Stickbuilder
Posts: 8432
Score: 346 Joined: 11/20/2005 Last Login: 6/19/2013 From: Leesburg,
FL, USA Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: mango12 So if the model is actually 1&1/2 inches than what it should be, I wouldn't be marked of for it? Wouldn't the documentation and specs dictate that the model is incorrect, or are you saying that as long as the model represents the full scale accuratly, that the slight discrepency woul not be significant to the judge? The reason I ask all of this is there is rumor that the District V jamboree is going to be at our new field this coming year, and I thought about competing . Scott I have no idea of the caliber of the judges that will be working that event. I am saying that in Scale Contests of a National, International or High level Invitational level. The Outline Judge will look and compare your model against the documentation that you provide. If the model misses the outline, he will normally pick up on it. There were top level airplanes that had a slight angle wrong, and the Judge nailed it. If your model is 1 1/2" shorter than it should be, chances are he will see that as well. Why not correct the shortcoming prior to finishing the model? That Is a tremendous amount to be off on a 1/4 scale model. Where is the short length located? I suppose that if it is on a part of the model that has a reasonably long moment, you might not get tagged for it. If, however, it is on a section with a short moment, you can bet that it will be quickly picked up. If you lose 1/4 point in static, you can normally make that up in either craftsmanship, or in flying. If you lose one full (or more) point in static, it becomes very difficult to overcome. Once again.....Build the model to match the documentation. You can't get the documentation to match the model. The Judging that I do is far removed from what you will find at a District Jamboree. As I said, it all depends on who is the Judge. If they use old Henry from one of the local clubs, he may not have ever judged an event before. If you go to the ScaleMasters or something like that, you will be facing Judges who know what to look for. We will ask you to orient your model to match one of the 3 views (Profile, Head On, and Top and/or Bottom). We will hold the three view up so that the profile matches the model. We start a a given point (I start at the point of the spinner, or prop hub, and work around the model along the bottom, up the rudder, and along the top of the model ending back at the prop hub/spinner. Next, I will ask you to orient the model to a head-on profile. I will ask you to either elevate the tail or lower the tail until the profile matches the 3 view. Again I will look at the entire perimiter of the model, paying close attention to transition points, as well as the dihedral, and wing thickness, also looking closely at root fairings, scale exhaust, landing gear angles, and any external store rails or mounts. Next I will ask you to present the top of the model to me, and continue to compare the model to your 3 view. I may ask you to present the bottom of the model if you provided me with a split top view (half shows the top and half shows the bottom). Next I will ask you to return you model to the profile view, where I will look for landing gear rakes, tail wheel position, and design, or nose gear rake and oleo scissors, with any accessories that should be on the model (per your 3 view) Next, I look at all antenna, fuel fills (if applicable) and all other items that are mounted to the airframe. I do not look at any engine protrusions (spark plugs, plug wire, or cut-outs for cooling the actual flight engine). I do not look at the flying muffler either. I will ask you to show me your flying propellor, and spinner if used. You should bring them to the judges table with you. All this is completed in 15 minutes, and I fill out your Judging sheet, highlighting any area that caused a downgrade. I take many notes on the judging sheet, and you should always ask for a copy at the scorekeepers tent. These are useful to correct anything so that you may point better at the next event you attend. Again, this probably not what you will see at a local event. It is what you see at an event such as Top Gun. Hope it helps. Bill, AMA 4720 WACO Brotherhood #1
< Message edited by Stickbuilder -- 11/25/2007 3:32 AM >
_____________________________
Its easy, just glue all the pieces together, and sand off everything that doesnt look like an airplane.
Hide Signatures
|