Mini PCM reciever
#1
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Waseca,
MN
Posts: 8,456
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mini PCM reciever
Just curious, is anyone aware of a PCM 4 or 5 channel receiver compatable with a Futaba transmitter?
Don't see one either by Futaba or Hitec, any ideas?
Looking for something rather small and light for a fast plane.
Don't see one either by Futaba or Hitec, any ideas?
Looking for something rather small and light for a fast plane.
#2
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
Why does it have to be PCM?
There are a growing number of small, light, reliable and very sophisticated receivers out there now which offer virtually all the benefits of PCM but at a lower cost and with greater compatibility. Some of these receivers offer failsafe capabilities and automatically filter out interference. Others add the ability to respond only to your transmitter's electronic signature, significantly reducing the chances of beign shot down by someone accidentally using the same channel while you're flying.
The newest of the breed even offer fully-synthesized operation such that you can quickly change to any channel with the push of a button or the turn of a few knobs.
PCM is great -- but it's not the only way to get a virtually bullet-proof setup.
There are a growing number of small, light, reliable and very sophisticated receivers out there now which offer virtually all the benefits of PCM but at a lower cost and with greater compatibility. Some of these receivers offer failsafe capabilities and automatically filter out interference. Others add the ability to respond only to your transmitter's electronic signature, significantly reducing the chances of beign shot down by someone accidentally using the same channel while you're flying.
The newest of the breed even offer fully-synthesized operation such that you can quickly change to any channel with the push of a button or the turn of a few knobs.
PCM is great -- but it's not the only way to get a virtually bullet-proof setup.
#3
Senior Member
RE: Mini PCM reciever
Others add the ability to respond only to your transmitter's electronic signature,
I do understand how TX and RX can be purchased together.
Bill S
#4
My Feedback: (3)
RE: Mini PCM reciever
ORIGINAL: BillS
Daven asked about buying only a receiver. I don’t quite understand how the receiver only can respond to the signature of an existing Futaba transmitter. Do all Futaba transmitters transmit a signature? Is only a matter of buying the correct receiver? Would you mind clarifying?
I do understand how TX and RX can be purchased together.
Bill S
Others add the ability to respond only to your transmitter's electronic signature,
I do understand how TX and RX can be purchased together.
Bill S
I'm wondering why one would want a low channel count PCM receiver, but that's what he asked about.
Best wishes,
Dave Olson
#5
My Feedback: (31)
RE: Mini PCM reciever
daven
Futaba has a small 8 channel PCM RX on 72mhz available.
As mentioned above, there are alternatives to our tried and true PPM RX's which offer fail-safes, IPD (Intelligent pulse decoding), DSR (digital signal recognition) and or DSP (Digital signal processing).
Essentially these RX's have intelligent signal processing which works pro-actively to keep your model flying glitch free. The RX is able to reconcile an errant pulse train between a valid one by comparing previous valid instructions or positional information. Once confused, the RX will generate a frame to replace a known bad frame, if the inference continues a Fail-safe Setting will take over much like with a PCM RX. Additionally the DSR capable RX's recognize/memorize the pulse train and modulation shift signature of your TX and attempt to ignore other TX's.
What's neat about these RX's is they offer features in line with PCM and work with any PPM TX, some even have auto-shift select capabilities. These Rx’s are also reasonably priced IMO.
Berg, Multiplex and FMA offer this technology in Small footprint RX's currently and its widely utilized and accepted in the electric world.
Futaba has a small 8 channel PCM RX on 72mhz available.
As mentioned above, there are alternatives to our tried and true PPM RX's which offer fail-safes, IPD (Intelligent pulse decoding), DSR (digital signal recognition) and or DSP (Digital signal processing).
Essentially these RX's have intelligent signal processing which works pro-actively to keep your model flying glitch free. The RX is able to reconcile an errant pulse train between a valid one by comparing previous valid instructions or positional information. Once confused, the RX will generate a frame to replace a known bad frame, if the inference continues a Fail-safe Setting will take over much like with a PCM RX. Additionally the DSR capable RX's recognize/memorize the pulse train and modulation shift signature of your TX and attempt to ignore other TX's.
