Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (13)
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Merced, Ca.,
CA
Posts: 2,118
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
YELLOW JACKET II & CEARMARK SWITCHES
Well, the shop renovation is complete, and its panic time. Our club races usually start in April, so I thought I had lots of time to develop something for the local go fasters and the Brothers "Buddude 8". Have been working on a idea like crazy for the past two weeks, and survived throu the maden flight with lots of scary stuff poping up. Honest, will post some pics in the coming days, but for now, must stay on the building board and get everything going correctly.
Ok, emagine a Q-500 Viper wing cut down to 45" and mated to a streemlined formula airframe. For power, we stick a Jett 60LX in the thing with black pipe, all new servos, switch and Berg receiver weighing in at 3.2lbs dry. Looks scary just sitting there.
Off to the field we go. Fuel up, check battery, range check good, crank her up. Ok tack the thing, yea, 19,850 with a apc 8.8 X 8.75. Wheeeee. Get directly behind my helper and let it go wfo. Well, no big run to the left, comes off nice and gently and starts to disappear rather quickly. Turn, come back and trim at 1/2 throttle. Ok, lets wfo and see what goes. Good, no trim change needed. Lets run a few turns around the pylons. Wow, that turn was more than asked for. At least the wing did not fold. Come off the power back to 1/2 which in reality is more like 80% with these engines. Wow, the thing moves, but does not feel right. Come back here, she finally turnds back when a speck way out there. Then its off to one side and then another, obvious problems, cut throttle, the thing stays at 80% for a few seconds and finally drops to idle. I am thinking, well that little light Berg receiver is just not so tough and full range as they claim. Now its try to get back to the field and the engine quit without command. She glides left, she glides right, but at least its not wfo and there is up elevator in it. As it nears the landing area, were back to weaving left and right without input. I get back a little control every few seconds and somehow keep the nose up as she drops into a adjacent affalfa field. Shi-Poo, must be toast. We go after the thing, supprise, supprise, wing and wheels still on, no major damage, just dirt, good old soft dirt.
Ok, I condemned the receiver during the flight because of the off and on control situation. Back in the cave (shop), I clean things up, yank the receiver and replace with a JR 700. After revising the pushrod congrol horn (darting), we start testing, or try to. Darn JR receiver not working. New battery, still not working. Wire around the switch, everything starts humming along with the typical digital servo dance. Ok, Burg, you were unfairly given the boot, but the trust factor is gone so its relagated to the rcx foamy.
NEW CERMARK SWITCH WITH OUTSIDE CHARG JACK
I have tried to make this creature user friendly, give up a little drag and keep the switch and jack on the outside for battery check convenience etc. It went away on its first flight and aged me 10 years in 10 seconds whiched seemed like foreaver at the time. DOES ANYONE OUT THERE KNOW OF A NEAR BOMB PROOF SWITCH? I would sure appreciate a word from you guys in this regard. ENJOY guys and will get back to you with some pics in the near future, promise. THANKS
Well, the shop renovation is complete, and its panic time. Our club races usually start in April, so I thought I had lots of time to develop something for the local go fasters and the Brothers "Buddude 8". Have been working on a idea like crazy for the past two weeks, and survived throu the maden flight with lots of scary stuff poping up. Honest, will post some pics in the coming days, but for now, must stay on the building board and get everything going correctly.
Ok, emagine a Q-500 Viper wing cut down to 45" and mated to a streemlined formula airframe. For power, we stick a Jett 60LX in the thing with black pipe, all new servos, switch and Berg receiver weighing in at 3.2lbs dry. Looks scary just sitting there.
