Saito FG-60R3
#1751
#1753
My Feedback: (2)
Iridium is good for glow plugs. It's better than the conventional glow plugs from what I remember. I don't believe it's essential but it's an improvement.
Try your low end adjustment to solve the #3 drop out at idle. You might be a little too rich.
I don't recall having any issues breaking in my FG60 on a test stand. I set my settings per the Mfg's instructions.
Try your low end adjustment to solve the #3 drop out at idle. You might be a little too rich.
I don't recall having any issues breaking in my FG60 on a test stand. I set my settings per the Mfg's instructions.
#1754
#1756
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Sherwood,
OR
Posts: 76
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I measured the plugs before the first run, #1 was 0.015", 2 and 3 were 0.023". That is why i swapped 2 and 3. HS is set to 1.3 and LS is set at 6.0. 1 3/4 gallons through it.
I cleaned and swapped plugs 2 and 3. After it warmed up, I held it at 5k rpm for two minutes and got 100-100-99c, best yet! 6k rpm got 100-100-112. Max rpm is 6,500.
At 4k and 3k rpm #3 drops about 20c degrees behind 1& 2. At 2.2k rpm, #3 drops 40c degrees below #1. #2 goes 20c below #1. Going lower on the LS drops the rpm and it wants to die. LS spec is 6.5, but at that setting, it won't idle below 3k rpm.
I cleaned and swapped plugs 2 and 3. After it warmed up, I held it at 5k rpm for two minutes and got 100-100-99c, best yet! 6k rpm got 100-100-112. Max rpm is 6,500.
At 4k and 3k rpm #3 drops about 20c degrees behind 1& 2. At 2.2k rpm, #3 drops 40c degrees below #1. #2 goes 20c below #1. Going lower on the LS drops the rpm and it wants to die. LS spec is 6.5, but at that setting, it won't idle below 3k rpm.
#1757
I measured the plugs before the first run, #1 was 0.015", 2 and 3 were 0.023". That is why i swapped 2 and 3. HS is set to 1.3 and LS is set at 6.0. 1 3/4 gallons through it.
I cleaned and swapped plugs 2 and 3. After it warmed up, I held it at 5k rpm for two minutes and got 100-100-99c, best yet! 6k rpm got 100-100-112. Max rpm is 6,500.
At 4k and 3k rpm #3 drops about 20c degrees behind 1& 2. At 2.2k rpm, #3 drops 40c degrees below #1. #2 goes 20c below #1. Going lower on the LS drops the rpm and it wants to die. LS spec is 6.5, but at that setting, it won't idle below 3k rpm.
I cleaned and swapped plugs 2 and 3. After it warmed up, I held it at 5k rpm for two minutes and got 100-100-99c, best yet! 6k rpm got 100-100-112. Max rpm is 6,500.
At 4k and 3k rpm #3 drops about 20c degrees behind 1& 2. At 2.2k rpm, #3 drops 40c degrees below #1. #2 goes 20c below #1. Going lower on the LS drops the rpm and it wants to die. LS spec is 6.5, but at that setting, it won't idle below 3k rpm.
#1759
Roger
Last edited by ForcesR; 06-10-2018 at 08:52 AM.
#1760
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Dubai, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
Posts: 500
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
My engines weren't happy until I was down to about 4.5 - 5 turns, I richened them up a little after that to sacrifice the low idle but to have it running a little rich. The LSN affects most of the rev range, so once you have a good steady idle, and good transition, richen the LSN a little for safety. You sound like you are way too rich.
#1761
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Sherwood,
OR
Posts: 76
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I warmed it up and did a 5k burn since that gives me the best heat balance at 100C each. #2 was slow to warm up this time. I then started slowly down on the LSN with the rpm at 3200. #3 cooled off as before. so it had a #1 at 80c, #2 at 60c and #3 at 40c. finally at 4.5 the rpm came up to 3400 and the #3 temp came up to 57. But after about 20 seconds it died. I had to open the LSN up to 5 for it to restart. I repeated the attempt with the HSN opened up by 4 clicks, same result. The air temp is about 15C. The throttle response was very bad too. max rpm is still at 6500. This was the last of gallon #2.
Since #2 is running colder than the other cylinders now, I will change out that spark plug. It was the one taken from #3 and it may just have to much carbon on it. I think I will check the valve clearances for good measure.
Since #2 is running colder than the other cylinders now, I will change out that spark plug. It was the one taken from #3 and it may just have to much carbon on it. I think I will check the valve clearances for good measure.
Last edited by Jeffryz; 06-10-2018 at 03:10 PM. Reason: added info.
#1762
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (9)
Finally got a few flights on Topflite P-47 Saito FG-60R3 with temp sensors on #1 & #3. Curious to get feedback on temps.
