Brushless Motor Information
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Collierville, TN
Posts: 116
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Brushless Motor Information
So I know nothing about Brushless motors basically. I know lower KV gives you more torque..... but I am not interested in that. I want to buy a HIGH-KV motor and try it out in my VXL-Rustler for speed runs. I have the Anaconda REAR tires, stock FRONT tires.
So I believe the highest KV Motor I have found.... which will not work with my VXL ESC because it is sensored is 10650KV(but the Orion goes down to 2.5T so maybe thats higher?)
Hyperion RC Car Swift SENSORED Brushless Motor $79.95 Bishop Power Products http://www.b-p-p.com (I bought a mamba max combo from them for $155)
So I believe the highest KV Motor I have found.... which will not work with my VXL ESC because it is sensored is 10650KV(but the Orion goes down to 2.5T so maybe thats higher?)
Hyperion RC Car Swift SENSORED Brushless Motor $79.95 Bishop Power Products http://www.b-p-p.com (I bought a mamba max combo from them for $155)
- [*]4900 KV[*]5850 KV[*]7150 KV[*]7990 KV[*]9130 KV[*]10650 KV[/list]Orion Vortex ProRace Brushless Motor $84.95 http://www.stormerhobbies.com
- [*]2.5T[*]3.0T[*]3.5T[*]4.0T[*]4.5T[*]5.5T[*]6.5T[*]8.5T[*]9.5T[/list]Castle Creations Mamba Max $77.95 StormerHobbies
- [*]4600 KV[*]5700 KV[*]6900 KV[*]7700 KV[/list]Hacker Brushless E40 $74.95 StormerHobbies
- [*]3.5T = 9320 KV[*]4.5T = 7200 KV[*]5.5T = 5800KV[/list]So is it even plausible to go with a 2.0T or 2.5T motor?(9000 - 10000+KV) I understand it will get hot, I just want to see what it will do and how fast it would run on my Turnigy 5000mAh 2S1P. Those are just some motors I found while at work(They have crappy filters so I can't surf most websites). Any other suggestions for good motors?
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Arlington,
TX
Posts: 3,344
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
The reason why you dont want to use high Kv motors wtih just 7 volts for speed runs is in the long run they DO heat up, most do too much, too often, literally within 5 minutes. They may be fun, but you'll just heat things up in pursuit of speed that way.
You want a low Kv motor with HIGH voltage, to make up for the low rpm rating per volt. This is done with the motor geared low so the extra voltage will give it speed, and usually the best way to run COOLER and more efficient, generally without as much amp draw and the resulting heat that plagues uber high Kv motors.
Try to run a 8-10,000 Kv motor in anything but a 2-3 lbs on-road sedan geared for anything but useful practical speed AND not overheat. I think you'll find it next to impossible. Unless you literally just want to drive the car for 2 minutes up and down the street at 60-70 mph before causing overheating in many different components, with not real control other than straight line driving.
With a low Kv motor such as the VXL 3500 kv motor, and 3s lipo you have the ability to start off with slower speeds at first, and work yuor way up the gearing and voltage from 2s to 3s until you heat things up too much and find your peak performance.
You want a low Kv motor with HIGH voltage, to make up for the low rpm rating per volt. This is done with the motor geared low so the extra voltage will give it speed, and usually the best way to run COOLER and more efficient, generally without as much amp draw and the resulting heat that plagues uber high Kv motors.
Try to run a 8-10,000 Kv motor in anything but a 2-3 lbs on-road sedan geared for anything but useful practical speed AND not overheat. I think you'll find it next to impossible. Unless you literally just want to drive the car for 2 minutes up and down the street at 60-70 mph before causing overheating in many different components, with not real control other than straight line driving.
With a low Kv motor such as the VXL 3500 kv motor, and 3s lipo you have the ability to start off with slower speeds at first, and work yuor way up the gearing and voltage from 2s to 3s until you heat things up too much and find your peak performance.
#3
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Collierville, TN
Posts: 116
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
I think my rustler is a bit slow on the 3500KV motor it comes with... but then again I am running 2S1P. My 4600kV 2WD Slash seems to go faster than my VXL Rustler.... unless I am mistaken. I would actually like to go 4S just for the hell of it, but neither of my trucks can handle 4S.
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: SA, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 668
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
for any off road vehicle, even for on road speed runs, you'll want something in the range of 2500 - 4500kv, off 3s or 4s.
