RCU Review: Great Planes U-Can-Do 3D Ep


More On This Product

  • 1 Active For-Sale Ad!
  • Discussions on this Product
  • Show user ratings
  • Check for Retailers
  •  
     
    Contributed by: Mathew Kirsch | Published: November 2005 | Views: 63564 | email icon Email this Article | PDFpdf icon


    Navigation


    Manufacturer Info

    Great Planes
    Model Distributors
    P.O. Box 9021
    Champaign, IL 61826-9021
    Phone: 217-398-3630
    Fax: 217-398-0008
    www.greatplanes.com


    Ratings
    Quality
    Packaging
    Ease of Assembly
    Aerobatic ability
    Looks
    Price
    Manual
               Hardware


    Hits
    • Confidence-building design that survives most crashes with no damage.
    • Surprisingly positive control from such a flexible plane.


    Misses
    • If not stored carefully, the plane will "set" crooked.
    • Aileron hinges are challenging to install with the recommended hot glue.

    Introduction

    One thing Great Planes isn't shy about is trying a revolutionary approach to solving a common problem. In this case, the issue is practicing those low-and-slow 3D maneuvers without fear of doing major damage to the airplane when the "dumb thumbs" come a-calling. Face it, the plethora of flat-plate foamies out there on the market are inexpensive and relatively tough, but they're nowhere near indestructable. Pile one in, and you're likely to end up spending a signifigant amount of time with the foam-safe CA and kicker, if the plane can be repaired at all.

    Great Planes's new FlightFlextm technology takes rather unique approach to the issue. While the materials, EPP foam and carbon fiber, are hardly new to the foamie R/C industry, the way they're put together to make the UCanDo3D EP is quite novel. Conventional EPP foam construction consists of solid chunks of EPP shaped with hot-wire cutting equipment, and reinforced with carbon fiber rods, resulting in an extremely bounceable, but unfortunately heavy, airplane. Great Planes took the Zen approach of "bend, not break," designed an EPP framework similar to that of a built-up balsa plane, and sheeted it with a thin layer of EPP foam. The end result is an airframe that is surprisingly light considering what it's made of, amazingly flexible, and.... SQUISHY!



    Specifications


    Wingspan: 33.5 in
    Wing Area: 369 sq in
    Weight (Recommended): 14-15 oz
    Weight (As Tested): 13.7 oz
    Wing Loading: 5 oz/sq ft
    Length: 36.5 in
    Radio: 4-channel with 4 micro servos and 30A brushed ESC
    Power: 280BB motor, 5:1 gearbox

    Equipment

    Power: 280BB motor, 5:1 gearbox (included)
    Prop: 12x8 GWS (included)
    ESC: Castle Creations Griffin 35
    Battery: Great Planes 1200mAh 3S LiPoly
    Servos: Futaba 3108 sub micro
    Receiver: GWS Pico 4-channel
    Transmitter: Futaba 8UAPS


    First Impressions & Getting Started

    I fought the driver, and the driver won.
     The inner box isn't much more encouraging.
    Hmmm... No damage!

    Tail looks good...
    The cowl may have gotten flattened, but it doesn't
    look like it.
    Well, the damage wasn't THAT bad... It takes a lot to hurt hardware.
    Yep, I said SQUISHY. When I opened the box and started pulling parts out, I kept looking over my shoulder for Mr. Whipple to come storming up behind me, shouting "Please don't squeeze the airplane!" How is a pile of parts that is this squeezably soft, with all the rigidity of a bowl of spaghetti, going to turn into a flyable airplane, let alone something capable of basic 3D? Read on to find out.

    The FlightFlextm technology got its first real test on the trip from RCU headquarters to my place in Rochester, NY. When I got the box, it literally looked like it had gotten into a fight with someone, and lost. Even the inside box was badly damaged during transit, but as I pulled each part out and inspected it, there was no visible damage. Everything was intact! Still, I was skeptical as to how a couple of "funoodles" glued together would result in a flyable airplane.

