RCU Forums - View Single Post - Knowledge Quiz for Warbird wiz
View Single Post
Old 01-30-2018, 12:42 PM
  #15340  
Hydro Junkie
 
Hydro Junkie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Marysville, WA
Posts: 10,524
Received 130 Likes on 123 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Top_Gunn
Well, according to this account, which seems to be informed, the Russians didn't use the P-39 against tanks at all:

"Contrary to popular myth, the P-39 was not employed as a "tank-buster" for two very good reasons: the M4 37mm cannon was slow-firing and only had 30 rounds of ammunition, and the Soviets never received M80 Armor Piercing Shot ammunition for this cannon through Lend-Lease. (Even had they received AP ammo, it was only capable of penetrating 1.0 inches of armor at 500 yards. After 1943 there weren't many German tanks that vulnerable, especially from the top quadrant.) Our government did deliver approximately 1.2 million M54 High Explosive shells, however, and Soviet P-39 aces put them to good use against both air and soft ground targets." (From Bell P-39 Airacobra - Fighter Airplane Used by Russia in WW2).

At Kursk, where the Germans lost a lot of tanks, the Russians used Il-2's, which claimed a lot of tank kills but which may have been ineffective. The Wikipedia article on the Il-2 says this about German tank losses in Russia (after reporting impressive claims by Il-2 pilots):

"... Other studies of the fighting at Kursk suggest that very few of German armour losses were caused by the IL-2 or any other Soviet aircraft. In fact, total German tank losses in Operation Citadel amounted to 323 totally destroyed, the vast majority to anti-tank guns and armored fighting vehicles.[24] In addition it is difficult to find any first-hand accounts by German panzer crews on the Eastern Front describing anything more than the occasional loss to direct air attack. The vast majority, around 95%–98%, of tank losses are due to enemy anti-tank guns, tanks, mines, artillery, and infantry assault, or simply abandoned as operational losses like mostly happened during the last eleven months of the war."

I don't claim any particular knowledge of this myself, but a quick scouring of the internet turns up several sources saying the P-39's that went to Russia never had anti-tank rounds. It does seem clear that the Russians used them mainly as fighters and for ground attack against soft targets. They weren't of much use in Europe because of their poor high-altitude performance, but that wasn't important in Russia.
Your source could very well be correct as mine had some questions about accuracy and has since been pulled down. Then again, any information coming from the Russian Front is subject to question since the Russians weren't really forthcoming on losses and many of the German records were lost/destroyed.