RCU Review: Top Flite P-40 Warhawk


More On This Product

  • 2 Active For-Sale Ads!
  • Discussions on this Product
  • Show user ratings
  • Check for Retailers
  •  
     
    Contributed by: Mike Buzzeo | Published: May 2011 | Views: 44250 | email icon Email this Article | PDFpdf icon
    RCUniverse.com Review of the Top Flite P-40 Warhawk
    Mike Buzzeo
    (MinnFlyer)

    Email Me




    Distributed Exclusively by:
    Great Planes
    Model Manufacturing Company


    P.O. Box 9021
    Champaign, IL 61826-9021
    www.top-flite.com

    By 1937 it was becoming obvious to the U.S. that neutrality in world events wouldn't last much longer. In foresight, the Curtis-Wright Corporation redesigned their radial engine P-36 to incorporate an Allison 12-cylindar in-line engine. When the U.S. called for a new fighter that could be produced easily and inexpensively, the newly dubbed P-40 won out over newer designs like the P-38 Lightning due to its more proven airframe.

    The P-40 was the workhorse of the US inventory. It developed an undeserved reputation as a poor fighter because it was out maneuvered by the Japanese Zero, but what is often dismissed is the fact that the Zero out maneuvered ALL U.S. fighters!

    At first, it did not fare well in combat, but as time went on, tactics were developed to utilize the Warhawk's strengths and avoid situations where its abilities were lacking. The P-40's lack of a two-stage supercharger made it inferior to Luftwaffe fighters in high altitude combat and it was rarely used in operations in Northwest Europe. But between 1941 and 1944, the P-40 played a critical role with Allied air forces in three major theaters: North Africa, the Southwest Pacific and China. The P-40's high altitude performance was not as critical in those theaters, where it served as an air supremacy fighter, bomber escort and fighter bomber.

    Now, the P-40 Warhawk is the latest of the Top Flite Gold Edition Series to be created in ARF form. Their attention to detail is outstanding on this model which is presented in the color scheme and markings of the most famous of the P-40 squadrons, The Flying Tigers!

    Let's get started!


    • Built-Up Balsa and Light Ply
    • Painted Fiberglass Cowl
    • Scale Cockpit
    • Many Other Scale Details
    • MonoKote? Covering
    • Aluminum Spinner


    • Tail Wheel location is not to scale


    Skill Level:

    Time Required to Build:

    Frustration Level:

    What do these ratings mean?


    Name:Top Flite P-40 Warhawk

    Price: $349.98
    Stock Number: TOPA0970
    Wingspan: 64.5" (1640mm)
    Wing Area: 722 sq in (46.6 sq dm)
    Weight: 9.75 - 10lb (4420 - 4536g)
    Wing Loading: 31 - 32 oz/sq ft (95 - 98 g/sq dm)
    Length: 55" (1395mm)
    Airfoil: Fully-symmetrical, low-wing
    Center of Gravity: 3-1/4" (83mm) Back from the wing's leading edge
    Radio Used:Futaba 10CG
    Engine Used: O.S. 91 Surpass II
    Battery Used: HydriMax 4-Cell 4.8V 2000mAh NiMH
    Channels Used: 6 total - Elevator, Aileron, Throttle, Rudder, Flaps, Retracts

    Control Throws:
    Elevator:
    Rudder:
    Ailerons:
    Flaps:

    High Rate
    Up & Down 5/8" (16mm) 11°
    Right to Left 1-1/2" (38mm) 18°
    Up & Down 5/8" (16mm) 14°
    1-1/2" (38mm) 32°

    Low Rate
    7/16" (11mm) 7°
    1" (25mm) 12°
    1/2" (38mm) 12°
    3/4" (19mm) 15°





    The full-color box looks great and displays some of the scale features as well as recommended accessories and options.






    While some of the contents on top had shifted a bit, it was nothing major and no damage was done. The lower compartment had all items completely intact.






    Some of the more noteworthy items are the painted cowl (no decals here) the detail on the inside of the split flap (Note: the picture above was taken after the flap had been installed in the wing) and the scale cockpit; All of which add to the scale looks of the Warhawk.






