RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size?  
View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Tower Hobbies
Enter up to 4 keywords or Tower stock numbers
Logged in as Guest



Users viewing this topic: none
  Printable Version
       

All Forums >> RC Airplanes >> Twin & Multi Engine RC Aircraft >> RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size?
Page: <<   < prev  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8] 9 10   next >   >>  

Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/16/2005 11:37:54 PM   
SaviCatses



Posts: 245
Joined: 10/11/2002
From: Montreal, QC, CANADA
Status: offline
I'm done!

Turns out to weigh in at approximately 9lbs and 6 oz. The 6oz is the weight I added to the nose in order to balance it out. Lucky for me, the change in CG As I retract the wheels is negliable (a slightly shift rearward when the wheels are in).

Unfortunately, the weather has turned for the worst and I may only be able to fly it next year. This past week has been terrible with much rain and wind. Next week may be my only chance, since in November I'm moving into our new home and will not have any time for flying at all. And well, December is just too cold.

Attachments
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize
Click to see fullsize image.
Click for fullsize

(in reply to rryman)
       Post #: 176

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/17/2005 5:25:02 PM   
FallDownGoBoom



Posts: 194
Joined: 10/12/2003
From: Colbert, WA, USA
Status: offline
Savi: IT LOOKS GREAT! Very nice finishing work. I really like your camo paint job, and the dual pilots give your Bronco a touch of realism.

I haven't had a chance to weigh mine, but I'm guessing yours is a little heavier because of the retracts and the extra servo's. Friday night I took out the "big" nose weight and replaced it with the "small" one that's about half as heavy (maybe 6 vs. 3 oz?); checked the CG and things are pretty neutral right now. Also changed the wheel sizes to 3" on the nose and 2.5" on the mains. I got the cowls on the engines (that took some wrestling and creative plastic removal with a Dremel!)... did you cut any extra cooling holes, or just leave openings around the cylinder heads?

Like yours, our weather is beginning to deteriorate. Very windy this weekend, so I didn't even try to get off the ground. Hopefully things will calm down during the next couple of weeks.

(in reply to SaviCatses)
       Post #: 177

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/17/2005 10:41:25 PM   
SaviCatses



Posts: 245
Joined: 10/11/2002
From: Montreal, QC, CANADA
Status: offline
Thanks for the comments

For the cowls, I have the hole up front (the arc right in front of the carburator), a hole to let the cylinder head poke through the cowl, and the muffler exit hole. That's it. I'm hoping this will be enough (it will be for this year, we currently have roughly 10C weather!). If not, I'll add another at the bottom of the cowl. As for the weight, I also have paint and a clear coat adding to the whole project. I don't think it will be much trouble, but I want the wet weather to go away.

By the way, why would you want a bigger wheel up front? Is it because you couldn't make your nose gear longer (or your main gear shorter?). My own gear are wobbly as hell, maybe 40 size retracts were not the way to go for a 9+ lbs plane. I used Hobbico mechanicals and even with all the adjustments, they move slightly from side to side. They were the cheapest in terms of money, but we'll see how they withstand some landings.

Our field is 'blessed' with weeds and trees. We have a 300 foot long runway made of some type of canvas material, so it's fairly smooth. On the other hand, that is our ONLY place we can land. Right beside the canvas runway is a grass runway, but usually any 40 size or under plane that touches down in there stops in a hurry (my taildragger noses over when I go into there). The rest of the area is bushes, weeds and trees. Which can be a good thing, or a bad thing.

One of my first crashes was when I never made it to the runway. It was very windy, and I was coming it way too slow. Then the wind died. It was rather funny really - the plane simply dropped out of the sky and hit the... well, it never hit the ground. When I got to it, I saw that the weeds had caught the plane and the plane was suspended in them - the propellor didn't even break (the servo tray did seperate inside the plane, but some glue fixed it quickly).

