Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing for your electric RC!  
View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Tower Hobbies
Enter up to 4 keywords or Tower stock numbers
Logged in as Guest



Users viewing this topic: none
  Printable Version
       

All Forums >> RC Cars, Buggies, Trucks, Tanks and more >> RC Electric Off-Road Trucks, Buggies, Truggies and more >> Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing for your electric RC!
Page: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10   next >   >>  

Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing for yo... - 1/26/2005 9:42:59 PM   
SkrapIron



Posts: 2093
Joined: 5/18/2004
From: Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Status: offline
What is the best set-up for my truck? How fast will it go?

These are questions that have haunted me for nearly 10 years. I have been running 1/10 scale R/C trucks off and on, without a real good understanding of how to properly set it up. To me, it was FM ( friggin magic). What pinion should I use? What if I change the spur gear. It was all trial and error, that resulted in several melted motors, blown ESC’s and damaged batteries.

But I have found the answer! And it is good!

Question 1: What size spur gear should I run? Well……. When selecting the spur gear size, you need to keep in mind that the ratio between the tire circumference and the final drive ratio should be 1 to 1. 1 to 1? What? Here’s how it works. We’ll use my RC10t3 as the example vehicle. The first thing to consider is the diameter of your tire. It is used to calculate the circumference of the tire. Multiply the diameter of the tire by pi. ( Ex: 3.25”xpi=10.2101”) Now, you need to consider the final drive ratio of your drive train. Begin by dividing the number of teeth on the spur gear by the number of teeth on the pinion gear. This will give you your drive ratio. ( Ex: 87/19=4.5789). Now multiply your drive ratio with your transmission gear ratio ( Ex: 2.4x4.5789=10.9893 ). This is your final drive ratio.

Now the magic part. Subtract the final drive ratio from the running circumference of your tire . (Ex: 10.2101-10.9893= -0.77926) That is VERY close to a 0, but is geared a tad to the torque side of the motor ( anything below 0 is always geared towards more torque). Want more speed than torque? Redo your calculation adding another tooth on the pinion : ( Ex: 87/20= 4.35 ( drive ratio )x2.4 ( transmission gear ratio )= 10.44 ( final drive ratio ) Then subtract your final drive ratio ( 10.44 ) from your circumference ( 10.2101 ) ( Ex: 10.2101-10.44= -0.2299 ) This is your optimum gear ratio, since it is closest to a 0 margin. Any ratio that is greater than 1 will run faster, but will overheat your motor, battery and esc, eventually damaging them.

Question 2. How fast will it go? Well, we have half the equasion already. Using the circumference of the tire divide that by the final drive ratio. ( Ex: 10.2101/10.44=.977797) multiply that number by the maximum working rpm that your motor is capable of. I have a Trinity Jade 15 turn motor. It is rated for 23,500 rpm. ( Ex: .977797*23500= 22982.504 inches per minute )
Convert that sum to feet per minute by dividing by 12 ( 12 inches in a foot) ( Ex: 22982.504/12=1915.2087 feet per minute ). Now multiply your feet per minute by 60 minutes ( Ex: 1915.2087*60= 114912.5239 feet per hour ). Now divide your feet per hour by 5280 ( the number of feet in a mile ). ( Ex: 114912.5239/5280= 21.7637 miles per hour ). Keep in mind that this number is theoretical and is affected my the age of your motor, condition and charge of your battery, friction and or slip from your tires etc. Despite this, it is pretty close to accurate!

So, the key to speed and longevity is a high rpm motor coupled to a properly geared drive train. It will make for many a happy afternoon of backyard bashing with your truck!

Enjoy!


< Message edited by SkrapIron -- 1/27/2005 3:24:35 PM >


_____________________________

If I can't be a role model, at least I can be a warning!
       Post #: 1

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing fo... - 1/26/2005 11:09:04 PM   
aliens8mycow



Posts: 3172
Joined: 10/31/2004
From: Liberty, MO, USA
Status: offline
The first part of that is about a scientific as I've seen!

The second part is a good basic speed calculator that will put you a bit on the high side up to 30 or 40mph, then it starts getting way off due to drag and wind resistance. Consider a speed record car capable of 110mph to 130mph. That equation would predict that car to reach closer to 200mph.

Agreed, for most of us running in the 20 - 40mph range, it's a great way to guess-timate top speed!

