ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: huntington Woods,
MI
Posts: 234
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
I am very excited about 3d printing. I am sure that many RC goers are as well due to the ramifications that it would have for us. Like many similar technologies (substantial R/D and low cost of productions), these printers will cost as little as $200 or less in about 5 years. 3d printing CAD software will become incredibly simplified as well so that a typical consumer can easily just take a few pictures of the item they want and press start. I am wondering how it will change the R/C market though. Of course some people will chime and and state that it wont. Most of us know that is not true. Manufacturers and hobby stores make most of their Margin on parts as opposed to vehicles. Like many other businesses, they get by on a small percent margin. That margin will disappear without a market for standard replacement parts. Of course, not everything is plastic but more than enough is. Plastic parts of all grades will be easily re-produceable in home and the major manufacturers will not be sustainable under that business model. My concern is that even the largest manufacturers are very small companies. They likely lack the resources and talent required to re-tool their business model (This is just an assumption but it may not be correct). This might change the hobby but it will certainly not hurt it. It might even bring more people in. Nonetheless, I am concerned that we will loose some of our favorite companies.
What do you think?
What do you think?
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Akron, OH
Posts: 2,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
The parts are too weak, being made out of layered plastic, as opposed to molded, and are not suited for long term or heavy duty usage. The printers work by printing in layers, and would not hold up to any kind of heavy usage.
#3
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
i dont see these printers being used for most parts. not strong enough.
where I can see a area of rc they would be awsome for, is scale rock crawler parts. bumpers, light bars, jacks, coolers, guns ect. all the small scale details that cost a fair bit now as they come from big manfucturers. I mean, a kit with a few small scale bits is $15.
and think of a scale v8 motor for your scx10!
Blowers, winches, roll cages and more.
right now, we are limited by what the companies can come up with. unless you are skilled enough to to work with metal, your only option is to buy whats out there. but with 3d printer, if you can think it up and put it into cad you can then print it out of plastic and paint it.
could be very cool stuff.
where I can see a area of rc they would be awsome for, is scale rock crawler parts. bumpers, light bars, jacks, coolers, guns ect. all the small scale details that cost a fair bit now as they come from big manfucturers. I mean, a kit with a few small scale bits is $15.
and think of a scale v8 motor for your scx10!
Blowers, winches, roll cages and more.
right now, we are limited by what the companies can come up with. unless you are skilled enough to to work with metal, your only option is to buy whats out there. but with 3d printer, if you can think it up and put it into cad you can then print it out of plastic and paint it.
could be very cool stuff.
#4
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
I think its staples in europe is launching(been a long time since I read it so it might have launched already) a 3d printing service that uses a mind boggling number of (very thin) paper layers glued together with a resin to form the item, and they claimed its stronger then plywood in the press release I read. From what I remember reading the item that's printed can even be printed in full color so it has a huge benefits over traditional current 3d printing tech.
One thing it couldn't do though that resin based 3d printers can do way better is use say a wax to make a mold for metal casting.
One thing it couldn't do though that resin based 3d printers can do way better is use say a wax to make a mold for metal casting.
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: huntington Woods,
MI
Posts: 234
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
At first, I did not think the strength would be there either. Then I saw the story about the guy who 3d printed a functional fire arm. The chamber was a little thicker than a traditional gun but any plastic would have to be. The fact that it was able to shoot a bullet w/o exploding made me think twice.
#6
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: john2364
At first, I did not think the strength would be there either. Then I saw the story about the guy who 3d printed a functional fire arm. The chamber was a little thicker than a traditional gun but any plastic would have to be. The fact that it was able to shoot a bullet w/o exploding made me think twice.
At first, I did not think the strength would be there either. Then I saw the story about the guy who 3d printed a functional fire arm. The chamber was a little thicker than a traditional gun but any plastic would have to be. The fact that it was able to shoot a bullet w/o exploding made me think twice.
also have to remember the forces at work are way different.
#7
Senior Member
My Feedback: (9)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: White,
GA
Posts: 1,958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
Until they develop new materials for them I don't think parts would be strong enough, I saw a video/short documentary about a guy that was making free plans for ar-15 parts such as magazines, lowers ect and the last I heard they got about 100 rounds from the lower before it broke but they keep improving the design and the life keeps getting longer but the materials are just too weak.
