Patriot Retracts - Mechanical or Pneumatic?
I've got a Patriot kit and am planning out how to build. The plans call out the Hobbico 3 gear mechanicals. What I was wondering is whether the robart pneumatics would give a lower weight. The mechanical setup requires two servos, a standard for the nose and a low profile for the mains. If the pneumatic valve can be driven by a mini or micro, the total weight might be less.
Hobbico doesn't publish weights so does anyone out there have a set, mains and nose, they could weigh? Robart does list their weights and the servo weights are easy to get to. |
Patriot Retracts - Mechanical or Pneumatic?
Mechanical work fine. Not much room in theplane for tanks and such
|
Concur-
The weight would probably be pretty even, when considering tanks and the beefier Pneumatic gear...
B&D makes some pretty small gear, I know Galen put those in his Lanier F-4 (Similar size plane..) and has had good luck. What motor you gonna use? james |
Patriot Retracts - Mechanical or Pneumatic?
Tossed up on motor right now, but leaning towards an OS 50FSR I already have. My goal is 120mph. I had a scat cat several years ago that I got to 97mph (radar) with a K&B 40 on a pipe and perry carb.
I'm going to put the 50 on the test stand and test with some smaller higher pitch props to see what it will turn. I'll add a pipe if it looks close, but otherwise I'll be looking for a new engine to pull it around. Do you have a Patriot to? |
Who me?
I have a "well used"Patriot ARF, and one that was recently built from a kit (Not by me.. :D ) so it is built straight and nice-
YS-45 on the nicer one (Not yet finished..) TT pro 46 on the beater Patriot- Keep us posted, james |
Patriot Retracts
I just bought my Patriot kit from the LHS I got lucky and they had two left so I bought one. I also bought the Hobbico mechanical retracts. I plan to use a retract servo for the main gear, low profile. And an HS 85 MG for the nosegear Its got more than enough power to pull and push the retract and I can dial in my EPA so the servo is not stalled when it retracts the nose gear or extends it. This way the servo will not suck excess current. And I am using a 5 cell 1100 mahr pack for the plane its the same size as a 5 cell 600 mahr pack.
But I am still trying to decide on an engine myself. I first thought of the OS 50 SX because I have a Macs header and pipe for it but then I was thinking about a YS if I can find one. I have also considered a Jett 50. Controlmech please keep us updated on your testing of the 50 SX. Thanks Joe |
Patriot Retracts - Mechanical or Pneumatic?
My 50 is an older vintage 50FSR, not the newer SX. I just bought a new OS 32SX for my Modeltech Extra 300. I'm going to break it in this weekend, but if the props listed in the manual are for real, the SX is a much stronger engine than the OS 32F it is replacing. Are the OS manuals optimistic?
|
Patriot Retracts - Mechanical or Pneumatic?
Viper 21 - I forgot to ask, do you have a way to weigh the Hobbico retracts you bought? I'm trying to decide on retracts now and Hobbico doesn't list weights on the web site.
|
OS Engines
In my expiernce with OS engines their manuals have been pretty close to the real time flying data. I run a 12x8 in my 61SF on the pipe it will run at 14+ grand rpm so that's pretty respectable. I may go with the 50 SX on a Macs pipe for my Patriot.
Not sure yet. Joe |
Hobbico Retracts
I sure can weigh the retracts for you if you give me about 10 minutes to go out to my shop and do it?
Joe |
Patriot Retracts - Mechanical or Pneumatic?
That would be awesome!!!!
|
Patriot Retracts - Mechanical or Pneumatic?
From the Robart site for the Patriot:
6.7 oz 605hd mains 3.3 oz 607 nose gear 3.0 oz air kit (tank, valve, etc...) 13.0 oz for gear For pneumatic only 1 micro servo is needed, for the mechanicals it requires 2 and 1 as to be a low profile. With al the weights I can figure out which one comes out lighter. |
Hobbico Retracts
Controlmech, as weighed by my very accurate 4 pound digital scale. All three Hobbico Mechanical retracts weigh 7.0 ounces. But I did not have a retract servo on hand so you would need to take that into account. And I plan to operate my nosegear buy a Hitec HS 85 bb Metal gear servo that weighs less than an ounce. I hope that his helps. Now how about some ideas for which engine I should buy? I have a Macs header and pipe that will fit the OS 50 SX or I can buy a header for a YS 45 and use the same pipe on it?
Joe |
Patriot Retracts - Mechanical or Pneumatic?
Thanks - looks like the I'd have to save 6 oz on servos to break even. Mechanicals it is.
I'll post what I get out of my 50FSR, but that ones been out of production for a while. I've read good things about Jett, but no experience myself. |
why not air for the wings & servo for the nose!
I have a Patriot kit waiting on my building board :) .
I will be using an MVVS .48 fitted with a "mousse" muffler and a combination of- pneumatic retracts in the wing and a mechanically operated nose gear. The servo in the tail will operate the front retract AND at the same time will control the valve for the pneumatic mains. I am not sure about the total weight of this arrangement, but I am sure about eliminating the low profile servo (and some rods) in the wing! If anyone has a similar setup, let me see some PICS!!!!! :D |
Retracts
Vasek, I am just going to run two low profile retract servos one for the nose wheel and one in the wing for the main gear. Had I thought about this before I bought the Mechanicals I probably would have sprung the extra money for a set of slimline Spring Airs. All the Slim Rhom Airs that I have are going into glow Ducted fan jets so they are out. So it looks like to be on the safe side I pop for two retract servos or figure out how to make a mini servo shut itself off.
I will tell you one thing however and thats that I have decided to just buy a new OS 50 SX and use my new Macs Header and Pipe and just fly the plane it will be plenty fast. And if I need to go really fast I will just fly one of my ducted fans. I am not paying 300 bux for an engine on a sport plane? I wish I had thought about the retracts though before I bought them. Mechanicals are great once they are all set up I am installing a new set of Supra Mechanicals in my new old Style EZ Dago Red. They are just a pain to hook up right is all. Viper |
Hmm..
OS 50 it is!!
I was gonna run a mini on the nose gear, but did not realize the possibility of servo drain during flight... Hmmm- I don't wanna pop for another retract servo- Keep us posted- What D/F's are you flying? james |
Ducted Fan
Razor, yep that's a major concern of mine is to have a stalled out mini servo sucking juice from my battery for the entire flight not good :( So I will most likely run two low profile retract servos.
Right now I am halfway through building a Jet Hangar Hobbies FJ-3 Fury Navy version of the F86 Sabre. I have all the scale landing gear for it and am installing a new OS 46VX with a Turbax I 5 inch fan and it will have retracts, flaps and speed brakes. I just bought a brand new OS 91VR and Dynamax Fan for my next ducted fan and that will be a Jet Hangar F4 Phantom with scale landing gear and all the goodies on it. You gonna run the OS 50 SX too huh. I hear its pretty hot for the price and since I already have the Macs Header and Quite pipe I will buy one and try it out. Joe |
Hey Viper-
1 Attachment(s)
I got a Patriot (right here on RCU- :eek: ) and it has Spring Air gear- and split flaps!
They work flawlessly, and the small air tank fits easily in front of the servos... On 60PSI I can cycle them about 8 times- What happened with yours? Also, I got ahold of a JHH A-4 Dynamax combo- should be a hoot |
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:31 AM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.