Setup FG-60R3 w/Saito titanium exhaust ring, RE mods, baffle, Xoar WWII 20x10x3 (not scale, but couldn't find a 4-blade setup that works). Idles low, revs are linear with 6300 max RPM on ground. Fuel - 15:1 Klotz KL-200 w/ 1 oz Seafoam/gal
Ambient temp was 88F
Is this a safe temp?
Setup FG-60R3 w/Saito titanium exhaust ring, RE mods, baffle, Xoar WWII 20x10x3 (not scale, but couldn't find a 4-blade setup that works). Idles low, revs are linear with 6300 max RPM on ground. Fuel - 15:1 Klotz KL-200 w/ 1 oz Seafoam/gal
Ambient temp was 88F
Is this a safe temp?
Last edited by marksp; 07-07-2018 at 10:05 AM.
#1763
My Feedback: (3)
Same
That graph looks exactly like mine. Temps go up on all three cylinders to about 290F-310F while flying and when I land they come down fast. My probes are glued to the backside of the cylinders. I know if you had them glued to the front of the cylinders you would see a major difference in temps. I’ve been flying this way and haven’t had any issues.
#1765
My Feedback: (10)
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Ladera Ranch, CA
Posts: 678
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have 2 of the FG60-R3's bought when they came out for a pair of TopFlite birds... They will consistently crack a cylinder and I go through the motions of sending them in to HH and eventually getting a fixed or replacement engine (this has happed 7 times across the 2 engines)
Sunday while flying my TF Wulf with the engine slightly rich (static 6K RPM) and flew for about 5 minutes only to have the #1 cylinder crack at the base, huge drop in power, but was able to get the plane on the deck w/o too much damage (it amazes me that the engine continues to idle with a cracked cylinder base). I called HH and they say they won't cover it under warranty. Frustrating!
I have DLE and DA engines that have hundreds of flights (maybe over a thousand on a DLE55RA that has been in multiple planes) yet I continue to try to get these saitos to be consistent, stable engines. Rant over!
Sunday while flying my TF Wulf with the engine slightly rich (static 6K RPM) and flew for about 5 minutes only to have the #1 cylinder crack at the base, huge drop in power, but was able to get the plane on the deck w/o too much damage (it amazes me that the engine continues to idle with a cracked cylinder base). I called HH and they say they won't cover it under warranty. Frustrating!
I have DLE and DA engines that have hundreds of flights (maybe over a thousand on a DLE55RA that has been in multiple planes) yet I continue to try to get these saitos to be consistent, stable engines. Rant over!
#1766
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (9)
That graph looks exactly like mine. Temps go up on all three cylinders to about 290F-310F while flying and when I land they come down fast. My probes are glued to the backside of the cylinders. I know if you had them glued to the front of the cylinders you would see a major difference in temps. I’ve been flying this way and haven’t had any issues.
#1767
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Sherwood,
OR
Posts: 76
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I flew my fg60 yesterday with the cowl on for the first time. Sensor on exhaust header. This values were after 5 minute warm-up on the ground, static holding 5K rpm.
No cowl temp was about 90C (194f) on #1, with cowl temp was about 100C (212f) on #1. ambient outside temp was about 26C.(80f)
What telemetry system are you guys using. I have the spektrum tm1000 module. The loop temperature wire doesn't lend itself to fitting near the top of the head so I was going to wrap it around the exhaust pipe fitting. This only has one temp probe.
also, no info on how to connect to the saito rpm module. ( all three wires or just the signal?).
tx JJ
No cowl temp was about 90C (194f) on #1, with cowl temp was about 100C (212f) on #1. ambient outside temp was about 26C.(80f)
What telemetry system are you guys using. I have the spektrum tm1000 module. The loop temperature wire doesn't lend itself to fitting near the top of the head so I was going to wrap it around the exhaust pipe fitting. This only has one temp probe.
also, no info on how to connect to the saito rpm module. ( all three wires or just the signal?).
tx JJ
Last edited by Jeffryz; 07-08-2018 at 06:14 AM. Reason: calc error
#1768
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Dubai, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
Posts: 500
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Jeffry,
I am using JETI Systems equipment, and the temp telem comes with 2 loops. I put on one on cyl-1, and the other on cyl-2. I know what you mean about getting the sensors placed. With the loop setup, its not easy to install on the 4T engines as you have to get around the inlet manifild and the pushrod tupes. The only way to do it is to remove the cylinder.... OR....what did was I cut the loop, and then used a male and female servo connector (not the entire 3 pin connector, just th internal brass connectors) and then wrapped the sensor around the cylinder, and reconnected it with some shrink tube over....works like a charm, and you can take them off again when you want...