(in reply to SkrapIron)
       Post #: 2

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing f... - 1/27/2005 2:12:54 AM   
Speedmunkey



Posts: 5199
Joined: 1/26/2004
From: Knoxville, TN, USA
Status: offline
I think.......... I'm gonna like the new guy =)

I've gotta sit down and crunch some numbers tonight, but you might be on to something.. One thing I notice right off though is that your initial math is incorrect.. 3.25”x2pi=10.2101 is wrong..

(3.25) x (2pi) = (3.25) x (6.283) = 20.420

Or am I misunderstanding your formula?


_____________________________

Over the mountain, kissing silver inlaid clouds
Watching my body disappear into the crowd

(in reply to aliens8mycow)
       Post #: 3

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing f... - 1/27/2005 2:25:46 AM   
aliens8mycow



Posts: 3172
Joined: 10/31/2004
From: Liberty, MO, USA
Status: offline
He's got the right answer, but a misprint in the math...

Circumference = Pi x Diameter (not 2Pi x diameter)

(in reply to Speedmunkey)
       Post #: 4

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing f... - 1/27/2005 2:30:50 AM   
Speedmunkey



Posts: 5199
Joined: 1/26/2004
From: Knoxville, TN, USA
Status: offline
Now that I'll agree with. I was wondering why he'd be doubling the circ.. <evaluates the rest of this interesting formula>

Skrap, you'll find that people around here accept NOTHING wihtout picking it to little tiny pieces and driving the original poster insane =)


_____________________________

Over the mountain, kissing silver inlaid clouds
Watching my body disappear into the crowd

(in reply to aliens8mycow)
       Post #: 5

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing f... - 1/27/2005 3:54:51 AM   
aliens8mycow



Posts: 3172
Joined: 10/31/2004
From: Liberty, MO, USA
Status: offline
I'm not nit-picking, just trying to help!

I do have one question for the jury, though -- how about weight? This looks at circ., which is definitely a factor, but what about vehicle weight? Take an emaxx - you could put 2.2 truck tires on it, and come up with the same gearing for it as a T4, but the maxx is gonna weigh a lot more and require some different gearing to suit. Just something to ponder.

(in reply to Speedmunkey)
       Post #: 6

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing f... - 1/27/2005 4:45:28 AM   
Speedmunkey



Posts: 5199
Joined: 1/26/2004
From: Knoxville, TN, USA
Status: offline
I meant *I* was picking hehehe

I'm not bothering with the speed calculation, cuz I don't care exactly how fast I'm going. I figure if I win the A-main, it was fast enough. If I lose, then it WASN'T fast enough. Simple equation =)


_____________________________

Over the mountain, kissing silver inlaid clouds
Watching my body disappear into the crowd

(in reply to aliens8mycow)
       Post #: 7

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing f... - 1/27/2005 4:56:46 AM   
MBX5T Maniac



Posts: 8763
Joined: 12/21/2004
From: none, TX, USA
Status: offline
circumference=2*pi*r or pi*d =)

_____________________________

My toys: LST, Mini Inferno, XX-CR, GrassHopper, RC10, Rustler, MBX5T Prospec, Mugen MST-1

(in reply to Speedmunkey)
       Post #: 8

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing fo... - 1/27/2005 6:54:23 AM   
jah00


 

Posts: 9
Joined: 1/16/2005
From: Wellington, NEW ZEALAND
Status: offline
So if I have a torquey motor that has low revs I should run with the final equation coming out into a negative value, whereas if I run a motor that revs high I should run with the final equation coming out to a positive value? Obivously the type of motor has some impact on the gearing that should be used.

Pete.