A couple weeks later I executed a roll while too low. Lost too much altitude and dove into the weeds. Only a bush happened to be around there and did quite a bit of damage to the wings. Again, the propellor wasn't broken - but the engine mount and needle valve broke apart! I never quite understood that one

(in reply to FallDownGoBoom)
       Post #: 178

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/17/2005 11:27:17 PM   
rryman


 

Posts: 971
Joined: 2/24/2002
From: Harrisonburg, VA, USA
Status: offline
For reasons I haven't figured out yet, the Bronco lands much slower than it seems to take off. At least mine does, especially into some headwind. I believe the ticket is to have the wing at least level, I know for a fact that mine wouldn't take off with the nose sitting with any down attitude. Before I got all the nose weight removed, it was uncertain when the beast would take off, but when it did, (usually after hitting just the right bump in the runway), it would just leap into the air. Now, it is fairly predicitable on take off, although I start the take off roll, and after about 100', just hold up elevator until it decides to fly. Seems to work well.
Randy

(in reply to SaviCatses)
       Post #: 179

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/17/2005 11:27:54 PM   
FallDownGoBoom



Posts: 194
Joined: 10/12/2003
From: Colbert, WA, USA
Status: offline
I put a bigger wheel up front, combined with the smaller wheels on the mains, to raise the angle of attack on the main wing. Hopefully this will generate more lift on the takeoff run, which will lighten up the plane allowing it to reach flight speed. We've got about 5/600 feet of short weeds/grass, surrounded by longer (3') weeds. No real tree's to speak of, and like you, I've had the weeds "catch" me a couple of times.

I had a pair of Hangar9 retracts on my .46 sized T-34 ( think they're the same as the Hobbico's). The mains seemed pretty strong, but the nose wheel just wandered all over the place, and the grass played havoc with the alignment of all the wheels. I finally gave up and went back to fixed gear.

(in reply to SaviCatses)
       Post #: 180

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/18/2005 12:37:02 AM   
rryman


 

Posts: 971
Joined: 2/24/2002
From: Harrisonburg, VA, USA
Status: offline
............................. but the nose wheel just wandered all over the place,.....................
=================
I've got the same problem now with my B-24. Nose wheel steering is crazy until I get enough speed that the rudders become effective, then it's all right. I've tried and tried, but can't seem to get the sensitivity out of it.
As far as flying, The Bronco rolls real nicely, and I've done a loop or two with it, very carefully! All in all, it flies like any other single engine semi-hot trainer. (except it sounds a lot nicer!)
Randy

(in reply to FallDownGoBoom)
       Post #: 181

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/18/2005 6:08:32 PM   
FallDownGoBoom



Posts: 194
Joined: 10/12/2003
From: Colbert, WA, USA
Status: offline
The biggest problem I had with my retracts was being able to keep the axles aligned. Even though I ground flat spots in the struts and tightened down/loctited the set screws, taxi runs would twist the wheels out of kilter, especially on the nose wheel. I managed to tame the wandering tendencies by going to inside servo hole/outside tiller arm hole on the nose gear push rod, but I was always worried about the steering connection holding up. If I was going to do it again, think I'd go to a pull/pull system on the nose gear, and bend a single piece of music wire into a strut/axle combination.

I still haven't figured out if I'm going to replace the T-34... I could just go buy another H9 ARF, but one of the LHS's has a Top Flite Mentor kit they've been sitting on for six months and finally marked it down to $170. I'd also have to spend another $180 for a .90 four stroke, plus all the other not-so-small expenses associated with a kit. Also muddying up that decision is the fact that the Mentor is a militarized version of the Beech Bonanza, which is the low wing monoplane that I'd really love to build (so many planes, so little time!). Maybe I'll just simplify things, bite the bullet, and start on the Wing B-25 that's over in the corner.

So a twin just wasn't enough? You just had to go to four engines ? When I was on vacation I ended up reading a book about George McGovern and his experiences flying B-24's during WWII. From what I read, the Liberator took an extreme amount of both physical strength and mental concentration to fly. It had absolutely no pilot/crew amenities, with mission temperatures of 25 to 50 degrees below zero. Gives one a better appreciation of what our fathers/grandfathers went through during the war.