I was running a 3500kv in my firestorm, off 3s it did 100kph, so, I tried 4s, and got to 107kph (66 miles per hour) but the shell creates massive issues at these speeds, and removing it just makes it worse.
I suggest you start with a 3500kv and 3s, get to 100kph like this, and see what the truck does at those speeds!
I was running a 3500kv in my firestorm, off 3s it did 100kph, so, I tried 4s, and got to 107kph (66 miles per hour) but the shell creates massive issues at these speeds, and removing it just makes it worse.
I suggest you start with a 3500kv and 3s, get to 100kph like this, and see what the truck does at those speeds!
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: SA, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 668
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
ORIGINAL: theunleet
I think my rustler is a bit slow on the 3500KV motor it comes with... but then again I am running 2S1P. My 4600kV 2WD Slash seems to go faster than my VXL Rustler.... unless I am mistaken. I would actually like to go 4S just for the hell of it, but neither of my trucks can handle 4S.
I think my rustler is a bit slow on the 3500KV motor it comes with... but then again I am running 2S1P. My 4600kV 2WD Slash seems to go faster than my VXL Rustler.... unless I am mistaken. I would actually like to go 4S just for the hell of it, but neither of my trucks can handle 4S.
if the esc can't handle 4s, get a $50 hobby king 100amp esc
#6
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Collierville, TN
Posts: 116
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
I don't have 3S or 4S Lipos yet. That will be my next HK order. Possibly thishttp://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/uh_viewItem.asp?idProduct=11939TURNIGYnano-tech6000MAH 3S 25~50C LIPO PACKorhttp://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/uh_viewItem.asp?idProduct=11940TURNIGYnano-tech6000MAH 4S 25~50C LIPO PACK
Any idea if the new nano-tech stuff is good? I bought a 5000mAh 2S1P hardcase pack and LOVE it.
Any idea if the new nano-tech stuff is good? I bought a 5000mAh 2S1P hardcase pack and LOVE it.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: SA, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 668
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
ORIGINAL: theunleet
I am aiming for HIGH on-road speeds, but then be able to bash it around in the yard and elsewhere.
I am aiming for HIGH on-road speeds, but then be able to bash it around in the yard and elsewhere.
#10
Senior Member
My Feedback: (325)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: LaGrange, OH
Posts: 14,857
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
Plug the numbers into here along with desired speed and do it anyway you want. Low voltage x high kv or low kv and high voltage. Or a little of both.
http://www.scriptasylum.com/rc_speed/_top_speed.html
http://www.scriptasylum.com/rc_speed/_top_speed.html
#11
RE: Brushless Motor Information
you can get a lower KV motor, but gear it up much higher and run it on 3s lipo. the vxl system can get your traxxas upto 75mph with the max gearing and a 3s lipo.
and if you want to do high-speed and run off road the a low KV motor is the way to go. just change the size of the pinion gear. a 18t pinion on my vxl will get me 35mph even in the grass without overheating anything. but then i can put on a 25t pinion for much higher top speeds on the street. i have never even bothered to put on the smaller spur gear. my rusty does alittle better than 50mph with a medium gearing and thats plenty of speed for me.
and if you want to do high-speed and run off road the a low KV motor is the way to go. just change the size of the pinion gear. a 18t pinion on my vxl will get me 35mph even in the grass without overheating anything. but then i can put on a 25t pinion for much higher top speeds on the street. i have never even bothered to put on the smaller spur gear. my rusty does alittle better than 50mph with a medium gearing and thats plenty of speed for me.
#13
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Anderson,
CA
Posts: 157
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
My $.02:
A motor with more poles will give you more torque. So if you have a couple of motors with the same KV rating and one is 2 poles while the other is 6 poles, the 6 pole motor will have the greatest torque.
I think it would make sense to choose a *lower KV, higher pole motor for your application. The lower KV would do well for keeping speed manageable on the dirt and you would have plenty of torque. The greater torque would also enable you to gear up for on-road if you like, without excessive worry about over-gearing. Of course, you will still need to pay attention to motor temperatures as a final rule. So if you are looking for a motor to drive on-road and off-road, a low KV, higher pole motor may give you the most flexibility when it comes to a greater range of gearing for performance within the different environments you mentioned while keeping the voltage the same.
*By lower KV I don't mean excessively lower. I would stay close to, but still lower than, the recommended KV rating of a 2 pole motor for your specific vehicle. Most vehicle specific KV suggestions are for 2 pole motors.
A motor with more poles will give you more torque. So if you have a couple of motors with the same KV rating and one is 2 poles while the other is 6 poles, the 6 pole motor will have the greatest torque.