I am using JETI Systems equipment, and the temp telem comes with 2 loops. I put on one on cyl-1, and the other on cyl-2. I know what you mean about getting the sensors placed. With the loop setup, its not easy to install on the 4T engines as you have to get around the inlet manifild and the pushrod tupes. The only way to do it is to remove the cylinder.... OR....what did was I cut the loop, and then used a male and female servo connector (not the entire 3 pin connector, just th internal brass connectors) and then wrapped the sensor around the cylinder, and reconnected it with some shrink tube over....works like a charm, and you can take them off again when you want...
#1769
Senior Member
I have 2 of the FG60-R3's bought when they came out for a pair of TopFlite birds... They will consistently crack a cylinder and I go through the motions of sending them in to HH and eventually getting a fixed or replacement engine (this has happed 7 times across the 2 engines)
Sunday while flying my TF Wulf with the engine slightly rich (static 6K RPM) and flew for about 5 minutes only to have the #1 cylinder crack at the base, huge drop in power, but was able to get the plane on the deck w/o too much damage (it amazes me that the engine continues to idle with a cracked cylinder base). I called HH and they say they won't cover it under warranty. Frustrating!
I have DLE and DA engines that have hundreds of flights (maybe over a thousand on a DLE55RA that has been in multiple planes) yet I continue to try to get these saitos to be consistent, stable engines. Rant over!
Sunday while flying my TF Wulf with the engine slightly rich (static 6K RPM) and flew for about 5 minutes only to have the #1 cylinder crack at the base, huge drop in power, but was able to get the plane on the deck w/o too much damage (it amazes me that the engine continues to idle with a cracked cylinder base). I called HH and they say they won't cover it under warranty. Frustrating!
I have DLE and DA engines that have hundreds of flights (maybe over a thousand on a DLE55RA that has been in multiple planes) yet I continue to try to get these saitos to be consistent, stable engines. Rant over!
#1770
My Feedback: (48)
Been busy with other concerns, but finally got some time to "play" with the P47/FG60 a couple weeks ago. I've had difficulty getting it stay in tune reliably and deduced after fooling around with it for awhile that the low speed needle just wasn't acting right. ( easy to turn, not holding position). I removed the engine and tore down the carb to find that the low speed needle has a pretty sloppy fit where it threads into the barrel. I replaced the o ring with a new one, but it wasn't much better at holding/sealing it, so I added another one and that did it. (the throttle extension holds them in BTW). Got everything back together, fired it up, and got what seemed to be a good reliable and consistent tune.
Put two good flights on it the following day running the best it ever has. Good power and excellent response.
Put two good flights on it the following day running the best it ever has. Good power and excellent response.
#1771
Junior Member
Join Date: Jul 2018
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My next project is a Topflite Corsair and after watching a lot of youtube videos of this Saito I decided thats what I want for the Corsair.
After reading through this thread Im not so sure anymore. There seems to be alot of problems with it. All of you that owns this Saito, would you buy it again or look for a different brand?
After reading through this thread Im not so sure anymore. There seems to be alot of problems with it. All of you that owns this Saito, would you buy it again or look for a different brand?
#1772
My Feedback: (46)
My next project is a Topflite Corsair and after watching a lot of youtube videos of this Saito I decided thats what I want for the Corsair.
After reading through this thread Im not so sure anymore. There seems to be alot of problems with it. All of you that owns this Saito, would you buy it again or look for a different brand?
After reading through this thread Im not so sure anymore. There seems to be alot of problems with it. All of you that owns this Saito, would you buy it again or look for a different brand?
#1773
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: laval,
QC, CANADA
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hi,
My Saito FG60R3 can't get more than 3300 rpm (6700 rpm reading out of a two blade digital tach) on my engine.
On full throttle rpm drop sometime to 2700 rpm and go back to 3300 rpm. I did try to lean it from Hi and Low needle but nothing change. Hi also try seperatly to increase fuel on both needle and nothing change also.
Engine have use about 3 liters 15:1 to 20:1 mix.
Hi is at 2 to 2.5 turn
Low is at 6.5 turn
Prop is a 19x8 4 blade
top cylindre temp
1= 140f
2= 95f
3=90f
Thanks for your help
My Saito FG60R3 can't get more than 3300 rpm (6700 rpm reading out of a two blade digital tach) on my engine.
On full throttle rpm drop sometime to 2700 rpm and go back to 3300 rpm. I did try to lean it from Hi and Low needle but nothing change. Hi also try seperatly to increase fuel on both needle and nothing change also.
Engine have use about 3 liters 15:1 to 20:1 mix.
Hi is at 2 to 2.5 turn
Low is at 6.5 turn
Prop is a 19x8 4 blade
top cylindre temp
1= 140f
2= 95f
3=90f
Thanks for your help