RCU Forums

RCU Forums (http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/)
-   Glow Engines (http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/glow-engines-114/)
-   -   ASP 180 fs (http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/glow-engines-114/4888947-asp-180-fs.html)

asmund 10-19-2006 03:22 PM

ASP 180 fs
 
Today I got my ASP 180 fs and it looks like the 91 on steroids. I weighed it, and all up weight was 1045 grams and 950 grams without silencer, that makes it about only 70 grams heavier than the Saito 180 sans muffler (I thought there would be a more significant differense) I will break it in during this weekend using some straight fuel with 20% oil, plenty of that castor. I`m thinking to use either a wooden 17-6 or 18-6. I will get back here with the results shortly. The engine sure is a beauty, looking just as good as most everything else, so it looks very promising:) I hope to swing the 18-6(it`s a Volk from Peakmodel) at about 8200+ eventually, if not on straight, then on 15% or I can play with the compression a bit to see if that does anything good

Test005 10-19-2006 04:16 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
Video on it running please :)

fiery 10-20-2006 01:24 AM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
A month ago I bought an ASP 1.80 FS from Peak Model ... all up weight (everything on the engine inc. plug, prop nuts etc) 1054 grams.

Most impressed ... lower than quoted weight from specs.

I have an 18x6 APC wide blade "paddle" prop I will use on it ... not run the engine yet but it looks good!

$250 US, plus $10 shipping, arrived in 8 days, can't complain at all

fiery

seanychen 10-20-2006 03:18 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
Who sells it for $250?

asmund 10-20-2006 04:18 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
http://www.peakmodel.com/index.php?m...roducts_id=220

Edge3644 10-20-2006 04:46 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
From time to time the top class engines like Saito have their bad moods. Good luck with your Magnum!!!.

asmund 10-20-2006 04:56 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
All brands have their lemons. My first YS 110 was replaced under warranty because it just refused to run properly and it was leaking fuel[:'(] I have several Magnum`s and I am very satisfied with all of them, so I am very exited about this new big one, if it is as good as my 91 I will be a happy camper:)

stelios 10-21-2006 05:29 AM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
Asmund,

give us the rpm numbers please...

Stelios

asmund 10-21-2006 11:37 AM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
Hello I am so happy right now:D I have just had a chance to run my 180 and after only 3 tanks(12oz) of rich running in it produced 8100 rpm peak on a Menz s 18-6 wooden prop(wide blades) running on 0% fuel. Then I switched to 15% and tached it again, this time it peaked at 8350 rpm on the same prop( I peaked it only briefly to tach it before richening it up again). I find these numbers very impressive and they are higher than I was hoping for. For comparising, my MVVS 26cc gasser on tunedpipe(3.8 hp) turnes that very same prop at 8600 peak so the ASP is breathing it in the neck, plus the ASP will certainly produce more power after a couple of gallons. Just to top that off it idles steady at 1800-1900 on both 0% and 15%, runs smooth and is overall GREAT! The best is that it will get even better as it fully breaks in, he he:D:D:D

P-40 DRIVER 10-21-2006 11:55 AM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
According to my thrust calculator, Thats 2.6 hp and 21 pounds of thrust which is right in line with what should be getting. I'm a little puzzled though, the directions say to break that motor in on a 16/8 prop. An 18/6 is a lot of load for break in.

asmund 10-21-2006 01:12 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
I intended to use a Volk 17-6 for break in but the hub was to narrow to be secured by the prop nut because the threaded portion of the shaft was to short, if you know what I mean. Anyway I watched the temperature and it never became hotter than I could grab it after it had stopped. Isn`t that thrust calc a little optimistic? If it really pulls 21 pounds my harrier 90 will be a bullet in verticals

seanychen 10-21-2006 01:24 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
Don't mean to burst your bubble, but 18x6W @ 8350 rpm is not close to 21 lb. of thrust. I measured APC 18x6W @ 9400 rpm to be 19 lb. of thrust. At 8350 rpm, 18x6W pulls 15 lb. Realistically, you can probably get 8500 rpm on 18x6W if you go 30% nitro. But you are still looking at 16 lb. Mens-S and APC wide prop have about the same load and efficiency.

