SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
#1
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Maryland,
MD
Posts: 1,748
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
Hello...
An article in Apr/May 06 RC Jet International by Tom Wilkinson, “The Nexus engine featured here is the result of more than a year’s research and development by SimJet into the engine’s compressor, diffuser and combustion chamber design. The result is an engine that can claim to be the most advanced in the market for model aircraft use.”
The article ended with, “Early models gas turbines suffered from significant ‘throttle lag’- this is literally a think of the pas with the Nexus, there should never be any anxious moments during a missed approach, the thrust will be there when needed, and those who enjoy the ‘3D’ style of jet flying will have a ball!”
I own a Yellow Aircraft F-15 ARF and a SimJet Nexus—have yet to build—nerveless and too lazy to start. Anyways, will you guys give me your tried and tested experiences with the Nexus and the others out there: Rhino, P160, Merlin, etc. and tell me what you think and/or know.
All turbines basically look the same, but that Nexus sure is sweet—see?
Thanks…
Mr DJ
An article in Apr/May 06 RC Jet International by Tom Wilkinson, “The Nexus engine featured here is the result of more than a year’s research and development by SimJet into the engine’s compressor, diffuser and combustion chamber design. The result is an engine that can claim to be the most advanced in the market for model aircraft use.”
The article ended with, “Early models gas turbines suffered from significant ‘throttle lag’- this is literally a think of the pas with the Nexus, there should never be any anxious moments during a missed approach, the thrust will be there when needed, and those who enjoy the ‘3D’ style of jet flying will have a ball!”
I own a Yellow Aircraft F-15 ARF and a SimJet Nexus—have yet to build—nerveless and too lazy to start. Anyways, will you guys give me your tried and tested experiences with the Nexus and the others out there: Rhino, P160, Merlin, etc. and tell me what you think and/or know.
All turbines basically look the same, but that Nexus sure is sweet—see?
Thanks…
Mr DJ
#3
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Maryland,
MD
Posts: 1,748
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
c/f
I don’t know what class the AT 400 is in—I don’t know all that’s out there—I just want opinions from all of you on all that is in use and what you think/know of the Nexus.
I will look into AMT—who deals them in the US?
Mr DJ
I don’t know what class the AT 400 is in—I don’t know all that’s out there—I just want opinions from all of you on all that is in use and what you think/know of the Nexus.
I will look into AMT—who deals them in the US?
Mr DJ
#4
My Feedback: (1)
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
Here you go...........
http://www.usamt.com/
Cincinatti OH based, Dr J John Liggons heads up the operation and is a rgeular at most big USA Jet meets.............
http://www.usamt.com/
Cincinatti OH based, Dr J John Liggons heads up the operation and is a rgeular at most big USA Jet meets.............
#8
My Feedback: (13)
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
I don't own a Nexus, but sure looks like a great engine. I do have a simjet 2300 and had a very good experience with it. More likely the challenge will be quick turnaround in any service required from Simjet. They do have a US dealer.
I do have three Artes jet engines (Rhino, Eagle and Bee). Good experience with them and super fast service from both Eric Clapp (dealer) and the Mexico factory (both the Felipe Nieto (owner) and the lead technician (Juan) provide great support.
Good luck
I do have three Artes jet engines (Rhino, Eagle and Bee). Good experience with them and super fast service from both Eric Clapp (dealer) and the Mexico factory (both the Felipe Nieto (owner) and the lead technician (Juan) provide great support.
Good luck
#12
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Leeds, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 1,449
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
8 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
A friend of mine has a Nexus in a Eurosport. I have a Merlin 160 in a Eurosport, so it has been interesting to compare and contrast. My model is a bit heavier but nonetheless my model has better vertical performance. There is little in it in straight line speed. My Merlin accelerates faster than any engine I have previously owned, but the Nexus is faster still, almost instantaneous! Both engines have performed very well over several years.
John
John
#13
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
Hi Mr DJ -
being a neighbor country to Denmark, a lot of guys here have flown Simjet turbines ever since we started flying jets.
The Nexus is indeed a nice engine, but there have been 6 or 7 cases here where it has thrown a compressor blade in
the air and had to be returned to the factory for a complete overhaul. This has happened at top RPM, and I would
strongly suggest that you dial down at least 3-4000 rpm from the top allowed speed, as a turbine failure is something
you don't want (at least not in the air..) The pictures show Cato Hortens Nexus-powered Yellow F-18 just when the
turbine "explodes" and the result of the following very hard "landing".
Tor
being a neighbor country to Denmark, a lot of guys here have flown Simjet turbines ever since we started flying jets.
