Fly Eagle Jet F-14 Crash (video)
#2152
My Feedback: (5)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNLy2o5d60s
#2154
Senior Member
My Feedback: (3)
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: VA, USA
Posts: 332
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Kevin
I am interested in purchasing a Fly Eagle Jet F-14. I am aware of the many crashes involving (flutter). I am proud member of the U.S. MARINES and AIR FORCE. As Aircraft Weapons Armament Craftsman on both the F/A 18 and F-16 aircraft, I have talk to others about this structure failure and crashes. It sounds like the poor quality of design and or parts used to built this RC jet.
I am interested in purchasing a Fly Eagle Jet F-14. I am aware of the many crashes involving (flutter). I am proud member of the U.S. MARINES and AIR FORCE. As Aircraft Weapons Armament Craftsman on both the F/A 18 and F-16 aircraft, I have talk to others about this structure failure and crashes. It sounds like the poor quality of design and or parts used to built this RC jet.
#2156
Join Date: Apr 2014
Posts: 15
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hello
i lost my FEJF14 during flight with a wing failure
i made 55 flights
when i saw the inside wing I understand, the building is inadapted
i advised IMAA in France and sent some mails to FEJ WITHOUT answer from him
Eric
i lost my FEJF14 during flight with a wing failure
i made 55 flights
when i saw the inside wing I understand, the building is inadapted
i advised IMAA in France and sent some mails to FEJ WITHOUT answer from him
Eric
#2157
Junior Member
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: london, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 12
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
These arf producers release a few videos of their 'products' flying once or twice and you pile in with both feet without a thought for the underlying structure/engineering that is underlying that flashy, beautifully painted, but ultimately doomed, facade!
Unless you KNOW what's under that 'skin' why in the world would you even contemplate committing it to the air ......blind faith??
Build you own models people and learn a little along the way, or accept the consequences.
#2158
#2159
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Perth, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 331
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Consequence you say. What, lots of flying of models now. When I purchase an ARF Jet, I find plenty of proof of how they are constructed usually. You have to want to look past the paint when checking for your supplier. The day of the scratch built aircraft is over and saying otherwise is crazy. The ARF's I have bought lately, are much better than I could construct, are quicker to obtain, usually straight and have better scale features, like rivets and ordnance etc.
#2160
Hi,
Getting sick and tired. Of hearing about the amazing paint jobs. They're glossy. That's about it. Highly inaccurate in the scale ones and have stuff like "poll handle" with nomenclature in the wrong font half the time. Let's say 'shiny' paint jobs, ok?
Getting sick and tired. Of hearing about the amazing paint jobs. They're glossy. That's about it. Highly inaccurate in the scale ones and have stuff like "poll handle" with nomenclature in the wrong font half the time. Let's say 'shiny' paint jobs, ok?
#2161
True that.
#2163
My Feedback: (32)
Shaun,
I've only known you to be an intelligent, honest, long term jet advocate, pro builder, and the go to man for anything yellow.
Thomas,
We all marvel at what you are doing with your Tomcat project. No doubt, an old school innovator and craftsman.
I am puzzled at the vigor you both display, in expressing condescending, demeaning responses to people trying to share their new toys, because they're understandably excited about them.
Lets face it, the experience level on this board ranges from total newbie to Shui, Ali, etc. The newer dudes are the ones coming on excited about their shiny new jets. My thoughts are, a "Good for you, good luck. Here's how to reach me if you need help. " , beats "I'm tired of people calling their stuff nice and scale, when clearly, the nomenclature is the wrong font!". I dunno. These days, my feeling is, this is my hobby. I do it to relax, have fun, and spend time with my friends. I'm over the judgement and politics. Blue skies and tailwinds to all jet buds,
Erik
I've only known you to be an intelligent, honest, long term jet advocate, pro builder, and the go to man for anything yellow.
Thomas,
We all marvel at what you are doing with your Tomcat project. No doubt, an old school innovator and craftsman.
I am puzzled at the vigor you both display, in expressing condescending, demeaning responses to people trying to share their new toys, because they're understandably excited about them.
Lets face it, the experience level on this board ranges from total newbie to Shui, Ali, etc. The newer dudes are the ones coming on excited about their shiny new jets. My thoughts are, a "Good for you, good luck. Here's how to reach me if you need help. " , beats "I'm tired of people calling their stuff nice and scale, when clearly, the nomenclature is the wrong font!". I dunno. These days, my feeling is, this is my hobby. I do it to relax, have fun, and spend time with my friends. I'm over the judgement and politics. Blue skies and tailwinds to all jet buds,
Erik
#2164
My Feedback: (23)
Shaun,
I've only known you to be an intelligent, honest, long term jet advocate, pro builder, and the go to man for anything yellow.
