LiFE Batteries
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: GeelongVictoria, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 203
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
LiFE Batteries
Some questions on LiFE Batteries.
How long do they keep their charge, i.e if I charge them last Saturday and don't use them, are they right to go this Saturday?
How do I measure their charge? i.e. coming form NiCd's or NiMh's you could use a battery checker to "know" the charge in the batteries. How do we accurately do that with LiFe's?
How far allowable is it to use them and be safe, say an 1100 mah pack, down to 25% (when I figure out how to measure 25% capacity).
Thanks
How long do they keep their charge, i.e if I charge them last Saturday and don't use them, are they right to go this Saturday?
How do I measure their charge? i.e. coming form NiCd's or NiMh's you could use a battery checker to "know" the charge in the batteries. How do we accurately do that with LiFe's?
How far allowable is it to use them and be safe, say an 1100 mah pack, down to 25% (when I figure out how to measure 25% capacity).
Thanks
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Cape Town, SOUTH AFRICA
Posts: 2,744
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
RE: LiFE Batteries
I've been using Hyperion Life battery packs now for over a year.
I find they hold their charge for months with very little self discharge. I have charged a pack and stored it. Fitted it to a plane 4 months later and it showed the same voltage it had 15 min off the charger 4 months later.
Measuring their capacity is a bit of a problem. there are battery checkers availble that measures voltage against an ideal curve and interpolates the capacity. These are reasonable accurate but trend to be conservative (A good thing). the Hyperion EOS Battery checker is such a device.
Some folk prefer to charge a LIFE battery pack , fly it for a fixed perid of time say 20 min and then recharge it to measure what has been put back into the battery. they then have an idea of current draw per min. My reservation with this is that on no two flights will he current draw be the same.
However again approximations are good enough if he user is clever enough to recharge when capacity ius reaching 30%.
I have found thedrop off voltage for the Hyperion LiFePO4 packs to be around 6.2V.
thereafter you are within 5% of a broken plane. I never fly a plane with a LiFePO4 pack at voltage lower than 6.4V (excluding those packs that have a nominal voltage of 6.4V)
I find they hold their charge for months with very little self discharge. I have charged a pack and stored it. Fitted it to a plane 4 months later and it showed the same voltage it had 15 min off the charger 4 months later.
Measuring their capacity is a bit of a problem. there are battery checkers availble that measures voltage against an ideal curve and interpolates the capacity. These are reasonable accurate but trend to be conservative (A good thing). the Hyperion EOS Battery checker is such a device.
Some folk prefer to charge a LIFE battery pack , fly it for a fixed perid of time say 20 min and then recharge it to measure what has been put back into the battery. they then have an idea of current draw per min. My reservation with this is that on no two flights will he current draw be the same.
However again approximations are good enough if he user is clever enough to recharge when capacity ius reaching 30%.
I have found thedrop off voltage for the Hyperion LiFePO4 packs to be around 6.2V.
thereafter you are within 5% of a broken plane. I never fly a plane with a LiFePO4 pack at voltage lower than 6.4V (excluding those packs that have a nominal voltage of 6.4V)
#3
Senior Member
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: ozzieflyer Some questions on LiFE Batteries. How long do they keep their charge, i.e if I charge them last Saturday and don't use them, are they right to go this Saturday? How do I measure their charge? i.e. coming form NiCd's or NiMh's you could use a battery checker to "know" the charge in the batteries. How do we accurately do that with LiFe's? How far allowable is it to use them and be safe, say an 1100 mah pack, down to 25% (when I figure out how to measure 25% capacity). Thanks
Optima Transceiver (RX) - Battery set up for Nitro/Gas models #1 - caution re NiMH & Alert re LiFE.
ORIGINAL: A.T. <snip></snip>Update 30Dec10:
Alan T.
Originally Posted by martyfly147 hi guys ,i want to use 2x Life/a123 batteries in parallel with no regulators plugged straight into optma rx's via the servo bus not spc ,will this be ok and what voltage would you set the alarm to considering the flat discharge curve of these batteries |
Usual specs of genuine 2S RX packs show
" Nominal pack voltage: 6.6V (3.3V per cell)
Fully-charged pack voltage: 7.2V (3.6V per cell)
Recommended cut-off voltage: 5V (2.5V per cell)
Minimum voltage: 4.0V (2.0V per cell)
Do not charge above 7.2V."
