Competing with AMA

Competing with AMA
View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as Guest

Users viewing this topic: none

Printable Version

All Forums >> RC Airplanes >> AMA Discussions >> Competing with AMA

Page: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 next > >>

Login

Message

<< Older Topic Newer Topic >>

Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 2:02:44 PM

Posts: 2
Joined: 6/8/2006
From: Harriburg, PA, USA
Status: offline

I just saw on page 12 of the May issue of MA that I now have to compete in the foam wing business against the largest modelling organization in the world, and I practically have to be a member.

I've been cutting foam wings with CNC equipment, both custom and for our own kits, for 25 years. I really don't see how AMA, as a non-profit organization, can justify starting businesses that compete with their members own. Why not start building radios, hmmm??? The AMA is supposed to be a non-profit, educational organization. Cutting foam wings for sale just doesn't fit in with that. Selling trophies is a bit different, since nicely done aero trophies are hard to find almost everywhere. But even there, they are competing with several member run trophy houses that specialize in model aviation.

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 2:26:19 PM

Posts: 955
Joined: 1/29/2007
From: Muscle Shoals, AL, USA
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: ferocious

I just saw on page 12 of the May issue of MA that I now have to compete in the foam wing business against the largest modelling organization in the world, and I practically have to be a member.

I've been cutting foam wings with CNC equipment, both custom and for our own kits, for 25 years. I really don't see how AMA, as a non-profit organization, can justify starting businesses that compete with their members own. Why not start building radios, hmmm??? The AMA is supposed to be a non-profit, educational organization. Cutting foam wings for sale just doesn't fit in with that. Selling trophies is a bit different, since nicely done aero trophies are hard to find almost everywhere. But even there, they are competing with several member run trophy houses that specialize in model aviation.

This is outrageous. With all the things AMA needs to be doing this not one of them.

(in reply to ferocious)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 5:10:46 PM

Posts: 4770
Joined: 4/28/2003
From: Brunswick, GA, USA
Status: offline

The current leadership is not interested in the actual mission of the AMA. It is profit oriented. With a declining membership, instead of cutting costs, they are looking for ways to increase income.
This is basically the same beef I have with them over the ad prices in MA. They will try to use leverage to put you out of business and take your market from you. I am sorry to see this happen.

_____________________________

HomeMachinist.net!
Ulmer-RC.com

(in reply to JUGFLIER)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 6:09:10 PM

Posts: 580
Joined: 12/26/2001
From: Pasadena, TX 77505/77508, TX, USA
Status: offline

As someone who is in the industry as well, I was very surprised to see this when I got the magazine. You reckon they are paying an employee to do this as part of his or her job description there at AMA? Or are they farming it out? I guess the next thing will be a line of Li-po batteries and brushless motors followed by a line of foamie arfs.

(in reply to ferocious)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 6:12:41 PM

Posts: 4770
Joined: 4/28/2003
From: Brunswick, GA, USA
Status: offline

The pictures looks like it's in-house.

_____________________________

HomeMachinist.net!
Ulmer-RC.com

(in reply to glowplugboy)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 9:58:43 PM

Posts: 462
Joined: 10/23/2004
From: MAnsfield, MA, USA
Status: offline

Ummm... Though I agree that the AMA probably shouldn't be getting into this, I have to say that I see this as no different than the trophies. A trophy store would have the same ability to do what the AMA is doing in regards to trophys. The AMA does not make the trophy parts, another company that specializes in trophy toppers does. The AMA just puts them together.
I see this type of increasing income a relatively good idea.
\Look increasing income while reducing costs is smart business. This is the same reason that a local government has their own electric company.
Now having said this I agree that the AMA needs to work on reducing costs and focusing their efforts in other ways, but if this income stream helps this process(which remains to be seen) than fine with me. It's better than raising the dues. I see no real issue with additonal revenue streams

_____________________________

"I haven't Forgotten"

(in reply to ptulmer)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 11:00:03 PM

Posts: 950
Joined: 12/22/2002
From: pinehurst, TX, USA
Status: offline

No you wouldn't see any problem with it as long as it did not hit you in your pocket. I cannot say it any better than fercious, mike or jugflier.

_____________________________

"WE WILL NEVER FORGET"

(in reply to SSRCCPREZ)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 11:04:44 PM

Posts: 9237
Joined: 3/12/2003
From: Manhattan, NY, USA
Status: offline

Not for nothing, but what's the difference between doing this and running ads in their magazine? You don't think they are pulling from the pockets of the other rags? If MA went down, those other publishers would be quite please with the new revs.

_____________________________

Here At The Wall

(in reply to PLANE JIM)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 11:15:32 PM

Posts: 3765
Joined: 3/8/2005
From: x, , USA
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: ferocious

I just saw on page 12 of the May issue of MA that I now have to compete in the foam wing business against the largest modelling organization in the world, and I practically have to be a member.

I've been cutting foam wings with CNC equipment, both custom and for our own kits, for 25 years. I really don't see how AMA, as a non-profit organization, can justify starting businesses that compete with their members own. Why not start building radios, hmmm??? The AMA is supposed to be a non-profit, educational organization. Cutting foam wings for sale just doesn't fit in with that. Selling trophies is a bit different, since nicely done aero trophies are hard to find almost everywhere. But even there, they are competing with several member run trophy houses that specialize in model aviation.

Ferocious,
While I have not seen the ad, I would agree based on what little I know. The AMA should stick to insurance and advertising model airplanes, and not selling products. After all, aren't they a 501-C3 organization?