    Included in the hardware package are genuine pinned hinges, carbon fiber pushrods, special-purpose control horns, along with matching servo arms for three different types of servos. Great Planes includes special pushrod ends that are secured to the carbon fiber rods by way of a drop of thin CA. These fit in the special oversize holes in both the control horns and servo arms, and typical servo arms don't have enough "meat" in them to drill out to the right size. To use the stock pushrods, the buyer has to use a servo that one of the sets of arms fit. In my case, I used the recommended Futaba 3108 Sub Micro servos. With a street price of about $15, legendary Futaba quality, and better torque than the Hitec HS55, these servos are an awesome bargain.

    Your main assembly tools are a tape measure and a hot glue gun.
    Hot glue fillets...
    Bead of hot glue on the wing/fuse interface.

    Considering the low parts count, assembling the UCanDo3D EP is practically a slam-dunk affair. The main difference in the assembly is the recommended adhesive used to hold the plane together. Nope, it's not CA and kicker. It's not 5 minute epoxy, either. What's this magical mystery adhesive? It's HOT GLUE, low temperature hot glue to be exact, but hot glue nonetheless. To all those experienced modelers out there who have raided their wife's/mother's/girlfriend's craft or sewing supplies in the past, it's time for another mission to borrow the hot glue gun. Or, just break down and spend the $5 at WalMart for your own. Make sure it's the LOW TEMP hot glue gun and glue. High temperature glue will melt the EPP foam. There's nothing saying you couldn't use CA and kicker, or even epoxy, but frankly, hot glue works just fine and is the quickest way from the workbench to the air.

    Attaching the small horizontal stabilizer is typical ARF fare: Center side-to-side, square up to the fuselage, and glue. The main thing to keep in mind is keeping the fuselage straight. Because this is a bend-not-break design, the fuselage is by no means rigid... The term "wiggle worm" comes to mind. Sight down the fuselage to ensure it's straight, then carefully measure from each tip of the stab to the nose of the airplane. Run beads of hot glue along the top and bottom of each side, then use the hot tip of the glue gun to smooth and "bake" the glue into the foam as described in the instructions for best results.

    The assembly procedure wastes no time here. Next to be installed is the wing, which is again the typical ARF process: Insert, center side-to-side, square up to the fuselage, and glue. On this particular example, getting the wing slid into place seemed to be a little hairy; I was afraid of damaging the wing by pushing or pulling too hard on it. Patience won the day, though, and the wing finally slid into place. What was surprising is how much more rigid the plane became once the beads of hot glue were added to the wing/fuselage joint. Between the stabilizer and wing, the entire plane became surprisingly rigid, though there was still some signifigant waggle in the tail.

     

    Get everything close together, then apply a dab of glue.
    Time's a wastin'. Get the hinge into the slot before it cools too much, or do it over!
    Success! The last aileron hinge is glued into place, and not a moment too soon...

    Once the wing is fixed in place, it's time to move on to the control surfaces, specifically the ailerons. To be absolutely truthful, this was the one frustrating part of assembling this plane. The instructions describe a hinging method where the hinges are glued in with hot glue. Unfortunately, the working time with low-temp hot glue is very short, and the glue is very hot. It's a neat trick getting a hinge with a half-cooled gob of hot glue into a slot before the glue completely cools. It took three or four failed attempts to get the technique down, and all I can say is that I'm glad that I only had to hinge the ailerons in this manner. Hot glue is nice in this respect because it can be reheated and removed from the hinges for the next attempt
    Threading the carbon fiber
    "tube hinge."
    Both elevator halves
    glued in place.

    The elevator is an interesting design intended to allow the extreme elevator throws necessary for 3D. Three short pieces of plastic tubing are attached along the trailing edge of the horizontal stabilizer. A carbon fiber tube threads through the plastic tubes, completing the hinge. Each elevator half is then hot glued to tube. The carbon tube rotates inside the plastic tubes for a near 180 degree range of motion. As with most of the assembly techniques, this was a new one on me, but it proved to be simple and effective.
    Tie one on.
    Ready for two dabs of hot melt.
    A tight squeeze for the two servo plugs going in at the same time.
    An even tighter squeeze
    for the connectors.
    The rudder servo.
    Radio Installation

    Great Planes designed the UCD3DEP with drawstrings running from each of the servo pockets to the radio compartment to make servo installation more convenient. Four Futaba 3108 servos, three short tugging sessions, and 8 dabs of hot glue later, I had the UCanDo's muscles in place. Even though the instructions recommend 12" extensions for the elevator and rudder servos, they're a little short to work with inside the radio compartment, so I ended up pulling the servos out and reinstalling them with 15" extensions.

