View Poll Results: A poll
Voters: 178. You may not vote on this poll
Saito 220 or OS FS200
#51
Junior Member
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: HARWICH, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 29
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
I have just purchased the OS 200 pump version engine.
Comes withoiut any tools, i.e. spanners or valve adjusting tools. I only make this comment as previously purchased OS 120 did so.
Now, moving on to the muffler/silencer. Looks good and I expect it will be effective.
However, for "scsale" typoe usage, i.e. in cowl and mounted in an inverted postion, the large muffler is going to be a problem I can forsee. I,m thinkin terms of Mustang H 9 etc.
An adaptor of some kind is necessary to re position the muffler; or an after market muffler system. So far, as commented above in this forum, there dosn't seem to be one.
Would be grateful if any of the readers and contributors have (as yet) solved the problem.
regards
John SErjeant.
Incidentally, I finf that this engine doesn't fit the )S 120 engine mount; too long by a few mm.
Comes withoiut any tools, i.e. spanners or valve adjusting tools. I only make this comment as previously purchased OS 120 did so.
Now, moving on to the muffler/silencer. Looks good and I expect it will be effective.
However, for "scsale" typoe usage, i.e. in cowl and mounted in an inverted postion, the large muffler is going to be a problem I can forsee. I,m thinkin terms of Mustang H 9 etc.
An adaptor of some kind is necessary to re position the muffler; or an after market muffler system. So far, as commented above in this forum, there dosn't seem to be one.
Would be grateful if any of the readers and contributors have (as yet) solved the problem.
regards
John SErjeant.
Incidentally, I finf that this engine doesn't fit the )S 120 engine mount; too long by a few mm.
#52
Junior Member
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: HARWICH, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 29
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
Has anyone with an OS 200 fs pump or other wise, solved the problem of after market exhausts/manifold for this engine?>
Apart from the aforemntioned Hatori pipe, there isn't anything available.
Would previous contributors with similar problems like to reply re this with their experiences.
Has anyone an email direct to O S engines?>
John Serjeant
Apart from the aforemntioned Hatori pipe, there isn't anything available.
Would previous contributors with similar problems like to reply re this with their experiences.
Has anyone an email direct to O S engines?>
John Serjeant
#58
Junior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Van Nuys,
CA
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
Hi to everyone,
I have a doubt regarding the 200S-P I recently purchase..
Originally I bought the original FS200S, the one without pump, and I use this engine in a Carl Goldberg Obsession; everything was fine, ant the performance of the engine were great like all the other OS i own, the only issue was the cg shifting caused by the fuel tank right behind the firewall, so I decive to sell the 200P and Buy the new FS200S-P.
The new one instead to be more powerful (like the advertise says..) has instead less power and torque, turning at less rpm the same prop the "old" use to spin very well. I notice also more fuel consumption and from the hole in the black assembly in the carburator there are a lot of fuel spitting, making a mess in the cowl of the plane. The engine seems to be almost non sensible to any high speed needle adjustment, with the best position oround half turn from full closed. the rpm are always around 7300-7500 using from a small APC 16X8 up to a Graupner G-sonic 18X10, but always hundreds rpm slower than the standard 200.
I dont really have reilability problem (never had a engine failure) but just very poor performances.
I'm using a 20% sintetic oil and 10% nitro fuel and the new 200 has less than 2 gallons thru it.
Thanks for any input
I have a doubt regarding the 200S-P I recently purchase..
Originally I bought the original FS200S, the one without pump, and I use this engine in a Carl Goldberg Obsession; everything was fine, ant the performance of the engine were great like all the other OS i own, the only issue was the cg shifting caused by the fuel tank right behind the firewall, so I decive to sell the 200P and Buy the new FS200S-P.
The new one instead to be more powerful (like the advertise says..) has instead less power and torque, turning at less rpm the same prop the "old" use to spin very well. I notice also more fuel consumption and from the hole in the black assembly in the carburator there are a lot of fuel spitting, making a mess in the cowl of the plane. The engine seems to be almost non sensible to any high speed needle adjustment, with the best position oround half turn from full closed. the rpm are always around 7300-7500 using from a small APC 16X8 up to a Graupner G-sonic 18X10, but always hundreds rpm slower than the standard 200.
I dont really have reilability problem (never had a engine failure) but just very poor performances.