I think it would make sense to choose a *lower KV, higher pole motor for your application. The lower KV would do well for keeping speed manageable on the dirt and you would have plenty of torque. The greater torque would also enable you to gear up for on-road if you like, without excessive worry about over-gearing. Of course, you will still need to pay attention to motor temperatures as a final rule. So if you are looking for a motor to drive on-road and off-road, a low KV, higher pole motor may give you the most flexibility when it comes to a greater range of gearing for performance within the different environments you mentioned while keeping the voltage the same.
*By lower KV I don't mean excessively lower. I would stay close to, but still lower than, the recommended KV rating of a 2 pole motor for your specific vehicle. Most vehicle specific KV suggestions are for 2 pole motors.
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Arlington,
TX
Posts: 3,344
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
ORIGINAL: HRCules77
My $.02:
A motor with more poles will give you more torque. So if you have a couple of motors with the same KV rating and one is 2 poles while the other is 6 poles, the 6 pole motor will have the greatest torque.
I think it would make sense to choose a *lower KV, higher pole motor for your application. The lower KV would do well for keeping speed manageable on the dirt and you would have plenty of torque. The greater torque would also enable you to gear up for on-road if you like, without excessive worry about over-gearing. Of course, you will still need to pay attention to motor temperatures as a final rule. So if you are looking for a motor to drive on-road and off-road, a low KV, higher pole motor may give you the most flexibility when it comes to a greater range of gearing for performance within the different environments you mentioned while keeping the voltage the same.
*By lower KV I don't mean excessively lower. I would stay close to, but still lower than, the recommended KV rating of a 2 pole motor for your specific vehicle. Most vehicle specific KV suggestions are for 2 pole motors.
My $.02:
A motor with more poles will give you more torque. So if you have a couple of motors with the same KV rating and one is 2 poles while the other is 6 poles, the 6 pole motor will have the greatest torque.
I think it would make sense to choose a *lower KV, higher pole motor for your application. The lower KV would do well for keeping speed manageable on the dirt and you would have plenty of torque. The greater torque would also enable you to gear up for on-road if you like, without excessive worry about over-gearing. Of course, you will still need to pay attention to motor temperatures as a final rule. So if you are looking for a motor to drive on-road and off-road, a low KV, higher pole motor may give you the most flexibility when it comes to a greater range of gearing for performance within the different environments you mentioned while keeping the voltage the same.
*By lower KV I don't mean excessively lower. I would stay close to, but still lower than, the recommended KV rating of a 2 pole motor for your specific vehicle. Most vehicle specific KV suggestions are for 2 pole motors.
Here are 2 very common examples. My Feigao 7XL 2-pole motor (36x75mm size) is ~2300 Kv and rated to handle about ~94 amps max. That means at that amp draw, it is able to put out about 53 in-oz of torque. Similarly sized Medusa 36-70 motor 2300 Kv is rated for a maximum of 118 amps, which gives you a torque rating of 69 in-oz. On top of that the Medusa happens to be more efficient in design so it can put more of that power down to the wheels instead of converting it to wasted heat, without getting too complicated.
The reason a multi-pole motor is better and preferred however, is because it is more smoother at putting out power. That is due to the increased rate of "commutation" or switching, of the motor's wire coil polarity (the "poles") since there are more of them so the rotor turns in more "controlled" smaller increments. Think of it as having a smoother powerband.
Your part about using a low Kv motor for off-road is correct. It is generally more manageable. Also a 4 pole motor (such as Neu, Medusa, Aveox etc.) will put this power down better than a Hacker 2-pole motor would so you don't get that uncontrolled unpredictable burst of power as much.
#15
Senior Member
My Feedback: (2)
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: boca raton ,
FL
Posts: 1,105
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Brushless Motor Information
yeah and if you havent even seen the vxl on 3s than i would hold off on dumping more money into it, i ran my srt a few weeks running a vxl w/ 3s pack geared 24/83 and ill tell you what, that sucker moved! it squated for a seconed as the slipper wound out and then the car floated by, idk how fast (ill ball park it at 55+) and its a beast to handle, the amount of actual tire on the ground is minimal so the slighltest thing can upset it (thats why i say floated), its insane. then the next day, same gearing on 2s i went and spanked some t4's at the track, 3rd in the heat and 1st in the main
good example of how the cars goes at its limits http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vVtK_...eature=related
good example of how the cars goes at its limits http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vVtK_...eature=related