Thomas,
We all marvel at what you are doing with your Tomcat project. No doubt, an old school innovator and craftsman.
I am puzzled at the vigor you both display, in expressing condescending, demeaning responses to people trying to share their new toys, because they're understandably excited about them.
Lets face it, the experience level on this board ranges from total newbie to Shui, Ali, etc. The newer dudes are the ones coming on excited about their shiny new jets. My thoughts are, a "Good for you, good luck. Here's how to reach me if you need help. " , beats "I'm tired of people calling their stuff nice and scale, when clearly, the nomenclature is the wrong font!". I dunno. These days, my feeling is, this is my hobby. I do it to relax, have fun, and spend time with my friends. I'm over the judgement and politics. Blue skies and tailwinds to all jet buds,
Erik
I've only known you to be an intelligent, honest, long term jet advocate, pro builder, and the go to man for anything yellow.
Thomas,
We all marvel at what you are doing with your Tomcat project. No doubt, an old school innovator and craftsman.
I am puzzled at the vigor you both display, in expressing condescending, demeaning responses to people trying to share their new toys, because they're understandably excited about them.
Lets face it, the experience level on this board ranges from total newbie to Shui, Ali, etc. The newer dudes are the ones coming on excited about their shiny new jets. My thoughts are, a "Good for you, good luck. Here's how to reach me if you need help. " , beats "I'm tired of people calling their stuff nice and scale, when clearly, the nomenclature is the wrong font!". I dunno. These days, my feeling is, this is my hobby. I do it to relax, have fun, and spend time with my friends. I'm over the judgement and politics. Blue skies and tailwinds to all jet buds,
Erik
Erik,
i am a stickler for details to a fault and very demanding in that i get the most out of my money (which is why i hardly buy an arf anymore). When i see people saying how perfect their new shiny Arf is, but then it has mispelling nomenclature on it, it strikes me as kind of funny. You have a company selling globally and they cant spell (and im definitely not a spelling bee Wizard!) simple English words correctly when they are Copying the words! I mean a "O" looks nothing like a "U".
I dont see how my comment was demeaning to any one person in particular. If they are happy with what they have, great for them!
I really am on my last 2% of nerves with this site. No one can take a joke anymore
#2165
#2166
Erik,
i am a stickler for details to a fault and very demanding in that i get the most out of my money (which is why i hardly buy an arf anymore). When i see people saying how perfect their new shiny Arf is, but then it has mispelling nomenclature on it, it strikes me as kind of funny. You have a company selling globally and they cant spell (and im definitely not a spelling bee Wizard!) simple English words correctly when they are Copying the words! I mean a "O" looks nothing like a "U".
I dont see how my comment was demeaning to any one person in particular. If they are happy with what they have, great for them!
I really am on my last 2% of nerves with this site. No one can take a joke anymore
i am a stickler for details to a fault and very demanding in that i get the most out of my money (which is why i hardly buy an arf anymore). When i see people saying how perfect their new shiny Arf is, but then it has mispelling nomenclature on it, it strikes me as kind of funny. You have a company selling globally and they cant spell (and im definitely not a spelling bee Wizard!) simple English words correctly when they are Copying the words! I mean a "O" looks nothing like a "U".
I dont see how my comment was demeaning to any one person in particular. If they are happy with what they have, great for them!
I really am on my last 2% of nerves with this site. No one can take a joke anymore
#2167
My Feedback: (32)
Erik,
i am a stickler for details to a fault and very demanding in that i get the most out of my money (which is why i hardly buy an arf anymore). When i see people saying how perfect their new shiny Arf is, but then it has mispelling nomenclature on it, it strikes me as kind of funny. You have a company selling globally and they cant spell (and im definitely not a spelling bee Wizard!) simple English words correctly when they are Copying the words! I mean a "O" looks nothing like a "U".
I dont see how my comment was demeaning to any one person in particular. If they are happy with what they have, great for them!
I really am on my last 2% of nerves with this site. No one can take a joke anymore
i am a stickler for details to a fault and very demanding in that i get the most out of my money (which is why i hardly buy an arf anymore). When i see people saying how perfect their new shiny Arf is, but then it has mispelling nomenclature on it, it strikes me as kind of funny. You have a company selling globally and they cant spell (and im definitely not a spelling bee Wizard!) simple English words correctly when they are Copying the words! I mean a "O" looks nothing like a "U".
