RCU Forums

RCU Forums (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/)
-   Beginners (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/beginners-85/)
-   -   Best J-3 Cub? (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/beginners-85/1279399-best-j-3-cub.html)

airzinho 11-15-2003 11:18 AM

Best J-3 Cub?
 
Looking to get a J-3 Piper Cub, and was wondering which one is the best out there (instructions, included parts, etc)? I want a kit not an ARF. Maybe something around a .40-.61.

phread59 11-15-2003 02:12 PM

RE: Best J-3 Cub?
 
Hello Airzino:

I may not be able to comment on all of the Cub kits but I can comment on one. The GP (Great Planes) Cub is a fair kit. I had some problems with this kit. The wing tips and rudder and elevators use a built up section. The outer or trailing edge pieces or these surfaces are built of 2 or3 pieces glued together. They are supposed to be CAD drawn. But they are die cut and the fit is absolutely pitiful. I had to do some serious fitting and had to use epoxy to assure good bond strength. The firewall is a royal pain in the a** to install. They have you build the fuse and then as one of the last operations install the firewall. Bending the fuse sides to meet the firewall was horrible. I would reccomend putting the firewall in before any other former first to avoid this. Do not forget to brace it with triangular stock. The firewall fit was poor also. The construction instruction book can be confusing. There are some important stepps that are buried in the book. Such as a piec of lite ply to go from the wing mount to the top of the fuse to reinforce the front of the cabin. I missed it completely and I read through the instructions before I started. So read the book carefully.

Now having knocked the kit I will say the plane came out very strong and exceptionally light. It also looks great. I am an experienced builder and IMHO pretty darn good at it. I did go at it and not go step by step as in the manual. So some of the problems I ran into were my own damn fault. I am at the covering stage and will hopefully fly it this spring. I am covedring it with 21St Century fabric and using a Saito 80 in the nose with the standard wing. I will save the wood that the wing parts came in so I can use the die cut outer pieces to fabricate my own wing parts to make a clipped wing later. I did modify the kit to use 2 servos in the wing. I just used the hatch where the rods from the pivots out in the wing to the ailerons to mount the servo. The servo will stick out of the bottom of the wing but so what, I'm not gonna compete with this model. Used lite ply for the hatch and screwed the hatch to rails I glue in on the ribs. I think this model will work nice when I finish it. Other than the poor parts fit and some wood being too soft in my opinion ( I did not replace it We will see how it goes) and the supplied cowl being flimsy ( I am going to reinforce with fiberglass) I thing it is an ok kit. If you take your time and be carefull I am sure you will like it. By the way the kit is pretty darn scale, with a little detail work this plane would make a decent starter scale competition model.

Sorry for the wordy post. I hope this can help you, I got it from my LHS at a very good price 89$ so I think I got pretty good value for my money.

Mark Shuman

Live Wire 11-15-2003 05:32 PM

RE: Best J-3 Cub?
 
You get what you pay for, but I think the SIG 1/5 cub will serve the purposeMy $ .02

MinnFlyer 11-16-2003 10:17 AM

RE: Best J-3 Cub?
 
I have flown several, and my favorite is still the Goldberg Anniversary Cub (Clipped wing version)

waagbuck 11-16-2003 11:34 AM

RE: Best J-3 Cub?
 
I vote for the Great Planes J-3 cub, built in the clipped wing version with a nice four stroke engine. I have flown a friend's Goldberg cub, and it flies very similarly. I like the barn door ailersons on the Great Planes version - you get strip ailerons on the Goldberg. After crashing my great planes cub into a tree (pilot error) earlier this year, I am planning to replace it with a World Models Clipped Wing Cub .48 ARF. It's a little smaller than the Great Planes, but it's an ARF and it's only about $5 more than the great planes kit. Except for all the metric hardware, the WM arfs are great. If were going to build a J-3 kit, I would build the 60-size great planes cub and cover it with fabric and put a 91 four stroke in it.

But Minnflyer's advice is always easily followed. I'm building the GP Extra 300 this winter, partially as result of his suggestion.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:37 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.