    The rudder horn.
    Okay, okay... I know I installed the servo horns out of sequence (notice the empty servo pockets).
    ...and just to prove it again. Bad reviewer, no biscuit

    Control horn installation could not be simpler. The locations are clearly dimensioned in the instructions, and all that's required is to cut a 3/4" slot in the prescribed location, and to snap the control horn in place.

    Elevator linkage complete.
    Rudder linkage? Check!
     Here's the right aileron servo with the prescribed 15 degree forward sweep for aileron differential.

    It's at this point that I swapped out the stock Futaba 3108 servo arms for the ones included with the UCD3DEP. No surprise, they fit perfectly. Hitec and GWS fans take note here: None of the included servo arms fit the HS55, the GWS Pico or the GWS Naro servos. Each control horn and servo arm receives a "plastic Z-bend clevis" as Great Planes terms them. These are the little doodads that the carbon fiber pushrods slide into. Finally, servos are centered, surfaces are neutralized, and pushrods are installed. The pushrods are a bit of a tight fit in the plastic Z-bend clevises, but this is actually a good thing because it makes final adjustments easier, and helps the drops of thin CA hold them securely.

    Power System

    The motor and gearbox use a conventional stick mount. Notice the preinstalled prop saver.
    The heart of the system is this Electrifly 1200mAh 3S LiPoly pack.
    There's some room to move the battery back and forth for CG adjustments. CG was spot on with the battery here.

    Great Planes includes a GD280 brushed motor and gearbox with the UCanDo3D EP, and they recommend a 3S, or 11.1V Lithium Polymer battery pack for power. I followed their recommendations and used the stock setup. Those of you familiar with my postings on RCU will probably say, "Hey! He always says brushed motors on 3S LiPolys don't last long." Well, this is a little different. Cheap can motors like the Speed 300 have brass bushings and flimsy wiper brushes that can't hold up to the high RPM generated by a 3S LiPoly. The motor that comes with the UCD3DEP is a 280BB, with ball bearings and replaceable brushes, so it should hold up fairly well. It's hardly ideal, but I wanted to see how it performed before condemning it. A Castle Creations Griffin 35 ESC and a Great Planes 1250mAh 3S LiPoly pack round out the power system.
    The antenna can just
    dangle out the back.
    My stash of spare prop
    saver O-rings.

    All that's left is to button everything up, install the cowl and prop, and go flying! The included O-ring for the prop saver was a little too stiff to stretch over the prop, so I used a thinner O-ring from my assortment.

     



    Test Flying


    It was probably a little too breezy the day of the UCanDo3D's maiden flight, but I was anxious to see how the brushed setup would perform. Any doubts about the UCD3DEP's ability to handle wind were quickly washed away the moment I released the plane into the air. Even at less than half throttle, the sleek fuselage of the UCD3DEP cut through the wind quite well, though downwind passes were a bit on the lightning-quick side.

    After a few circuits around the field and some slow aerobatics, I flipped the high rates on, and haven't looked back since. The 8 MPH wind was a little high to even attempt hovering, but everything else was fair game. Axial rolls were crisp and quick, and would be even quicker if I ran the ATV on my transmitter to 140%. The plane shows absolutely no signs of snapping with elevator input, even though maximum deflection is over 45 degrees, and will loop in about twice its length.

