Four Stroke concern...
#1
Four Stroke concern...
I don't have a lot of experience with four stroke engines. I have a ThunderTiger .54 mounted in a Sig Rascal .40 turning an APC 11X5. I do not have any tach numbers. I replaced the air bleed carb with the newer twin needle carb and find I'm using very little of the barrel travel to achieve "normal" operation from idle to what I think is full throttle. Full throttle "sounds" like it is producing full power... Throttle operation is not linear and uses quite a bit of expo to operate at what I consider normal for a two stroke. The airplane will loop from level flight but can't hold verticals for very long. Can anybody tell me if there is a problem based on what I'm seeing or is this considered normal performance?
#2
My Feedback: (102)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Colonial Beach, VA
Posts: 20,370
Likes: 0
Received 25 Likes
on
25 Posts
RE: Four Stroke concern...
An 11x5 is not nearly enough prop, a 12x6 would be much more appropriate. Of course I'm judging by Saito .56 experience but the ,54 should be in the same power range.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Dubbo, New South Wales, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 1,484
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Four Stroke concern...
G'day
My Saito 56 has run for years on a 12 x 6. I am just now putting it back in a VMAR Apache trainer and it will be getting a 12 x 6 again. Might be a RAM or an APC. If I still had any Bolly 12.5 x 6 props I would try one of them.
I have had both the Thunder Tiger 54 with the airbleed and the twin needle and I liked the airbleed better. I did find the twin needle harder to tune. The air bleed was mounted inverted in a Ryan STA and worked perfectly. I think it had a 12 x 6 too.
Mike in Oz
My Saito 56 has run for years on a 12 x 6. I am just now putting it back in a VMAR Apache trainer and it will be getting a 12 x 6 again. Might be a RAM or an APC. If I still had any Bolly 12.5 x 6 props I would try one of them.
I have had both the Thunder Tiger 54 with the airbleed and the twin needle and I liked the airbleed better. I did find the twin needle harder to tune. The air bleed was mounted inverted in a Ryan STA and worked perfectly. I think it had a 12 x 6 too.
Mike in Oz
#6
RE: Four Stroke concern...
Thanks for the feedback.
I made the mods I have seen in these forums: i.e. opening up the air bleed port and filing a notch in the carb barrel to allow more air at idle but perhaps went too far. After extensive tinkering, I replaced the air bleed carb with the "new" twin needle carb. The engine never seemed happy with more than a Zinger or APC 11X5 although I never tried more prop with the new carburetor. Now, I can achieve a low reliable idle and transition smoothly to what seems like full power however, the carb is not fully open. If I move further towards aligning the barrel opening with the carb opening, it goes lean and quits - like it's getting too much air - is this condition normal for most four strokes?
I made the mods I have seen in these forums: i.e. opening up the air bleed port and filing a notch in the carb barrel to allow more air at idle but perhaps went too far. After extensive tinkering, I replaced the air bleed carb with the "new" twin needle carb. The engine never seemed happy with more than a Zinger or APC 11X5 although I never tried more prop with the new carburetor. Now, I can achieve a low reliable idle and transition smoothly to what seems like full power however, the carb is not fully open. If I move further towards aligning the barrel opening with the carb opening, it goes lean and quits - like it's getting too much air - is this condition normal for most four strokes?
#7
My Feedback: (102)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Colonial Beach, VA
Posts: 20,370
Likes: 0
Received 25 Likes
on
25 Posts
RE: Four Stroke concern...
It could be that your idle is too good, meaning that the LS needle is too lean, this will make the HS needle ineffective; creating the exact condition you're describing. Try backing the LS needle out about one half turn then bring the HS needle to absolute peak and then set the LS again.
#8
RE: Four Stroke concern...
ORIGINAL: Hobbsy
It could be that your idle is too good, meaning that the LS needle is too lean, this will make the HS needle ineffective; creating the exact condition you're describing. Try backing the LS needle out about one half turn then bring the HS needle to absolute peak and then set the LS again.
It could be that your idle is too good, meaning that the LS needle is too lean, this will make the HS needle ineffective; creating the exact condition you're describing. Try backing the LS needle out about one half turn then bring the HS needle to absolute peak and then set the LS again.
So then, the carb barrel of a four stroke should be able to align perfectly with the carb opening at full power?
#12
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Upplands Vasby, SWEDEN
Posts: 7,816
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
RE: Four Stroke concern...
Hi!
11x5 is too small prop for that engine! As has been said prevously use a 12x6 APC ,RAM or Graupner "Sonic" prop, those are the best!
Aim for around 9000-10000 rpm.
11x5 is too small prop for that engine! As has been said prevously use a 12x6 APC ,RAM or Graupner "Sonic" prop, those are the best!
Aim for around 9000-10000 rpm.
#13
RE: Four Stroke concern...
The TT operating manual suggests an 11X5 for break-in so I stuck with it but I'll try a 12X6 again. As if I'm a glutton for punishment, I may try the air-bleed carb again too. Excuse my ignorance regarding props - what is RAM and are they available in the U.S.?
#14
RE: Four Stroke concern...
