New Turbine on The Block
#1
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Mercersburg, PA
Posts: 773
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
New Turbine on The Block
#4
RE: New Turbine on The Block
Yep, that's the same ET that was banned from RCU.
Do follow the link to his site & read his rant paralleling cars & turbines as he bags the countries where
the more established turbines are made.
He didn't let the facts get in the way of a good story.
Is he for real? - John.
Do follow the link to his site & read his rant paralleling cars & turbines as he bags the countries where
the more established turbines are made.
He didn't let the facts get in the way of a good story.
Is he for real? - John.
#6
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Latrobe,
PA
Posts: 2,326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
ORIGINAL: bigplumbs
With all these new Turbines comming to market you have to wonder if building them is not actually a little easier them many would like us to believe
Dennis
With all these new Turbines comming to market you have to wonder if building them is not actually a little easier them many would like us to believe
Dennis
In reality... it is. All the real engineering has been done. We know the tolerances, and the materials that need to be used. The only reason JJ got such a bad wrap, is because they tried to use cheap materials.
In my short visit to the dark side (playing with turbines) the only company that did a new design is King Tech. As far as I know... they are the only guys using the diffuser as the fuel manifold, and spraying into J-tubes. Everyone else uses a tube manifold, and sprays into straight evaporators. Honestly... I like KingTech's design better. You have a longer tube to possess the fuel... but the bigger tubes do occupy a lot of room in the combustion chamber.
The hard part is building a good ecu... and Xcioy already makes a good universal unit, at a good price.
Mind you... this is coming from a Physicist, that got tired of being in a lab, and opened a machine shop. If the materials weren't so expensive... I would probably experiment with building my own engine.
#7
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Mercersburg, PA
Posts: 773
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
This just reminds me of the amount of companies producing turbines that have come and gone over the past ten years. It seems they run an ad for a year or so never to be seen again after that period of time. I think it's harder then they think to compete in the R/C Turbine Business.
Turbine companies that have died
I-Jets
RAM
FTE
JetJoe Copy "Forget the name?"
I know there is more
Turbine companies that have died
I-Jets
RAM
FTE
JetJoe Copy "Forget the name?"
I know there is more
#8
My Feedback: (8)
RE: New Turbine on The Block
At one point back in 2004 there were over 30 different turbine manufacturers. More than the traditional 2-stroke engine.
Wasn't it Easytiger who told us all the companies who were selling turbines for over $1000 were ripping us off? HA! I love it.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
Wasn't it Easytiger who told us all the companies who were selling turbines for over $1000 were ripping us off? HA! I love it.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
#9
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Co. Donegal, IRELAND
Posts: 2,760
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
I am all for new turbines as competition is good for us the customer, the Italians will do a good job in regard to the product quality, but if you are entering a market of strong manuf loyalties you need to have an edge.
I cant see any reason that would make me buy one of these turbines over others, especially when for example you have say the Testarossa speed 12 turbine which is (with kero start) the same price as a Merlin 140 which has 3lb more thrust, and comes from a manuf who is highly regarded with a proven track record and reliability.
When kingtech came into the market they said we will give you a reliable turbine at affordable price, the K80 is that, so they sold loads.
If you are coming into the market you need to give us something, better price, smaller turbine, more thrust. Look at the VT80 or K80 to see how it should be done.
I cant see any reason that would make me buy one of these turbines over others, especially when for example you have say the Testarossa speed 12 turbine which is (with kero start) the same price as a Merlin 140 which has 3lb more thrust, and comes from a manuf who is highly regarded with a proven track record and reliability.
When kingtech came into the market they said we will give you a reliable turbine at affordable price, the K80 is that, so they sold loads.
If you are coming into the market you need to give us something, better price, smaller turbine, more thrust. Look at the VT80 or K80 to see how it should be done.
#10
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: ferrara, ITALY
Posts: 1,567
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
#12
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Latrobe,
PA
Posts: 2,326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
ORIGINAL: John Redman
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
I was unaware that AMT used J tubes. My AT-180 is old ('94 vintage) I guess it has them then.
ORIGINAL: Mike06659
I think it's harder then they think to compete in the R/C Turbine Business.
I think it's harder then they think to compete in the R/C Turbine Business.
That's the key. Making an engine wouldn't be hard... but to be competitive, and to recoup your investment on the initial production run would be the hard thing.
AND... as you guys already said... to get a foot hold in a market with loyal customers is hard. KingTech was able to get that because they came out 30% under market price with a good turbine. (that should be the key right there) Heck... JJ still sells engines because they are so darn cheap.