    The UCanDo3D EP's real test came two days later when the winds had calmed down somewhat. I'm not a 3D pilot by any stretch of the imagination, but I was able to hover the plane longer than I have been able to hover any other plane. With the stock power system, the UCD3DEP can hover at half throttle, but doesn't really have much in reserve to pull out. It seems that most of the energy put into the motor above half throttle is simply cast off as heat, and what heat it is. After landing, the battery pack was hot enough to make it uncomfortable to hold for long, so it was definitely too hot. If you're going to run the stock power system, heed my advice: Keep your flights relatively short, and strictly limit use of throttle over half.

    With that advice in mind, I continued to push the envelope of both the UCD3DEP and my own flying skills. During one flight, I said "Aw heck!" rolled the plane over on its back, headed for the deck, and began making low inverted circuits around the field. I've been looking to expand my repertoire, and the UCanDo3D EP's advertised toughness gave me the confidence to try some new maneuvers. It wasn't too long before the plane's alleged resiliency was put to the test. I got a little too low, caught the rudder, and plopped the plane in the middle of the runway. Okay, it wasn't the most violent crash, but the plane wasn't even scuffed.

    Watch the UCanDo3D Ep in Action
    5.00 MB











    Summary


    I've had many plane-ground contacts since the first flight, and the UCD3D has sustained very little damage, at least nothing that couldn't be fixed with a quick dab of hot glue. Most of these were minor tears in the EPP skin. I've dropped it, I've crashed it, I've stepped on it, and it just keeps coming back for more. The only thing I've noticed is that great care must be taken in how it's transported and stored. Remember your mother telling you not to make a face, because it would stick that way? Well, unless you store the UCD3DEP flat and straight, it will set up in whatever position it was left in. This doesn't adversely affect the plane's flying qualities, but it does look goofy. Luckily, the plane can be straightened out by leaving it sitting straight for an equal period of time. I recommend storing the plane hung up by the prop, or on a flat shelf.

    Power with the stock power system and recommended battery are more than adequate for basic 3D maneuvers and general low-level hot-dogging. However, great care must be taken to limit flight times and full throttle usage to prevent heat buildup and possible damage to the ESC and especially the battery.

    It's not indestructable by any stretch of the imagination; the instructions warn that a straight nose-in crash will rip the nose off, but even with that weakness, the UCD3D is far more resilient than your typical foamie. If you're looking for a plane to develop or hone your 3D skills in low and slow without fear, take a look at FlightFlex(tm) technology.

     


    Manufacturer Information


    Great Planes
    Model Distributors
    P.O. Box 9021
    Champaign, IL 61826-9021
    Phone: 217-398-3630
    Fax: 217-398-0008
    www.greatplanes.com
    productsupport@greatplanes.com


    Comments on RCU Review: Great Planes U-Can-Do 3D Ep

    Posted by: ThomasAnderson on 07/19/2008
    Are you guys flying the same plane I am? I consider myself an advanced intermediate. This is my first "3D" plane, but I had tons of hours on both a Multiplex Sky Scooter and Space Scooter, both with brushless motors and stunted the heck out of them. I have a dozen other planes too. I followed the instructions closely. I used a 1450 3 cell lipo, and the instructions said maximum 1500 so I felt safe. The standard 280 engine on this was a total dog. I spent my entire first flight just trying to get some altitude so I could feel comfortable to stunt. I had one slightly hard landing and picked the "indestructible" plane up to continue to fly to find the whole nose ripped and hanging, and the neat zippered pouch ripped at the bottom. Yeah the wing was fine. I was able to glue the fuse back together, and I replaced the 280 motor with a 370 and new gearbox made for the wood spar also, so it was a quick transplant. With this motor I was able to stunt and get some altitude, but forget about "hovering". In my opinion, you would have to go brushless to do this. As far as the "generous hardware kit" provided, that's a laugh. I have never seen cheaper control horns in my life. I broke both aileron horns on my first flight. And get this, the pushrods go through these tiny little z-shaped pieces of plastic, and you HOT GLUE them into place. Forget any adjustments in the field. If this weren't enough, the server arms supplied (they give you three different sets of 4 to match potential servers) easily strip out, leaving your control surface in whatever position there were last in. Can you say CRASH? I had to replace EVERYTHING with Du-bro components, adding again time to get the plane into the air for its second flight. As I said, the plane flew better, but I can hardly recommend it. And if you really hose the fuselage, forget replacing it, because you will have hot-glue fused the wings and fuselage together and you'll just rip it trying to separate it. If this is a "great plane", I am wondering how bad the not-so-great planes are.
    Page: 1
    The comments, observations and conclusions made in this review are solely with respect to the particular item the editor reviewed and may not apply generally to similar products by the manufacturer. We cannot be responsible for any manufacturer defects in workmanship or other deficiencies in products like the one featured in the review.