The Nexus is indeed a nice engine, but there have been 6 or 7 cases here where it has thrown a compressor blade in
the air and had to be returned to the factory for a complete overhaul. This has happened at top RPM, and I would
strongly suggest that you dial down at least 3-4000 rpm from the top allowed speed, as a turbine failure is something
you don't want (at least not in the air..) The pictures show Cato Hortens Nexus-powered Yellow F-18 just when the
turbine "explodes" and the result of the following very hard "landing".
Tor
#14
My Feedback: (2)
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
Hi Tor,
I know of the several incidents you have referenced and had spoken to Simjet-Denmark concerning this as here in the states we have not experienced this issue as the clearance between the Compressor OD and Diffuser ID has been increased on subsequent production runs to eliminate this.
Best regards,
I know of the several incidents you have referenced and had spoken to Simjet-Denmark concerning this as here in the states we have not experienced this issue as the clearance between the Compressor OD and Diffuser ID has been increased on subsequent production runs to eliminate this.
Best regards,
#15
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Longwood ,
FL
Posts: 2,341
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
A very popular engine in this thrust class is the JetCat Titan...
See [link=http://www.jetcatusa.com]JetCat USA[/link] for more information.
The TITAN SE makes 34 pounds, and has very fast throttle response with famed JetCat reliability.
Harley Condra
BVM REP
JetCat REP
See [link=http://www.jetcatusa.com]JetCat USA[/link] for more information.
The TITAN SE makes 34 pounds, and has very fast throttle response with famed JetCat reliability.
Harley Condra
BVM REP
JetCat REP
#17
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Maryland,
MD
Posts: 1,748
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
ORIGINAL: JohnMac
A friend of mine has a Nexus in a Eurosport. I have a Merlin 160 in a Eurosport, so it has been interesting to compare and contrast. My model is a bit heavier but nonetheless my model has better vertical performance. There is little in it in straight line speed. My Merlin accelerates faster than any engine I have previously owned, but the Nexus is faster still, almost instantaneous! Both engines have performed very well over several years.
John
A friend of mine has a Nexus in a Eurosport. I have a Merlin 160 in a Eurosport, so it has been interesting to compare and contrast. My model is a bit heavier but nonetheless my model has better vertical performance. There is little in it in straight line speed. My Merlin accelerates faster than any engine I have previously owned, but the Nexus is faster still, almost instantaneous! Both engines have performed very well over several years.
John
Now that's what I'm talkin' 'bout, "faster still." I'm ling.
Thanks...
Mr DJ
#18
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Maryland,
MD
Posts: 1,748
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
ORIGINAL: icepilot
Hi Mr DJ -
being a neighbor country to Denmark, a lot of guys here have flown Simjet turbines ever since we started flying jets.
The Nexus is indeed a nice engine, but there have been 6 or 7 cases here where it has thrown a compressor blade in
the air and had to be returned to the factory for a complete overhaul. This has happened at top RPM, and I would
strongly suggest that you dial down at least 3-4000 rpm from the top allowed speed, as a turbine failure is something
you don't want (at least not in the air..) The pictures show Cato Hortens Nexus-powered Yellow F-18 just when the
turbine "explodes" and the result of the following very hard "landing".
Tor
Hi Mr DJ -
being a neighbor country to Denmark, a lot of guys here have flown Simjet turbines ever since we started flying jets.
The Nexus is indeed a nice engine, but there have been 6 or 7 cases here where it has thrown a compressor blade in
the air and had to be returned to the factory for a complete overhaul. This has happened at top RPM, and I would
strongly suggest that you dial down at least 3-4000 rpm from the top allowed speed, as a turbine failure is something
you don't want (at least not in the air..) The pictures show Cato Hortens Nexus-powered Yellow F-18 just when the
turbine "explodes" and the result of the following very hard "landing".
Tor
Wow--that's some serious biz goin' on in that bird--scary too... But like Vampire said, I've not heard of that stateside, but I will be praying still that that doesn't happen to me or to any pilots in the future--you know what I'm sayin'.
Thanks...
Mr DJ
#19
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Maryland,
MD
Posts: 1,748
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
ORIGINAL: Harley Condra
A very popular engine in this thrust class is the JetCat Titan...
See [link=http://www.jetcatusa.com]JetCat USA[/link] for more information.
The TITAN SE makes 34 pounds, and has very fast throttle response with famed JetCat reliability.
Harley Condra
BVM REP
JetCat REP
A very popular engine in this thrust class is the JetCat Titan...
See [link=http://www.jetcatusa.com]JetCat USA[/link] for more information.
The TITAN SE makes 34 pounds, and has very fast throttle response with famed JetCat reliability.