Off to the field we go. Fuel up, check battery, range check good, crank her up. Ok tack the thing, yea, 19,850 with a apc 8.8 X 8.75. Wheeeee. Get directly behind my helper and let it go wfo. Well, no big run to the left, comes off nice and gently and starts to disappear rather quickly. Turn, come back and trim at 1/2 throttle. Ok, lets wfo and see what goes. Good, no trim change needed. Lets run a few turns around the pylons. Wow, that turn was more than asked for. At least the wing did not fold. Come off the power back to 1/2 which in reality is more like 80% with these engines. Wow, the thing moves, but does not feel right. Come back here, she finally turnds back when a speck way out there. Then its off to one side and then another, obvious problems, cut throttle, the thing stays at 80% for a few seconds and finally drops to idle. I am thinking, well that little light Berg receiver is just not so tough and full range as they claim. Now its try to get back to the field and the engine quit without command. She glides left, she glides right, but at least its not wfo and there is up elevator in it. As it nears the landing area, were back to weaving left and right without input. I get back a little control every few seconds and somehow keep the nose up as she drops into a adjacent affalfa field. Shi-Poo, must be toast. We go after the thing, supprise, supprise, wing and wheels still on, no major damage, just dirt, good old soft dirt.
Ok, I condemned the receiver during the flight because of the off and on control situation. Back in the cave (shop), I clean things up, yank the receiver and replace with a JR 700. After revising the pushrod congrol horn (darting), we start testing, or try to. Darn JR receiver not working. New battery, still not working. Wire around the switch, everything starts humming along with the typical digital servo dance. Ok, Burg, you were unfairly given the boot, but the trust factor is gone so its relagated to the rcx foamy.
NEW CERMARK SWITCH WITH OUTSIDE CHARG JACK
I have tried to make this creature user friendly, give up a little drag and keep the switch and jack on the outside for battery check convenience etc. It went away on its first flight and aged me 10 years in 10 seconds whiched seemed like foreaver at the time. DOES ANYONE OUT THERE KNOW OF A NEAR BOMB PROOF SWITCH? I would sure appreciate a word from you guys in this regard. ENJOY guys and will get back to you with some pics in the near future, promise. THANKS
#2
Senior Member
My Feedback: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Mather, CA
Posts: 2,222
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
I dont know about bomb proof but, I use the MPI (Maxx Products) charge switches with on-board battery checker. Have 4 of them, no problems. Selectable 4 or 5 cell reading.
I mount them flush by cutting through the mouting surface a hole the same size as the switches out side mounting flange shape (the flange is about 1/16 thick) and glue a thin ply frame on the in-side of the fuselage to screw it to. A bit pricy at $25!
I mount them flush by cutting through the mouting surface a hole the same size as the switches out side mounting flange shape (the flange is about 1/16 thick) and glue a thin ply frame on the in-side of the fuselage to screw it to. A bit pricy at $25!
#4
My Feedback: (19)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Cleveland,
OH
Posts: 5,576
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
for the real intense applications, I only use the larger JR gold contact switches (the big format switch). I know that one holds up pretty well.
I have also had good luck with the MPI switches.
I recently had one of those hobbico inexpensive switches litterally fall apart - in a 1/4 scale cub of all things. Not exactly a high vibration environment, but the switch litterally came apart into a few pieces.
I have also had good luck with the MPI switches.
I recently had one of those hobbico inexpensive switches litterally fall apart - in a 1/4 scale cub of all things. Not exactly a high vibration environment, but the switch litterally came apart into a few pieces.
#5
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Waseca,
MN
Posts: 8,456
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
I agree with Bob, and so do many of the top racers.
JR Heavy Duty Gold Deluxe Switch. I wish I had the number.
They are rock solid in the enviroment you are looking at.
JR Heavy Duty Gold Deluxe Switch. I wish I had the number.
They are rock solid in the enviroment you are looking at.
#6
My Feedback: (540)
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
I use the ones sold by Electrodynamics Ultra Switch II
klet the page load and then scroll down about 3/4 down
http://electrodynam.com/rc/conn/index.shtml#misc
klet the page load and then scroll down about 3/4 down
http://electrodynam.com/rc/conn/index.shtml#misc
#7
Senior Member
My Feedback: (7)
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
ORIGINAL: daven
JR Heavy Duty Gold Deluxe Switch. I wish I had the number.