    EMAIL THIS ARTICLE OR CHECK OUT THESE OTHER GREAT REVIEWS!
     
    PhotoManufacturerProductSummaryReviewed
    Knox Hobbies.56 Glow BB/ABC Engine & Tower HobbGoing back to my initial meeting with the guys from Knox Hobbies it is easy to see why they are so excited about this engine....02/06/2010
    Great Planes Model DistributorsRealFlight BASIC Flight SimulatorIn recent years, several companies have introduced a new generation of flight simulators. I remember the first time I saw one...02/06/2010
    FutabaWTR 7 FASST™ Wireless Trainer SysteThen I started going through my mental check list. "Let's see, I know I still have an old buddy cord, but it's one of the rou...01/31/2010
    Hangar 9Toledo Special 40 "Inspired by free-flight models from the Big Band Era, the Hangar 9 Toledo Special is a unique blend of 1940's styling and sm...01/31/2010
    Great PlanesElectrifly VFOWhen I first saw the VFO advertised, I thought now this is different. I love the simplicity and bang for the buck that foamie...01/31/2010
    Hangar 9Pulse 125 XTThis new plane has all the great flying characteristics of its siblings, while being even easier to see in the air. The Pulse...01/16/2010
    E-Flite Blade mSR RTFBlade mSR RTFE-flite has just released their latest model, the Blase mSR. The mSR (Single Rotor) fills the gap between the co-axial helico...01/16/2010
    ParkZoneBf-109 G6 BNFThe ParkZone Messerschmitt Bf-109G BNF (PKZ4980) is a fully-aerobatic scale reproduction model that utilizes Bind-N-Fly™ DSM2...01/16/2010
    Hangar 9RV-8The Hangar 9 RV-8 is an easy building and great flying sport plane. She'll do about anything you ask of her, yet she's very s...01/16/2010
    Hangar 9Funtana 125What blew me away was how I was able to perform nice rolling harriers without having to blip the throttle to bring the nose b...01/16/2010
    Hobby CNCCNC Foam Cutting Machine. Part 2In this review I will show you how to setup and operate the CNC Foam Cutting Machine that we built in Part 1 HERE. A CNC Foam...12/20/2009
    FMA DirectFunJet RTF/ARF with On-Board FlightThe RTF version includes everything you need in one box to be successful. All you do is some basic assembly then charge the b...12/20/2009
    E-FliteRV9The successful Van's RV-9 kitplane can now be assembled for a lot less time and money in the form of a park flyer by E-Flight...12/20/2009
    Great PlanesShoestring - 60Aerobatics can be done with very little effort. Large, graceful loops look beautiful and rolls look like they are done on a s...12/13/2009
    Futaba8FG transmitter, 1700 mAh battery, The 8FG Transmitter is so full of features, there is no way to cover all the functions of this radio. This review is going to...12/13/2009
     

      Return to Magazine Homepage






     
    RCUniverse is a service of Kaango, LLC dba RC Universe. Copyright © 2001-2010.  Privacy Policy
     
    GET FREE RC CONTENT FOR YOUR WEBSITE

    Search | Marketplace | Event Central | Local Clubs | Magazine | Product Ratings | New Products | Discussion Forums

    Photo Gallery | Instructor Search | Field|Track|Marina Search | RCU Videos | RCU Youtube Channel | | RCU Twitter!

    Member Locator | Advertisers | Hobby Vendor Resources | Rate Manufacturers | Sign In/Sign Up

    Products Videos WattFlyer.com RC Classifieds

    RCU5 | 38.107.191.99 | 0 | 1 | 10:41:55 AM EST | YC