I dont see how my comment was demeaning to any one person in particular. If they are happy with what they have, great for them!
I really am on my last 2% of nerves with this site. No one can take a joke anymore
I get all that. I am in a position of leadership at work, and in this hobby. I have been truly humbled by how devastating criticism is to some people, and empowering words of encouragement are to them. Things that you or I may feel are insignificant. Remember when you were coming up, in this hobby, or as a full scale pilot. Obviously you took pride in your dedication and commitment at first, then later your professionalism and skills. Remember how the words of your instructors,etc cut right to your core,good or bad.
I hope your nerves get better. Blue skies,
Erik
#2168
Erik,
Likewise, first of all.
To be honest, I'm still quite disgusted at the damage to this facet of the hobby that I think is being done by unscrupulous outfits like this one. This thread is about a crashed jet. This isn't one of those few where someone is just sharing about his jet (and I'm leaving out the recent one where it's pretty obvious that there's some collusion with the manufacturer). When a guy is just sharing about his airplane, I'm reluctant to poo-poo it. This FEJ thing is far more personal, though.
I watched them totally screw some good guys who busted their butts to help them succeed in this market... even to considerable damage to their reputations and pocketbooks. I watched them deliver egregiously sub-par products without the slightest regard for the safety of our people over here or the viability of our hobby. I've watched them do and say anything (including outright lies and character assassination attempts to defend their indefensible practice of selling static models as RC flying model jets.
I believe that the bar has been lowered to a point where the market itself is significantly damaged. Outfits like this have flooded the market with dangerous junk and have helped 'evolve' the concept of jet modeling to the newest generation of jet guys. It's like a virus that adapts the host environment to make it more comfortable for the new organism. Nowadays, it's harder for legitimate outfits to stay in business, and more people accept this new meme where you send your payment in full (in a way that leaves you no recourse if you're being screwed) and then wait a year to see if they send you everything. When I read the newbies frothing over their shiny jet, in total denial or dismissal about the mountains of evidence that the gamble is worse than it seems... I'm thinking, 'maybe THIS is the jet that comes apart at the wrong time in the wrong place and is the straw that starts the moratorium on jet modeling.' That may sound hyperbolic, but I've built several of these ARFs for people and I stand behind every word.
Erik, you are correct that some of the people who've been on the 'bash FEJ' wagon are just there for the fun of it or for some tribal mentality. I'm not. I take this stuff very seriously, and I love this hobby at the same time. I want everyone to enjoy it, and I don't want one more guy to get suckered by thieves and liars like these.
Likewise, first of all.
To be honest, I'm still quite disgusted at the damage to this facet of the hobby that I think is being done by unscrupulous outfits like this one. This thread is about a crashed jet. This isn't one of those few where someone is just sharing about his jet (and I'm leaving out the recent one where it's pretty obvious that there's some collusion with the manufacturer). When a guy is just sharing about his airplane, I'm reluctant to poo-poo it. This FEJ thing is far more personal, though.
I watched them totally screw some good guys who busted their butts to help them succeed in this market... even to considerable damage to their reputations and pocketbooks. I watched them deliver egregiously sub-par products without the slightest regard for the safety of our people over here or the viability of our hobby. I've watched them do and say anything (including outright lies and character assassination attempts to defend their indefensible practice of selling static models as RC flying model jets.
I believe that the bar has been lowered to a point where the market itself is significantly damaged. Outfits like this have flooded the market with dangerous junk and have helped 'evolve' the concept of jet modeling to the newest generation of jet guys. It's like a virus that adapts the host environment to make it more comfortable for the new organism. Nowadays, it's harder for legitimate outfits to stay in business, and more people accept this new meme where you send your payment in full (in a way that leaves you no recourse if you're being screwed) and then wait a year to see if they send you everything. When I read the newbies frothing over their shiny jet, in total denial or dismissal about the mountains of evidence that the gamble is worse than it seems... I'm thinking, 'maybe THIS is the jet that comes apart at the wrong time in the wrong place and is the straw that starts the moratorium on jet modeling.' That may sound hyperbolic, but I've built several of these ARFs for people and I stand behind every word.
Erik, you are correct that some of the people who've been on the 'bash FEJ' wagon are just there for the fun of it or for some tribal mentality. I'm not. I take this stuff very seriously, and I love this hobby at the same time. I want everyone to enjoy it, and I don't want one more guy to get suckered by thieves and liars like these.
#2169
My Feedback: (32)
Shaun,
Thank you for your respectful, well reasoned response. Dantley knows that I have the utmost respect for him, and understand his pain. I have already suffered significant losses this season, through no fault of the airframe manufacturer.
