Wing Drop
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Christchurch, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 191
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wing Drop
I have a problem...
My 72" Edge 540 has a tendancy to drop a wing and go into a spin when you pull on high G's.
I have balanced the model and it flys ok doing big manouvers, but if you fly too slow or pull on the G's it will snap dropping its right wing.
I checked the lateral balance and had add a bit of tip weight to the left wing, but still there is no real improvement..
Is there anything else I can do to stop this from happaning?
I am putting it down to a poorly designed model.
Cheers
My 72" Edge 540 has a tendancy to drop a wing and go into a spin when you pull on high G's.
I have balanced the model and it flys ok doing big manouvers, but if you fly too slow or pull on the G's it will snap dropping its right wing.
I checked the lateral balance and had add a bit of tip weight to the left wing, but still there is no real improvement..
Is there anything else I can do to stop this from happaning?
I am putting it down to a poorly designed model.
Cheers
#3
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Tucson, AZ
Posts: 173
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wing Drop
Sounds like you are experiencing "snapping". This happens when a wing stalls, usually in slower flight and at high angles of attack. Certain airfoils are better than others at flying at certain speeds. Your symetrical wing will stall and snap much sooner than a flat bottom (trainer) wing at low speeds.
Your Edge is a high-performance airframe with an airfoil to match and that wing needs a certain amount of airflow over it to fly. High rates and low speed = stalling. If you have a 72" Edge I am betting you have a computer radio as well. I recommend using dual rates and switching to low rates when you are going to do slow-speed maneuvers. Keep turning down the low rates until the snapping stops at the speed you want to fly. Of course, too slow and you won't fly at all so I hope you have plenty of power and the correct prop to pull you out of trouble.
We fly combat, we build our own planes and cut our own wings. We just built some Sellig 8036 airfoils and they turn GREAT. We just keep turning up the rates on the elevator until the aircraft snaps out of a turn, then back off the rates a notch or two.
Your Edge is a high-performance airframe with an airfoil to match and that wing needs a certain amount of airflow over it to fly. High rates and low speed = stalling. If you have a 72" Edge I am betting you have a computer radio as well. I recommend using dual rates and switching to low rates when you are going to do slow-speed maneuvers. Keep turning down the low rates until the snapping stops at the speed you want to fly. Of course, too slow and you won't fly at all so I hope you have plenty of power and the correct prop to pull you out of trouble.
We fly combat, we build our own planes and cut our own wings. We just built some Sellig 8036 airfoils and they turn GREAT. We just keep turning up the rates on the elevator until the aircraft snaps out of a turn, then back off the rates a notch or two.
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Los Angeles,
CA
Posts: 2,162
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Wing Drop
Originally posted by NZ Scythe
I have a problem...
My 72" Edge 540 has a tendancy to drop a wing and go into a spin when you pull on high G's.
I have balanced the model and it flys ok doing big manouvers, but if you fly too slow or pull on the G's it will snap dropping its right wing.
I checked the lateral balance and had add a bit of tip weight to the left wing, but still there is no real improvement..
Is there anything else I can do to stop this from happaning?
I am putting it down to a poorly designed model.
Cheers
I have a problem...
My 72" Edge 540 has a tendancy to drop a wing and go into a spin when you pull on high G's.
I have balanced the model and it flys ok doing big manouvers, but if you fly too slow or pull on the G's it will snap dropping its right wing.
I checked the lateral balance and had add a bit of tip weight to the left wing, but still there is no real improvement..
Is there anything else I can do to stop this from happaning?
I am putting it down to a poorly designed model.
Cheers
Good luck!
-David
#5
Senior Member
My Feedback: (13)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Wasilla,
AK
Posts: 433
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wing Drop
I second what David said. I have a 73 inch Cap and while entering a high alpha manuver the thing would tip to the left all the time even with spoileron. After scratching my head and walking around in circles I decided to check the differential of the elevators. I found this tip on a pattern website and I made the gauges. Really easy to make and makes it easy to check differential throughout the whole range of elevator travel.