    Other items that caught my eye were the aluminum spinner, a set of fixed landing gear (in case you choose to opt out of using retracts) and a set of decals that denote the famous "Flying Tigers".


    Manual


    While the manual was excellent overall, there were a few simple omissions which were covered in an added addendum.

    Download the manual


    FLAP AND AILERON HINGES





    The flaps are hinged with hinge points. You'll need to open the front of the holes a little to fit the bulky center of the hinges, but the hinges go in straight which makes alignment very easy. I used Epo-Grip #30 paste to epoxy the hinges in.






    The ailerons use CA hinges which you cut to size from a sheet of hinge material. If you haven't seen it yet, please read my article on CA hinges. Even if you think you know how to install these hinges, the article is worth your time to read: A Closer Look at CA Hinges



    AILERON AND FLAP SERVOS





    After you epoxy the hardwood blocks to the hatches, the servos can be mounted and the hatches installed. Be sure to harden all holes with thin CA. Each pocket has a pull string installed for routing the servo wires.






    Now the pushrods for the flaps and ailerons can be formed and installed using "L" bends and "FasLinks".



    WING ASSEMBLY





    The landing gear mounts get epoxied into the wing. I will be using the supplied fixed gear for now, but I intend to upgrade to retracts in the future, so I installed a pull string now for pulling the air lines through at a later time.






    Now it's time to join the two wing halves. Again, here I used Epo-Grip #30 paste which, as it turns out was the perfect adhesive to use as the joiner was a bit loose, but the #30 paste easily filled any gaps without oozing out of place.






    The belly pan comes next. With the wing mounted to the fuse, you align and mark the pan, remove the covering, and epoxy the pan in place.






    As I said earlier, I'm going to use the fixed gear for now. Top Flite provides an interesting gear arrangement where the fixed gear are mounted into plugs which fit the same mounts used for the retractable gear unit.

    The addendum warns that the fixed gear's wire must sit above the surface of the plug, so a shim might need to be used - and indeed, it was. I found that a small strip of a plastic outer pushrod tube worked perfectly for this.

    Finally, the wheels and fiberglass covers are added and the wing is complete.



    TAIL SECTION






    The tail section begins by installing the stab, aligning it and marking the covering with a felt-tip pen. The lines are now used as a guide to remove the covering and the stab is epoxied in place. For this, I used 30-Minute Epoxy.

    Next, the rudder and elevators are installed with CA Hinges.






    As you attach the rudder, the tail wheel assembly is also epoxied in place.

    Now the Control horns are added. Do not forget to remove them and harden the mounting holes with thin CA.




    ENGINE AND TANK


    The tank components are packaged together and Top Flite supplies everything needed for a 3-Line system.



    Once the tank was assembled, I used some colored DuBro fuel line for easy reference.



    The tank slides in behind the firewall and will be secured with the throttle servo tray.



    OS FS-91 II Surpass Closer Look
    O.S. FS-91 II Surpass

    The First Choice for Quality, Durability and Performance

    The OS 91 four stroke is a ringed piston engine which puts out 1.6bhp while weighing in at only 23 oz with muffler. It's practical rpm range is 2,000 to 12,000 rpm. Full specifications are below:

    • Bore: 27.7mm (1.09")
    • Stroke: 24.8mm (.976")
    • Displacement: 14.95cc (0.912 cubic inch)
    • Power Output: 1.6 BHP at 11,000 rpm
    • Practical RPM Range: 2,000 - 12,000 rpm
    • Crankshaft Thread Size: 5/16" x 24
    • Weight: w/o muffler- 21.3 oz (603g) with muffler- 23.0 oz (655g)

    The manufacturer recommends this engine be run on fuel containing 5% to 15% nitromethane and oil content at a minimum of 18%. I chose to use Cool Power with 15% nitro and 18% synthetic oil as I've found it runs extremely well in all my engines and especially the 4 strokes. The synthetic oil helps to keep the 4 stroke cleaner while castor can gum them up over time.

    Some of the advantages of the 4 stroke engines are fuel economy, their ability to swing a larger prop, and (My favorite) that cool 4-stroke sound!

