Spektrum DX18
#326
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: , , UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 346
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Spektrum DX18
Oh hearing this about the channels it does tend to put me off to.
However can someone answer this. If I need 2 servos on the elevator and I mix a proportional channel to a non proportional channel does that work. I am sort of confused as to what a non proportional channel is exactly.
Tim
However can someone answer this. If I need 2 servos on the elevator and I mix a proportional channel to a non proportional channel does that work. I am sort of confused as to what a non proportional channel is exactly.
Tim
#327
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Upstate NY although I often wonder why...
Posts: 465
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Spektrum DX18
ORIGINAL: TimWatson
I am sort of confused as to what a non proportional channel is exactly.
Tim
I am sort of confused as to what a non proportional channel is exactly.
Tim
Tom
#328
RE: Spektrum DX18
ORIGINAL: tomfiorentino
It's on or off. Like a toggle switch on retracts, or smoke etc.
Tom
ORIGINAL: TimWatson
I am sort of confused as to what a non proportional channel is exactly.
Tim
I am sort of confused as to what a non proportional channel is exactly.
Tim
Tom
Where does it say (officially) that the eight X-plus channels are not proportional??? I've been told by "knowledgeable sources" that the X-plus channels ARE proportional, but that they will have 512 bit resolution, instead of the 2048 bit resolution of the other channels. This is like the old JR 10X transmitter. 512 bit resolution is fine for everything but aileron, elevator and (maybe) rudder. I've also heard that the DX18 will have the option of giving you a full 12 channels at 2048 bit resolution (for full compatibility with current 12 ch. receivers) vs. 9 channels at 2048 bit resolution and 9 more X-plus channels at 512 bit resolution. .... but I'd like someone to confirm that.
#329
My Feedback: (8)
RE: Spektrum DX18
Okay, it seems the world wide web has delivered another foolish rumor. Ugh.
Let me clarify.
The radio comes with a 9 channel receiver, and then you can buy the x-plus module which gives you a total of 17 channels. Yes, this is a bit ridiculous. I work here and am in full aggreance with all of you on this.
Next; if you use a 12 channel DSM2 or DSMX receiver, you get 12 channels on the 22 ms frame rate. Hence it is the same as a JR 12x in performance.
If you use a 12 channel x-plus compatible receiver, the first 10 channels are on the 22ms frame rate and then you can add the x-plus module to get the other 8 channels on a 512 update rate. ALL CHANNELS are fully proportional as stated many times before in this thread and on the information regarding the DX18 on the Horizon Hobby website. Channels 11 - 18 can be used for anything you want and are fully mixable, adjustable, to equal the same abilities of the top 10 channels. The only down side is they offer a 512 update rate, not the 22ms frame rate. This is due to the bandwidth on the 2.4 band.
So please, if you are going to offer up information at least read what Horizon has stated in print first before electing to deliver very false info. More than a bit frustrated this morning with this thread and the misinformation that put a few in confusion.
http://www.horizonhobby.com/products...r9020-SPM18000
Let me clarify.
The radio comes with a 9 channel receiver, and then you can buy the x-plus module which gives you a total of 17 channels. Yes, this is a bit ridiculous. I work here and am in full aggreance with all of you on this.
Next; if you use a 12 channel DSM2 or DSMX receiver, you get 12 channels on the 22 ms frame rate. Hence it is the same as a JR 12x in performance.
If you use a 12 channel x-plus compatible receiver, the first 10 channels are on the 22ms frame rate and then you can add the x-plus module to get the other 8 channels on a 512 update rate. ALL CHANNELS are fully proportional as stated many times before in this thread and on the information regarding the DX18 on the Horizon Hobby website. Channels 11 - 18 can be used for anything you want and are fully mixable, adjustable, to equal the same abilities of the top 10 channels. The only down side is they offer a 512 update rate, not the 22ms frame rate. This is due to the bandwidth on the 2.4 band.
So please, if you are going to offer up information at least read what Horizon has stated in print first before electing to deliver very false info. More than a bit frustrated this morning with this thread and the misinformation that put a few in confusion.
http://www.horizonhobby.com/products...r9020-SPM18000
#331
RE: Spektrum DX18
John,
Many thanks for clarifying, I was certainly starting to get confused but you have answered my question clearly,
Thanks again, (mine's been on order!)
Gary.
Many thanks for clarifying, I was certainly starting to get confused but you have answered my question clearly,
Thanks again, (mine's been on order!)
Gary.
#333
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Miramar,
FL
Posts: 958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Spektrum DX18
ORIGINAL: madmodelman
You certainly know how to wind John up, he sounds pd of enough already!