I think it would be tough to build a low production run of engines, and be less than $1k retail. The only way that could happen is to sell direct... but then you would loose your world market. Remember... the importer, and the dealer both want to make $$$.
Sorry... I guess I got off topic. But, no... for the price... I won't be buying one.
#13
RE: New Turbine on The Block
ORIGINAL: Mike06659
This just reminds me of the amount of companies producing turbines that have come and gone over the past ten years. It seems they run an ad for a year or so never to be seen again after that period of time. I think it's harder then they think to compete in the R/C Turbine Business.
Turbine companies that have died
I-Jets
RAM
FTE
JetJoe Copy ''Forget the name?''
I know there is more
This just reminds me of the amount of companies producing turbines that have come and gone over the past ten years. It seems they run an ad for a year or so never to be seen again after that period of time. I think it's harder then they think to compete in the R/C Turbine Business.
Turbine companies that have died
I-Jets
RAM
FTE
JetJoe Copy ''Forget the name?''
I know there is more
Are you talking about these I-Jets Turbines? [link=http://www.i-complete.com.my/i-jets/listproducts.php?catid=1&cattxt=Engines]I-Jets[/link]
Geez, maybe I should call the factory to see if they are still producing, oh wait I don't have to as I have you to keep me up to date on what my manufacturer is doing. Thanks for the info Mike.
Ps. I think you'll find they are still producing engines if you cared to get the facts.
#14
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Latrobe,
PA
Posts: 2,326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
I don't know the inside story... the the US distributor (Dreamworks) no longer carries them, and on thier web site, it says.... "Due to lack of manufacturer availability of the Mamba engines; we have decided to discontinue carrying I-Complete Products. "
That doesn't sound too positive that they are still in biz. I guess Todd would have the real story.
That doesn't sound too positive that they are still in biz. I guess Todd would have the real story.
#16
My Feedback: (39)
RE: New Turbine on The Block
ORIGINAL: John Redman
At one point back in 2004 there were over 30 different turbine manufacturers. More than the traditional 2-stroke engine.
Wasn't it Easytiger who told us all the companies who were selling turbines for over $1000 were ripping us off? HA! I love it.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
At one point back in 2004 there were over 30 different turbine manufacturers. More than the traditional 2-stroke engine.
Wasn't it Easytiger who told us all the companies who were selling turbines for over $1000 were ripping us off? HA! I love it.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
I would rather see the current mfrs come with better and lower cost solutions such as the VT80 from Jets Munt than new brands that have no real commerical incentive to swtich to.
PaulD
#17
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Mercersburg, PA
Posts: 773
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
molo_30
The information I read was from the Dreamworks site as Dr. Honda stated as well but if there still going strong that is great as competition is good.
As for the new turbine on the block you cannot come in at these prices and expect to sell turbines. I think they need to re-think their business plan.
The information I read was from the Dreamworks site as Dr. Honda stated as well but if there still going strong that is great as competition is good.
As for the new turbine on the block you cannot come in at these prices and expect to sell turbines. I think they need to re-think their business plan.
#18
My Feedback: (349)
RE: New Turbine on The Block
Somehow, I think this company is going to have a copyright issue with Ferrari for using the Testarossa name.
And I like the way their write-up drifted from fresh mozzarella and canelloni, to pizza, Mercedes, taxis, Jaguars, cement cookie-cutter homes, aged oak from the Forest of Nottingham, the VW Beetle, and boring jobs to these turbines. I can't believe they forgot to write about the space shuttle program and somehow tie that in!
And I like the way their write-up drifted from fresh mozzarella and canelloni, to pizza, Mercedes, taxis, Jaguars, cement cookie-cutter homes, aged oak from the Forest of Nottingham, the VW Beetle, and boring jobs to these turbines. I can't believe they forgot to write about the space shuttle program and somehow tie that in!
#19
My Feedback: (57)
RE: New Turbine on The Block
ORIGINAL: PaulD
There's still too many turbine mfrs IMO....
I would rather see the current mfrs come with better and lower cost solutions such as the VT80 from Jets Munt than new brands that have no real commerical incentive to swtich to.
PaulD
ORIGINAL: John Redman
At one point back in 2004 there were over 30 different turbine manufacturers. More than the traditional 2-stroke engine.
Wasn't it Easytiger who told us all the companies who were selling turbines for over $1000 were ripping us off? HA! I love it.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
At one point back in 2004 there were over 30 different turbine manufacturers. More than the traditional 2-stroke engine.
Wasn't it Easytiger who told us all the companies who were selling turbines for over $1000 were ripping us off? HA! I love it.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
I would rather see the current mfrs come with better and lower cost solutions such as the VT80 from Jets Munt than new brands that have no real commerical incentive to swtich to.