JR Heavy Duty Gold Deluxe Switch. I wish I had the number.
http://www.jrradios.com/Products/Def...ProdID=JRPA001
I've even begun mounting these on grommets, like a servo ... you know me, never can leave well enough alone. But a constant flow of voltage to your receiver and servos is sort of important. It MAY even be more important than beer. [X(]
#9
My Feedback: (8)
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
Do you guys have a "duty cycle" or replacement time for your switches? How many flights under a high r.p.m. environment do ya recon even one of the expensive switches will function reliably before failure? 100 flights...200 flights...300???
Sure, there are variables, but there should probably be an approx. replace before failure time...and that's something I have been wondering about.
I've been using the MPi switch with the charge port (has the little sliding cover over that part)...that sucker seems to be H.D.
Sure, there are variables, but there should probably be an approx. replace before failure time...and that's something I have been wondering about.
I've been using the MPi switch with the charge port (has the little sliding cover over that part)...that sucker seems to be H.D.
#10
My Feedback: (19)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Cleveland,
OH
Posts: 5,576
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
ORIGINAL: DHG
Dave, it's JRPA001.
http://www.jrradios.com/Products/Def...ProdID=JRPA001
I've even begun mounting these on grommets, like a servo ... you know me, never can leave well enough alone. But a constant flow of voltage to your receiver and servos is sort of important. It MAY even be more important than beer. [X(]
ORIGINAL: daven
JR Heavy Duty Gold Deluxe Switch. I wish I had the number.
JR Heavy Duty Gold Deluxe Switch. I wish I had the number.
http://www.jrradios.com/Products/Def...ProdID=JRPA001
I've even begun mounting these on grommets, like a servo ... you know me, never can leave well enough alone. But a constant flow of voltage to your receiver and servos is sort of important. It MAY even be more important than beer. [X(]
In the QM40 planes, the switch ends up on the servo tray, and some numbers of years ago I learned about GOOPing in the servo tray to help a bit with isolating it.
As important as beer.... probably. Its hard to enjoy your beer while sifting through a pile of stuff that use to be an airplane.
#13
Senior Member
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (13)
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Merced, Ca.,
CA
Posts: 2,118
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
Vicman:
As much as I would love go make a trip down there and give you young bucks a hard verbal time bench racing, I just do not have the time for now. The 24th of this months race is critical for the year, and I still must do some modifications to the original Yellow Jacket and must build another backup prior to the race. I give the Buddude8 brothers a hard time in our posts out of pure affection and respect in addition to having a ball with them. At my age, I feel safe saying things like that as there is little room for criticism. I have not punched anyone out for a few years, and the leader of "Hells Angeles" is now dead, so consider me nice and cuddley old defenseless man who never deserved the super mean, don't mess with him reputation. Manuel Victor was really a missunderstood person and was always good to me. Honestly, he did not really kill as many people as they claimed he did, and always did the guys that most needed it. I ranble, by.
As much as I would love go make a trip down there and give you young bucks a hard verbal time bench racing, I just do not have the time for now. The 24th of this months race is critical for the year, and I still must do some modifications to the original Yellow Jacket and must build another backup prior to the race. I give the Buddude8 brothers a hard time in our posts out of pure affection and respect in addition to having a ball with them. At my age, I feel safe saying things like that as there is little room for criticism. I have not punched anyone out for a few years, and the leader of "Hells Angeles" is now dead, so consider me nice and cuddley old defenseless man who never deserved the super mean, don't mess with him reputation. Manuel Victor was really a missunderstood person and was always good to me. Honestly, he did not really kill as many people as they claimed he did, and always did the guys that most needed it. I ranble, by.