(in reply to rryman)
       Post #: 182

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/19/2005 1:33:00 AM   
rryman


 

Posts: 971
Joined: 2/24/2002
From: Harrisonburg, VA, USA
Status: offline

So a twin just wasn't enough? You just had to go to four engines ?..................................
==========I couldn't help myself. Had to hear what 4 sounded like! I actually have an AC-130 and the B-24. Both fly very nice.

....................Gives one a better appreciation of what our fathers/grandfathers went through during the war.
It sure does. Those guys went through some unimaginable hardships. I have read several books on the B-24, including the one you read.

My Bronco still wants to track to the left, but I have resigned myself to just deal with it. I line up on the runway, firewall it, and go. All I have to deal with then is steering.
Randy

(in reply to FallDownGoBoom)
       Post #: 183

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/19/2005 8:18:39 PM   
R/C Lee


 

Posts: 164
Joined: 12/21/2002
From: Black Butte Ranch, OR, USA
Status: offline
We fly on a bumpy grass field, and I have occasionally struggled to get my OV-10 off. I was using 2.5 inch wheels all around, and they would catch on the taller grass. I finally went to 3 inch wheels and it definitely makes a difference. Last week I forgot that I had my flaps down and took off. It definitely made a difference, as I was able to get off before using up all of the runway. However, since I didn't pay attention to the flaps down condition, and wondered why it was climbing so rapidly, I had to put in a lot of down trim. Figured it out after landing . Clearly, raising the angle of attack on the wing will help on takeoff. Just be careful to not get into too high of an angle of attack at takeoff. Having done that, I found the airplane right at the stall and it was very exciting to level the wing, dive to the ground, and try to keep the speed up. Many thanks to the radio manufacturers for exponential. One good thing about that, though, is that the airplane is very capable of flying through problems like this. Good luck on your first flight. Lee

_____________________________

Shot up, engine overheating, losing oil, but still flying.

(in reply to rryman)
       Post #: 184

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/19/2005 10:26:24 PM   
FallDownGoBoom



Posts: 194
Joined: 10/12/2003
From: Colbert, WA, USA
Status: offline
Guys:

Thanks for all the guidance on takeoff characteristics. I'm all set to go try, but Mother Nature has decided that rain/wind is in order this week, so it's a holding pattern for now... maybe Saturday. It'll be interesting to see if the half-inch change in the wheel height will have a noticable effect on getting up to flight speed.

Lee, sorry we couldn't hook up when I was in Oregon, but we didn't get in until late Sunday, and were driving home on Friday when you while you were up in Portland.

(in reply to R/C Lee)
       Post #: 185

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/24/2005 7:21:33 PM   
FallDownGoBoom



Posts: 194
Joined: 10/12/2003
From: Colbert, WA, USA
Status: offline
OMIGOD, IT FLIES!

Weather was good this weekend, but with a vicious crosswind, discretion was the better part of valor on Saturday. But on Sunday... no excuses.

First try (with new wheels and lighter nose weighting): still not enough speed for takeoff Ended up in the weeds.

Second try (re-tune the engines, and have a fellow flyer hold it during initial run-up): almost! After about 400 ft run (and full up elevator) it bounced about 3" off the ground, then settled back and ran into the weeds... no damage, but...

Fellow flyer flew his Sig 4* 60 for a bit (nice plane!) and we decided to try again. Tweaked the engines a little more, but when he took it out to the runway all I said to myself was "Secret weapon time!" and dropped the flaps. Ran up the engines, he let her go, and about 200 feet later I pulled full elevator, and up she goes as nice as you please! Gained a little altitude, and as airspeed rose the nose seemed to want to pitch down so I raised the flaps and kept climbing. Gentle left turn, now about 100 feet up, backed off the throttles a little, and ... gotta keep some up elevator in all the time, otherwise it starts to lose altitude. Full "up" trim still doesn't solve the problem, no yaw or roll tendencies, but it's definately pitching down.