#8
My Feedback: (1)
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
I heard the interview with that F***-Wit who designed, test fired, and posted the plans on-line. I couldn't believe my ears! Just what we need, more cheap guns.....NOT!! Now we can have kids and crazy people making their own! Brilliant. [:@] Jerk.
The fact that someone was able to make something like that implies the material can be made strong enough to handle an exploding bullet. But for how many times? And RC parts are not as solidly assembled as a firearm. Think suspension arm.
But for cosmetic RC items it'd probably be great.
The fact that someone was able to make something like that implies the material can be made strong enough to handle an exploding bullet. But for how many times? And RC parts are not as solidly assembled as a firearm. Think suspension arm.
But for cosmetic RC items it'd probably be great.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Akron, OH
Posts: 2,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
Got a problem with our given rights? If he wants to make it, let him. Besides, do you really think "kids and crazies" are going to go out of their way and spend the kind of coin to make one of these? Nah, gun shows work just fine, and are more affordable.
That being said, it is clear you have no clue about the workings of a firearm and the forces exerted. The gun did fire, for a while, but not for very long. Not even enough RDR from said gun to make it worth entertaining as a viable option. The thing simply did not hold up for very long, heat being one of its biggest enemies. I liken it to making a shiv in prison out of compressed toilet paper and water. You won't be doing much with it for very long.
That being said, it is clear you have no clue about the workings of a firearm and the forces exerted. The gun did fire, for a while, but not for very long. Not even enough RDR from said gun to make it worth entertaining as a viable option. The thing simply did not hold up for very long, heat being one of its biggest enemies. I liken it to making a shiv in prison out of compressed toilet paper and water. You won't be doing much with it for very long.
ORIGINAL: EXT2Rob
I heard the interview with that F***-Wit who designed, test fired, and posted the plans on-line. I couldn't believe my ears! Just what we need, more cheap guns.....NOT!! Now we can have kids and crazy people making their own! Brilliant. [:@] Jerk.
The fact that someone was able to make something like that implies the material can be made strong enough to handle an exploding bullet. But for how many times? And RC parts are not as solidly assembled as a firearm. Think suspension arm.
But for cosmetic RC items it'd probably be great.
I heard the interview with that F***-Wit who designed, test fired, and posted the plans on-line. I couldn't believe my ears! Just what we need, more cheap guns.....NOT!! Now we can have kids and crazy people making their own! Brilliant. [:@] Jerk.
The fact that someone was able to make something like that implies the material can be made strong enough to handle an exploding bullet. But for how many times? And RC parts are not as solidly assembled as a firearm. Think suspension arm.
But for cosmetic RC items it'd probably be great.
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: eastern,
IL
Posts: 3,951
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: EXT2Rob
I heard the interview with that F***-Wit who designed, test fired, and posted the plans on-line. I couldn't believe my ears! Just what we need, more cheap guns.....NOT!! Now we can have kids and crazy people making their own! Brilliant. [:@] Jerk.
The fact that someone was able to make something like that implies the material can be made strong enough to handle an exploding bullet. But for how many times? And RC parts are not as solidly assembled as a firearm. Think suspension arm.
But for cosmetic RC items it'd probably be great.
I heard the interview with that F***-Wit who designed, test fired, and posted the plans on-line. I couldn't believe my ears! Just what we need, more cheap guns.....NOT!! Now we can have kids and crazy people making their own! Brilliant. [:@] Jerk.
The fact that someone was able to make something like that implies the material can be made strong enough to handle an exploding bullet. But for how many times? And RC parts are not as solidly assembled as a firearm. Think suspension arm.
But for cosmetic RC items it'd probably be great.
#11
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: huntington Woods,
MI
Posts: 234
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
This seems to be going in a bad direction. Lets try to keep politics out of this and keep it about RC parts and the industry. The firearm was just an example but I do recognize that the forces exerted on a compression chamber are different from something like an A arm.
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: , ON, CANADA
Posts: 974
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
I saw a thread a few years ago highlighting a small scale indoor R/C aircraft - I believe it was an F6F Hellcat. The structure was entirely printed, with integral and servo and motor mounts. It was then covered with light weight film. Extremely cool and gives hugepossibilities for the prior mentioned scale details. Do I want a full scale interior for my Spitfire? Print it off as a single piece. Since then, there have been some highly publisised 3D printed drones and UAV's as well - including a model similar in size and appearance to a Kadet Senior.
