RCU Forums

RCU Forums (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/)
-   RC Pattern Flying (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/rc-pattern-flying-101/)
-   -   Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/rc-pattern-flying-101/10192449-pattern-plane-dorsal-ventral-fins.html)

DT56 12-12-2010 11:06 AM

Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
1 Attachment(s)
I've been searching for more information on a pattern plane of unusual configuration that I read of approximately 15 years ago. The model had low aspect ratio dorsal and ventral "fins" located about the aerodynamic center. The vertical stabilizer area was divided equally above and below the fuselage centerline. I believe the designer / builder may have been from Louisiana.

Anyone have a lead on the identification of this model?

Thanks!!!

This slope model is of approximately the same configuration.

pattratt 12-12-2010 11:26 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
DT56

Nat Penton was the designer builder

Had a number of designs from Voodo to Voodo Express.

Dick

burtona 12-12-2010 12:03 PM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
1 Attachment(s)
Here's a Voodoo Express I built this year from plans I got from Mark Hunt.

DT56 12-12-2010 03:22 PM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
Thanks guys, I really appreciate it!!!

Bundubasher 12-13-2010 12:58 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
Very interesting concept.

How does it fly (i.e. knife edge, roll, cross wind handling)compared to a "normal" plane of that size without the fins?

Just wondering - The power version makes sense but the slope soarer in 1st postmay side slip in cross wind on a slope.If this powered concept makes a big difference, why don't we see more ofthese type planes around?

Except for "foamies" etc, I've seen some planes with "canard " wings and "stall strakes" but not with these extended vertical fins.

Bundu

wind junkie 12-13-2010 08:34 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 

ORIGINAL: Bundubasher
...
Just wondering - The power version makes sense but the slope soarer in 1st post may side slip in cross wind on a slope. If this powered concept makes a big difference, why don't we see more of these type planes around?
...
There is a segment in the slope scene associated with a Europen term "VTPR" which involves low and slow aerobatics on a hill which provides the right kind of lift where penetration isn't a big issue. For that concept, broad "fish like" fuselages work well, and allow a flyer to spend more time off the (main) wing.

Here's a good explanatory thread:

http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showt...130761&page=30

As a power flyer (who's used to much better and crisper yaw control), VTPR isn't really my cup of tea, but it does offer another slant on waking up your left thumb on the slope.

Joe

geoffroyBelgium 12-13-2010 09:43 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
Hello,

Here is mine:

http://www.lumay.be/imagesForums/ant...tonRepare1.jpg

The construction:

http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_9749764/tm.htm

It's realy a nice pattern plane! In particular with the electric propulsion.

geoffroyBelgium 12-13-2010 09:52 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
We don't see more of this type of planes around because, according to the general opinion, this plane is not fashionable. It's not my point of view, but I can tell that the first reaction when you arrive at the flying field with this plane is: "Beurk, it's horrible". After this first reaction, people are amazed by the flying qualities. But it's only the second reaction...

Bundubasher 12-13-2010 10:00 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
1 Attachment(s)
Thanks guys, this is most interesting. I'm keen on giving this a try.
I've got a modified Mirage (Cheetah) with canards etc, but all these mods are only horizotally orientated. Just shows one can learn always something new... even after 40 years.

Just a question - would you place these dorsal fins at the same cg point as the main wing or does it not matter too much?

Thanks

Bundu

geoffroyBelgium 12-13-2010 10:09 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
Yes the cg of the dorsal fins and the cg of the main wing are the same.

DT56 12-13-2010 11:25 PM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 


ORIGINAL: Bundubasher

Very interesting concept.

How does it fly (i.e. knife edge, roll, cross wind handling) compared to a ''normal'' plane of that size without the fins?

Just wondering - The power version makes sense but the slope soarer in 1st post may side slip in cross wind on a slope. If this powered concept makes a big difference, why don't we see more of these type planes around?

Except for ''foamies'' etc, I've seen some planes with ''canard '' wings and ''stall strakes'' but not with these extended vertical fins.

Bundu
Here's a video of the sloper in action.

http://www.vimeo.com/17705369

Rendegade 12-14-2010 04:09 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
wow, if there ever was a soarer to keep me interested, that'd probably be it.

Even though I live in one of the windiest cities in the world, we just don't have good enough sloping hills!

Mike Wiz 12-14-2010 10:28 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
Pattern slope soaring... Now that would be interesting and pretty cool too.


ORIGINAL: Rendegade

wow, if there ever was a soarer to keep me interested, that'd probably be it.

Even though I live in one of the windiest cities in the world, we just don't have good enough sloping hills!

