Split the forum
 

Hello
I just wanted to suggest to split his forum into two.
There are way too many 3D related threads and it gets really hard to find anyone talking about patterns, F3A, IMAC etc.
It looks like the only thing we should aim to is 3D and I personally think there are other interesting categories.
That's why I suggest to the moderator to split this forum, so you can really sharpen the search for the kind of aerobatics of your likings.
Regards
Omar

Split the forum
 

I will second that motion

Split the forum
 

sure

Split the forum
 

I wouldn't mind too. How about putting it in this in the suggestions forum.

Done
 

Done, it's already in the suggestions forum, jut waiting for the moderators to see it
Thanks all for the support

Split the forum
 

great stuff :)

Split
 

I have suggested it on a couple of occasions.

Pattern
IMAC
3D/Freestlye/Artistic

I agree, better separation.

Split the forum
 

I would think that pattern and artistic should be together, as they are very similar.....similar airframes, engines, radio gear, etc.

I give this suggestion a big applause
 

This is a exellent suggestion!!!
To much 3D stuff in here...let us get a separate pattern forum.

Split the forum
 

I agree too

how about:

pattern / IMAC

3D / freestyle / artistic

Hubb

Good Idea
 

AGree
IMAC/F3A/Pattern
3D/Artistic/Freestyle
That would do it
ALl in favor please go to
http://www.rcuniverse.com/showthread...677&forumid=40
For adding votes :)
Regardss

Split the forum
 

Splitting is the only way to not have to read about the pattern stuff ! 3D forum could be called "Fun" and the Pattern "Boring" Just kidding guys, so don't get excited or mad !

Definitely another vote for the Split !

Split the forum
 

Sounds like a GREAT idea. I would like even better to have a "giant scale 3D forum" because there is a lot of talk about the GP U-Can-Do and flip3d and all that other small not scale stuff which, to me, should be in the funfly and profile planes forum. Just an opinion.

more
 

This opens up the big question I have raised.

There is Pattern. Flow with Pattern Planes

There is Artistic. Different then pattern, in style of flyn, however same type of equipment used.

There is IMAC or Scale Aerobatics. They fly sequences like pattern, however also perform 3D maneuvers during freestyle. And the obvious equipment differences.

Pattern and IMAC are both flown in competition and AA is being recognized World wide.

Then there is 3D planes. 3D planes have thick airfoil wings and some sort of of fuse the resembles a cross between a Cap and a pattern plane. These planes are designed for 3D flight, could be flown in pattern, not legal for IMAC and legal for AA comps.

Then there are Profiles and other short coupled Fun Fly type planes. Not really flown in comps and not the best tracking plane, sort of an entry level 3D plane, but would never consider for pattern.

Long and the short: 3D is a style of flyn. Not a type of plane. It can be flown with many types of planes.

IMAC and Pattern must be flown with their respective type planes.

We are crossing up the type of planes with the style of flyn. Some can do others, however none can do all.

How about 4 sub-catagories under Aerobatic.

Pattern
IMAC
3D
Artistic

http://www.rcuniverse.com/showthread...557&forumid=31]

Split the forum
 

I think four categories is too many, on the other hand I see the reason for separation.

You could have:
Precision Aerobatics (IMAC and Pattern), and
Freestyle/3D (IMAC freestyle and AA).

If the discussions revolved around flying techniques such as how to use rudder to keep your lines straight, trimming techniques, etc. then this breakdown would make sense. However the reality is that people end up talking about specific planes, like is the Extra or Edge better. Or are the PLProd or ZNLine pattern planes better. Fact is that the pattern guys don't want to see all those posts about the H9 Edge and the IMAC guys don't want to read about the Smaragd. However, both could benefit from discussions on trimming and using rudder. Therein is the snag.

Do we break the IMAC and Pattern forums to filter out all the stuff about planes that we don't care about and loose the benefit of crossover topics or do we keep them together and just skip the threads about planes that don't interest our particular bent?

I'm definilty for separating out the 3D stuff, and ideally I'd like to be able to read about only IMAC planes or only Pattern planes, but honestly I'm not sure I want to give-up possible crossover topics.

Finally, I definitely wouldn't split AA out as a separate topic because there will be virtually no posts in it. If we were to take YNOT's approach I would just do three categories:

Pattern / Artistic
IMAC
3D

My thoughts,
Keith

Split the forum
 

i think now that the forum board is so huge that dividing into smaller sub-forums would be a good idea

Split the forum
 

What KeithB said.

Larry

Split the forum
 

I think that CLEARLY there is a benefit to splitting into two forums; Pattern, and Scale Aerobatics. The 3D or AA themes will find there own way within one or the other. I think most of us acknowledge that AA is "pattern" and 3D is in the "Giant Scale Aerobatics" realm....so why not, moderators???

Would seem you'd heighten activity because of sharper focus.

Split the forum
 

hmmmmmmm?

Split the forum
 

This was brought to my attention in the Moderators forum. Heres my reply,

I dont see why not.

I say make an aerobatics forum then have a few sub-forums under it.

Aerobatics:
(3D)
(Imac)
(pattern)

Split the forum
 

i second....wait third...wait fourth that one

Split the forum
 

There's really no harm in splitting.

Folks who want to see ALL thest topics (like me) may simply subscribe to more than 1 folder.

Actually, I was a bit surprised to see 3D lumped in with pattern when I first got here.

Joe (buried in snow)

Split the forum
 

Please vote now!

http://rcuniverse.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=88473

Split the forum
 

Yes... move everything to do with hovering over to the helicopter forum :)

Split the forum
 

Uhhh....how bout we don't ;)