I'm using a 20% sintetic oil and 10% nitro fuel and the new 200 has less than 2 gallons thru it.
Thanks for any input
#59
Senior Member
My Feedback: (14)
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
You may have answered your own question right at the end of your post. You said it only has two gallons of fuel through it. It could be that the engine isn't broken-in yet and still requires a rich mixture to keep running without overheating. I would give it another gallon or two of fuel before worrying about it. A gallon of fuel really isn't much for such a large engine. Also, check the obvious things such as valve lash and switching to another glow plug.
Ed Cregger
Ed Cregger
#61
Junior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Van Nuys,
CA
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
hi, thanks for the fast answers, the next time I go to fly I try with some more oil, the valve clearence is ok now ( was a little loose but I felt no change in performances after the adjustment..) the plug seems to be ok, but maybe Y will try another one.....
What do you think about the fuel spitting from the hole in the pressure regulator and carburator and the non-sensibility to the high speed needla (where the "old"200S was very sensible to every click and almost spitting-free...)
Thanks a lot and have a nice landing..
What do you think about the fuel spitting from the hole in the pressure regulator and carburator and the non-sensibility to the high speed needla (where the "old"200S was very sensible to every click and almost spitting-free...)
Thanks a lot and have a nice landing..
#62
Senior Member
My Feedback: (42)
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Singapore, SINGAPORE
Posts: 548
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
I think you have a leak in the regulator preventing optimum fuel delivery. Therefore the loss of power and poor HS needle response. It sounds like the diaphragm is not seated properly or it has sprung a leak.If its under warranty, send it back for a fix. If you must,open the regulator and have a look, hopefully its the diaphragm that is misaligned.Sometimes they goof at the factory.
#63
Junior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Van Nuys,
CA
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
to be honest this is one of my 1'st option, but I bought the engine in US and I am now for a medium period of time in another country, so the shipping / warranty process should be too long....
Do you know whats the story with the pressure regulator on the carburetor of the OS200 (should be just a diaphragm and a spring..) I cant see also what I can damage disassembling the regulator ans look if there is something unusual.. (I usually do mechanical repair / rebuild in rc and bigger engine).
Thanks for the input.
Do you know whats the story with the pressure regulator on the carburetor of the OS200 (should be just a diaphragm and a spring..) I cant see also what I can damage disassembling the regulator ans look if there is something unusual.. (I usually do mechanical repair / rebuild in rc and bigger engine).
Thanks for the input.
#64
Senior Member
My Feedback: (42)
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Singapore, SINGAPORE
Posts: 548
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
Thats the problem with OS pump engines.The regulator is not sold separately but as a whole with the carb.It costs a lot so its better to send it back for warranty repair.If you must do it yourself, you must firstly ascertain that the leak is positively from the regulator and not from somewhere else. then unscrew the reg cover and you will see the diaphragm.The leak is caused when the diaphragm does not seat properly.Make sure the diaphragm is centred properly.If unfortunately you spot a tear then there's nothing you can do but send the motor back.I have done this before, its not really difficult.Do not overtighten the cover screws as it might distort and leak when putting it back on.Good luck!
#65
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
It's easy.OS engine has no rearward facing exhaust,and the one they have side mounted is pig ugly(2)no flex pipe(3)they sound awfull(4)not as much hp(5)dodgy hard plating?(6)what's a diaphram??..the handbrake is asking that question for me! and can it be replaced..at what cost to you??
The saito's heavier,just found that out reading this and will check the specs,but who relly cares?
The saito's heavier,just found that out reading this and will check the specs,but who relly cares?
#66
Junior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Van Nuys,
CA
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
hi, I inspect the "diaphragm" today was alright, just the two screw where a little over-tight (the plastic cap was a little bent) now the screw are just tighten enaugh to hold the cap in place and to prevent to be unscrewed in flight. now is cold and rainy but if the weather turns good I try on the test stand another time.
just to clarify the engine runs ok, just at full throttle show a very pronunced roughness and lack of power (compared with the 200 without pump I had in the past..)
What nitro % are you using? I'm using just 10% because my other glow (120 AX and the 200S use to run good and strong with this percentage)
THX
just to clarify the engine runs ok, just at full throttle show a very pronunced roughness and lack of power (compared with the 200 without pump I had in the past..)