Rendegade 12-14-2010 03:36 PM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
Something tells me we'd get pretty tired of the weak verticals very quick.

wind junkie 12-14-2010 03:50 PM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 

ORIGINAL: Rendegade

Something tells me we'd get pretty tired of the weak verticals very quick.
Not on a good hill on a good day. The really amazing thing about flying slope pattern on a good hill is the "terminal velocity" on a really clean and capable slope plane is MUCH faster than what you'd dare to do with most powered pattern birds. The name of the game in modern pattern is "constant speed". Slope pattern is much more reminiscent of old time "ballistic pattern" except you really can use your energy much more efficiently than the old thick winged chariots we know and love. Combine that with being ON TOP of a really big cliff, and you can dive repeatedly at yourself at very high speed so you can hear everything as you streak by, and then carve super big and fast valley filling loops== flying below your feet for a long time until you use up your energy and come back for more. On the really big hills, it feels like the entire sky is rising, so you can really just put your plane anywhere you desire, a true "cursor in the sky" == just like a pattern flyer would want.

When you fly a really fast heavy bird like that, there is a rule which you learn pretty fast == What comes down, must go UP! That means you've got a lot of energy to play with after each dive, and it's up to you to decide where to spend it all. Like I said, on a really good hill on a good day, you really won't miss having a motor if you just want to fly patterns.

It's when you want to do multiple snaps, successive spin recoveries, extended KE maneuvers (any type of energy killing move), or any real 3D stuff that the slope falls short. But for max speed and adrenaline, the sheer size of the maneuvers, and breathtaking places to fly, it's still among my favorite ways to spend a few hours (or weeks!:D)

guille2006 12-15-2010 02:41 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 


ORIGINAL: Bundubasher

Just a question - would you place these dorsal fins at the same cg point as the main wing or does it not matter too much?

Thanks

Bundu
You have to place the fins matching the Aerodinamic center of the fin with the CoG of the plane; otherwise you'll get an extra moment around the yaw axis...

Magne 12-16-2010 04:47 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 

You have to place the fins matching the Aerodinamic center of the fin with the CoG of the plane; otherwise you'll get an extra moment around the yaw axis...
But then again, all the T-canalisers I have seen have been mounted behind the C of G, and their purpose is to an extent the same as these Dorsal and Ventral Fins.
The aerodynamic centre of pressure is normally not the same whether the model is flying the right way up or in knife edge. Is it not the location of the TOTAL aerodynamic centre of pressure that matters, including all the stick-on bits?
Magne

robert 12-16-2010 05:40 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 

ORIGINAL: Magne


You have to place the fins matching the Aerodinamic center of the fin with the CoG of the plane; otherwise you'll get an extra moment around the yaw axis...
But then again, all the T-canalisers I have seen have been mounted behind the C of G, and their purpose is to an extent the same as these Dorsal and Ventral Fins.
The aerodynamic centre of pressure is normally not the same whether the model is flying the right way up or in knife edge. Is it not the location of the TOTAL aerodynamic centre of pressure that matters, including all the stick-on bits?
Magne
I think I see what you're saying. Having the fins away from the aerodynamic centre isn't necessarilly a bad thing. Just think of the stab or fin, the moment they produce is used to counter other moments and add stability. But these fins are designed to add lift in knife-edge, not for stability. By having them on the CoG they won't change the attitude (yaw) of the aircraft at different fin angles of attack (sideslip angles). All they do is add lift.

By having them say behind the CoG, you're actually adding in a sense to the size of the fin at the rear of the aircraft as it's adding stability as well as side area. In fact, if you were to put these fins far behind the CoG, so that the moment they produce during a side slip is large, you would have to increase the size of the rudder or it's throw. This is because the rudder will have to 'fight' the extra stability provided by the fins, which may be counter-productive for pattern.

guille2006 12-16-2010 05:50 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 


ORIGINAL: robert

I think I see what you're saying. Having the fins away from the aerodynamic centre isn't necessarilly a bad thing. Just think of the stab or fin, the moment they produce is used to counter other moments and add stability. But these fins are designed to add lift in knife-edge, not for stability. By having them on the CoG they won't change the attitude (yaw) of the aircraft at different fin angles of attack (sideslip angles). All they do is add lift.
Yes!!!!!


ORIGINAL: robert
By having them say behind the CoG, you're actually adding in a sense to the size of the fin at the rear of the aircraft as it's adding stability as well as side area. In fact, if you were to put these fins far behind the CoG, so that the moment they produce during a side slip is large, you would have to increase the size of the rudder or it's throw. This is because the rudder will have to 'fight' the extra stability provided by the fins, which may be counter-productive for pattern.
By having them say behind the CoG, you're actually adding in a sense to the size of the fin at the rear of the aircraft as it's adding stability.
But it's not necessarily an advantege... may be for one flight condition; but could be even dangerous for others...

Diver09 12-16-2010 07:59 PM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
1 Attachment(s)
Here's mine:
Slightly different fuselage but same concept with the vertical fins. Also inspired by Nat Penton and Mark Hunt and with the help of many others (Rusty Dose, Jim Sheffield, Richard Lewis, to name a few.)


-Chris

geoffroyBelgium 12-25-2010 10:21 AM

RE: Pattern Plane With Dorsal And Ventral Fins
 
Chris,

Your GT Express is realy nice!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:45 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.