NGH 9cc
#52
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Somewhere,
DC
Posts: 9,825
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

A needle braring on the big end of the rod is necessary because most fliers don't want to use enough oil in the fuel...Large converted 2 strokes can get by on 10%, smaller ones need the same amount as a small glow engine...Then there will be complaints about oil on the fuselage, just like glow engine...Can't have it both ways.....
If the needle bearing was not necessary Tom at BME would not go to the trouble of pushing the crank pin out and replacing it with a harder one....
If the needle bearing was not necessary Tom at BME would not go to the trouble of pushing the crank pin out and replacing it with a harder one....
#53

My Feedback: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Hervey Bay Queensland, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 2,995
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

A needle bearing conrod on a 9 cc engine is possible, but not economically feasible on an engine designed to a $165- retail price point.
There is nothing difficult about running 5% (20:1) oil mix .. it's only 50 millitres per litre.
There is nothing difficult about running 5% (20:1) oil mix .. it's only 50 millitres per litre.
#54
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Somewhere,
DC
Posts: 9,825
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

The pump is larger than the carb...A Cline regulator does the same thing but is pricey....
So how come the video doesn/t show the pressure fitting for the pump in the rear cover ?
So how come the video doesn/t show the pressure fitting for the pump in the rear cover ?
#55
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Tres Cantos, SPAIN
Posts: 464
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

ORIGINAL: Antique
A needle braring on the big end of the rod is necessary because most fliers don't want to use enough oil in the fuel...Large converted 2 strokes can get by on 10%, smaller ones need the same amount as a small glow engine...Then there will be complaints about oil on the fuselage, just like glow engine...Can't have it both ways.....
If the needle bearing was not necessary Tom at BME would not go to the trouble of pushing the crank pin out and replacing it with a harder one....
A needle braring on the big end of the rod is necessary because most fliers don't want to use enough oil in the fuel...Large converted 2 strokes can get by on 10%, smaller ones need the same amount as a small glow engine...Then there will be complaints about oil on the fuselage, just like glow engine...Can't have it both ways.....
If the needle bearing was not necessary Tom at BME would not go to the trouble of pushing the crank pin out and replacing it with a harder one....
Like Saito small gas engines ? The FG36 (36cc) does not have needle bearings on the con-rod.
Like oldies spark plug small engines ?
On a 4 Stroke engine the amount of fuel (with oil) is smaller than a 2S engine and oil-fuel flow mix does not goes directly to crankcase (and con-rod) as 2S does.
Lubricity of gas(petrol) is much more than methanol.
I've count the needles on a small needle bearing availables today (caged), and the contact surface with the crankshaft pin is so small and can cause more troubles than a plain bushing.
Only my experience.
Best regards
#56
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Tres Cantos, SPAIN
Posts: 464
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

ORIGINAL: Antique
...
So how come the video doesn/t show the pressure fitting for the pump in the rear cover ?
....
...
So how come the video doesn/t show the pressure fitting for the pump in the rear cover ?
....
Find the last one with this device installed and you can see the pressure fitting in the rear cover.
Best regards
#57
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: PerthWA, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 2,924
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

ORIGINAL: mpascual
Like Saito small gas engines ? The FG36 (36cc) does not have needle bearings on the con-rod.
Like oldies spark plug small engines ?
On a 4 Stroke engine the amount of fuel (with oil) is smaller than a 2S engine and oil-fuel flow mix does not goes directly to crankcase (and con-rod) as 2S does.
Lubricity of gas(petrol) is much more than methanol.
I've count the needles on a small needle bearing availables today (caged), and the contact surface with the crankshaft pin is so small and can cause more troubles than a plain bushing.
Only my experience.
Best regards
Like Saito small gas engines ? The FG36 (36cc) does not have needle bearings on the con-rod.
Like oldies spark plug small engines ?
On a 4 Stroke engine the amount of fuel (with oil) is smaller than a 2S engine and oil-fuel flow mix does not goes directly to crankcase (and con-rod) as 2S does.
Lubricity of gas(petrol) is much more than methanol.
I've count the needles on a small needle bearing availables today (caged), and the contact surface with the crankshaft pin is so small and can cause more troubles than a plain bushing.
Only my experience.
Best regards
A couple of things about your post
Comparing anything of Michaels creation to a Saito is quite an insult to Saito

