Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning?  
View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Tower Hobbies
Enter up to 4 keywords or Tower stock numbers
Logged in as Guest



Users viewing this topic: none
  Printable Version
       

All Forums >> RC Airplanes >> Aerodynamics >> Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning?
Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3   next >   >>  

Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/8/2003 7:30:09 AM   
Ben Lanterman



Posts: 1296
Joined: 10/27/2002
From: St. Charles, MO, USA
Status: offline 		I wonder where the CG location as a percent of mac is on each of these Caps especially the original airplane in question.

But the bottom line is that a lot of airplanes with the same planform and tail moments arms that don't have the difference in vertical positioning don't have the problem.

It has to be something that effects pitching moments. Since similar wings don't have a problem like this then you are stuck with the horizontal tail. Keep in mind that the moment change required is very very small.

I doubt it is a stall of the horizontal tail since the flow would seem to be seperating and reattaching awfully easily.

Those of you with Caps and are familiar with the flight path angles and are good at estimating the angles of attack need to do a little arm waving at the airplane and estimate where the wing wake is going.

The thing about a configuration with the wing and tail in relatively the same vertical position is that the tail is almost always in the wing wake except for high alpha maneuvers.


_____________________________

Ben Lanterman

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 26

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/8/2003 9:31:32 PM   
KJohn


 

Posts: 264
Joined: 2/19/2003
From: Medina, OH, USA
Status: offline 		If we can't find the solution with what we have available it would be nice to see the same design built with the stab in a different vertical location and see if there is any improvement in handling during the same flying conditions. Adding a temporary additional horizontal surface higher on the vertical stabilizer to work in unison with the original stab would probably not be sufficient to make a solid conclusion because we would not 'eliminate' the original 'suspected problem' from the experiment.

I am curious to know if there is any noteable difference with the ailerons raised equally on each side. I believe you stated that you are prepared to experiment with that during your next trip to the flying field. I would hate to see this issue go unresolved because then I won't be able to sleep well at night.

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 27

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/8/2003 9:52:37 PM   
Tall Paul



Posts: 4725
Joined: 6/23/2002
From: Palmdale, CA, USA
Status: offline 		I probably have the world's sole surviving GP CAP ARF...
I'd be willing to reinstall the motor (OS 70) and go fly it with tufts around the rear fuselage and have it video'd... or video it myself while someone I trust flies it..

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 28

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/8/2003 10:13:03 PM   
Montague



Posts: 4672
Joined: 4/19/2002
From: Laurel, MD,
Status: offline 		I have a really old GP Cap21 .40 size kit that I flew years ago. It's not flyable at the moment, so I'm thinking back quite a long time. I don't recall it having any odd landing behaviours, though I did always bring it in fairly hot and do "wheel landings", no 3-pointers, as it had a very nast tip stall and could depart with out any warning. In my case, the wingloading was in the "way way to high" range, as I had an OS .61FS in the nose, and the plane glided like a homesick manhole cover. So I'm more than willing to believe that I never got the plane in to an attitude that whould show up the problem.

I'll be rehabing this plane over the winter (assuming I have time) so I'm really curious about this thread. I plan to really lighten the heck out of the structure, since it looks way over built.


_____________________________

Kirk Montague Adams
RCCA 560

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 29

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/9/2003 12:43:26 AM   
Flyin Woodbutcher


 

Posts: 836
Joined: 12/16/2002
From: Ashland, VA, USA
Status: offline 		Keith I am going to do the ail. experiments this week end I"ll let everone know how it goes.

Kent

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 30

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/9/2003 2:34:43 AM   
Tall Paul



Posts: 4725
Joined: 6/23/2002
From: Palmdale, CA, USA
Status: offline 		I discussed the peculiarities of the CAP configuartion today with Tony Frackowiak.
His observation is the plan-view area of the cheek cowls have to considered when determining the c.g. of that plane.
I agree.
The c.g. will be a bit forward of where it would be on an identical plane sans cheek cowls.
A way to finger this out would be build a "normal" streamlined cowl,... faired from the spinner to firewall, and fly both it and the scale cowl.

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 31

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/9/2003 2:46:41 AM   
Paul Cataldo


 

Posts: 816
Joined: 2/9/2003
From: Fayetteville, GA, USA
Status: offline 		[QUOTE]the plane glided like a homesick manhole cover.[/QUOTE]


YOU KILL ME!!!!!

_____________________________

Paul Cataldo

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 32

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/9/2003 2:57:33 AM   
DICKEYBIRD



Posts: 2675
Joined: 4/8/2002
From: Collierville, TN, USA
Status: offline 		[QUOTE]Originally posted by Paul Cataldo
YOU KILL ME!!!!! [/QUOTE]That is a good one for sure....at our club field it's "Geez, that thing glides like a handful o' car keys!"

_____________________________

"He who dies with the most good Cox engines wins!"