(in reply to SkrapIron)
       Post #: 9

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing fo... - 1/27/2005 1:32:18 PM   
SkrapIron



Posts: 2093
Joined: 5/18/2004
From: Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Status: offline
Using your e-maxx example, yes, you would end up with a different gear ratio as the t4. The RPM of the motors ideally should run X number of revolutions for X inches of circumference of the overall wheel, but weight is a huge factor. Remember that the emaxx is using 32 pitch gears ( 66x18 ) and the transmission is 28.9:1 in first and 17.9:1 in second gear..... the E-maxx is geared WAY LOW ( -10.8359 ). Starting off in second (17.9:1) is closer to the 1 to 1 ratio (18.0641" circumference), but the truck is a dog! If you switch to smaller diameter tires ( such as Pro Line Road Rage ) you need to raise the spur gear to compensate for the smaller diameter tire. Divide your old tire diameter by your new tire diameter ( Ex 18.0641/17.278= 1.04549 ) and multiply that by the number of teeth in your original pinion ( Ex 1.04549x18= 18.8189) Rounding to the nearest whole number shows that you should raise the pinion 1 tooth to keep the same final drive ratio. Just try to keep as close to the starting value ( -10.8359 ) when selecting a new pinion or you will lose the torque required to get this rig rolling.

So to answer your question, yes. Weight is a factor when determining where to start out. Obviously, tipping the scale at over 9 pounds requires the motors to be OVERLY torquey, low RPM and geared WAY LOW. To gear the truck at a closer 1 to 1 ratio would require a motor that is 10 times as powerful as what is supplied but would require more batteries, and thus add more weight!

_____________________________

If I can't be a role model, at least I can be a warning!

(in reply to jah00)
       Post #: 10

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing fo... - 1/27/2005 1:52:04 PM   
SkrapIron



Posts: 2093
Joined: 5/18/2004
From: Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Status: offline
Before I get beat up, I said the transmission ratio is 28.9:1 and 17.9:1. I mistyped. These are the FINAL DRIVE RATIOS. In first gear, the RPM to circumference is nearly 2 to 1. The transmission gear ratio is final drive ratio/(Spur/pinion) ( 66/18= 3.6667) 28.9/3.6667=7.881

Pete, your observation is correct. the gearing of your truck is heavily dependent on the type of motor you are using and it's peak rpm as well as the size and diameter of your tires.

I ran the numbers on an e-maxx using 2.2" Proline Gladiators : 10.2101 ( Gladiator circumference ) - 28.9 ( E-maxx final Drive) = -18.6899. That's a huge drop that will rev the heck out of the truck without going anywhere. That would require a 31 tooth pinion to get up to the original ratios! at that point, you need to add a larger spur gear, and calculate your pinion gear from there!

< Message edited by SkrapIron -- 1/27/2005 3:46:20 PM >


_____________________________

If I can't be a role model, at least I can be a warning!

(in reply to SkrapIron)
       Post #: 11

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing fo... - 1/27/2005 2:34:09 PM   
SkrapIron



Posts: 2093
Joined: 5/18/2004
From: Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Status: offline
By the way, you guys are right. Circumference is Pi times the radius squared, of Pi times the diameter. My Bad!

I ditched the Speed gems and the LRP ESC yesterday. I bought the Novak SS brushless 4300 kit. Holy Cripes is that thing fast!!!!!!! I used my magic formula to determine the proper pinion gear for the setup. I ended up with an 87x17, running my Pro Line Dirt Works. I came up with a final drive ratio of 12.28. According to the Novak web site, the optimum final drive ratio is 12.30. Pretty good for someone who dropeed out of college 15 years ago!

The theoretical top speed for my truck with this motor ans setup is 30.75mph. That is 2.57 mph faster than my over geared Speed Gems Chromium, that I melted.

Oh I'm using math! I hate math!!!!


_____________________________

If I can't be a role model, at least I can be a warning!

(in reply to SkrapIron)
       Post #: 12

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing f... - 1/27/2005 3:07:53 PM   
Speedmunkey



Posts: 5199
Joined: 1/26/2004
From: Knoxville, TN, USA
Status: offline
Skrap, I'm still trying to wrap my brain around all the intricacies of your formula, but thus far, you are scoring points with me for your logic. I may have to give this formula my official stamp of approval! I mean, the numbers are nothing new, we've all used them before. But finding the correlation between the 2 is brilliant. I'm currently building a spreadsheet to make this all run more smoothly for me at the track. I take my PDA with all my spreadsheets. People look at me like I'm crazy when I'm sitting there doing "math" to figure out my gearing or picking which pack and motor to run together, but it obviously works =)


_____________________________

Over the mountain, kissing silver inlaid clouds
Watching my body disappear into the crowd

(in reply to SkrapIron)
       Post #: 13

RE: Mystery Solved! How to select the proper gearing f... - 1/27/2005 3:58:45 PM   
Speedmunkey