The "Oldy" engines to which you refer also ran high oil QTY in their fuel.
I never realised the NGH 9cc was a 4 stroke - why even compare it to one? On a 4 stroke, the heat input is also for half the revolutions of a 2 stroke.
Michaels creations to date have a long history of early crankpin / bushing failures - that is called the proof in the pudding.
#58

My Feedback: (1)

It would seem that the reputation takes quite a hit if all other considerations are ignored except profit, and a quick return on investment. I bear no personal ill will powards Mr. Chow but do hold him accountable for selling an untested product that has proven to be defective. It will take a long time to earn back lost trust. There's an old saying that applies here:" Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me!" It is very difficult to fool me twice.
#59
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Somewhere,
DC
Posts: 9,825
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

"Oldy" spark engines use 3 parts gas and 1 part 70 weight oil...Just like all old 2 stroke outboard motors, 1/2 pint oll to 1 gallon gas....No roller bearings needed with that much oil...
big converted gassers like ST 3000s can get by with 10 % oil and no roller bearings...
One of the best old time glow fuels was sold by Duke Fox, 18% castor...21.6 OUNCES in a gallon...
big converted gassers like ST 3000s can get by with 10 % oil and no roller bearings...
One of the best old time glow fuels was sold by Duke Fox, 18% castor...21.6 OUNCES in a gallon...
#60
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Tres Cantos, SPAIN
Posts: 464
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

ORIGINAL: aussiesteve
Whilst I do applaud Michaels attempts to creat something attractive to part of the market by making it a little diufferent to the myriad of other offerings fom his countrymen, He has not done to well so far in making his offerings anywhere near to decent for regular flight over an extended number of flying days.
A couple of things about your post
Comparing anything of Michaels creation to a Saito is quite an insult to Saito
Who has compared engines ? I've oly said Saito engines does not mount needle bearings, only plain bushing on the crankshaft side , and nothing on wrist pin side on some gas engines
The ''Oldy'' engines to which you refer also ran high oil QTY in their fuel.
And people using this kind of engines keep manufaturers instructions about recommended fuel/oil ratio. Do the same on NGH engines.
I never realised the NGH 9cc was a 4 stroke - why even compare it to one? On a 4 stroke, the heat input is also for half the revolutions of a 2 stroke.
Are you sure? I know the difference between a 4s and a 2S. Only was a reference to compare with engines with less lubrication and higher running temp than a 2Stroke
Michaels creations to date have a long history of early crankpin / bushing failures - that is called the proof in the pudding.
Maybe you're saying Saito gas engines does not have crankpin/bushing failures? We can talk about crank pin bushing/needle bearings failures on MANY engines brands. What's the first ?
ORIGINAL: mpascual
Like Saito small gas engines ? The FG36 (36cc) does not have needle bearings on the con-rod.
Like oldies spark plug small engines ?
On a 4 Stroke engine the amount of fuel (with oil) is smaller than a 2S engine and oil-fuel flow mix does not goes directly to crankcase (and con-rod) as 2S does.
Lubricity of gas(petrol) is much more than methanol.
I've count the needles on a small needle bearing availables today (caged), and the contact surface with the crankshaft pin is so small and can cause more troubles than a plain bushing.
Only my experience.
Best regards
Like Saito small gas engines ? The FG36 (36cc) does not have needle bearings on the con-rod.
Like oldies spark plug small engines ?
On a 4 Stroke engine the amount of fuel (with oil) is smaller than a 2S engine and oil-fuel flow mix does not goes directly to crankcase (and con-rod) as 2S does.
Lubricity of gas(petrol) is much more than methanol.
I've count the needles on a small needle bearing availables today (caged), and the contact surface with the crankshaft pin is so small and can cause more troubles than a plain bushing.
Only my experience.
Best regards
A couple of things about your post
Comparing anything of Michaels creation to a Saito is quite an insult to Saito