What's neat about these RX's is they offer features in line with PCM and work with any PPM TX, some even have auto-shift select capabilities. These Rx’s are also reasonably priced IMO.
Berg, Multiplex and FMA offer this technology in Small footprint RX's currently and its widely utilized and accepted in the electric world.
#6
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
ORIGINAL: mglavin
Berg, Multiplex and FMA offer this technology in Small footprint RX's currently and its widely utilized and accepted in the electric world.
Berg, Multiplex and FMA offer this technology in Small footprint RX's currently and its widely utilized and accepted in the electric world.
I'm using these receivers in much larger planes (.90-sized) where they outperform conventional PPM and in some cases even PCM receivers. It's quite surprising just how good some of these smart receivers are.
As I often say (:-), I can't understand why people continue to buy "dumb" FM/PPM receivers when these smarter alternatives are available for the same (or sometimes even less) money.
#7
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Waseca,
MN
Posts: 8,456
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
Ok,
Maybe I should have clarified this a bit better. I run both a Futaba 9c and 8uafs with Hitec 555 and Electron 6 receivers. In MOST cases, they are bullet proof in my 170-180 mph racing planes. However, on several ocassions over the past couple of years, I have gotten bad bumps while flying at major national racing events. Not saying this has ever costed me a race, but it scares the crap out of you in the middle of a heat when your plane acts like full down elevator has been applied for about 1/2 a second at these speeds.
The pylon Futaba sponsored guys have recommended the 149 DP PCM receiver, but I struggle spending $160 on a relatively large and heavy receiver for pylon racing. If there was a smaller 4-5 channel PCM (or anything better than what I'm using) receiver, I'd give it a try.
These are very expensive planes, and I never reuse electronics (receivers/switches/and servos) after a crash in my "traveling" planes so I know my equiptment is sound.
Thanks for your comments so far.
Maybe I should have clarified this a bit better. I run both a Futaba 9c and 8uafs with Hitec 555 and Electron 6 receivers. In MOST cases, they are bullet proof in my 170-180 mph racing planes. However, on several ocassions over the past couple of years, I have gotten bad bumps while flying at major national racing events. Not saying this has ever costed me a race, but it scares the crap out of you in the middle of a heat when your plane acts like full down elevator has been applied for about 1/2 a second at these speeds.
The pylon Futaba sponsored guys have recommended the 149 DP PCM receiver, but I struggle spending $160 on a relatively large and heavy receiver for pylon racing. If there was a smaller 4-5 channel PCM (or anything better than what I'm using) receiver, I'd give it a try.
These are very expensive planes, and I never reuse electronics (receivers/switches/and servos) after a crash in my "traveling" planes so I know my equiptment is sound.
Thanks for your comments so far.
#8
My Feedback: (31)
RE: Mini PCM reciever
ORIGINAL: XJet
They're no longer limited to small electrics and park-fliers though.
They're no longer limited to small electrics and park-fliers though.
Were also using this new technology (although its not that new anymore) in our larger birds... Multiplex offers several IPD RX's standard size and smaller.
We rigged Josh's 39% Aeroworks Extra with MPX's new 12 channel IPD synth RX for the 2004 XFC last year and have been using it ever since... We also have a few large electric with the smaller IPD's.
#9
My Feedback: (31)
RE: Mini PCM reciever
Dave
The IPD stuff is better than the any standard PPM RX........ In case I wasn't clear these intelligent RX's are running neck and neck with PCM RX's and may even be better in some aspects. read through my comments above and you'll note that this technology affords all the benefits of PCM and then some.
Multiplex the innovator of PCM protocol to the RC world no longer offers PCM and has moved into the future with IPD RX's.
The IPD stuff is better than the any standard PPM RX........ In case I wasn't clear these intelligent RX's are running neck and neck with PCM RX's and may even be better in some aspects. read through my comments above and you'll note that this technology affords all the benefits of PCM and then some.