An Idiot Proof Elevator Differential Gauge
If you have split elevators a very simple way to test for elevator differential is to get two stadard clothes pegs and epoxy in two straight piece of piano wire (as in the diagram). Clip the cloths pegs to your elevator's at an angle so the ends of the wire are almost crossed, then move your elevator up and down. If the wires stay the same vertical distance throughout the movement, you have perfect elevator movment! but if the wires change their distance apart you need to (if you have a computer radio) mix in some opposite aileron to couteract the elevator differential. I found this out after two years of flying a pattern plane that when ever you did loops you had to hold in right aileron.
Guy McCaldin (design John Payne)
Australia email: [email protected]
An Idiot Proof Elevator Differential Gauge
If you have split elevators a very simple way to test for elevator differential is to get two stadard clothes pegs and epoxy in two straight piece of piano wire (as in the diagram). Clip the cloths pegs to your elevator's at an angle so the ends of the wire are almost crossed, then move your elevator up and down. If the wires stay the same vertical distance throughout the movement, you have perfect elevator movment! but if the wires change their distance apart you need to (if you have a computer radio) mix in some opposite aileron to couteract the elevator differential. I found this out after two years of flying a pattern plane that when ever you did loops you had to hold in right aileron.
Guy McCaldin (design John Payne)
Australia email: [email protected]
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Christchurch, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 191
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wing Drop
Thanks for the tips,
I will re check my throws tonight, I do however think I may have just a tad too much up elevator programed in - what should a model of this size have on the elevator? the instructions are very brief..
Cheers
I will re check my throws tonight, I do however think I may have just a tad too much up elevator programed in - what should a model of this size have on the elevator? the instructions are very brief..
Cheers
#10
Member
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: LaVergne,
TN
Posts: 74
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wing Drop
It sounds to me like your plane may be too nose heavy. I know this goes against conventional wisdom, but believe it or not nose heavy aircraft are much more "snappy" than properly balanced aircraft. If you have alot of throw and the plane is not very pitch sensitive, try moving the CG back a bit, and reduce the elevator throw. I usually set a plane up with the CG towards the rear of the manufacturer's recommended range, then shift things around after flying it some to suit my tastes. When I get finished, sometimes I'm way behind the recommended range. Most manufacturers are very conservative with the CG locations. Next time you go out to fly move your battery or reciever back or add lead to the tail, and see if that helps. In my opinion, nose heavy airplanes are much harder to fly than slightly tail heavy planes.
Greg
Greg
#11
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Christchurch, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 191
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wing Drop
GMM,
That is an interesting thought...
I know it is a tad on the nose heavy side and by the sounds of it I have way too much elevator movement. I will add a little tail weight and decrease my throws and hopefully it will be a much better plane.
Thanks for all the help
That is an interesting thought...
I know it is a tad on the nose heavy side and by the sounds of it I have way too much elevator movement. I will add a little tail weight and decrease my throws and hopefully it will be a much better plane.
Thanks for all the help
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Los Angeles,
CA
Posts: 2,162
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wing Drop
Originally posted by fishgod
Believe it or not about 16 mm up and down for low rate. Mesured furthest inboard.
Believe it or not about 16 mm up and down for low rate. Mesured furthest inboard.
There seems to be a close correlation between the thickness of the wing section and the snappiness of a model. For example, I can't get my SIG Somethin' Extra to snap without using the rudder, and that has a thick section, whereas the GP CAP snaps if you just try a tight loop, and that has a very thin section.
-David
#13
Senior Member
My Feedback: (8)
Wing Drop
i had the same problem with a 40 extra 300 and it was the differential in the elevator. I was using one servo on a Y push rod and it would get more than a 1/4 inch off at full throw. This made it barrel roll in a tight loop. I connected the elevator haves together with a piece of piano wire. It solved that problem. I don't know if this will work on a 120 size but central hobbies sales an elevator bell crank that eliminates differential throw. If your servo are in the tail then, never mind , try a match box.