50%

p.s. do you have a website for your business?

< Message edited by 50%plane -- 5/23/2007 4:45:58 PM >

_____________________________

Model Airplanes don't kill people. Chuck Norris kills people.
Christopher A. Todd AMA# 637636

(in reply to ferocious)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/22/2007 11:19:47 PM

Posts: 2228
Joined: 5/4/2005
From: Park Rapids, MN, USA
Status: offline

I agree, I think this is out of the AMA's realm of services it should be providing.

_____________________________

Mode One, AMA 59157

(in reply to 50%plane)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/23/2007 12:38:52 AM

Posts: 1648
Joined: 12/11/2003
From: El Paso, TX, USA
Status: offline

You all act surprised? The AMA stopped being what it needs to be for some time. The membership lost control years ago and its going to take a mass exodus to bring them in line. It started with the Muncie site (spending our money without asking) to losing its A$$ every month publishing that so called mag. The only thing there trying to promote is the bottom line. If they think cutting foam cores is the answer... they need to think again. But what the He$$ it anit there money.

(in reply to Mode One)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/23/2007 1:25:51 AM

Posts: 1136
Joined: 3/28/2006
From: Galveston, TX, USA
Status: offline

Thankyou for letting me know about this. I will take that in to consideration when and if I rejoin AMA.

(in reply to rcmiket)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/23/2007 1:53:41 AM

Posts: 462
Joined: 10/23/2004
From: MAnsfield, MA, USA
Status: offline

First and foremost, please do not think for a moment that I do not know about competition in the open market!!! I opwn a retail store and compete in retail against chain stores and the like, so before you make the assertion that the reason I do not see a problem with it is because it does not financially effect me think again!! Everytime someone goes to a Wal-Mart or big boxs store I feel it, and they do this to save a few dollars.
Second, if you cannot handle the competition than maybe the retail market is not for you. In business there is competition. I am sure that the AMA and you are not the only 2 dogs in the foam core yard, so please gimme a break!!
Third, the 501-C3 status has nothing to do with what they are doing, the money is still going to a non-profit organization. So lets drop that argument quick, because it is clear that if that is the argument, than it is lost before it has begun. You need to read what a 501-c3 can and cannot do before you throw that out there.
fourth, although I agree that they probably are delving into realms they ought not, if this revenue stream keeps dues stable and pays for more overhead, than great!! Stop complaining, if they did not try this first and just upped the dues you all would be screaming from the mountains.
Fifth, As I said before increasing revenue is only half the game, the AMA needs to cut costs as well. give them a chance. But for god sake stop the whining that they are financially effecting you. Anyone could potentially effect you financially!! This is called a FREE MARKET ECONOMY!!!
The AMA needs to fine tune the things they should be doing before getting into other avenues, no argument here, but if you have a problem with this, than why no problem with the banners trophies, t-shirt printing etc...... It's the same thing, you are not looking at this objectively.

_____________________________

"I haven't Forgotten"

(in reply to BUDMAN27)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/23/2007 3:04:48 AM

Posts: 955
Joined: 1/29/2007
From: Muscle Shoals, AL, USA
Status: offline

SSRCCprez, you overlook one serious problem. It look like AMA will be advertising their service in their magazine paid for by us the members FREE OF CHARGE. While ferocious will have to pay for the same advertising. Now AMA is not playing on the same field, advertising subsidized by you and me. That's not free market. That's called taking advantage of you and me. I don't want my dues paying for a business that another fellow modeler is capable of supplying without my subsidy.

(in reply to SSRCCPREZ)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/23/2007 4:24:03 AM

ira d

Posts: 830
Joined: 5/29/2003
From: Rancho Belago, CA, USA
Status: offline

Im not a big fan of the AMA but I see nothing wrong with them providing a service
to its members while at the same time bringing in more income.

_____________________________

Ira d

(in reply to JUGFLIER)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/23/2007 1:38:54 PM

Posts: 462
Joined: 10/23/2004
From: MAnsfield, MA, USA
Status: offline

Jug, the AMA loses money on MA every month as Hoss always let's us know. If the AMA does not increase evenue streams they will increase dues. As for your advertising,point, do you think I pay the same in advertising than does BesBuy,Saverite,Rite-aid,Staples, etc.? Do you thin I pay the same as them for the same products fromt he same manufacturer...NO, I don't. That IS a free market. Everyone has their own particular advantages. Your argument is that the ad space is free and Ferocious has to pay, therefore it's not fair........... I ask again what about the t-shirts, mugs, signs, trophies, plaques,plans printing, etc.? These are all advertised and are all found out in the open(free) market. There is NO difference.None whatsoever.
Again, I am thinking the AMA is swimming in the wrong pool, but I applaud the effort. Let's not be so quick to judge the AMA on EVERYTHING they do!!!
If you are so nhappy witht he foam cutting and other services, than by all means send them extra money for dues, because without the additional revenue streams they will have no choice but to increase the dues!! Be thankful they are using that as a las resort not a first!
HAving said this I again wills ay that YES they need to reduce costs as well, and Yes they probably need to focus on the things they are currently doing and work to do them betterbefore getting into other things, but to say they shouldn't do it because it efects other people in business is sily.

_____________________________

"I haven't Forgotten"

(in reply to JUGFLIER)

RE: Competing with AMA - 5/23/2007 9:25:25 PM

Posts: 1648
Joined: 12/11/2003
From: E