Harley Condra
BVM REP
JetCat REP
I looked at the Titan--in fact, JetCat USA told me that Titans come in as 36lb P160s--they tune in down to 34lbs--He was going to sell me normal P160 but then I read the article above and was sold on the Nexus. The only reason why I'm thinkin' about the Rhino is because of it's Lifetime Warranty and $250 or less service interval--can't beat that.
Thanks...
Mr DJ
#20
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Maryland,
MD
Posts: 1,748
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
ORIGINAL: Vampire
Hi Tor,
I know of the several incidents you have referenced and had spoken to Simjet-Denmark concerning this as here in the states we have not experienced this issue as the clearance between the Compressor OD and Diffuser ID has been increased on subsequent production runs to eliminate this.
Best regards,
Hi Tor,
I know of the several incidents you have referenced and had spoken to Simjet-Denmark concerning this as here in the states we have not experienced this issue as the clearance between the Compressor OD and Diffuser ID has been increased on subsequent production runs to eliminate this.
Best regards,
I just realized it's you. Hay gang, this is the Man who sold me on the Nexus--not too mention took all of my money
As you can see, Vamp--I'm searchin' for more opinions over the RCJI article above--so far, so good...
That charger is on it way, by-the-way...
Thanks...
Mr DJ
#22
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Maryland,
MD
Posts: 1,748
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
Rob
38? I'm liking that and at the same price. But is that on Rhinos sold overseas Only--are US versions tuned to 36?
Mr DJ
38? I'm liking that and at the same price. But is that on Rhinos sold overseas Only--are US versions tuned to 36?
Mr DJ
#23
My Feedback: (11)
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
ORIGINAL: Mr DJ
Harly, what's up...
I looked at the Titan--in fact, JetCat USA told me that Titans come in as 36lb P160s--they tune in down to 34lbs--He was going to sell me normal P160 but then I read the article above and was sold on the Nexus. The only reason why I'm thinkin' about the Rhino is because of it's Lifetime Warranty and $250 or less service interval--can't beat that.
Thanks...
Mr DJ
ORIGINAL: Harley Condra
A very popular engine in this thrust class is the JetCat Titan...
See [link=http://www.jetcatusa.com]JetCat USA[/link] for more information.
The TITAN SE makes 34 pounds, and has very fast throttle response with famed JetCat reliability.
Harley Condra
BVM REP
JetCat REP
A very popular engine in this thrust class is the JetCat Titan...
See [link=http://www.jetcatusa.com]JetCat USA[/link] for more information.
The TITAN SE makes 34 pounds, and has very fast throttle response with famed JetCat reliability.
Harley Condra
BVM REP
JetCat REP
I looked at the Titan--in fact, JetCat USA told me that Titans come in as 36lb P160s--they tune in down to 34lbs--He was going to sell me normal P160 but then I read the article above and was sold on the Nexus. The only reason why I'm thinkin' about the Rhino is because of it's Lifetime Warranty and $250 or less service interval--can't beat that.
Thanks...
Mr DJ
I think I'd rather have a 3 yr warranty, pay slightly more than $250 and have JetCat Reliability. Even one jet down can be as much as a $10,000 bill. I am not a JetCat Rep. Like most of us on these threads, I can buy any turbine I want.
Raf
#24
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
I know Simjet and Lars over here have adressed the problem, and I think the new turbines will be better
and not have this problem. As you say, the clearance between the compressor OD and the diffuser ID was
too tight, and this was what caused the problem at full RPM.
I still have Simjet turbines and fully trust the guys in Denmark.
Tor
and not have this problem. As you say, the clearance between the compressor OD and the diffuser ID was
too tight, and this was what caused the problem at full RPM.
I still have Simjet turbines and fully trust the guys in Denmark.
Tor
#25
My Feedback: (12)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Davie,
FL
Posts: 883
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: SimJet Nexus vs. The Rest in 36lb Class
ORIGINAL: Mr DJ
Rob
38? I'm liking that and at the same price. But is that on Rhinos sold overseas Only--are US versions tuned to 36?
Mr DJ
Rob
38? I'm liking that and at the same price. But is that on Rhinos sold overseas Only--are US versions tuned to 36?
Mr DJ
I think the Jet Central Rhinos are now baseline 37 pounds and usually produce more. Real thrust, not just an advertised number. I took a SuperBee I had which was advertised at 14 pounds and it produced 14.8 at 85 degrees in Florida humidity. Tested at Modellbau-USA's test stand. Jet Central 's thrust reports seem to be always at least what they advertise and usually more.
Sounds like you need someone to have a side by side Nexus and Rhino. It would be interesting to hear.
BC