Jimmy Skids
Posts: 716
Score: 100
Joined: 6/10/2003
Last Login: 5/17/2013
From: Sacramento,
CA, USA
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: still4given
quote:
ORIGINAL: speedracerntrixie
quote:
ORIGINAL: still4given
quote:
ORIGINAL: speedracerntrixie
The 115 is faster then the 120. I have seen a few of these airplanes fly at Sam's and they are always fast. I think I heard that Sam's has been talking about excluding this wing saying that the outline is not scale enough. The tip cord is too small. How is the 3 blade prop working?
That's too funny. I have seen pics of the SAM's races where guys have P51's with straight leading edges. Every time someone goes faster than the old boys club, they start talking about outline, color scheme, T designation. It's never ending.
I'm so glad we don't have to worry about that in RCPRO.
Blessings, Terry
Terry, I would have to disagree, I have been racing at Sam's for the past 3 seasons and have seen zero rules changes in that time. One particular PM Strega was outlawed the previous year for having a strait LE.The airplane as a whole was outlawed because it's just not very scale. It was a decision based on scale outline and not that the airplane was any faster then the rest. That particular airplane was powered with an OS 90 DF and was definetly not keeping up with the YS 115 powered airplanes. IMO as a scale racing orginization we have to better define the term '' Scale outline '' IMAC had the same issue decades ago and went with a 10% deviation with the ultimate call going to the CD. It was not unusual to see guys carrying 3 veiws and specs for the full scale aircraft and documentation that supported the model was within 10%. One must also thing of safety. You are aware that the PM strega wing is not in any means overbuilt. 1/16'' sheet ribs with no caps, balsa spars, 1/16 sheeting. I think we can agree that most guys are not able to go in and beef that up enough to hold up to gold speeds.
Several of us have flown PM Stregas in the Gold class for years in the RCPRO races and I have never seen a Strega wing fail. On the contrary, I have seen several WM P51 wings fail, even in the Silver class. The incidences I was referring to happened more than three years ago and were the reason the AZ guys quit attending the races there. I am a lover of rules, and if the SAM guys don't want PM Stregas at their races that is their choice. At least folks know that before they go there to race. My point is that the wing that Jason makes is closer to scale than a lot of the other stuff I have seen being used at the SAM races. They are not using the SWRA rules and there is no scale judging. Do you think the WM P51 is scale? How about the Kiosho Spitfire? They are all ''Stand-off Scale''. If they start getting out tape measures, there are a lot of the planes being flow there that will not make the 10% rule.
This thread is about an RCPRO race, and like I said, I am glad we don't have to deal with that any more. At our races, you don't need twice as big a plane to run a two stroke and you can even run electric power if you want to.
The SAM guys can run their races any way they want to, I just think it is funny when I hear someone say they are planning to outlaw another plane that is beating the regulars. It won't matter, Verano will outrun them with something else if they outlaw the plane he is currently using. 
Blessings, Terry
Terry,
I have read this whole thread and it does seem as if you do have some problem with the way SAM's does their racing. I'll make a few comments here with the hope to not be blasted for them and in no way would I want you to take this personal, just listen and maybe see things a bit differently.
1. No Az flyer was ever turned away from a race due to outline or plane type or any other reason. I do recall some planes not being liked by CD's and others and as such the planes were asked not to return a following year. Agree or disagree with the planes, not an issue, but you make it seem like these experienced pilots were turned away. Not true at all.
2. Just because a lot of the SAM's flyers take issue with the PM Strega does not mean that we should be criticized for it. We discussed future rules changes with all pilots prior to making changes and allowed many to race two or three races with PM Stregas prior to banning them. Not a very hard line approach if you ask me.
3. The wings that you have seen (I will assume thru photos or videos) with straight leading edges are Jason's wing. It is a widely used wing by many pilots, and it is very fast. But the Gold Champions of the last 4-5 years as well as 2nd place pilots haven't used said wing. How do I know.... well I, Dave Sullivan, the late Jerry Votaw, Tommy Gun, and Dan Hughes have dominated the gold over the last 5 years in the series and none of us have used said wing. (these pilots are used in reference as 1st or 2nd place finishers in the season long points race over the last 4 to 5 years)
4. Wing area, 2 stroke, 4 stroke, etc. You have your rules, we have ours, and it really shouldn't be such a point of issue. In fact, until you have tried a SAM race I would ask that you not "cast stones".
5. Any pilot is welcomed to come and fly and beat any of us. Due to family commitments I am not always able to stay as late as many at the field. I have however given parts to friends to help repair others planes in my absence, given retracts to pilots during the course of a race day to help them make the next heat, or helped many a competitor (close or barely known) compete. I would believe this is a common thread for all racers everywhere. This is what makes our sport so great. Focus on the great. Each group has differences, but down deep we are probably very similar (I believe).
6. Kiosho is spelled Kyosho.
I'm not sure if this will change the way you feel about SAM's racing, its CD's, or competitors, but hopefully you will change your view somewhat. I've read a lot of your posts regarding SAM's rules, etc and there is always a common theme of disgust or resentment. I'm not sure why. I would seriously believe that if you came to a Sacramento event you would be impressed with how the event is run and enjoy yourself. Just don't bring a PM Strega  (that was a joke).
Jimmy Skids
_____________________________
Spitfire Brotherhood #99
Outlaw Racing CD 2001 to present
Hide Signatures
|
Search This Thread
Printable Version
All Forums >> RC Airplanes >> Pylon Universe - RC Pylon Racing >> Scale Racing >> RE: RCPRO Race 2/09/13, Tucson Az. 
RE: RCPRO Race 2/09/13, Tucson Az. - 