You certainly know how to wind John up, he sounds pd of enough already!
Doug.
#334
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Fort Wayne,
IN
Posts: 270
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Spektrum DX18
John, thanks for restating / clarifying! In 7 days I'll be at Toledo eager to hold one of these in my hands to get up close and personal with it. Can't wait! I can put just about all 18 channels to work with my Wingspan Models 1/9th B-17 I'm building.
(Off Topic Alert)... one of my frustrations with Toledo is that I get very excited visiting the HH booth and reps and seeing all the cool stuff and not having vendors there selling your great products. (Not referring to the DX18 as I know it won't be available anywhere yet). Guys with cash in hand and a strong instant gratification desire need vendors there selling all your cool stuff! [>:]
djstar
(Off Topic Alert)... one of my frustrations with Toledo is that I get very excited visiting the HH booth and reps and seeing all the cool stuff and not having vendors there selling your great products. (Not referring to the DX18 as I know it won't be available anywhere yet). Guys with cash in hand and a strong instant gratification desire need vendors there selling all your cool stuff! [>:]
djstar
#336
My Feedback: (8)
RE: Spektrum DX18
Directly pulled from the DX 18 product page.
"The Spektrum DX18 is a true milestone for RC pilots who operate models with a lot of functions or a lot of servos. It’s the RC world’s first hand-held transmitter with 18 fully-proportional channels. Until the DX18, the highest number of proportional channels in a hand-held transmitter was 16."
With the 512 update rate it is recommended to not use the back 8 channels for flight controls.
I am still frustrated that we offer only a 9 channel receiver with the radio out of the box but I have lost that battle. Using and flying the DX18 has been very nice. I love the feel and programming. Very happy with it through all of the testing.
"The Spektrum DX18 is a true milestone for RC pilots who operate models with a lot of functions or a lot of servos. It’s the RC world’s first hand-held transmitter with 18 fully-proportional channels. Until the DX18, the highest number of proportional channels in a hand-held transmitter was 16."
With the 512 update rate it is recommended to not use the back 8 channels for flight controls.
I am still frustrated that we offer only a 9 channel receiver with the radio out of the box but I have lost that battle. Using and flying the DX18 has been very nice. I love the feel and programming. Very happy with it through all of the testing.
#337
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: , , UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 346
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Spektrum DX18
What is even more confusing is that the Horizon Hobby UK site says available. So is it available now if not why say it is talk about customers causing confusion
http://www.horizonhobby.co.uk/
http://www.horizonhobby.co.uk/
#338
RE: Spektrum DX18
ORIGINAL: John Redman
Directly pulled from the DX 18 product page.
''The Spektrum DX18 is a true milestone for RC pilots who operate models with a lot of functions or a lot of servos. It’s the RC world’s first hand-held transmitter with 18 fully-proportional channels. Until the DX18, the highest number of proportional channels in a hand-held transmitter was 16.''
With the 512 update rate it is recommended to not use the back 8 channels for flight controls.
I am still frustrated that we offer only a 9 channel receiver with the radio out of the box but I have lost that battle. Using and flying teh DX18 has been very nice. I love the feel and programming. Very happy with it through all of the testing.
Directly pulled from the DX 18 product page.
''The Spektrum DX18 is a true milestone for RC pilots who operate models with a lot of functions or a lot of servos. It’s the RC world’s first hand-held transmitter with 18 fully-proportional channels. Until the DX18, the highest number of proportional channels in a hand-held transmitter was 16.''
With the 512 update rate it is recommended to not use the back 8 channels for flight controls.
I am still frustrated that we offer only a 9 channel receiver with the radio out of the box but I have lost that battle. Using and flying teh DX18 has been very nice. I love the feel and programming. Very happy with it through all of the testing.
Ah, I completely missed that.
Is 12 the max number of 2048 channels available?
#339
My Feedback: (8)
RE: Spektrum DX18
Hey Tim, Ugh. Well it is tough to help you guys when we can't even help ourselves. [:@] I will see if I can get this fixed.
Yes, the top 12 channels when used with any 12 channel receiver only (no x-plus) is 2048 resolution.
So if you were to take a currently equiped model with say a 1222 receiver and program up your DX18 it would be the same performance on all 12 channels as your 12X.
Yes, the top 12 channels when used with any 12 channel receiver only (no x-plus) is 2048 resolution.
So if you were to take a currently equiped model with say a 1222 receiver and program up your DX18 it would be the same performance on all 12 channels as your 12X.