I seriously believe that not only will 3D printers be commonplace in 15-20 years, but they will change our hobbies as well. The winners of Top Gun or the Nats won't be the best builders, but those who possess the most advanced CAD skills.
Graeme
#13
Senior Member
My Feedback: (9)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: White,
GA
Posts: 1,958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: EXT2Rob
I heard the interview with that F***-Wit who designed, test fired, and posted the plans on-line. I couldn't believe my ears! Just what we need, more cheap guns.....NOT!! Now we can have kids and crazy people making their own! Brilliant. [:@] Jerk.
The fact that someone was able to make something like that implies the material can be made strong enough to handle an exploding bullet. But for how many times? And RC parts are not as solidly assembled as a firearm. Think suspension arm.
But for cosmetic RC items it'd probably be great.
I heard the interview with that F***-Wit who designed, test fired, and posted the plans on-line. I couldn't believe my ears! Just what we need, more cheap guns.....NOT!! Now we can have kids and crazy people making their own! Brilliant. [:@] Jerk.
The fact that someone was able to make something like that implies the material can be made strong enough to handle an exploding bullet. But for how many times? And RC parts are not as solidly assembled as a firearm. Think suspension arm.
But for cosmetic RC items it'd probably be great.
#14
Senior Member
My Feedback: (9)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: White,
GA
Posts: 1,958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: GraemeEllis
I saw a thread a few years ago highlighting a small scale indoor R/C aircraft - I believe it was an F6F Hellcat. The structure was entirely printed, with integral and servo and motor mounts. It was then covered with light weight film. Extremely cool and gives huge possibilities for the prior mentioned scale details. Do I want a full scale interior for my Spitfire? Print it off as a single piece. Since then, there have been some highly publisised 3D printed drones and UAV's as well - including a model similar in size and appearance to a Kadet Senior.
I saw a thread a few years ago highlighting a small scale indoor R/C aircraft - I believe it was an F6F Hellcat. The structure was entirely printed, with integral and servo and motor mounts. It was then covered with light weight film. Extremely cool and gives huge possibilities for the prior mentioned scale details. Do I want a full scale interior for my Spitfire? Print it off as a single piece. Since then, there have been some highly publisised 3D printed drones and UAV's as well - including a model similar in size and appearance to a Kadet Senior.
I seriously believe that not only will 3D printers be commonplace in 15-20 years, but they will change our hobbies as well. The winners of Top Gun or the Nats won't be the best builders, but those who possess the most advanced CAD skills.
Graeme
#15
Senior Member
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
I just finished 3d printing a dual movable camera mount for a FPV plane my son and I are working on. We can now tilt both cameras down or straight ahead while in flight instead of using 4 camera's to get the same effect. I noticed a couple of things good and bad with 3D printing. This particular mount was designed completely on CAD with only minimal measuring of the camera's and location ahead of time and the accuracy is perfect. If you can dream it, you can fabricate it on the printer. This printer layers the material and bonds it together in very thin layers forming the item. It seems to be vey durable, but due to the way its made the items are thicker than I would have liked in order to keep the structure stable. Being on a very large FPV plane its not really an issue buton a smaller structural part... Not there yet. I was told they can use ABS plastic and its thinner, but still not as strong as the nylon/plastic blends we currently use. But that will be available eventually and thats when these printers will come into their own.. its getting there and will be soon.. I can think of so many things I would love to print.. but everything I need is structural..
#16
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
duct tape one would probably last more than 1-2 shots too.
Or go get a metal lath and make one...
Now to get to topic (or a topic) how high do you think traxxas will raise prices when people start printing parts as it will cut into their replacement parts income
duct tape one would probably last more than 1-2 shots too.
Or go get a metal lath and make one...
Now to get to topic (or a topic) how high do you think traxxas will raise prices when people start printing parts as it will cut into their replacement parts income
#17
Senior Member
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
Well, one possibility for 3D printing is building extremely precise tooling parts.......male parts that can then be molded into useful molds. Fuselages, wings, stabs, rudders, wheel pants, landing gear, literaly any component that we currently require to complete a model, can be molded with extreme precision.