Now that I physically have posession of my F-16 replacement, I will share some thoughts. Based on the credible reports, it is clear that they haven't treated others as well as they treated me. Since I wasn't party to those interactions, I can't speak to them. I have received a new F-16, and elected to have Nir build it. The important bulkheads are plywood, and the wings and stabs are the strongest I've seen from an arf scale jet company. Servos are all direct drive, as in no linkages.
Wanting to minimize my cash risk, I had JR repair the servos from the first, 8711's all around, and I bought a used P-200 to power it. I promise you I will fly it like a fighter. Look at my F-18 maiden vid in a different thread. Nir did a 10 out of 10 job building my F-16.
If it fails, I will post it here immediately. Otherwise, I won't say a word til the 100th flight. Aside from FEJ, I've just felt a harsh vindictiveness in the jet community lately. My heart says we're all brothers, and need to back each other up, and look out for one another. Too many facets taking pleasure in others misfortune, or just being overly judgemental.
I still remember being scared to send you 1100 for a Starfire before 9/11. That was my first internet jet buying experience. As then, you've turned out to be one of the good guys. Blue skies,
Erik
Thank you for your respectful, well reasoned response. Dantley knows that I have the utmost respect for him, and understand his pain. I have already suffered significant losses this season, through no fault of the airframe manufacturer.
Now that I physically have posession of my F-16 replacement, I will share some thoughts. Based on the credible reports, it is clear that they haven't treated others as well as they treated me. Since I wasn't party to those interactions, I can't speak to them. I have received a new F-16, and elected to have Nir build it. The important bulkheads are plywood, and the wings and stabs are the strongest I've seen from an arf scale jet company. Servos are all direct drive, as in no linkages.
Wanting to minimize my cash risk, I had JR repair the servos from the first, 8711's all around, and I bought a used P-200 to power it. I promise you I will fly it like a fighter. Look at my F-18 maiden vid in a different thread. Nir did a 10 out of 10 job building my F-16.
If it fails, I will post it here immediately. Otherwise, I won't say a word til the 100th flight. Aside from FEJ, I've just felt a harsh vindictiveness in the jet community lately. My heart says we're all brothers, and need to back each other up, and look out for one another. Too many facets taking pleasure in others misfortune, or just being overly judgemental.
I still remember being scared to send you 1100 for a Starfire before 9/11. That was my first internet jet buying experience. As then, you've turned out to be one of the good guys. Blue skies,
Erik
Last edited by Erik R; 06-04-2014 at 03:39 PM.
#2170
My Feedback: (23)
Thomas,
I get all that. I am in a position of leadership at work, and in this hobby. I have been truly humbled by how devastating criticism is to some people, and empowering words of encouragement are to them. Things that you or I may feel are insignificant. Remember when you were coming up, in this hobby, or as a full scale pilot. Obviously you took pride in your dedication and commitment at first, then later your professionalism and skills. Remember how the words of your instructors,etc cut right to your core,good or bad.
I hope your nerves get better. Blue skies,
Erik
I get all that. I am in a position of leadership at work, and in this hobby. I have been truly humbled by how devastating criticism is to some people, and empowering words of encouragement are to them. Things that you or I may feel are insignificant. Remember when you were coming up, in this hobby, or as a full scale pilot. Obviously you took pride in your dedication and commitment at first, then later your professionalism and skills. Remember how the words of your instructors,etc cut right to your core,good or bad.
I hope your nerves get better. Blue skies,
Erik
Otherwise, i dont have much else to add since Shaun said it pretty well. There are very few things i post negatively about here, 1. F14's being done wrong (and mines not perfect either), 2. FEJ stuff (ive seen enough in person to know not to deal with them) 3. Products that fail. Over the past 3 months i have had a LOT of negative issues with many products and well regarded suppliers in this hobby, never once did i make a post about those suplliers or products as we all have off days (and most of the issues were not making stated delivery times).
I believe its time for me to do like so many others and begin to post less and less.
#2171
My Feedback: (569)
Shaun,
Thank you for your respectful, well reasoned response. Dantley knows that I have the utmost respect for him, and understand his pain. I have already suffered significant losses this season, through no fault of the airframe manufacturer.
Now that I physically have posession of my F-16 replacement, I will share some thoughts. Based on the credible reports, it is clear that they haven't treated others as well as they treated me. Since I wasn't party to those interactions, I can't speak to them. I have received a new F-16, and elected to have Nir build it. The important bulkheads are plywood, and the wings and stabs are the strongest I've seen from an arf scale jet company. Servos are all direct drive, as in no linkages.
