JMP Starfire - EDF
#1
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (14)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: St. Mary\'s City,
MD
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
JMP Starfire - EDF
I've been working on an electric conversion of a very old, original, JMP Starfire kit for about two months now. First up was some custom inlet ducting to allow the battery to be mounted in the center V.
Equipment used: DS-94 fan, Nue 1521-1.5Y motor, Castle Creations 110HV ESC, 4 Hitec 5125 thin wing digitals on ailerons and flaps, 2 digital 5245's on elevator and one on rudder, and a sub-micro analog on the airvalve + HS-225 on the nose steering. Battery is a Tanic 9S1P 5,000 mah pack. Classic B&D plastic framed retracts + BVM 5/32" wire struts and axles with Hanger 9 2.5" plastic wheels on the mains. The nose got a cheap Eurokit trailing link sprund strut and a 2.25" Skylite wheel. All up weight at this point with a bit of paint repair, markings and clearcoat still to go is 11 pounds 14 ounces. The fan generates 10 pounds of thrust @ about 2,800 watts. I've got a different wind motor that works on 12S, that will be something to try in the future
So, today was test flight day. Take apeak, nothing fancy. I just spent about 3 minutes or so trimming the three flap positions and feeling out the low speed handling. That plus the couple of full throttle runs to test thrust used 2.4 AH.
Video at:
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showa...mentid=1031904
Equipment used: DS-94 fan, Nue 1521-1.5Y motor, Castle Creations 110HV ESC, 4 Hitec 5125 thin wing digitals on ailerons and flaps, 2 digital 5245's on elevator and one on rudder, and a sub-micro analog on the airvalve + HS-225 on the nose steering. Battery is a Tanic 9S1P 5,000 mah pack. Classic B&D plastic framed retracts + BVM 5/32" wire struts and axles with Hanger 9 2.5" plastic wheels on the mains. The nose got a cheap Eurokit trailing link sprund strut and a 2.25" Skylite wheel. All up weight at this point with a bit of paint repair, markings and clearcoat still to go is 11 pounds 14 ounces. The fan generates 10 pounds of thrust @ about 2,800 watts. I've got a different wind motor that works on 12S, that will be something to try in the future
So, today was test flight day. Take apeak, nothing fancy. I just spent about 3 minutes or so trimming the three flap positions and feeling out the low speed handling. That plus the couple of full throttle runs to test thrust used 2.4 AH.
Video at:
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showa...mentid=1031904
#4
Banned
My Feedback: (119)
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
Nice work, as always. Faster than the Viper, you think?
I like the hatch in primer. It looks like a 68 Charger I had in high school with the hood from a 69 on it. Nobody will steal it!
Nice work on the intake ducting, I know how much work that represents.
I like the hatch in primer. It looks like a 68 Charger I had in high school with the hood from a 69 on it. Nobody will steal it!
Nice work on the intake ducting, I know how much work that represents.
#5
My Feedback: (18)
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: North Hollywood, CA
Posts: 3,713
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
Chris, what do you think a 8 minute flight will take from the battery? 5Amps? There is a guy out here that flys the heck out of this plane with an old 14lbs wren turbine. It looks to be a very good flyer and is on my list. How was the build? Are you going to add some rub on nomenclature or another color then clear? 12S? Oh man!!!
Joe
Joe
#6
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (14)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: St. Mary\'s City,
MD
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
ORIGINAL: EASYTIGER
Nice work, as always. Faster than the Viper, you think?
I like the hatch in primer. It looks like a 68 Charger I had in high school with the hood from a 69 on it. Nobody will steal it!
Nice work on the intake ducting, I know how much work that represents.
Nice work, as always. Faster than the Viper, you think?
I like the hatch in primer. It looks like a 68 Charger I had in high school with the hood from a 69 on it. Nobody will steal it!
Nice work on the intake ducting, I know how much work that represents.
Paint, don't ask! I had a disaster with some masking film and not quite fully cured paint. Wound up with adhesive on all the white areas and some spots that lifted. It'll all get fixed...
Joe - 8 minutes is a little ambitious. This is a 5-6 minute power system unless you want to fly around like an old timer. This flight didn't use much because it was a test flight and I was concentrating on trimming and then flying slow which is what's needed for that 1 mandatory test flight manuever - LANDING!
I have some markings on the way from Ralf Schneider, it'll be similar to one of those Swiss Hawks with a red circle / white cross on the fin, white cross on the wing tips, #'2 of the fuse side etc.
