Oacker
Posts: 87
Score: 100 Joined: 2/9/2011 Last Login: 10/2/2011 From: , PA, USA Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: proanti1 quote:
ORIGINAL: Oacker quote:
ORIGINAL: nitroexpress quote:
ORIGINAL: Oacker The fuel I am running is Sigs, who normally makes airplane fuel, but has a couple different RC car blends too. This stuff is 50% castor - 50% Klotz synthetic with 10% nitro. Sounds like you are trying to run Champion ''10''. A good airplane fuel, but inappropriate for car engines. 20% total lubrication is way too high. And why cheap out with the 10% nitro level? I've seen people go round and round about the oil content, and I just don't care to do it. Granted, I am CHEAP, thus I buy inexpensive fuel... but there are too many red herrings in this hobby if you ask me. The bottom line is airplane fuel is not all that different than car fuel aside from marketing and a couple percent more or less oil. To the professional racer there is probably a difference... to the back yard basher, I doubt it. I have had terrific luck with this inexpensive fuel (not necessarily low quality fuel thought) thus far... no issues with wear inside the engine - crank rod and sleeve are all good. I did have to replace the rear bearing which is common in the 3.3, but have had no issues since replacing it. After almost 5 gallons I did a re pinch on the sleeve to bring the compression and performance back up to like new. Also, no issues with tuning until now. For what it's worth, my brother in law's revo is running traxxas top fuel 20%... he swears my revo is faster with the 10% nitro, though I can't tell the difference myself. This is not to say there are no other mitigating factors that would cause this scenario to play out, ie tuning, piston/sleeve fit, etc etc. I did run a half a tank of traxxas fuel through recently just to check if my fuel was the issue and i basically had the same results just at different needle settings. Well, I said I wasn't going to do it, but as far as oil content goes... one thing I will say is that it makes sense to run higher total oil content with lower nitro content. From what I understand, nitro brings additional oxygen to the combustion cycle, thus allowing for more fuel to be entered into each combustion stroke which generates more power. With a lower nitro content, you have less fuel going through each combustion cycle... in order to keep the VOLUME of oil the same through each stroke, you would need then a higher total oil percent. What exactly these ratios are I do not know. All I know is that I have run this fuel in two different 3.3's without issue. Tuning is definitely different... but once it's tuned your good to go. All that said... I do not think 20% oil content is necessary, though I personally dont see a problem with it. Heck, isn't traxxas fuel like 17 or 18%? At this point I am just going to run the engine. I was able to keep it below 270 last night bashing about pretty hard, mostly in the 240 range, so I'm good. It may not be running perfectly, but again I'm not racing... just bashing about. cheers. 20% oil content is WAY too high, especially for car engines. Plane engines run a lot cooler due to a prop being right in front of them. The parts never heat up enough to expand, so the extra oil is needed. Same is true for boats. An oil content that high in a car leads to pre-ignition, overheating, and crappy idle, they are just not designed for it. 18% is the max you should ever run in a car, which is still too high IMO. Traxxas Fuel is 16%. O'Donnell Race is 7% synthetic, which is what I run. I totally understand this point of view... but the first 4 gallons of fuel with 20% oil I have run through this engine without issue tells me (and perhaps only me - lol) that it's not as big a deal as some say. Really, tuning on this 3.3. hasn't been a problem until just the last week or so. Idle has been good, plugs don't foul, and the power has been great. That having been said... to each his own. I experimented making my own fuel at one time... proanti I think you helped me out on that... I was running zero nitro and 16% castor oil with raised compression. Ran unbelieveably well after I got the bugs worked out of the tuning. I stopped making the fuel cause the easy start didn't seem to like the extra compression. At the end of the day, I just think there is more than one way to skin the proverbial cat... but I digress. At some point I will probably try some fuel with less oil content... but the low cost of the sigs is hard to pass up. In my mind, $40 for a gallon of traxxas fuel at the lhs or $24 per gallon with freight for the sigs is a no brainer... that's like 40% more runtime per dollar and I like that. Is my engine performing at peak? Maybe not. Does it perform well enough for a schmuck who wants to bash around the yard a little bit and cant drive worth a hoot anyhow? Absolutely. Thanks everyone for their thoughts. Different strokes for different folks - it's what makes the world go around. -cheers
Hide Signatures
|