Drop off is extremely rapid,
ESC/BEC are now being supplied with min setting of 3.0v per cell for A123.
Users of A123 for RX packs suggest Low Battery Warning of at least 6.0v to allow time for landing.
Care with brand of LiFe pack, recommended reading:
Battery (Receiver packs) . LiFePO (aka A123 & LiFe) - Alert re False Labels & excess voltage
Battery (Receiver packs) . LiFePO (aka A123 & LiFe) - full thread
A123 Battery (aka LiFe PO4 cells) FAQ for Giant Scale and IMAC
A123 (LiFePO4) Cells for Receiver Packs - Very good graphs of the various battery chemistry type and relative discharge curves.
HYPERION G3 LiFePO4 Batteries for Radio Transmitters and Receivers - Warning
"SERVOS - Many servos on the market, and particularly many of the lower-cost analog types, cannot operate at the voltage supplied by these LiFe Receiver packs. Attempting to use a servo rated for maximum of 6V or less WILL RESULT in reduced servo life, and may lead to in-flight failure. Any such failure is the sole responsibility of the user."
"If you have any concerns about the voltage rating of your servos, you may choose to run a BEC unit, such as the 5V/6V selectable Hyperion SBEC (HP-TICOOL-BEC), in order to regulate voltage down to suit your servos. This offers greater safety compared to BEC units running off the main flight pack because even if your main flight pack is completely depleted in flight the radio and servos will maintain power via the Rx pack."
<snip></snip>
Alan T.
Alan's Hobby, Model & RC FAQ Web Links
(quick search = Ctrl+F)
" Nominal pack voltage: 6.6V (3.3V per cell)
Fully-charged pack voltage: 7.2V (3.6V per cell)
Recommended cut-off voltage: 5V (2.5V per cell)
Minimum voltage: 4.0V (2.0V per cell)
Do not charge above 7.2V."
Drop off is extremely rapid,
ESC/BEC are now being supplied with min setting of 3.0v per cell for A123.
Users of A123 for RX packs suggest Low Battery Warning of at least 6.0v to allow time for landing.
Care with brand of LiFe pack, recommended reading:
Battery (Receiver packs) . LiFePO (aka A123 & LiFe) - Alert re False Labels & excess voltage
Battery (Receiver packs) . LiFePO (aka A123 & LiFe) - full thread
A123 Battery (aka LiFe PO4 cells) FAQ for Giant Scale and IMAC
A123 (LiFePO4) Cells for Receiver Packs - Very good graphs of the various battery chemistry type and relative discharge curves.
HYPERION G3 LiFePO4 Batteries for Radio Transmitters and Receivers - Warning
"SERVOS - Many servos on the market, and particularly many of the lower-cost analog types, cannot operate at the voltage supplied by these LiFe Receiver packs. Attempting to use a servo rated for maximum of 6V or less WILL RESULT in reduced servo life, and may lead to in-flight failure. Any such failure is the sole responsibility of the user."
"If you have any concerns about the voltage rating of your servos, you may choose to run a BEC unit, such as the 5V/6V selectable Hyperion SBEC (HP-TICOOL-BEC), in order to regulate voltage down to suit your servos. This offers greater safety compared to BEC units running off the main flight pack because even if your main flight pack is completely depleted in flight the radio and servos will maintain power via the Rx pack."
<snip></snip>
Alan T.
Alan's Hobby, Model & RC FAQ Web Links
(quick search = Ctrl+F)
#5
Moderator
RE: LiFE Batteries
Measuring the charge put in after a few flights is not as accurate as a measured discharge because some of the charging current goes toward heating up the battery, but it does get you in the ballpark. Lithium based batteries do not benefit from being used up like NiCd's do, so flying to about 50% capacity and topping off is best.