    Props recommended by the mfg. for the OS 91FS are:
    Stunt planes: 11 x 11-12, 12 x 10-12, 13 x 9
    Scale models: 13.5 x 8, 14 x 7, 15 x 6, 16 x 6, (12 x 8 & 12.5 x 7-3 blade)

    The prop used for this review was a Graupner 14 x 7

    This version II of the OS 91 sports more power than its former model and comes with a full 2 year warranty from OS.

    O.S. 2-Year Warranty icon

    Download the manual in PDF format - Click here





    The engine mount can now be installed. Blind nuts are pre-installed in the firewall, so the mount just screws right in. Now the engine can be placed and marked for an 8-32 tapped hole.

    Using an optional 90° exhaust header, you can fit the muffler completely inside the cowl.



    RADIO INSTALLATION



    With the engine in place, you can now mount the throttle servo. There is a pushrod tube pre-installed on both sides of the engine, so all that's left is to bend a pushrod to shape and secure it with the provided connectors.



    The rudder and elevator servos mount in the rear of the compartment. The two elevator pushrods connect to one servo. There is not much room back there, but the manual guides you through the process very nicely.

    Next, the battery and receiver are installed with Velcro. I used some 1/4" DuBro foam under each. Finally, I added a DuBro DuBro Kwik Switch & Charging Jack


    COWL



    Cowl installation is typical, but here again is one of the notes from the manual's addendum - In the manual, the bottom, rear screw is 1 1/4" from the bottom and the measurement from the bottom screw to the top screw is listed as 4 1/4". In reality, the top screw is 4 1/4" from the bottom of the plane, but only 3" from the bottom screw.

    I added a Graupner 14x7 prop and the spinner and she is lookin' good!



    COCKPIT



    Top Flite provides an easy-to-install scale cockpit that really adds to the looks. I added a Century Jet Models pilot for added realism.



    OPTIONAL RETRACTS



    If you choose to install the optional retracts it's an easy switch from the provided fixed gear. The retracts just bolt right in, then you measure and cut the struts and axles to size.



    The air tank fits into an opening in the rear fuse and a place is provided for the air valve servo and the valve itself.

    A bracket is provided if you are using the new Top Flite retracts, but I was using Robart's. I found that by enlarging the pushrod hole, I could make a bracket from scrap plywood to which I could mount the valve. Then the bracket can be screwed in place.



    FINISHING



    To finish things off, I mounted the air inlet valve just below the remote glow fixture and the canopy was glued in place with Pacer Formula 560 Canopy Glue.

    I also replaced the supplied canopy screws with some socket head screws.



    BALANCING



    I rarely say much about balancing, but I have to make an exception here. The P-40 needs a whopping "Hunk-O-Lead" up front. Mine required 22oz to balance at the recommended CG.

    Now, I can imagine that a lot of people out there are breaking out in a sweat over that - Relax, adding that much weight to a warbird is not unusual, nor is it anything to get excited about. Since the advent of 3D flying, a lot of people think that adding weight is some sort of sacrilege - It's not. It is far more important that the plane is properly balanced than you skimp on weight for the sake of skimping on weight.

    That said, if you're one of those people who would rather die than add dead weight, there is plenty of room on top of the engine mount to "piggy-back" a plywood plate to which you could mount the battery. This may not completely eliminate added weight, but it will save you quite a bit.



    Due to production delays, I didn't receive the P-40 until late October - which in Minnesota is like mid-winter for most of the country. By the time I had her ready, the weather had turned pretty bad and before long we had a good blanket of snow on the ground. My only hope of flying it before spring would be to make a trip down to Florida to visit my folks.

    I wasn't really looking forward to doing that drive again, but as it turned out, my friends Loren and Garret were driving down there with their wives in late February and were kind enough to haul a few airplanes down there for me (it's good to have friends in this hobby!). So I flew down to West Palm Beach, and my dad and I drove up to Orlando to meet up with the guys.

    Back at my dad's field a few days later, we fueled her up and cranked over the OS 91 for the first time. She sprang to life like a well-used engine (I even had the needle set perfectly!). In no time she was taxiing out to the paved runway. A few medium-speed taxis showed her to be a little squirrely on the ground, but this is not uncommon for a plane with such a narrow undercarriage.

