Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: cornwall,
ON, CANADA
Posts: 128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
I have an ARK X400 (MX-400) heli and I have the go ahead to finally complete what is need to get this bird flying. Charger and lipo packs and gyro and pitch gauge . Is a balancer necessary? I see so many people on here using the Triton or ICE chargers which have no balancer. Does it shorten the life of the lipo by not using one? Is it more dangerous to charge a lipo with out a balancer? I am so far looking at the Triton, ICE, TP0-1010C and the Astroflight 109 lithium Chargers.
Sparing no expense I am sure it would be the TP-1010C that would be recommended. How ever budget wise what would be best?
Thanks
Chris.
Sparing no expense I am sure it would be the TP-1010C that would be recommended. How ever budget wise what would be best?
Thanks
Chris.
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Colorado Springs,
CO
Posts: 591
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
Most of us who are using chargers like the ICE have balancers. I for one am using an ICE charger with an Equinox balancer. If you charge your packs without a balancer the packs just won't last as long.
#3
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Sometown, Northern Utah
Posts: 4,432
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
yeah it's bad news to charge lipos regularly without balancers. That's a real saftey issue, especially the faster you charge them (cant go over 1C). I am also using an ICE and an equninox. It's a great combo IMPO
Also check out the cellpro from www.fmadirect.com it's about 60 bucks and balances and all of that.
Also check out the cellpro from www.fmadirect.com it's about 60 bucks and balances and all of that.
#4
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
RE: Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
porscheaddiction - DN Power batteries and Charger / balancer combo for your bird. Everyone complains about batteries not fitting and where to mount them. Stick with this setup and your good to go. 140 bucks for the charger / balancer and 2 batteries combo and you can't go wrong. I am having a blast with it. BUT - upgrade the Speedcontroller to something else and the motor as soon as you can if you have the stock helimax stuff in it. Runs too hot.
www.grandrc.com
www.readyheli.com
Both of these places sell them as well as others.
Hope this helps.
Jeff
www.grandrc.com
www.readyheli.com
Both of these places sell them as well as others.
Hope this helps.
Jeff
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Savannah,
GA
Posts: 872
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
For the most part - charging with an ICE or Triton charger on a small 2-3cell LiPo will never result in a problem.
Before I knew what a balancer was, I charged my old CP Pro packs (had 4 of them) daily on the Triton which does not balance.
After about 3 months, a friend of mine recommended that I get a Blinky - and after putting the individual cells on a meter (through the charge plug) to check the voltages, they were off by less than a tenth of a volt from each other, respectively, with two being equal.
I put the cells on the balancer and rechecked and I had two mismatched cells with a difference of 3-4 tenths of a volt.
I understand thats such a minimal change, but after three months, I had unbalanced the cells presumably by one-tenth of a volt, unless they were stock that way.
For what it's worth, the only way I've ever gotten a precisely equal reading on Eflite LiPo's is to use the Triton and then put the pack on the Eflite Balancer for about 5 minutes. I can actually get the cells to read equal off the Eflite Balancer.
From what I've been told, you have to get up into the bigger MaH / More Cells to see a real problem with balanced cells.
I know for a fact I cycled my 4 Pro batteries at least 40 times before getting the Blinky. I probably cycled my CX/CX2 packs twice that many times.
Hope that helps,
Bryan
Before I knew what a balancer was, I charged my old CP Pro packs (had 4 of them) daily on the Triton which does not balance.
After about 3 months, a friend of mine recommended that I get a Blinky - and after putting the individual cells on a meter (through the charge plug) to check the voltages, they were off by less than a tenth of a volt from each other, respectively, with two being equal.
I put the cells on the balancer and rechecked and I had two mismatched cells with a difference of 3-4 tenths of a volt.
I understand thats such a minimal change, but after three months, I had unbalanced the cells presumably by one-tenth of a volt, unless they were stock that way.
For what it's worth, the only way I've ever gotten a precisely equal reading on Eflite LiPo's is to use the Triton and then put the pack on the Eflite Balancer for about 5 minutes. I can actually get the cells to read equal off the Eflite Balancer.
From what I've been told, you have to get up into the bigger MaH / More Cells to see a real problem with balanced cells.
I know for a fact I cycled my 4 Pro batteries at least 40 times before getting the Blinky. I probably cycled my CX/CX2 packs twice that many times.
Hope that helps,
Bryan
#6
Junior Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: , PA
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
I run the Align 2100 pack ($75) and bought a Venom balance charger from Heli Hobby ($30). It takes 3 hrs. to charge but is much easier on the battery. It charges at .75A and will also charge 2 cell Lipos. For a little more then a $100 your in the air. I also would not use anything but a balance charger. Just my 2 cents.
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: cornwall,
ON, CANADA
Posts: 128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
ORIGINAL: jw637362
porscheaddiction - DN Power batteries and Charger / balancer combo for your bird. Everyone complains about batteries not fitting and where to mount them. Stick with this setup and your good to go. 140 bucks for the charger / balancer and 2 batteries combo and you can't go wrong. I am having a blast with it. BUT - upgrade the Speedcontroller to something else and the motor as soon as you can if you have the stock helimax stuff in it. Runs too hot.
www.grandrc.com
www.readyheli.com
Both of these places sell them as well as others.
Hope this helps.
Jeff
porscheaddiction - DN Power batteries and Charger / balancer combo for your bird. Everyone complains about batteries not fitting and where to mount them. Stick with this setup and your good to go. 140 bucks for the charger / balancer and 2 batteries combo and you can't go wrong. I am having a blast with it. BUT - upgrade the Speedcontroller to something else and the motor as soon as you can if you have the stock helimax stuff in it. Runs too hot.
www.grandrc.com
www.readyheli.com
Both of these places sell them as well as others.
Hope this helps.
Jeff
I do not have the stock Helimax motor/esc combo. The heli is an original ARK400 bare bones kit.
My set up is.
Align 3550
rc-expert BS-40A esc
Spektrum DX-7 with AR6100
HS-81 boom mounted servo on the tail
HS-55's on the cyclic
Gyro yet to be determined (however I have small old rate gyro I could try, futuba G155)
lipos and charger yet to be determined.
thanks for the ideas everyone appreciate it.
Chris.
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: North Hollywood,
CA
Posts: 151
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Charger/balancer questions? (recommended)
ORIGINAL: jw637362
porscheaddiction - DN Power batteries and Charger / balancer combo for your bird. Everyone complains about batteries not fitting and where to mount them. Stick with this setup and your good to go. 140 bucks for the charger / balancer and 2 batteries combo and you can't go wrong. I am having a blast with it. BUT - upgrade the Speedcontroller to something else and the motor as soon as you can if you have the stock helimax stuff in it. Runs too hot.
www.grandrc.com
www.readyheli.com
Both of these places sell them as well as others.
Hope this helps.
Jeff
porscheaddiction - DN Power batteries and Charger / balancer combo for your bird. Everyone complains about batteries not fitting and where to mount them. Stick with this setup and your good to go. 140 bucks for the charger / balancer and 2 batteries combo and you can't go wrong. I am having a blast with it. BUT - upgrade the Speedcontroller to something else and the motor as soon as you can if you have the stock helimax stuff in it. Runs too hot.
www.grandrc.com
www.readyheli.com
Both of these places sell them as well as others.
Hope this helps.
Jeff
In regards to upgrading the speed controller and motor, do you or anyone else have suggestions to what works. Is there an easy way to set up with brushless motors? Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.