bodywerks
Posts: 3178
Score: 100 Joined: 12/10/2004 Last Login: 7/10/2011 From: Tucson,
AZ, USA Status: offline
|
Sorry to disagree 100%, but I am absolutely not concerned at all about power-to-weight, but wing loading. Yes, there is such a thing as too light, but 27-27.5 pounds is DEFINITELY not for this plane - heck, not even 26 pounds. My 35% Aeroworks 260 weighed 25.5 pounds with only one less inch of wingspan and 150 less squares. Sure, that plane flies great at 27-28 pounds, too, but better at 25.5, IMO. Also, I have never, ever heard of a heavier plane flying high alpha better and having less wing rock than a light plane - in fact, just the opposite. My lighter planes slow down better, recover from stalls quicker, are more responsive in high-alpha, hovering, and TRing, and most definitely more stable in post-stall situations. Man, I have been into this debate so very many times before! I don't know what to tell you, but I can tell the difference between a couple pounds on a plane this size. I am sorry if you can't. And, in EVERY scenario, except trying to fly in Gale-force winds, I have ALWAYS preferred the lighter plane. If you want to strap in some dual 3700 nimh's, smoke, and all that stuff and you like the way it flies, have a ball! But let me build mine light if I so choose. Trust me, "light weight" is not just a fad... As for the lighter batteries, I don't see your point about them causing me to crash. They are rated at 15-20C, whereas typical Fromecos can only handle like 2-4C. If a servo took a dump and started to draw excessive amps (not that I have ever heard of this being an issue - at least not one worth worrying about), or whatever, the Fromecos voltage would degrade faster than my 1320 lipos, and the limiting factor would be the regulator, anyway, or the servo wire itself. Basically, your scenario was a bad "what if". Back in the mid-90's, guys were getting by fine on a single 1800mah nicad on 100" planes. Mine will have almost 50% more capacity than that and double or quadruple the leads with which to distribute that power - it'll be fine. Oh, and here's the link to the company that makes carbon fiber pipes for 50-55cc cylinders: http://www.escomposites.com/petrol.htm And here's the post where Mike McConnville, himself, states the weight of his DA powered plane: http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/fb.asp?m=5723736 Now, please do some research of your own before you start accusing me of telling stories! The reason I say. "on another forum", is because most forums have a policy of not being able to link another forum's site on their own site, like www.**** notice the stars? Those weren't put there by me.
< Message edited by bodywerks -- 6/11/2007 5:46 AM >
_____________________________
STRAIGHTEN UP AND FLY LIGHT!!!
Hide Signatures
|