    Once I got the feel for how it rolls, I went to the far end of the runway and poured the coals to it. It took a good amount of right rudder, and even then she was pulling to the left. Once airborne, I needed a fair amount of right aileron trim to get her flying hands-off, (which explained the tendency to pull to the left so much on takeoff) but once she was trimmed out, she flew steady and true.

    I then put it through a few basic maneuvers. Rolls were very scale-like and loops tracked very well. In fact, it flew with a very scale feel throughout the flight. The full-scale P-40 was no aerobat, it was a workhorse, and this Top Flite model was very true to the nature of its namesake. She feels heavy, yet she can pull some surprisingly good aerobatics, and the 91 Surpass was an ideal choice of power!

    After a few more circuits, it was time to land. Once some speed had been bled off, the flaps were lowered and very little ballooning occurred. The gear came down nicely and she settled in on a perfect final. Knowing that the plane has a heavy wing loading, I didn't allow it to get too slow - I just flew it to the ground. She touched down on the mains and I slowly allowed the tail to drop. A few more landing attempts proved that you really need to keep a little speed going. This baby will not "float" in and if you try to do so, it will most likely stall and fall.

    The weather conditions were perfect and my buddy Jim Record was at the field that morning, so I asked him to take the sticks while I shot some video. Jim was happy to oblige, so I got out the cameras and started shooting.



    Check out the video to see her in action!





    Top Flite P-40 Warhawk
    Or, Download the Video (24meg)
    CLICK HERE












    The Top Flite P-40 Warhawk is not a sport plane disguised as a warbird, and anyone who is less than an experienced pilot will find takeoffs and landings more than they bargained for. She looks great in the air or on the ground and she's a very steady, rock-solid flier.

    Assembly is very well engineered. A few basic building skills are required, but nothing too difficult and assembly time is just under 20 hours.

    So if you are a warbird fan who has always dreamed of having a true-to-scale P-40, this is it!





    Distributed by
    Great Planes Model Distributors
    P.O. Box 9021
    Champaign, IL 61826-9021
    www.greatplanes.com



    Futaba Corporation of America
    Distributed by:
    Great Planes Model Distributors
    P.O. Box 9021; Champaign, IL 61826-9021
    Website: www.futaba-rc.com



    O.S. Engines
    Distributed through
    Great Planes Model Distributors

    2904 Research Rd.
    Champaign IL 61826
    Phone: (217) 398-8970
    Website: www.osengines.com



    Du-Bro
    Everything For The R/C Hobbyist
    Phone: 1-800-848-9411
    Website: www.dubro.com



    Robart Mfg, Inc.
    625 N. 12th St.
    St. Charles, IL 60174
    Phone: (630) 584-7616
    Website: www.robart.com


    Comments on RCU Review: Top Flite P-40 Warhawk

    Posted by: Kostas1 on 05/30/2011
    Excellent review! Well done! Ah and a friendly suggestion.... Use some glow fuel tubing with small diameter between the washer and wing servo hatches.....it will absorb the vibration and work as a safety-lock.... It worked really great on my GreatPlanes Cherokee 40 ARF : http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/fb.asp?m=10542903
    Posted by: LDM on 06/01/2011
    Nice flying, curiuos why the warning on wing loading? I did not see your final weight, but earler reports were good on weight vs the Gold Edition kit built verion. Also do you feel right thrust (engine) will take all the right aleron trim needed out or at leaste some?
    Posted by: MinnFlyer on 06/01/2011
    The warning is to remind people that the wing loading is high so if you try to float it in like a sport plane you're likely to stall. My weight came in just a hair over 10lbs. Right thrust might help, but the cowl has a fixed position, so it would require moving the mounting holes in the firewall to be moved to the left
    Posted by: rcjake on 06/01/2011
    Could a retractable tailwheel be installed without too much trouble? Jake
    Posted by: rcjake on 06/01/2011
    Double post...sorry! Jake
    Posted by: rcjake on 06/01/2011
    Triple post??? Sorry, AGAIN!!! Jake
    Posted by: MinnFlyer on 06/01/2011
    I don't see why not
    Posted by: EFHANC on 06/01/2011
    $350??
    Posted by: MinnFlyer on 06/01/2011
    Top flite are more expensive than some, but the quality makes up for it
    Posted by: TCraft Lover on 06/04/2011
    Think a 1.20 size 4 stroke is too much?
    Page: 1 2 3 >
    The comments, observations and conclusions made in this review are solely with respect to the particular item the editor reviewed and may not apply generally to similar products by the manufacturer. We cannot be responsible for any manufacturer defects in workmanship or other deficiencies in products like the one featured in the review.