#7
Banned
My Feedback: (119)
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
You should definitely do Swiss Naval colors. The Swiss Navy is undefeated.
As a sidebar, I made my own bungee and successfully flew my Hunter a bunch of times, finally smooshed the nose hitting a field table on landing, after I had to go around three times, each time slower than the next as the battery wound down, becuase some nimrod parked his car right on the approach path to watch, and was too thick to move...
What kind of range do you get out of the base-loaded white Deans mini antenna? Good enough for larger aircraft?
As a sidebar, I made my own bungee and successfully flew my Hunter a bunch of times, finally smooshed the nose hitting a field table on landing, after I had to go around three times, each time slower than the next as the battery wound down, becuase some nimrod parked his car right on the approach path to watch, and was too thick to move...
What kind of range do you get out of the base-loaded white Deans mini antenna? Good enough for larger aircraft?
#8
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (14)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: St. Mary\'s City,
MD
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
How large? If you are concerned about it use the non-baseloaded whip, I've been putting them on all my .91 size jets. They get the antenna away from all the high power electrics and does wonders for range checking. For a plane smaller than that I"d have no resrvations about the Deans mini whip.
#12
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (14)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: St. Mary\'s City,
MD
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
I'm not that much of a scale enthusiast but who knows. I've got an A-4 in the attic and a very old, missing the stab linkage, Yellow F-4 kit.
The A-4 is maybe shy on inlet area a little and probably needs inlet different ducts. The F-4 is so old the landing gear was in the wrong spot and needed to be moved forward an inch and a half or so - I got most of the way through that enjoyable task before I set it asside last year. At the time, twin 90mm fans was the way to go, nowadays maybe the single big fan?
No burning desire to do either at the moment Maybe BV will release a new version of the Sabre or T-33 / F-80...
The A-4 is maybe shy on inlet area a little and probably needs inlet different ducts. The F-4 is so old the landing gear was in the wrong spot and needed to be moved forward an inch and a half or so - I got most of the way through that enjoyable task before I set it asside last year. At the time, twin 90mm fans was the way to go, nowadays maybe the single big fan?
No burning desire to do either at the moment Maybe BV will release a new version of the Sabre or T-33 / F-80...
#13
My Feedback: (8)
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
Your report re your Starfire is timely. I, too, have a Starfire in which I'm considering EDF propulsion. BVM's system is reported to produce 12 pounds of thrust. Do you think the BVM EDF is a viable alternative for the Starfire?
BTW...I really enjoyed your video and congratulate you for the obvious success of your efforts.
BTW...I really enjoyed your video and congratulate you for the obvious success of your efforts.
#14
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (14)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: St. Mary\'s City,
MD
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
Thanks!
The only thing you'd need to check would be the physical dimensions of the packs - if they will slip in along the stock inlet duct into the space formerly occupied by the fuel tanks you are home free. Might need to thin out the hatch lip in that area a bit to make insertion / removal a little easier...
The only thing you'd need to check would be the physical dimensions of the packs - if they will slip in along the stock inlet duct into the space formerly occupied by the fuel tanks you are home free. Might need to thin out the hatch lip in that area a bit to make insertion / removal a little easier...
#15
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (14)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: St. Mary\'s City,
MD
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
On second thought, you might want the packs behind the fan for balance reasons. I'm thinking they might even fit better back there although you may have you elevator servo's in the way? Pretty sure it can be made to work
The reason I say further back for the packs is mine came out nose heavy! Without the heavy tuned pipe in the rear of the fuselage I needed to install my Rx pack back by the LE of the stab! I think if the packs were alongside the thrust tube behind the wing former and the Rx pack up in the nose it would all work out.
The reason I say further back for the packs is mine came out nose heavy! Without the heavy tuned pipe in the rear of the fuselage I needed to install my Rx pack back by the LE of the stab! I think if the packs were alongside the thrust tube behind the wing former and the Rx pack up in the nose it would all work out.
#17
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (14)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: St. Mary\'s City,
MD
Posts: 524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JMP Starfire - EDF
Every little bit helps but realistically, there is only so much difference you can make when the pack is drained in 5 minutes I've added little scoops made from plastic spoons and a hole or two further back in a low pressure area to try and encurage airflow on some planes, others I haven't bothered with. I can't say there's really a huge difference but maybe some.