THE apache is very happy with ANY engine turning 12X6 in the 9 to 10K range I have powered mine with an Irvine 40 diesel in that rev range that is an equiv. to a 52-56 4 strk glow in power martin
#16
RE: Four Stroke concern...
My first question would be is this a new engine? If not how was it put away (if you put it away for the winter) How are the bearings? What % on fuel? How old is the fuel? Try a 12x8 that's what I use on Saito 56. I think you are too lean. Test your tank and fuel line for an air leak.
#17
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Freedom, PA
Posts: 574
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Four Stroke concern...
Peak you high speed, then at idle pinch your fuel line at the carb...What happens? If it speeds up your idle is too rich, if It dies with no RPM increase its too lean. Perfect idle will gain a few RPM before it dies
#19
RE: Four Stroke concern...
My first saito engine was a 62 and i struggled to get a reasonable tune(read bad)on a 12x6 mas
http://www.modelshopleeds.co.uk/cata...105_106_51_156
Here is a place in the UK that sells the RAM props.
Here is a place in the UK that sells the RAM props.
My first question would be is this a new engine? If not how was it put away (if you put it away for the winter) How are the bearings? What % on fuel? How old is the fuel? Try a 12x8 that's what I use on Saito 56. I think you are too lean. Test your tank and fuel line for an air leak.
Peak you high speed, then at idle pinch your fuel line at the carb...What happens? If it speeds up your idle is too rich, if It dies with no RPM increase its too lean. Perfect idle will gain a few RPM before it dies
Just to reiterate: this engine runs and transitions well from idle to full power and back and flies the airplane adequately. So, I guess most would say: "What's the problem?" It just seems that a two stroke .40-45 would pull it further in up-lines... So I agree with what is said about turning a 12X higher pitch at 9K should be possible; however, from what I remember I don't think I saw much more than 6,7,8K rpm? with a 12X6.
BTW, comments about air leaks reminds me that I'm using the suggested Du-Bro Quick-Fill re-fueling valve on the Rascal .40 that I remember once vowing never to use again from previous unsatisfactory experiences on other airplanes. I had the tank out w/in the past year and it showed no bubbles anywhere when pinching one line shut and blowing 'till I was blue in the face while holding the tank submereged in a sink full of water...
#20
Senior Member
RE: Four Stroke concern...
My 4 stroke 50 size engines typically run the MA11X7.5 in the 10,000 rpm static range. It is desireable to keep the rpms down to this level with prop selection to prevent overrevving and damaging the valvetrain.
#21
My Feedback: (2)
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Weatherford,
TX
Posts: 1,379
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Four Stroke concern...
Definitely use a TACH on the engine. I had friend who thought his TT two stroke was right on. It was 1500 below max after he used a TACH. I can not hear so well as to determine max RPM on a four stroke. So use a TACH to set up the HSN, the check out the LSN.
#23
RE: Four Stroke concern...
Update 7/30/13:
I finally got out to fly this past weekend. I removed the 11X5 and installed a balanced, APC 12X6. I reset the ATV on the TX to achieve max open and absolute closed. To the best of my knowledge, I opened the LS needle 1/2~1 turn. I also opened the HS needle a bit. While setting up my glow driver, I blew the damn plug and I had all my spare OS type F's safely in a drawer at home. So, I stuck what I had on hand in and that was an old K&B long with idle bar...
To make a long story short, after baking myself in the hot sun screwing with needles and successive restarts through a tank of fuel, I just wanted to fly and am back where I was before: total throttle throw using ATV's is just 3/16" - tach read 3400 rpm at the low end and 8600 rpm at the high end. I put in one flight and called it a day. Airplane my have flown marginally better? Note: I may have been getting a lower idle in flight...
I finally got out to fly this past weekend. I removed the 11X5 and installed a balanced, APC 12X6. I reset the ATV on the TX to achieve max open and absolute closed. To the best of my knowledge, I opened the LS needle 1/2~1 turn. I also opened the HS needle a bit. While setting up my glow driver, I blew the damn plug and I had all my spare OS type F's safely in a drawer at home. So, I stuck what I had on hand in and that was an old K&B long with idle bar...
To make a long story short, after baking myself in the hot sun screwing with needles and successive restarts through a tank of fuel, I just wanted to fly and am back where I was before: total throttle throw using ATV's is just 3/16" - tach read 3400 rpm at the low end and 8600 rpm at the high end. I put in one flight and called it a day. Airplane my have flown marginally better? Note: I may have been getting a lower idle in flight...
#24
Senior Member
RE: Four Stroke concern...
Idle bar plugs are not normally used in 4 stroke engines. I would try opening up the low speed needle quite a bit and make sure you get the high speed needle right first.
#25
RE: Four Stroke concern...
ORIGINAL: jeffie8696
Idle bar plugs are not normally used in 4 stroke engines. I would try opening up the low speed needle quite a bit and make sure you get the high speed needle right first.
Idle bar plugs are not normally used in 4 stroke engines. I would try opening up the low speed needle quite a bit and make sure you get the high speed needle right first.
So I personally wouldn't be bothered using an I/B plug in a 4-stroke. Enya 3's run as well as OS F plugs do and cost half as much. Fox plugs are cheaper yet.