    EMAIL THIS ARTICLE OR CHECK OUT THESE OTHER GREAT REVIEWS!
     
    PhotoManufacturerProductSummaryReviewed
    AresTaylorcraft 130 (RTF) Meet the newest plane from Ares (pronounced Air-Ease). A state of the art, upgradeable Taylorcraft - it comes out of the box ...04/17/2014
    Maxford USAHansa-Brandenburg ARF with SkisHere's one of the later additions to Maxford USA's lineup. Maxford USA has been a great company to offer a wide array of airc...04/17/2014
    Best Pilotsrealistic looking pilot figuresI have been in the RC hobby for a long time and one thing that has always bothered me was that it has been next to impossible...03/23/2014
    SIGKadet Senior Sport EG ARFSIG's latest offering is the new Kadet Senior Sport EG. Like the Seniors of yesterday, this version offers stable and forgivi...03/23/2014
    Aeroworks20cc-30cc Trainer GT ARF-QBEvery year I attend the Weak Signals RC Show held in Toledo, Ohio, more commonly called "The Toledo Show". One booth I always...03/23/2014
    RedwingRCSBACH RedwingRC delivers their Sbach 342 in a 30cc size, developed specifically for 30cc power plants. The plane is available in 3 ...02/17/2014
    Michel Clavier ModelismeSalto RTFThe latest addition to MCM·s offering is a semi-scale reproduction of this majestic glider. The Salto MCM is a four meter ele...02/08/2014
    Esprit ModelStandbox SystemThe standbox is a unique product for our hobby. The product is marketed as a 4-in-1 unit with the main functions being storag...02/03/2014
    TacticTTX403-Channel SLT Mini Radio Now, if you go for the RTF aircraft, you get a nifty little radio - a Tactic TTX402. It's a nice, mini-sized transmitter that...01/31/2014
    Du-Bro’sHeavy Duty Pull-Pull System & Full Du-Bro has introduced a line of accessories for Giant Scale planes including a complete pull-pull package. The only item miss...01/18/2014
    Great PlanesEscapade MX ARFDesigned for both glow or electric power, this new version looks a little leaner and meaner. With its mid-mounted, straight w...01/11/2014
    Hitec RCD USAWeekender ZipperMix it up with your friends at the local park or field with our agile Zipper! Easy to hand launch and perfect for lunchtime s...01/11/2014
    AircoreModular Aircraft SystemNow, there's a new option! Designed to fly nearly anywhere, Flyzone has introduced AirCore - a new modular system that allows...01/01/2014
    Maxford USAProfile P-47 ARFNew from Maxford USA is the Profile P-47. Designed to be a fun-fly type plane, this plane looks to be a great plane for slow ...12/13/2013
    The World ModelsZero 40EP ARF with Electric PackageThe World Models has added a new Zero to their lineup - the Zero EP 40 ARF. The Zero EP is a warbird designed for electric po...11/17/2013
     

      Return to Magazine Homepage






     
    RCUniverse is a service of Internet Brands, Inc. Copyright © 2001-2014.  Privacy Policy
     
    GET FREE RC CONTENT FOR YOUR WEBSITE

    Search | Marketplace | Event Central | Local Clubs | Magazine | Product Ratings | New Products | Discussion Forums

    Photo Gallery | Instructor Search | Field|Track|Marina Search | RCU Youtube Channel | | RCU Twitter!

    Member Locator | Advertisers | Hobby Vendor Resources | Rate Manufacturers | Sign In/Sign Up

    Products Videos WattFlyer.com RC Classifieds

    RCU4 | 54.198.34.238 | 0 | 1 | 03:52:04 PM EST | NC