the Great Escape wing and stab (possibly modified) on a fuselage which looked very similar to a Dash-5 (inverted engine). The Malibu evolved into the very popular 4-stroke (120) version which was kitted in glass and foam. I'd love to hear from Bill about the 2-stroke 60 version of the Malibu.
#19
My Feedback: (11)
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: San Leandro CA
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
Checkout this old RCU thread where Bill Cunningham discussed with rainedave his Escape mods.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_82...tm.htm#8251286
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_82...tm.htm#8251286
#20
My Feedback: (34)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Tomball,
TX
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
I am still flying the attached Bridi Escape with a YS91FZ, and it is a real hoot. Dave Brown retracts from a grass field at Space City RC hold up well and the plane really grooves and is fast. Bought the plane about 8 years ago and it is still my favorite.
#21
My Feedback: (30)
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Lakeland,
FL
Posts: 158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
Just about done with my Bridi Great Escape. Will power it with a period correct MVVS .77 on a pipe and Sonic Systems retracts. Currently glassed and primed. Pic from before glassing is in my profile.
#22
RE: Bridi Escape vs Bridi Great Escape
ORIGINAL: funnflyerr
Checkout this old RCU thread where Bill Cunningham discussed with rainedave his Escape mods.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_82...tm.htm#8251286
Checkout this old RCU thread where Bill Cunningham discussed with rainedave his Escape mods.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_82...tm.htm#8251286
Jackpot!
Thanks for the pic sunfly3!!!
I am very much looking forward to all the new build pictures!
Brian