What nitro % are you using? I'm using just 10% because my other glow (120 AX and the 200S use to run good and strong with this percentage)
THX
#67
My Feedback: (102)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Colonial Beach, VA
Posts: 20,370
Likes: 0
Received 25 Likes
on
25 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
Mel, did you inspect the fuel tube from the pump to the regulator body, it appears to be mighty cramped, I think I would make it longer with a nice flowing loop in it. A longer loop would not effect performance since it is before the regulator.
#68
Junior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Van Nuys,
CA
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
Hi,
actually I had to rotate 180 degrees the carburetor because the throttle linkage was on the other side of the plane.
Anyway at the time I make sure to use good quality 2.5mm int. diameter fuel tubing and avoid any kind of tight turn. I still think I have an air leak somewhere in the line ;the only explenation for the roughness at full throttle and the very difficult 1st start each day where the engine remains dry for a long time showing difficulty to sucks the fuel. (all the other starts are easy).
bye bye
actually I had to rotate 180 degrees the carburetor because the throttle linkage was on the other side of the plane.
Anyway at the time I make sure to use good quality 2.5mm int. diameter fuel tubing and avoid any kind of tight turn. I still think I have an air leak somewhere in the line ;the only explenation for the roughness at full throttle and the very difficult 1st start each day where the engine remains dry for a long time showing difficulty to sucks the fuel. (all the other starts are easy).
bye bye
#69
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: STOCKHOLM Akersberga, SWEDEN
Posts: 1,116
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
I own both engines and have run about 1/2 gallon thru each of them. Both engines are running suprisingly smooth and very quiet and for now I run an APC18x6w on both to keep the plane speed down.
My vote goes for the Saito220 mainly because it is a whole lot stronger engine turning almost 1000rpm more on the same prop. My homebrew fuel contains 10% nitro and 15% oil Syntetic/castor blend and the fuel consumption is about 1-1.2oz/min on mixed aerobatic flight.
My vote goes for the Saito220 mainly because it is a whole lot stronger engine turning almost 1000rpm more on the same prop. My homebrew fuel contains 10% nitro and 15% oil Syntetic/castor blend and the fuel consumption is about 1-1.2oz/min on mixed aerobatic flight.
#70
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
I have a new OS 200 and as soon as we have a decent day here in Michigan I plan to begin the break-in.
I am using an APC 18x6W prop and 15% nitro PowerMaster Fuel.
What kind of RPM's should I expect to see??
Thanks All!
Ken
I am using an APC 18x6W prop and 15% nitro PowerMaster Fuel.
What kind of RPM's should I expect to see??
Thanks All!
Ken
#71
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: STOCKHOLM Akersberga, SWEDEN
Posts: 1,116
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
Hello, I am seeing about 8000rpm on the OS200 with the 18x6w but the engine is new and the weather is cold. I usually get 3-400rpm more on the sumer when the air is thinner.
#73
Senior Member
My Feedback: (8)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Silverdale,
WA
Posts: 1,398
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
I can't recall exactly, but my OS 1.60fx didn't turn the APC 18x6w much over 8500 rpm. If you are getting 8000 new for a significantly lighter engine (accounting for muffler, pump, etc) that is impressive.
#74
My Feedback: (13)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Center of the Flyover States,
Posts: 2,166
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
I've ran two tank fulls on my OS200s while on a test stand. THe crankcase line to the carb came off during the second tank and caused oily goo to go all over and made me think I had a leak someplace. So keep an eye on that line for a while while breaking in.
#75
Junior Member
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Heidelberg, GERMANY
Posts: 23
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Saito 220 or OS FS200
Hi Gary,
The crankcase liner problem is a bit of an issue with this engine. I have solved it successfully with a wooden plug in the access hole, following a suggestion from another forum member (see here: http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_63...tm.htm#6314745).
Mine is now running stable after about 20 litres of fuel, though not particularly powerful (8000 - 8300 on APC 18x6W). The FS200 is a good sports engine, but please don't expect high performance.
The crankcase liner problem is a bit of an issue with this engine. I have solved it successfully with a wooden plug in the access hole, following a suggestion from another forum member (see here: http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_63...tm.htm#6314745).
Mine is now running stable after about 20 litres of fuel, though not particularly powerful (8000 - 8300 on APC 18x6W). The FS200 is a good sports engine, but please don't expect high performance.