Who has compared engines ? I've oly said Saito engines does not mount needle bearings, only plain bushing on the crankshaft side , and nothing on wrist pin side on some gas engines
The ''Oldy'' engines to which you refer also ran high oil QTY in their fuel.
And people using this kind of engines keep manufaturers instructions about recommended fuel/oil ratio. Do the same on NGH engines.
I never realised the NGH 9cc was a 4 stroke - why even compare it to one? On a 4 stroke, the heat input is also for half the revolutions of a 2 stroke.
Are you sure? I know the difference between a 4s and a 2S. Only was a reference to compare with engines with less lubrication and higher running temp than a 2Stroke
Michaels creations to date have a long history of early crankpin / bushing failures - that is called the proof in the pudding.
Maybe you're saying Saito gas engines does not have crankpin/bushing failures? We can talk about crank pin bushing/needle bearings failures on MANY engines brands. What's the first ?
Regards
#61
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: , CHINA
Posts: 123
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

it seems the "key" Fuel-delivery-system work well.
http://s1207.photobucket.com/albums/bb472/Wolly22/?action=view¤t=PT-19.mp4
#63

ORIGINAL: captinjohn
Please do not load this video on photobucket. It works better and belongs on YouTube. Thanks Capt,n
Please do not load this video on photobucket. It works better and belongs on YouTube. Thanks Capt,n
#64

My Feedback: (9)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Copperas Cove, Tx.
Posts: 552
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

Just got my '9 today. 4 days from Himodel to San Diego. Paid $200 total. Chose DHL express. Hope to get broke in this weekend.
There are some very interesting videos from aguy called Surats on Youtube running this engine. Seems to run slightly better using muffler pressure instead of the pump.....Especially the throttle response. Must be some pressure lag in the pump but I did notice he was using some very long fuel lines. The manual has a supplement sheet that is pretty specific on pump placement and fuel line length. Anyway, should be fun.
Later,
Mike
There are some very interesting videos from aguy called Surats on Youtube running this engine. Seems to run slightly better using muffler pressure instead of the pump.....Especially the throttle response. Must be some pressure lag in the pump but I did notice he was using some very long fuel lines. The manual has a supplement sheet that is pretty specific on pump placement and fuel line length. Anyway, should be fun.
Later,
Mike
#66
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: , CHINA
Posts: 123
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

Sir, GT9 = One .56 size glow engine + CDI + fule-delivery-system, engine weight 425g, CDI weight 120g, Fule-delivery-system weight: 45g, total weight almost 590g
#67
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Tres Cantos, SPAIN
Posts: 464
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

Some rpm numbers ....
APC 10x6 : 13.400 rpm
APC 11x6 : 11.900 rpm
APC 11x7 : 11.700 rpm
APC 12x6 : 10.700 rpm
APC 12.25x3.75 : 12.300 rpm
rpm numbers without muffler installed, after 1 hour break-in as user manual procedure, 95 IO fuel mixed @ 20:1 ratio (5%) Motul 800 full esther shyntetic 2 Stroke.
Engine needs more break-in time to develop the full potential .
Here is a picture of the piston ring after the first break-in session.
Sorry, but comments added are in spanish, but the picture talk itself
Best regards
APC 10x6 : 13.400 rpm
APC 11x6 : 11.900 rpm
APC 11x7 : 11.700 rpm
APC 12x6 : 10.700 rpm
APC 12.25x3.75 : 12.300 rpm
rpm numbers without muffler installed, after 1 hour break-in as user manual procedure, 95 IO fuel mixed @ 20:1 ratio (5%) Motul 800 full esther shyntetic 2 Stroke.
Engine needs more break-in time to develop the full potential .
Here is a picture of the piston ring after the first break-in session.
Sorry, but comments added are in spanish, but the picture talk itself
Best regards
#70
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Tres Cantos, SPAIN
Posts: 464
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