#14
Senior Member
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (13)
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Merced, Ca.,
CA
Posts: 2,118
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
Crazy4flight:
These switches look exactly like the condemed Cermark!!!! I read their comments about rip offs, so ordered 2 as it looks like it will fit in the same hole as existing. Will keep the info for future use, THANKS for taking the time to reply!!! ENJOY
These switches look exactly like the condemed Cermark!!!! I read their comments about rip offs, so ordered 2 as it looks like it will fit in the same hole as existing. Will keep the info for future use, THANKS for taking the time to reply!!! ENJOY
#15
Senior Member
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (13)
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Merced, Ca.,
CA
Posts: 2,118
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
Guys:
I truly appreciate your help here, will stay with the recommendations in the future, and hope you get something from the Cermark switch comments. Interesting that the thing cost me $19.00 at our local crappy shop. See ya. ENJOY
I truly appreciate your help here, will stay with the recommendations in the future, and hope you get something from the Cermark switch comments. Interesting that the thing cost me $19.00 at our local crappy shop. See ya. ENJOY
#16
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Waseca,
MN
Posts: 8,456
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
As to "how many flights" can you expect out of a switch, it really depends.
To me, I get how ever many flights the plane gets before it crashes. Could be 10, could be 100+.
After anything other than a minor crash, I toss my switches and go with new. You can usually find someone willing to take your crashed switch before it goes into the garbage can. I've had two switches go bad in flight before switching to the HD type switch and haven't had a problem since.
I've never used Grommets, but on some installations I've used nylon plastic landing gear straps, one end on the switch and the other screwed to the servo tray. Works pretty good, and absorbs the vibration.
To me, I get how ever many flights the plane gets before it crashes. Could be 10, could be 100+.
After anything other than a minor crash, I toss my switches and go with new. You can usually find someone willing to take your crashed switch before it goes into the garbage can. I've had two switches go bad in flight before switching to the HD type switch and haven't had a problem since.
I've never used Grommets, but on some installations I've used nylon plastic landing gear straps, one end on the switch and the other screwed to the servo tray. Works pretty good, and absorbs the vibration.
#17
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
ORIGINAL: bob27s
cant argue with that....
Although Ed once taught me that Capt Morgan can be an adequte substitute
cant argue with that....
Although Ed once taught me that Capt Morgan can be an adequte substitute
it's one of those things, beer is great when the pile of parts are all new and ready for assembly, the Captain is better when they used to be fully assembled parts.
on the switches, in high vibration short flight duration setups i prefer the simple but very effective 'plug in' setup where you are just shorting the two connections with a Dean's plug, this eliminates the switch all together and has a gazillion flights before replacement time.
kc
#19
My Feedback: (8)
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
I gave up the beer and etc. years ago...now it's (too much) coffee [sm=lol.gif]
I usually use a switch one time...or on one airplane and don't re-use them...but sometimes my airplanes last longer than anticipated... (how 'bout that!?) and I have an airplane w/ over 400 flights on it...same original equipment (cheap Hitec) switch...maybe I should replace it.
Just thinking, because when I read the batt. voltage thru the charge lead/switch, the voltage is a few tenths lower than if I read it directly from the batt. lead.
That leads me to believe that there is increased resistance thru the switch. I figure the vibration is probably causing fretting between the contacts...(by cycling the switch (batt. disconnected) a bunch of times, the resistance changes/lessens)
I just talked myself into throwing that switch away...
I usually use a switch one time...or on one airplane and don't re-use them...but sometimes my airplanes last longer than anticipated... (how 'bout that!?) and I have an airplane w/ over 400 flights on it...same original equipment (cheap Hitec) switch...maybe I should replace it.
Just thinking, because when I read the batt. voltage thru the charge lead/switch, the voltage is a few tenths lower than if I read it directly from the batt. lead.
That leads me to believe that there is increased resistance thru the switch. I figure the vibration is probably causing fretting between the contacts...(by cycling the switch (batt. disconnected) a bunch of times, the resistance changes/lessens)
I just talked myself into throwing that switch away...
#20
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Ferndale,
WA
Posts: 225
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Were baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaak
ORIGINAL: Flyboy Dave
I'm down with the beer, and the Captn' too....but I replaced my OS switches
with Cermark....
....am I way behind the curve....burp ?
I'm down with the beer, and the Captn' too....but I replaced my OS switches
with Cermark....
....am I way behind the curve....burp ?