Multiplex the innovator of PCM protocol to the RC world no longer offers PCM and has moved into the future with IPD RX's.
#11
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
RE: Mini PCM reciever
a good start would be the FMA FS8 that only weighs about 15g without all the co-pilot crap.
fully programmable failsafe, scans your frequency for other users before you turn your Tx on, glitch counter that tells you of any interference you had during a flight and also has flight data recording ability with a PC interface.
i love mine!
dave
fully programmable failsafe, scans your frequency for other users before you turn your Tx on, glitch counter that tells you of any interference you had during a flight and also has flight data recording ability with a PC interface.
i love mine!
dave
#13
My Feedback: (31)
RE: Mini PCM reciever
Dave
Presently the only MPX IPD offerings less the synthesized stuff works with negative shift TX's only, so Futaba is out for now.
Berg and FMA make small foot print RX's.
http://bergent.net/
https://www.fmadirect.com/site/home.htm
Presently the only MPX IPD offerings less the synthesized stuff works with negative shift TX's only, so Futaba is out for now.
Berg and FMA make small foot print RX's.
http://bergent.net/
https://www.fmadirect.com/site/home.htm
#15
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
ORIGINAL: ZAGNUT
a good start would be the FMA FS8 that only weighs about 15g without all the co-pilot crap.
fully programmable failsafe, scans your frequency for other users before you turn your Tx on, glitch counter that tells you of any interference you had during a flight and also has flight data recording ability with a PC interface.
a good start would be the FMA FS8 that only weighs about 15g without all the co-pilot crap.
fully programmable failsafe, scans your frequency for other users before you turn your Tx on, glitch counter that tells you of any interference you had during a flight and also has flight data recording ability with a PC interface.
There are now a raft of IPD/DSP/SMART/etc receivers out there, all with their different strengths and weaknesses.
Perhaps the biggest problem for your application might be the lack of channels
The Sombra Shadow is a newcomer that's looking pretty good and it has the bonus that it's synthesized so you can switch to any legal 72MHz channel in just a few seconds without changing crystals. It's also one of the lightest/smallest of the current crop and their support seems superb so far. The version 1 is 6-channels but their 7-channel model is due out shortly.
The Bergs have a well-deserved reputation for performance and support -- but a maximum of 6 channels can/will be somewhat limiting.
Both the Berg and the Sombra have auto-shift detect which makes them compatible with just about every brand of transmitter (in PPM mode) that's out there. The only incompatibility at this stage is the synthesized Futaba transmitters, although most other brands of synthesized transmitters work just fine apparently.
Both the Berg and Sombra also have something called TSR which effectively locks the receiver onto the characteristics of its specific data-frame. This makes them far more resistant to the effects of another transmitter operating on the same channel. I was skeptical about this but it's incredibly effective.
While all these tech-features sound great, don't underestimate the importance of support either...
I've gotten replies to emails sent to Berg at 9pm on a Sunday evening and questions get answered very promptly, professionally and by someone with great technical ability.
And, while other manufacturers seem to struggle to even acknowledge faults, the guys at Sombra have identified, acknowledged and are making available a fix to a small firmware problem that occured in the first batch of these receivers. I know at least one other major RC manufacturer that, weeks later, still don't have fixes for their firmware woes in multiple products, leaving some users twiddling their thumbs or facing extra expenses to "work around" the problems.
As products become increasingly complex it's unreasonable to expect every new design to be perfect but what counts is the speed and efficiency with which any problems are addressed.
#16
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Waseca,
MN
Posts: 8,456
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
The limitation of channels is not a problem in my case. What I'm looking for is a rock solid "bullet proof" 5 channel receiver. If it costs a $120, I would be ok with that, I just need something that is going to be perfect. These planes tend to take a beating with midairs, crashes, and rough landings, so anything susecptable to damage from bouncing around will not be ok.