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 33

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/9/2003 11:06:49 AM   
Ben Lanterman



Posts: 1296
Joined: 10/27/2002
From: St. Charles, MO, USA
Status: offline 		Here is a site with a lot of photos of the Cap 21.

http://www.toni-clark.com/english/modelle/cap21/cap_foto.htm

Look at the photos. If the cowl bumps were strakes there could be some effect but the cowls are well rounded bumps with no edge to create vortex stuff or anything. The fuselage of the cap is really deep in the front which makes the area less effective.

I don't have the RC experience of Tony but have spent a lot of time evaluating configurations in analysis, wind tunnels and flight test. We did a lot of quick and dirty evaluations in wind tunnels by using a flat plate rather than a fully sectioned part. For instance leading edge strakes like on the F-15 where the gun is located. They can be replaced with a flat plate of the same planform and you will get almost the same data. But these are lifting surfaces. The rounded bump is not.

Based on that I would pretty well say the cowl is not going to act as a lifting surface and the inputs to the NP are pretty well trivial.

I also can't determine why the CG location (within reason) should have any effect on the balloon effect on landing as noted in the site where weight was added to the nose. He is working with approximately the same weight airplane which will require the same angle of attack on landing. There will be some tail trim lift difference but it is actually pretty small. Elevator response will be a little less sensistive but I can't see why that would prevent ballooning due to an aerodynamic factor.

I


_____________________________

Ben Lanterman

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 34

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/9/2003 2:31:53 PM   
Flyin Woodbutcher


 

Posts: 836
Joined: 12/16/2002
From: Ashland, VA, USA
Status: offline 		Ben , what you have stated about moving the cg is what I have found by experimentation. I have changed the cg from 7 in. to 4 in. with no change in the balloon. Only change was the elevator sensitivity. The only thing that changes it is a tad more speed, but this is way to much for landing.

Kent

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 35

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/9/2003 10:48:57 PM   
Tall Paul



Posts: 4725
Joined: 6/23/2002
From: Palmdale, CA, USA
Status: offline 		The next "usual suspect" would be the exaggerated bubble canopy.
There was a sport plane around here with somewhat of an Extra look, but slab sided.
The canopy was flat across the fuselage, although looking normal in the side view.
The plane got passed around thru a few fliers, as it was a very poor flier. Difficult to land,until one guy put strakes on the sides of the canopy at the top edge. About 1/4" square and not very long. This made all the difference in the world.
The cowl bulges are quite noticeable on the GP CAP 232 I have, and along with the bubble canopy could be disturbing airflow at high alphas.
So now there's two things to change... the cowl and canopy.
Yesterday while talking to Tony, I was observing his sport plane, the Top Flite Contender has a layout similar to the CAP; low wing, high horizontal. No ballooning problems.. and no fat cowl or exaggerated canopy.

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 36

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/9/2003 11:05:01 PM   
Flyin Woodbutcher


 

Posts: 836
Joined: 12/16/2002
From: Ashland, VA, USA
Status: offline 		Hey Paul tell some more about the strakes. Do these go on the side of the cowl and canopy longwise, and how big would they be? Also you said high alphas, when landing , this would not be a high alpha?? I'm not exactly sure what this means, I think. Thanks Kent

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 37

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/10/2003 2:54:25 AM   
Tall Paul



Posts: 4725
Joined: 6/23/2002
From: Palmdale, CA, USA
Status: offline 		The strakes were positioned here...
Flat fuselage sides all the way up to the top of the canopy.
The plane won 1st in a Novice pattern contest after the mod.

Attachments
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 38

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/10/2003 6:22:12 AM   
Tall Paul



Posts: 4725
Joined: 6/23/2002
From: Palmdale, CA, USA
Status: offline 		I'm prepping my GP CAP 232 for flight...
Measured the cowl width... the cheeks are 60% of the fuselage width.. there has to some effect, if only a burble along the fuselage sides.
OS 70, 102 oz. 23 oz/ft^2.

Attachments
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)
       Post #: 39

Horizontal Stab stalling/ ballooning? - 8/12/2003 2:11:53 AM   
Tall Paul



Posts: 4725
Joined: 6/23/2002
From: Palmdale, CA, USA
Status: offline 		Here's the way my CAP measured out..
I was surprised at the amount of downthrust!
Flew it today.
Wind 15-25 gusty.
Mostly slow stuff, low passes and touch-and-goes. Didn't oberve anything remarkable at all.
There was some ballooning, but only when turning from base to final, and that depending on the altitude... higher up it was less noticeable.. I attribute this to my not pulling the nose up to adjust the glide angle.
I did determine a 35% c.g. is too far aft.
Snapped out of a spin recovery! Too much elevator even on low-rate!
The c.g is going forward...
Here's a dimension photo....
And a few other shots...
http://www.angelfire.com/indie/aerostuff/GP-CAP-232-12.jpg

Attachments
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize

(in reply to Flyin Woodbutcher)