Once the molds are done (in record time, with minimal work) parts that are cast will be more precise than almost anything available today, (excepting APC propellers probably). The biggest advantage is in refining individual parts.... making changes will be far simpler.
Once the molds are done (in record time, with minimal work) parts that are cast will be more precise than almost anything available today, (excepting APC propellers probably). The biggest advantage is in refining individual parts.... making changes will be far simpler.
#18
Senior Member
My Feedback: (9)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: White,
GA
Posts: 1,958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: SyCo_VeNoM
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
duct tape one would probably last more than 1-2 shots too.
Or go get a metal lath and make one...
Now to get to topic (or a topic) how high do you think traxxas will raise prices when people start printing parts as it will cut into their replacement parts income
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
duct tape one would probably last more than 1-2 shots too.
Or go get a metal lath and make one...
Now to get to topic (or a topic) how high do you think traxxas will raise prices when people start printing parts as it will cut into their replacement parts income
#19
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: MTK
Well, one possibility for 3D printing is building extremely precise tooling parts.......male parts that can then be molded into useful molds. Fuselages, wings, stabs, rudders, wheel pants, landing gear, literaly any component that we currently require to complete a model, can be molded with extreme precision.
Once the molds are done (in record time, with minimal work) parts that are cast will be more precise than almost anything available today, (excepting APC propellers probably). The biggest advantage is in refining individual parts.... making changes will be far simpler.
Well, one possibility for 3D printing is building extremely precise tooling parts.......male parts that can then be molded into useful molds. Fuselages, wings, stabs, rudders, wheel pants, landing gear, literaly any component that we currently require to complete a model, can be molded with extreme precision.
Once the molds are done (in record time, with minimal work) parts that are cast will be more precise than almost anything available today, (excepting APC propellers probably). The biggest advantage is in refining individual parts.... making changes will be far simpler.
MAKING CAR BODIES
think about it get a 3d scanner (yes they have them, and I saw one that was made dirt cheap with common parts) then get a matchbox car in the design you want (or even a model car) and use the scanner to scan it in. Then you can use cad software to manipulate it to the size you need to fit a chassis. After that print it up, and use it to form a lexan shell as vacuum forming machines are quite cheap and easy to make.
#20
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: huntington Woods,
MI
Posts: 234
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
This was pretty much my point, once the tech and materials get there, the major rc manufacturers will probably be wiped out. These are not large companies and the do not likely have the capital to maintain long while operating at a loss. For example, apple is going to be pretty screwed as cloud becomes more consumer friendly. They make major profits by selling over priced proprietary hardware. Cloud computing prohibits most proprietary hardware so they will and are changing their business model. Apple has the resources and capital to handle this. A 50 to 200 employee rc manufacture with low gp (even the big guys are tiny in the general market place) does not have the capital. I also doubt that they have the business talent either. Their market is not really big enough to justify employing this talent resource. My prediction is that it will have a drastic change in the market.
ORIGINAL: SyCo_VeNoM
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
duct tape one would probably last more than 1-2 shots too.
Or go get a metal lath and make one...
Now to get to topic (or a topic) how high do you think traxxas will raise prices when people start printing parts as it will cut into their replacement parts income
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
duct tape one would probably last more than 1-2 shots too.
Or go get a metal lath and make one...
Now to get to topic (or a topic) how high do you think traxxas will raise prices when people start printing parts as it will cut into their replacement parts income
#21
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: john2364
This was pretty much my point, once the tech and materials get there, the major rc manufacturers will probably be wiped out. These are not large companies and the do not likely have the capital to maintain long while operating at a loss. For example, apple is going to be pretty screwed as cloud becomes more consumer friendly. They make major profits by selling over priced proprietary hardware. Cloud computing prohibits most proprietary hardware so they will and are changing their business model. Apple has the resources and capital to handle this. A 50 to 200 employee rc manufacture with low gp (even the big guys are tiny in the general market place) does not have the capital. I also doubt that they have the business talent either. Their market is not really big enough to justify employing this talent resource. My prediction is that it will have a drastic change in the market.