#6
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: jester_s1
Measuring the charge put in after a few flights is not as accurate as a measured discharge because some of the charging current goes toward heating up the battery,
Measuring the charge put in after a few flights is not as accurate as a measured discharge because some of the charging current goes toward heating up the battery,
#7
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: SydneyNSW, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 932
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: LiFE Batteries
There are now several manufactures that make switches or devices with built-in mAh counters. These are semi useful for eyeballing the usage but the model has be on the ground to read it. The pilot needs to check the mAh used from the pack before he takes off and decide whether there is enough charge remaining for a safe flight.
Personally, i'm using a telemetry current sensor on my Multiplex radio. The sensor measures current and mAh used and stores the sum of the usage in it's memory between flights. I have a constant real-time readout of remaining capacity and an alarm when the pack reaches a preset usage. The receiver also monitors the voltage and triggers an alarm if the voltage drops.
Personally, i'm using a telemetry current sensor on my Multiplex radio. The sensor measures current and mAh used and stores the sum of the usage in it's memory between flights. I have a constant real-time readout of remaining capacity and an alarm when the pack reaches a preset usage. The receiver also monitors the voltage and triggers an alarm if the voltage drops.
#8
RE: LiFE Batteries
That certainly is true of Nixx chemistry, but with A123's or Lipo's the difference between the measured discharge current and amount of current needed to recharge is more than close enough for Govamint work. I've never been able to detect any temperature rise in any Lithium based battery I've charged[8D]
Pete
Pete
#9
My Feedback: (11)
RE: LiFE Batteries
You could over engineer it all day long.
Or you could fly a couple of times and see how much you put in. Figure out your safe flights, and take a flight or two away as a safety margin.
FWIW I do an average of 325 per flight on my 50CC gassers, flying 3D with 5x 7955 servos and the ignition running off the same pack. I charge after 4 flights.
Or you could fly a couple of times and see how much you put in. Figure out your safe flights, and take a flight or two away as a safety margin.
FWIW I do an average of 325 per flight on my 50CC gassers, flying 3D with 5x 7955 servos and the ignition running off the same pack. I charge after 4 flights.
#12
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: lebanon,
MO
Posts: 380
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: CustomPC
There are now several manufactures that make switches or devices with built-in mAh counters. These are semi useful for eyeballing the usage but the model has be on the ground to read it. The pilot needs to check the mAh used from the pack before he takes off and decide whether there is enough charge remaining for a safe flight.
Personally, i'm using a telemetry current sensor on my Multiplex radio. The sensor measures current and mAh used and stores the sum of the usage in it's memory between flights. I have a constant real-time readout of remaining capacity and an alarm when the pack reaches a preset usage. The receiver also monitors the voltage and triggers an alarm if the voltage drops.
There are now several manufactures that make switches or devices with built-in mAh counters. These are semi useful for eyeballing the usage but the model has be on the ground to read it. The pilot needs to check the mAh used from the pack before he takes off and decide whether there is enough charge remaining for a safe flight.
Personally, i'm using a telemetry current sensor on my Multiplex radio. The sensor measures current and mAh used and stores the sum of the usage in it's memory between flights. I have a constant real-time readout of remaining capacity and an alarm when the pack reaches a preset usage. The receiver also monitors the voltage and triggers an alarm if the voltage drops.
Tim
#13
My Feedback: (2)
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: a1pcfixer
What are some of the better LiFe/A123 balance chargers available?
I've heard some say the FMA CellPro 4S Gold is great, but it only does a single pack at a time?
What are some of the better LiFe/A123 balance chargers available?
I've heard some say the FMA CellPro 4S Gold is great, but it only does a single pack at a time?
FMA makes a Powerlab 8 charger that can charge more than two packs and at up to 40a, I believe. It charges the packs in Parallel. Each pack still has to be the same number of cells.
You can charge through the Balancing Taps only, or through the Balancing Taps and the Charge Leads. You can see the Supply Voltage, Charge Current, Total mah In, Elapsed Time, Pack Voltage, Individual Cell Voltage, and Internal Resistance of each Cell. It also displays a representation of the amount of charge left, as Fuel Percentage.
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Cape Town, SOUTH AFRICA
Posts: 2,744
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: a1pcfixer
What are some of the better LiFe/A123 balance chargers available?