ORIGINAL: Lifer
Am I seeing evidence of a very rough casting, or wear from running?
Am I seeing evidence of a very rough casting, or wear from running?
I don't think so. You are seeing a picture taken with a magniscope.
Let me know what do you think about this picture of 50cc engine from a famous manufacturer.
Best regards
#72

My Feedback: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Hervey Bay Queensland, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 2,995
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

My engine (or should I say engine accessories) had the following faults "out of the box"
1. One of the screws on the pump was cross threaded. Resolved by myself.
2. Carb low speed needle was not centred on fuel nozzle. Resolved by myself.
3. Carb fuel nozzle inlet not centred on high speed neeedle. It was drilled "off centre". Result being, the engine could not be leaned out as the high speed needle tip could not enter the orifice.
As a result the supplied carb was for all intents useless. There is no purpose to the membrane at the front of the carb. It simply acts as a seal.
I have returned the carb to HiModel with a note explaining the defects and requesting a replacement. We will see.
In the meantime to avoid owning a paperweight I am adapting a standard 46 size twin needle glow carb to work with the pump and engine. Initial running results are promising although the low speed needle on the replacement carb requires a finer taper to ensure clean transition from idle to full speed.
1. One of the screws on the pump was cross threaded. Resolved by myself.
2. Carb low speed needle was not centred on fuel nozzle. Resolved by myself.
3. Carb fuel nozzle inlet not centred on high speed neeedle. It was drilled "off centre". Result being, the engine could not be leaned out as the high speed needle tip could not enter the orifice.
As a result the supplied carb was for all intents useless. There is no purpose to the membrane at the front of the carb. It simply acts as a seal.
I have returned the carb to HiModel with a note explaining the defects and requesting a replacement. We will see.
In the meantime to avoid owning a paperweight I am adapting a standard 46 size twin needle glow carb to work with the pump and engine. Initial running results are promising although the low speed needle on the replacement carb requires a finer taper to ensure clean transition from idle to full speed.
#74
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Tres Cantos, SPAIN
Posts: 464
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

ORIGINAL: fiery
My engine (or should I say engine accessories) had the following faults ''out of the box''
1. One of the screws on the pump was cross threaded. Resolved by myself.
2. Carb low speed needle was not centred on fuel nozzle. Resolved by myself.
3. Carb fuel nozzle inlet not centred on high speed neeedle. It was drilled ''off centre''. Result being, the engine could not be leaned out as the high speed needle tip could not enter the orifice.
As a result the supplied carb was for all intents useless. There is no purpose to the membrane at the front of the carb. It simply acts as a seal.
I have returned the carb to HiModel with a note explaining the defects and requesting a replacement. We will see.
In the meantime to avoid owning a paperweight I am adapting a standard 46 size twin needle glow carb to work with the pump and engine. Initial running results are promising although the low speed needle on the replacement carb requires a finer taper to ensure clean transition from idle to full speed.
My engine (or should I say engine accessories) had the following faults ''out of the box''
1. One of the screws on the pump was cross threaded. Resolved by myself.
2. Carb low speed needle was not centred on fuel nozzle. Resolved by myself.
3. Carb fuel nozzle inlet not centred on high speed neeedle. It was drilled ''off centre''. Result being, the engine could not be leaned out as the high speed needle tip could not enter the orifice.
As a result the supplied carb was for all intents useless. There is no purpose to the membrane at the front of the carb. It simply acts as a seal.
I have returned the carb to HiModel with a note explaining the defects and requesting a replacement. We will see.
In the meantime to avoid owning a paperweight I am adapting a standard 46 size twin needle glow carb to work with the pump and engine. Initial running results are promising although the low speed needle on the replacement carb requires a finer taper to ensure clean transition from idle to full speed.
Sorry to read all issues you have with the engine.
Mine works VERY well.
On the video idle seems to be not very reliable , it's my fault because i lost the pushrod retainer on the lever.
Also i must close the LNS almost 2 turns from factory settings.
Best regards and good luck with HiModel ....