#340
My Feedback: (8)
RE: Spektrum DX18
Hey Tim,
I believe the word available has more to do with the wording regarding the DX2e which is the same line and there is just an odd line break. The guys in the UK are checking it now. I do not believe it has anything to do with the DX18 text as this is a different color and font.
I believe the word available has more to do with the wording regarding the DX2e which is the same line and there is just an odd line break. The guys in the UK are checking it now. I do not believe it has anything to do with the DX18 text as this is a different color and font.
#341
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: , , UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 346
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Spektrum DX18
ORIGINAL: John Redman
Hey Tim,
I believe the word available has more to do with the wording regarding the DX2e which is the same line and there is just an odd line break. The guys in the UK are checking it now. I do not believe it has anything to do with the DX18 text as this is a different color and font.
Hey Tim,
I believe the word available has more to do with the wording regarding the DX2e which is the same line and there is just an odd line break. The guys in the UK are checking it now. I do not believe it has anything to do with the DX18 text as this is a different color and font.
Tim
#344
RE: Spektrum DX18
I saw a DX-18 today at Classic Jets 50 at Abingdon. Not sure whose it was - either Ali's or Dave's I think. Regrettably I didn't get around to finding out more.
Gordon
Gordon
#345
My Feedback: (34)
RE: Spektrum DX18
ORIGINAL: John Redman
Directly pulled from the DX 18 product page.
''The Spektrum DX18 is a true milestone for RC pilots who operate models with a lot of functions or a lot of servos. It’s the RC world’s first hand-held transmitter with 18 fully-proportional channels. Until the DX18, the highest number of proportional channels in a hand-held transmitter was 16.''
With the 512 update rate it is recommended to not use the back 8 channels for flight controls.
I am still frustrated that we offer only a 9 channel receiver with the radio out of the box but I have lost that battle. Using and flying the DX18 has been very nice. I love the feel and programming. Very happy with it through all of the testing.
Directly pulled from the DX 18 product page.
''The Spektrum DX18 is a true milestone for RC pilots who operate models with a lot of functions or a lot of servos. It’s the RC world’s first hand-held transmitter with 18 fully-proportional channels. Until the DX18, the highest number of proportional channels in a hand-held transmitter was 16.''
With the 512 update rate it is recommended to not use the back 8 channels for flight controls.
I am still frustrated that we offer only a 9 channel receiver with the radio out of the box but I have lost that battle. Using and flying the DX18 has been very nice. I love the feel and programming. Very happy with it through all of the testing.
#348
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: , , UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 346
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Spektrum DX18
ORIGINAL: DougV
I believe you can get 24 fully proportional channels with futaba 12 and 14 channel radios by adding an MPDX module.
Doug.
I believe you can get 24 fully proportional channels with futaba 12 and 14 channel radios by adding an MPDX module.
Doug.
#349
My Feedback: (14)
RE: Spektrum DX18
How about this, for an F-18 .. for the primary flight controls you need two channels (one for each surface) because of the diff and mixes:
You need separate channels for ailerons if you want to use differential: 2
Flaps: 2 if you want to mix ail to flap like the full scale
Elevators: 2 if you want to do ailevator mix
Rudders: 2 if you want to "cant" rudders in or out as full scale
throttle: 1
nosegear: 1
wheel brake: 1
smoke: 1
tailhook: 1
lighting on/off: 1
speed brake: 1
operating canopy: 1
that's 16 so far .. for things that are not terribly over the top. I admit it gets a little hard to imagine many more than this though! maybe one more for droppable ordnance to get to 17? I have a Yellow F-18 with all of these except the canopy...I used the 14mz with the MPDX-1 expander .. that gives you 11 proportional full speed/full res, 8 proportional slower update rate (you trade one of the 12 main channels for these 8), and the two digital (on/off) channels for a total of 20. The 18mz or the DX-18 could do this application easily.
Dave
You need separate channels for ailerons if you want to use differential: 2
Flaps: 2 if you want to mix ail to flap like the full scale
Elevators: 2 if you want to do ailevator mix
Rudders: 2 if you want to "cant" rudders in or out as full scale
throttle: 1
nosegear: 1
wheel brake: 1
smoke: 1
tailhook: 1
lighting on/off: 1
speed brake: 1
operating canopy: 1
that's 16 so far .. for things that are not terribly over the top. I admit it gets a little hard to imagine many more than this though! maybe one more for droppable ordnance to get to 17? I have a Yellow F-18 with all of these except the canopy...I used the 14mz with the MPDX-1 expander .. that gives you 11 proportional full speed/full res, 8 proportional slower update rate (you trade one of the 12 main channels for these 8), and the two digital (on/off) channels for a total of 20. The 18mz or the DX-18 could do this application easily.
Dave