Wanting to minimize my cash risk, I had JR repair the servos from the first, 8711's all around, and I bought a used P-200 to power it. I promise you I will fly it like a fighter. Look at my F-18 maiden vid in a different thread. Nir did a 10 out of 10 job building it.
If it fails, I will post it here immediately. Otherwise, I won't say a word til the 100th flight. Aside from FEJ, I've just felt a harsh vindictiveness in the jet community lately. My heart says we're all brothers, and need to back each other up, and look out for one another. Too many facets taking pleasure in others misfortune, or just being overly judgemental.
I still remember being scared to send you 1100 for a Starfire before 9/11. That was my first internet jet buying experience. As then, you've turned out to be one of the good guys. Blue skies,
Erik
Thank you for your respectful, well reasoned response. Dantley knows that I have the utmost respect for him, and understand his pain. I have already suffered significant losses this season, through no fault of the airframe manufacturer.
Now that I physically have posession of my F-16 replacement, I will share some thoughts. Based on the credible reports, it is clear that they haven't treated others as well as they treated me. Since I wasn't party to those interactions, I can't speak to them. I have received a new F-16, and elected to have Nir build it. The important bulkheads are plywood, and the wings and stabs are the strongest I've seen from an arf scale jet company. Servos are all direct drive, as in no linkages.
Wanting to minimize my cash risk, I had JR repair the servos from the first, 8711's all around, and I bought a used P-200 to power it. I promise you I will fly it like a fighter. Look at my F-18 maiden vid in a different thread. Nir did a 10 out of 10 job building it.
If it fails, I will post it here immediately. Otherwise, I won't say a word til the 100th flight. Aside from FEJ, I've just felt a harsh vindictiveness in the jet community lately. My heart says we're all brothers, and need to back each other up, and look out for one another. Too many facets taking pleasure in others misfortune, or just being overly judgemental.
I still remember being scared to send you 1100 for a Starfire before 9/11. That was my first internet jet buying experience. As then, you've turned out to be one of the good guys. Blue skies,
Erik
Bill
#2172
Holly smokes! Not to revive the dead here, but I had to reply after reading most of this 87 page topic.
I can't believe the things I read on here and some of the manufacturer/ business associates business practice standards! Wow
The entire thing is ridiculous as I read it. The fact the poor guy lost his rig was hard enough to look at, but once it was pretty much determined a structural failure nothing came of it. I know model manufacturers cannot guaranty a persons flying, and in no way responsible for that much, but when one has documented proof of such failures as this one and other testimonials that concur from said product/s, it is shameful at best. I recall marcpamjose coming off harshly at best, but in the end I think he was right in this instance. As a person who buys certain things from certain Asian countries/China etc.. for obvious price reasons, the one thing I have learned over the years is when it come to a guitar, stay American. In other words, anything that requires precision craftsmanship as in this case "a turbine jet", unfortunately cannot be the exception. Shame on these guys for not at least replacing the chassis that cost this man a small fortune alone.
I can't believe the things I read on here and some of the manufacturer/ business associates business practice standards! Wow
The entire thing is ridiculous as I read it. The fact the poor guy lost his rig was hard enough to look at, but once it was pretty much determined a structural failure nothing came of it. I know model manufacturers cannot guaranty a persons flying, and in no way responsible for that much, but when one has documented proof of such failures as this one and other testimonials that concur from said product/s, it is shameful at best. I recall marcpamjose coming off harshly at best, but in the end I think he was right in this instance. As a person who buys certain things from certain Asian countries/China etc.. for obvious price reasons, the one thing I have learned over the years is when it come to a guitar, stay American. In other words, anything that requires precision craftsmanship as in this case "a turbine jet", unfortunately cannot be the exception. Shame on these guys for not at least replacing the chassis that cost this man a small fortune alone.
#2175
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2014
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I used to fly RC aircraft years ago and recently got into RC quad copters and found that the quality of most anything out of China is poor.
I recently had a brand new Walkera QRX350Pro crash after a motor shut down in flight.
Everything was stock and batteries fully charged.
Just plain poor manufacturing and no customer service.
When I was reading Marks comments early in this thread I agreed with him 100%.
Beware of anything from China ... PLEASE !!!!!
I recently had a brand new Walkera QRX350Pro crash after a motor shut down in flight.
Everything was stock and batteries fully charged.
Just plain poor manufacturing and no customer service.
When I was reading Marks comments early in this thread I agreed with him 100%.
Beware of anything from China ... PLEASE !!!!!