I've heard some say the FMA CellPro 4S Gold is great, but it only does a single pack at a time?
What are some of the better LiFe/A123 balance chargers available?
I've heard some say the FMA CellPro 4S Gold is great, but it only does a single pack at a time?
Not sure that there is huge difference between most of the computerised chargers. Ihave been using a Turnigy Accucell 6 for 18 months and it charges the LiFePO4, A123, LiPO, LI-ION (3.6V) much better than the the industrial chargers Ihave for some of them.
It balance charges, and provides a on charge display of the cell balance. It works and its extremely cost effective. I know plenty of folk who also have great success with the iMax chargers
#16
RE: LiFE Batteries
The FMA10 S as mentioned above -easily the top of the heap
As for all the attempts at counting amps and using 6 volts as a cutoff ??
N F W- do it at your own risk.
Talk to guys who have some long time experience with the LIFE/A123 cells
Forget the guesswork. Some history:
The real reason for using the A123's (the best of the lot) was to keep voltage to servos as high as possible under loads.
This required technology which would supply high current levels throughout entire charged capacity.
The only close competitor is LIPO
The downside ,is a technology which has a severe drop at extreme end of capacity
For example -on my test station( two 1157 bulbs )- the output is at 3.3 v per cell for 75%of the cycle
(full cycle is almost exactly 30 minutes) at the end say 27 minutes the voltage fades - and when it hits 3 volts it quits in under a minute.
Recharge at 4 amps is possible, immediately- no problem
How good amp recording devices really are - I really don't know.
The relative weight of the cells to the total model weight is low - so I always doubled the possible battery needs
at field recharge -using a good balancing charger is quick- usually 15 minutes for my setups
The best part is NO friggen regulators needed so the failure points are minimal-
mainly you just need good wiring and a simple failsafe switch.
As for all the attempts at counting amps and using 6 volts as a cutoff ??
N F W- do it at your own risk.
Talk to guys who have some long time experience with the LIFE/A123 cells
Forget the guesswork. Some history:
The real reason for using the A123's (the best of the lot) was to keep voltage to servos as high as possible under loads.
This required technology which would supply high current levels throughout entire charged capacity.
The only close competitor is LIPO
The downside ,is a technology which has a severe drop at extreme end of capacity
For example -on my test station( two 1157 bulbs )- the output is at 3.3 v per cell for 75%of the cycle
(full cycle is almost exactly 30 minutes) at the end say 27 minutes the voltage fades - and when it hits 3 volts it quits in under a minute.
Recharge at 4 amps is possible, immediately- no problem
How good amp recording devices really are - I really don't know.
The relative weight of the cells to the total model weight is low - so I always doubled the possible battery needs
at field recharge -using a good balancing charger is quick- usually 15 minutes for my setups
The best part is NO friggen regulators needed so the failure points are minimal-
mainly you just need good wiring and a simple failsafe switch.
#17
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: GeelongVictoria, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 203
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: TimT2000
Where, who, Please share! I need 14 of them. Switches that is, not devices. The one I knew about was discontinued for rework.
Tim
ORIGINAL: CustomPC
There are now several manufactures that make switches or devices with built-in mAh counters. These are semi useful for eyeballing the usage but the model has be on the ground to read it. The pilot needs to check the mAh used from the pack before he takes off and decide whether there is enough charge remaining for a safe flight.
Personally, i'm using a telemetry current sensor on my Multiplex radio. The sensor measures current and mAh used and stores the sum of the usage in it's memory between flights. I have a constant real-time readout of remaining capacity and an alarm when the pack reaches a preset usage. The receiver also monitors the voltage and triggers an alarm if the voltage drops.
There are now several manufactures that make switches or devices with built-in mAh counters. These are semi useful for eyeballing the usage but the model has be on the ground to read it. The pilot needs to check the mAh used from the pack before he takes off and decide whether there is enough charge remaining for a safe flight.
Personally, i'm using a telemetry current sensor on my Multiplex radio. The sensor measures current and mAh used and stores the sum of the usage in it's memory between flights. I have a constant real-time readout of remaining capacity and an alarm when the pack reaches a preset usage. The receiver also monitors the voltage and triggers an alarm if the voltage drops.