Thanks to everyone who has responded so far. At this point, I haven't found anything better than what I am using.
Thanks to everyone who has responded so far. At this point, I haven't found anything better than what I am using.
#17
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
Thanks to everyone who has responded so far. At this point, I haven't found anything better than what I am using
#18
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Leeds, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 1,449
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
8 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
I am using Multiplex IPD and IPD Synth Rx's in my jets which are even faster (and I suspect even more expensive[]) than your Pylon racers. They also have the added benefit of slightly faster response. They do a relatively small 7 channel IPD Rx at a good price. Only single conversion but no problems with them in my electric models. The jets all have the larger 12 channel double conversion Rx's.
Simprop and Webra also make small IPD Rx's but I am not sure if they are available in the USA.
Regards,
John.
Simprop and Webra also make small IPD Rx's but I am not sure if they are available in the USA.
Regards,
John.
#19
Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Apex, NC
Posts: 96
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
Sombra! I just tried mine. I turn on both my TXs on the same channel. The Sombra only responded to the first TX that was turn on! Amazing. It is also dual conversion and weighs only 8g.
Victor
Victor
#20
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
ORIGINAL: vkmaynard
Sombra! I just tried mine. I turn on both my TXs on the same channel. The Sombra only responded to the first TX that was turn on! Amazing. It is also dual conversion and weighs only 8g.
Sombra! I just tried mine. I turn on both my TXs on the same channel. The Sombra only responded to the first TX that was turn on! Amazing. It is also dual conversion and weighs only 8g.
#21
My Feedback: (5)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: San Tan Valley,
AZ
Posts: 5,768
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
ORIGINAL: mglavin
Dave
Presently the only MPX IPD offerings less the synthesized stuff works with negative shift TX's only, so Futaba is out for now.
Berg and FMA make small foot print RX's.
http://bergent.net/
https://www.fmadirect.com/site/home.htm
Dave
Presently the only MPX IPD offerings less the synthesized stuff works with negative shift TX's only, so Futaba is out for now.
Berg and FMA make small foot print RX's.
http://bergent.net/
https://www.fmadirect.com/site/home.htm
#22
My Feedback: (1)
RE: Mini PCM reciever
XJet
I am interested in the same applications a Daven and there is nothing worse than carrying around extra baggage like 'channels' or the room to stuff them somewhere.
I have some links for Berg but can,t find anything on Sombra perhaps you have the info?
John
Team Geriatric
I am interested in the same applications a Daven and there is nothing worse than carrying around extra baggage like 'channels' or the room to stuff them somewhere.
I have some links for Berg but can,t find anything on Sombra perhaps you have the info?
John
Team Geriatric
#23
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
RE: Mini PCM reciever
ORIGINAL: daven
Thanks to everyone who has responded so far. At this point, I haven't found anything better than what I am using.
Thanks to everyone who has responded so far. At this point, I haven't found anything better than what I am using.
and from what i know the sombra receivers have all been scarfed up and people are waiting for the next production run. the radio forum at RCG has a couple of heavy-duty threads on the subject with plenty of comments from sombra.
dave
#25
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Waseca,
MN
Posts: 8,456
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Mini PCM reciever
Actually I am doubting it.
At 24000+ RPM and 180 mph, I need something I can trust. I'm not aware of any pylon racer using these new styles of receivers. NOT that I don't think their capable, I just am not sure I want to be a guinea pig.
I appreciate your suggestions, but there something about the FMA and even the Berg receivers that makes me think they look "cheap" and I'm not sure I am willing to take the risk.
Not trying to be a jerk, just my opinion.
thanks,
At 24000+ RPM and 180 mph, I need something I can trust. I'm not aware of any pylon racer using these new styles of receivers. NOT that I don't think their capable, I just am not sure I want to be a guinea pig.
I appreciate your suggestions, but there something about the FMA and even the Berg receivers that makes me think they look "cheap" and I'm not sure I am willing to take the risk.
Not trying to be a jerk, just my opinion.
thanks,