As for the prop hub being too short to be secured by the threaded shaft, are you using a spinner? A spinner backplate can bias the prop foward by about 5mm to 8mm. Furthermore, you can use a thicker thrust washer. If you need it only for breakin, get a cheap 16x8 prop like master Airscrew. it is plenty thick at the hub. The instruction says to break in with 16x8.

seanychen 10-21-2006 01:26 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
By the way, thanks asmund for the $250 link. I am thinking about Christmas present...

asmund 10-21-2006 01:38 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
Actually about 16 pounds of thrust is about what I expect to get on a fish scale, but that will be just enough on a 8 pound plane, don`t you think:) No I had no spinner big enough at hand and no thicker washer either, so I just had to slap on that Menz because the engine screamed to me: start me up! start me up!

Seanychen, does your Saito 180 turn the apc 18-6w at 9400?

seanychen 10-21-2006 01:51 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 

Quote:

ORIGINAL: asmund

Actually about 16 pounds of thrust is about what I expect to get on a fish scale, but that will be just enough on a 8 pound plane, don`t you think:) No I had no spinner big enough at hand and no thicker washer either, so I just had to slap on that Menz because the engine screamed to me: start me up! start me up!

Seanychen, does your Saito 180 turn the apc 18-6w at 9400?
It was a 180, but a Moki.

Saito 180 can swing 18x6W at about 9000 from what people post.

seanychen 10-21-2006 01:54 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
Oh, have fun taxiing your Harrier 90. I hope it's on grass. That thing will almost take off @ idle.

This is almost as sick as the other guy who has a Saito 220 on Funtana 90.:D

asmund 10-21-2006 02:15 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
yes, I fly of grass and when idling at 1900 rpm I think my harrier will stay put. Isn`t 2-1 power/weight ratio what we really want to achieve on our 3-d planes?[X(]. I currently fly my harrier 46 on a sc 91 fs and power/weight ratio is about 1.5-1, and a little more power would be fine(not that I have to little, but still)

NM2K 10-21-2006 02:46 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 


----------------


Oh no! It went UP $1.00! :D

Marcol 10-21-2006 04:33 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 

Quote:

ORIGINAL: asmund

20% oil, plenty of that castor.
It isn't going to be new for very long using castor oil in the mix. For goodness sake get into the 21st century and switch to a quality synthetic oil based fuel. First world war aircraft ran on castor oil 'cause they didn't have anything better, but 90 years later we have!!!

asmund 10-21-2006 04:59 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
well, do a search on that and see what you find out about castor before being so bombastic about that. As far as I can understand there still isn`t anything that will protect my engines better than some castor in the miks to make up for an occasional lean run, I have read all I can find on the web about castor vs synthetick and have settled on having at least some castor in my lube package.The only negative effect of castor is the thicker residue on the plane and the baked on brown on the engine.

P-40 DRIVER 10-21-2006 05:00 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
I was thinking my thrust calculator was a bit optimistic, What do want for free, I will adjust my calc down a bit when using it in the future. Thanks for the real world advise.

asmund 10-21-2006 05:21 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
By the way in rc-car industry the hottest fuel there is is called white lightning and it is 30% nitro and 8% castor and none synth whatsoever. Buggyengines have little airflow over them and run in then 30-40 000 rpm and still it is the good old castor putting meat on the table.

seanychen 10-21-2006 10:44 PM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
Magnum instruction tells you to use castor. YS instruction tells you to use synthetic only. Saito can go either way. It doesn't hurt to follow instruction.

Thrust-to-weight ratio of 2:1 is nice. But about the only maneuver that 1.75:1 cannot do but 2:1 can do is ascending flat spin and KE Waterfall. If there is a power package that gives you 2:1 without weighing down the plane, then awesome!

asmund 10-22-2006 06:28 AM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
I got some more fuel through it today and ran a smaller prop for the rest of the break in. The Volk 17-6 turned 8800 rpm on 0% and 9100 rpm on 15% and the Volk 18-6 turned 8000 rpm on 0% and 8200 rpm on 15%. The Volk 18-6 seems to be just a little more load than the Menz S 18-6 (8350 rpm) even though the Volk has narrower blades. Now I just need to find time and space to assemble my harrier 90 as my hobbyroom is pretty crowded at this time, but that`s a good thing:D

P-40 DRIVER 10-22-2006 07:03 AM

RE: ASP 180 fs
 
When you get a chance how about some numbers with an APC 16/8 for comparisan purposes, thats sort of the standard prop.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:29 PM.