This was pretty much my point, once the tech and materials get there, the major rc manufacturers will probably be wiped out. These are not large companies and the do not likely have the capital to maintain long while operating at a loss. For example, apple is going to be pretty screwed as cloud becomes more consumer friendly. They make major profits by selling over priced proprietary hardware. Cloud computing prohibits most proprietary hardware so they will and are changing their business model. Apple has the resources and capital to handle this. A 50 to 200 employee rc manufacture with low gp (even the big guys are tiny in the general market place) does not have the capital. I also doubt that they have the business talent either. Their market is not really big enough to justify employing this talent resource. My prediction is that it will have a drastic change in the market.
ORIGINAL: SyCo_VeNoM
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
duct tape one would probably last more than 1-2 shots too.
Or go get a metal lath and make one...
Now to get to topic (or a topic) how high do you think traxxas will raise prices when people start printing parts as it will cut into their replacement parts income
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
duct tape one would probably last more than 1-2 shots too.
Or go get a metal lath and make one...
Now to get to topic (or a topic) how high do you think traxxas will raise prices when people start printing parts as it will cut into their replacement parts income
like traxxas ever needed a reason to raise prices
Honestly though I don't see it cutting in at all really. As the people who would print their parts and make them strong enough to work, are the same people that would just make the parts out of aluminum sheets or other materials currently.
Lets face it think about how many people have issues trying to use a gfx editor to resize a picture on this site. Now imagine the same people trying to learn to use cad to design a part to be printed
so they MIGHT have a 1% sales drop but I do not see it as anything serious at all.
Great example is look at RPM they aren't putting the RC companies under with their parts as they are more durable then the stocks, and in a lot of cases cheaper too. Look at how RPM has almost every part for a traxas vehicle(isn't the chassis like the only thing they never made?), and how traxxas is still doing great in business.
Now it would help people like me who like to build their own RCs from scratch just so they can see their creation come to life.
#23
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
Not saying it isn't impressive, but honestly for how much it probably cost to make in materials a cheap tamiya that could take way more abuse could have been bought. I know cost savings wasn't the point, but I'm saying more for the common joe not someone that just wants to do it to prove a point, or for the fun of it
#24
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Akron, OH
Posts: 2,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: SyCo_VeNoM
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
as you can make a cannon that can fire from duct tape, I'm sure you can do the same with a gun. That would be even cheaper and easier to do then a 3d printer
Can make a twelve gauge "zip gun" out of two pieces of piping and a screw
#25
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: eastern,
IL
Posts: 3,951
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: ramifications of 3d printing on RC market
ORIGINAL: SyCo_VeNoM
just gave me a great idea on a use
MAKING CAR BODIES
think about it get a 3d scanner (yes they have them, and I saw one that was made dirt cheap with common parts) then get a matchbox car in the design you want (or even a model car) and use the scanner to scan it in. Then you can use cad software to manipulate it to the size you need to fit a chassis. After that print it up, and use it to form a lexan shell as vacuum forming machines are quite cheap and easy to make.
ORIGINAL: MTK
Well, one possibility for 3D printing is building extremely precise tooling parts.......male parts that can then be molded into useful molds. Fuselages, wings, stabs, rudders, wheel pants, landing gear, literaly any component that we currently require to complete a model, can be molded with extreme precision.
Once the molds are done (in record time, with minimal work) parts that are cast will be more precise than almost anything available today, (excepting APC propellers probably). The biggest advantage is in refining individual parts.... making changes will be far simpler.
Well, one possibility for 3D printing is building extremely precise tooling parts.......male parts that can then be molded into useful molds. Fuselages, wings, stabs, rudders, wheel pants, landing gear, literaly any component that we currently require to complete a model, can be molded with extreme precision.
Once the molds are done (in record time, with minimal work) parts that are cast will be more precise than almost anything available today, (excepting APC propellers probably). The biggest advantage is in refining individual parts.... making changes will be far simpler.
MAKING CAR BODIES
think about it get a 3d scanner (yes they have them, and I saw one that was made dirt cheap with common parts) then get a matchbox car in the design you want (or even a model car) and use the scanner to scan it in. Then you can use cad software to manipulate it to the size you need to fit a chassis. After that print it up, and use it to form a lexan shell as vacuum forming machines are quite cheap and easy to make.