This of course makes right/left turns real interesting, but not ultra-difficult. Mostly cruised around at between 50-75% of throttle getting the feel of the plane, doing straight & level/circles/figure 8's with both ailerons and rudders. Feels like it flies about the same speed as my Arrow trainer, and no bad habits in the air.

Landing time: brought her around, but couldn't really judge the sink rate because of the down-pitch problem. I was going to do a couple of passes at altitude, but the first approach looked so good that I just brought her straight-in, hotter than I'd like but a nice landing anyway.

So the maiden's in the book. Only flew the Bronco once, and sorry, no pictures or video yet. Some things to experiment with:

1) Controlling the down pitch: I suppose it could be the CG being too far forward, but I've got neutral balance on the CG machine, so my suspicion is that either the flaps aren't totally retracted (but they looked OK after landing) or there's a little bit of positive/negative wing/stabilizer incidence that's causing the plane to dive. I can re-attach the horizontal stab with some shims to see if that will fix the problem. Other ideas?

2) I agree with Randy's comments on the elevator: seems a bit small, and until you get enough airspeed, it's control effects are minimal. Because I can take the whole HS/elevator assembly off, I may re-build it this winter and widen the elevator from the 1-1/4" it is now to around 2".

3) See how it flies with the flaps down, hopefully that will slow approach speed.

Needless to say, I'm pretty happy. Great to see a box of sticks become a real aircraft! Oh yeah, there's another problem: the engine sound causes orgasms when you bring it down the runway!




(in reply to FallDownGoBoom)
       Post #: 186

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/24/2005 9:25:14 PM   
rryman


 

Posts: 971
Joined: 2/24/2002
From: Harrisonburg, VA, USA
Status: offline
..............................the engine sound causes orgasms when you bring it down the runway!

=========
Know just what you mean! Glad to hear it does OK. Sounds like it may be a tad nose heavy.
Randy

(in reply to FallDownGoBoom)
       Post #: 187

RE: OV-10 Bronco 52" 3-Blade Prop Size? - 10/25/2005 12:39:59 AM   
SaviCatses



Posts: 245
Joined: 10/11/2002
From: Montreal, QC, CANADA
Status: offline
Congradulations on your maiden! Your experiences sound little like mine - I maidened the Bronco on Saturday, the only good day we had in over a week (back to raining on sunday )

After breaking in the engines (no overheating with the cowl openings), and they sang perfectly. At one point we had the engines within 10 RPM of each other at full throttle, and 100 RPM at idle. Then came the biggest dissapointment. Refueled, started the engines, and taxied to the end of the runway. In front of a great many club members watching the maiden, I started down the runway, and immediately aborted. The retracts where woggling everywhich way and steering way next to impossible. Second and third was the same. I even got to the end of the runway, but couldn't achieve flying speed because of floopy landing gear and constantly correcting. On the forth try, it ran off to one side and an engine died in the weeds.

Refueled, restarted, and took it back to the runway. This time I advanced the throttle to full and was able to keep it fairly straight. Near the end of the runway, it lifted off on it's own, I fed in more elevator and off it went!

Aileron trim was off, and so was elevator trim (kept wanting to nose up). I forgot to put in exponential, so it was very twitchy. I circled a few times then went for the landing. 9lbs 8oz of airplane sinks fast. I didn't realise how fast it was moving until I crossed the threshold of the runway. It was easily the "hottest" landing I ever did. I touched down in the grass, and then rolled onto the runway. Others who witnessed the landing compared it to a aircraft carrier landing. was moving REALLY fast and then suddenly stopped within a few meters.

But it flies! I'll be chaging to 9x5 props (currently 9x6), adding exponential and some trim. And finally fixing that bloody landing gear. After that, we'll see how well it can fly