RCU Review: Basics of choosing a motor and ESC/MSC and Brushed vs. Brushless Systems


More On This Product

  • Research Airplanes
  • Research Boats
  • Research Cars
  • Research Helicopters
  • Research Engines & Motors
  • Research Radio Equipment
  •  
     
    Contributed by: Alex Berman | Published: April 2005 | Views: 212918 | email icon Email this Article | PDFpdf icon

    ?Basics of choosing a motor and ESC/MSC and Brushed vs. Brushless Systems?

    There are always a ton of threads about motors and ESCs and they are all usually variants on the same questions. In this article I will go through and explain the basics of choosing a motor and ESC/MSC, and talk about brushed vs. brushless systems.

    When choosing a motor it is important to choose one that meets your abilities and budget. The first thing to consider when buying a motor is how fast you realistically want the car to go. I know you all want your cars going 50mph, but there are only a few of us who have enough driving experience to go that fast without hitting straight into a wall. The basics on turns and winds are as follows:


    Lower Turn = Higher Top End/Less Torque
    Higher Turn = Lower Top End/More Torque

    As you look at motors with lower winds, you begin to see motors like a 9x3. This means that the motor is 9 turns and has 3 winds. The winds are simply for more speed, the more you have, the faster you go. One thing to note about lower turn motors is that they need a lot more maintenance. You can probably run a stock motor (27T) for 15-20 runs before it needs to have the commutator cut. On the other hand, a 9T motor needs to be cut every 3-5 runs.

    There are a few classes for brushed motors:
    Stock (27 Turn)
    19T Spec (19 Turn)
    Unlimited (Any amount of turns)

    Your hobby shop or race track may have others, but these are the common ones.

    Choosing whether to get an ESC or MSC is an easy decision. Get an ESC. MSCs (Mechanical Speed Controls) are very outdated and cannot handle today's motors.
    When choosing an ESC you truly have to rate your skill level. While you may have a 19 Turn motor today, will you be changing to an 8 Turn motor soon? The answer is probably not. An ESC's limit is the lowest number of turns that it can handle. Now you have to make a big decision. Since ESCs that can handle lower turn motors are more expensive, you will have to decide how low you're gonna go. It makes no sense to buy an ESC with no turn limits if you are going to race Stock and 19 Spec, nor does it make sense to buy an ESC with a 17T limit if you are going to race Unlimited. This is basically up to you (and your budget), but be reasonable and get an ESC with a limit that is around your skill level.

    My final rant will be on brushed vs. brushless. While these systems are in relatively the same price range, they each have their own pros and cons. A brushed system needs a lot of maintenance, but offers more flexibility because you can change motors depending on track conditions (how much torque you need). A brushless system on the other hand, needs almost no maintenance.

    There are two basic decisions you need to make when buying a brushless system. How much can you afford to spend and how many transmission gears you want to replace. The Novak systems are more affordable, ranging from about $180-210 and include both a motor and ESC. The next level up would be a Warrior/Feigao combo which will be about $250 and will have more power and a nicer ESC. The highest level of brushless are the Hackers, Lehners, and Shulze. These are not for novices, and must be geared almost perfectly. These systems can range from about $400-800 for just a motor and ESC. Also note that the Novak and Warrior/Feigao combos offer better customer support and are easier to get.

    I hope this article has answered most of your questions about motors and ESCs. Good luck, and have fun!

     

    Comments on RCU Review: Basics of choosing a motor and ESC/MSC and Brushed vs. Brushless Systems

    Posted by: drive2survive on 06/03/2009
    I just aquired a 1/12 pan car with A 19 T brushed motor, what Im trying to find out is what kind of ESC should I use??? what Ive heard is 230A max 20 constant, is this right, plez suggest something so I can get this car going thanx
    Page: 1

    EMAIL THIS ARTICLE OR CHECK OUT THESE OTHER GREAT REVIEWS!
     
    PhotoManufacturerProductSummaryReviewed
    HelionDominus 10SCv2The Helion Dominus SCv2 is a short course 4x4 truck, and it's a crowded space filled with many choices and price ranges. This...06/08/2014
    HPIBlitz RTRHPI Racing delivers another robust race ready Short Course Truck, the Blitz RTR. Out of the box, this truck is ready to lead ...11/02/2013
    VaterraKalahari 1/14 Scale 4WD Desert RaidPit your driving skills against the toughest terrain with the Kalahari desert raider. Its rugged, four-wheel drive chassis an...08/04/2013
    Vaterra1/14 RTR Kemora 4WD RallycrossThose are quotes taken from the Vaterra Kemora rallycross web page. Four wheel drive, brushless power, and four-wheel indepen...08/04/2013
    TraxxasEZ-Peak™ 5 Amp NiMH ChargerThe Traxxas EZ-Peak™ 5 Amp NiMH Charger is a great addition to Traxxas' charger line up. Although it only charges NiCD and Ni...08/04/2013
    TraxxasEZ-Peak™ 4 Amp AC NiMH ChargerThe Traxxas EZ-Peak™4 Amp NiMH Charger is an easy to use AC powered battery charger capable of charging NiCD and NiMH battery...08/04/2013
    DHK WolfBL 1/10 Scale 4WD Brushless BuggyThe Wolf came out of the box with a 2S 2300 mAh Lipo battery. Even this proved to be too much power for the track, as the tur...04/28/2013
    TraxxasSlash 4x4 Low Center of Gravity ChaThe Traxxas Slash has been a popular truck for both bashers and racers alike. With the 4 x 4 short course truck class growing...04/28/2013
    TraxxasUltra Premium Tire GlueTraxxas now offers a premium tire glue. This is a Cyanoacrylate based glue and will bond most plastics and rubber. Important ...04/14/2013
    TraxxasSlash, Robby Gordon Dakar editionDirt is where this truck truly belongs! The soft suspension helps this truck hook up in the dirt. There is a good balance of ...02/18/2013
    AtomikMetal Mulisha Brian Deegan 1:18 ScaAtomik RC is bringing some of that excitement to the RC world with their Metal Mulisha Brian Deegan 1:18 Scale Ford Raptor 15...12/09/2012
    AtomikMetal Mulisha Brian Deegan 1:18 ScaThe ford Fiesta's wide stance and short wheel base allow it to corner easily. The Fiesta is a handful to drive and is a great...12/09/2012
    Venom RacingGambler RTR Short Course TruckVenom completely designed this truck from the ground up and they've incorporated some great features. The Gambler's light wei...06/30/2012
    ARRMAFury Short Course TruckARRMA is a fairly new contender to the RC world and have launched several new vehicles. While their vehicles may incorporate ...06/04/2012
    DuratraxVW Baja BugDuratrax has recently taken on a new look. Not only with their logo, but also with their vehicles. First the Evader DT, with ...06/04/2012
     

      Return to Magazine Homepage






     
    RCUniverse is a service of Internet Brands, Inc. Copyright © 2001-2014.
    Terms of Service | Privacy Policy
     
    GET FREE RC CONTENT FOR YOUR WEBSITE

    Search | Marketplace | Event Central | Local Clubs | Magazine | Product Ratings | New Products | Discussion Forums

    Photo Gallery | Instructor Search | Field|Track|Marina Search | RCU Youtube Channel | | RCU Twitter!

    Member Locator | Advertisers | Hobby Vendor Resources | Rate Manufacturers | Sign In/Sign Up

    Products Videos WattFlyer.com RC Classifieds

    RCU4 | 54.198.3.154 | 0 | 1 | 11:04:15 AM EST | NC