PaulD
#21
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Latrobe,
PA
Posts: 2,326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
ORIGINAL: rcguy59
I can't help but think that this company didn't do any research on the U.S. market. If they had, they'd have chosen a different distributor. ANY different distributor.
I can't help but think that this company didn't do any research on the U.S. market. If they had, they'd have chosen a different distributor. ANY different distributor.
Todd (Deamworks) made mention in a different thread that they wanted him to carry their engines... but he too said there was nothing special, and the price was too high, and he felt there wasn't going to be a market for those engines in the USA.
#22
RE: New Turbine on The Block
How can you take Curtis seriously with thoughts like this from him?
**Quote from the intro**
I mean, you can buy a turbine made in GERMANY, they are fine, in a mundane, workaday kind of way, like a Mercedes, which is commonly used a a TAXI in many countries...they are fine, reliable choices for colorless middle-manager types that work for Mittelstand-type industrial machinery corporations like Werner and Pfleiderer in Dusseldorf, who just want to go back and forth to work to and from their cookie-cutter cement houses every day, until they retire or go postal and take out the whole neighborhood...I mean, that's fine, if that's all you want out of life, basic German-type transportation and German-type style...when you say "style" and "German" in the same sentence, that's like saying "love song" and "German" in the same sentence, it just does not work..." **
**Quote from the intro**
I mean, you can buy a turbine made in GERMANY, they are fine, in a mundane, workaday kind of way, like a Mercedes, which is commonly used a a TAXI in many countries...they are fine, reliable choices for colorless middle-manager types that work for Mittelstand-type industrial machinery corporations like Werner and Pfleiderer in Dusseldorf, who just want to go back and forth to work to and from their cookie-cutter cement houses every day, until they retire or go postal and take out the whole neighborhood...I mean, that's fine, if that's all you want out of life, basic German-type transportation and German-type style...when you say "style" and "German" in the same sentence, that's like saying "love song" and "German" in the same sentence, it just does not work..." **
#23
RE: New Turbine on The Block
ORIGINAL: Airplanes400
Somehow, I think this company is going to have a copyright issue with Ferrari for using the Testarossa name.
Somehow, I think this company is going to have a copyright issue with Ferrari for using the Testarossa name.
Sadly, another failed post by AP4. [8D]
"testarossa' is an adjective in Italian, and not a proper name.
#24
RE: New Turbine on The Block
ORIGINAL: John Redman
At one point back in 2004 there were over 30 different turbine manufacturers. More than the traditional 2-stroke engine.
Wasn't it Easytiger who told us all the companies who were selling turbines for over $1000 were ripping us off? HA! I love it.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
At one point back in 2004 there were over 30 different turbine manufacturers. More than the traditional 2-stroke engine.
Wasn't it Easytiger who told us all the companies who were selling turbines for over $1000 were ripping us off? HA! I love it.
J tubes used first by AMT netherlands and AMT USA back in the late 1990's. Not a Kingtech first, but a copy. Heck we had them in our first P-200 that was on my KingCat back in 2004 as well. Canged thos out real fast.
Barry
#25
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: SevenoaksKent, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 5,193
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: New Turbine on The Block
Guys, guys, guys, c'mon!! What we should all be wanting from a brand new range of turbines is 78 lines of utter nonsense introducing us to all their merits
Oh, and unfortunately, Italian cars are well known for having loads of history, passion, emotion but crap reliability and build quality!!! Heck, even my spanking new Ferrari had to go back in 2 or 3 times for stupid faults (alarm that set itself off, leaking passenger window and remote fuel flap mechanism that packed up!) - at that point in time I couldn't give a toss how F-e-r-r-a-r-i sounded when I said it. Infact, I found I stopped saying F-e-r-r-a-r-i and loving how it flowed off the tongue and simply went with W**KERS!!! So, even this most tenuous of analogies is as questionable as the marketing/turbines themselves...........
Oh, and unfortunately, Italian cars are well known for having loads of history, passion, emotion but crap reliability and build quality!!! Heck, even my spanking new Ferrari had to go back in 2 or 3 times for stupid faults (alarm that set itself off, leaking passenger window and remote fuel flap mechanism that packed up!) - at that point in time I couldn't give a toss how F-e-r-r-a-r-i sounded when I said it. Infact, I found I stopped saying F-e-r-r-a-r-i and loving how it flowed off the tongue and simply went with W**KERS!!! So, even this most tenuous of analogies is as questionable as the marketing/turbines themselves...........