Tim
Check this out,
http://www.boomarc.com/products/162-...lliswitch.aspx
pretty cool. But i haven't tried one but have heard its good.
#19
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: GeelongVictoria, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 203
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: LiFE Batteries
I guess my concern is, even though you calculate and know what you normally use, so you can estimate when to charge, with out a checker, you have no way of telling if a servo or something suddenly drew more current than normal, so reducing the capacity, way below the safe level, then 'OUCH' occurs.
#20
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: GeelongVictoria, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 203
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: Silent-AV8R
FWIW here is a discharge comparison between a Hyperion LiFePO4 pack and a pack made with the Sanyo Eneloop cells. 500 mA load.
FWIW here is a discharge comparison between a Hyperion LiFePO4 pack and a pack made with the Sanyo Eneloop cells. 500 mA load.
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Cape Town, SOUTH AFRICA
Posts: 2,744
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
RE: LiFE Batteries
Its a good char tot illustrate a point but its not correct. The Hyperion packs hit 6.6V and gradually drop to 6.5V so that straight flat line should have a slight slope to it.
Its that slope the battery checkers look for because they measure the LiFe batteries to .001 of a Volt.
Its that slope the battery checkers look for because they measure the LiFe batteries to .001 of a Volt.
#22
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: ozzieflyer
That is a really good chart to look at.
ORIGINAL: Silent-AV8R
FWIW here is a discharge comparison between a Hyperion LiFePO4 pack and a pack made with the Sanyo Eneloop cells. 500 mA load.
FWIW here is a discharge comparison between a Hyperion LiFePO4 pack and a pack made with the Sanyo Eneloop cells. 500 mA load.
The ENELOOP is a very high shelf life - low current app.
as such they are unbeatable
an example would be a TX pack whre the AA size makes them easy to fit. also cameras an all kind of low current stuff
The LIFE cell is for high current uses
prices are faaaar different too
#23
RE: LiFE Batteries
The point for this thread was not to imply or compare the ENeloop cells, but rather to simply show a constant current discharge curve. I did do the chart originally to show the difference in curves in order to highlight that Eneloop cells have a much higher voltage drop at a given load due to their higher internal impedance. I think they are great for transmitters and very low load airborne use. Higher load uses I would not use them.
#24
RE: LiFE Batteries
ORIGINAL: TimBle
Its a good char tot illustrate a point but its not correct. The Hyperion packs hit 6.6V and gradually drop to 6.5V so that straight flat line should have a slight slope to it.
Its that slope the battery checkers look for because they measure the LiFe batteries to .001 of a Volt.
Its a good char tot illustrate a point but its not correct. The Hyperion packs hit 6.6V and gradually drop to 6.5V so that straight flat line should have a slight slope to it.
Its that slope the battery checkers look for because they measure the LiFe batteries to .001 of a Volt.
#25
RE: LiFE Batteries
The FMA "fuel guage" is also not accurate - not even close
again it shows a number which never equals % of remaining power
Here is the rub:
depending on the rate at which you suck power from th e batts- the "remaining power "will change
stated differently if the outrush is extremely high, the cells change temp and measuring will not be accurate (kinda like that ENELOOP chart - it makes the ENELOOP look like a cheezy cell - -but the current is of course beyond design specs.)
I see over n over comments about 2.4 rx failing -when in most cases - the failure is simply a failure to provide voltage req'd under load
Selecting wrong battery is a classic screwup
classic evaluation is "the battery was still almost full"
means nothing if the load is high enough.
again it shows a number which never equals % of remaining power
Here is the rub:
depending on the rate at which you suck power from th e batts- the "remaining power "will change
stated differently if the outrush is extremely high, the cells change temp and measuring will not be accurate (kinda like that ENELOOP chart - it makes the ENELOOP look like a cheezy cell - -but the current is of course beyond design specs.)
I see over n over comments about 2.4 rx failing -when in most cases - the failure is simply a failure to provide voltage req'd under load
Selecting wrong battery is a classic screwup
classic evaluation is "the battery was still almost full"
means nothing if the load is high enough.