RCU Forums

RCU Forums (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/)
-   RC Pattern Flying (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/rc-pattern-flying-101/)
-   -   Pattern practice help (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/rc-pattern-flying-101/722562-pattern-practice-help.html)

Richardfast 04-25-2003 03:45 PM

Pattern practice help
 
I am practicing pattern flying. I am working on just the basic turnaround maneuvers, with concentration on coming out of the maneuver with wings level, at the right altitude and right throttle setting. My problem is with crosswind correction. It is obvious what to do during the straight and level flight portion (obvious, but not easy), but it is not clear to me how to correct for crosswind during the turnaround maneuver itself ( half loops). How do you make this correction during these half loop turnarounds? Are you using just rudder throughout the maneuver, during just part of the maneuver, or are you also throwing in some roll correction? Any help would be appreciated.

Anthony-RCU 04-25-2003 05:46 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Look for Wayne Apostolico (sp) book cross wind flying. Lots of good info.

Richardfast 04-27-2003 11:31 AM

Pattern practice help
 
I am starting to notice that pattern flyers (at least those on RCU) like to talk about airplanes a lot but apparently don't like to talk about flying. We might as well rename this forum "pattern airplanes". Look through all of the threads and you will see what I mean. I know how to build or buy airplanes, I want to learn how to fly pattern! With that having been said, does anyone out there know how to correct for crosswind? Maybe starting a new forum called "How to fly pattern" would help. Seriously, I would like a little assistance from all of the "experts" out there. No one at my field flies anything precision, they are just all over the sky.

GW-inactive 04-27-2003 12:46 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Richard,

What your asking is a question that has so many answers. So many different answers at that. If you will ask a specific question as to how to do a certain maneuver, someone like TroyN,
JAS, TonyF, DougC,other top pilots will surely help.

As far as crosswind correction, Rudder is always the key. You maintain heading in a crosswind by applying rudder throughout the schedule. Always being aware of the heading you established in your entry to the box, and maintaining it at all times. The hard part to explain is the steps to do this in. You use rudder alot, but you use it so that your plane seemingly is always flying straight and level. I call it sneaking the rudder in. I'm not good at sneaking mine in, but thats what you are looking for. Your example would be a good one or a 1/2 Cuban eight. Practicing in a crosswind, enter the 1/2 Cuban and use rudder across the back side to maintain your heading, coming out of it at the same entry height and on the same path(heading) you entered it. No closer to you, no further away.Making the plane looks as if it is not even flying in a crosswind.


See, I have totally made a mess out of trying to explain this, but I did give it a try.

PatternFlyer 04-27-2003 03:35 PM

Pattern practice help
 
GW did a hard job above.
Anthony's suggestion of the Crosswind flying book (I believe Don's hobby has them, but I never had a chance to buy one).

I am only in the Intermediate level and am definitely not an expert at all. I saw your posting right after it was posted, but wasn't brave enough to reply.

Also, it is beginning of contest season. The response time may get a little longer also. If I can, I would go out to fly rather than staying up all night looking at this computer screen for more than 8 hours a day!!

I also post reply to what I think I know. Otherwise, I mostly read.

Anyway.
here is what I try, but have not always been successful because of less time to practice and different conditions. My local flying field has cross wind almost every evening.

Suppose you are flying from right to left, upright.
Crosswind blowing from your back.
If you don't use rudder, your plane will gradually (depending on how strong the wind is) get pushed out if you keep the plane straight along the flight line.

So, the prevent the plane getting far out from the flight line, I keep slight left rudder. If you look at the plane from the top, its heading will be slightly inward.

it will be opposite when you fly back.

Not all plane fly same way because of different design and wind penetration characteristics.

My plane get pushed a lot because of large flat sides.
The surface area of vertical stab and rudder also make differences.

Speed of the plane also makes difference.

So, PRACTICE! PRACTICE! PRACTICE!!! :mad:
With a COACH or a CALLER who can tell you if your plane is moving inward or outward.

When I concentrate on my plane, I often forget where my plane is heading. :stupid:

Was my explanation correct?

Please!! Correct me if I am wrong.

Hmmm, I always write too long. :D

Richardfast 04-27-2003 07:47 PM

Pattern practice help
 
GW/Patternflyer,
Thanks for the input. Let's see if I understand this correctly:
Flying left to right, wind at my back and holding right rudder to stay crabbed into the wind so that my ground track stays parallel to the runway. Now I pull to a 45 for my entry into a 1/2 reverse cuban 8, with rudder correction staying the same. Neutralize rudder, roll inverted, and put in a left rudder correction. Hold this left rudder through the rest of the maneuver and into the flight back parallel to the runway. Now flying right to left with left rudder, pull through a 5/8 loop to a 45 down holding the same rudder. Neutralize the rudder, roll upright and put in right rudder for the flight up wind. Next, for the two inside loops at show center looks like I would hold the same rudder correction all the way through. Ok? Am I understanding this correctly?

GW-inactive 04-27-2003 11:44 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Your on the correct path now. Its not that you will always hold the same rudder throughout the maneuver, just the corrections needed to maintain heading. It may need to be held through the maneuver, or it may only need slight corrections at different intervals along the path. Thats where burning fuel makes these things second nature. You will almost feel what you need before your plane actually needs it. The more you know your plane, the more you will know what its going to need in certain circumstances to keep the flight level , on heading, pretty and graceful.

PatternFlyer 04-28-2003 12:37 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Richard,

If you pull with rudder applied, your flying path will most likely be incorrect.

Best way to realize who to look at a certain condition is using a small (stick or anything) plane to visualize the path and attitude of the plane.

As GW explained above, rudder is for correction only in this discussion.

1/2 Reverse Cuban Eight, Flying left to right, wind from back. >> Keep right rudder for straight flight line. This will steer your plane slightly to right (skidding attitude).

Now visualize your plane from top it will be like \ >> (the bottom of this back slash is the front of your plane although it is not that much).
If you pull elevator with rudder applied, where will your heading be?

Your heading will be inward causing more correction.
You need to release (or adjust) the rudder right before pulling, so that the plane pulls at the attitude of straight flying along the flight line without any tilting.

Once pulled, re-apply (or adjust) the rudder for wind correction to keep the path.

release rudder, 1/2 roll to invert, apply left rudder to stay on path.

release or adjust rudder to loop and stay on the flight path to finish the manuever.

I am not 100% correct here because releasing or adjusting rudder make differences.
You will have to familiarize yourself to many different conditions.

So, go out to field and burn fuel.

patternrules 04-28-2003 12:55 AM

Pattern practice help
 
This is all god but if you have a plane that really weather vanes bad it can actually do just the opposite the plane can come in if the wind is to your back that's why you don't get any replies to this type of question it is very plane specific, the Prophecy that I fly as my 2nd back acts different than the Focus which is my backup to the Smaragd that is different than both. If this make any sense one plane I have to use the opposite rudder to correct.
Steve Maxwell

GW-inactive 04-28-2003 12:57 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Excellent description Mr Park.
Your way with words is many times better than mine .

I never realized how hard this would be to explain till I tried to do it above. I also didn't realize all the inputs I may or may not make during a sequence ,given a certain set of circumstances, till I sat down and decided to give this topic a reply. Good thing my flying is a small bit better than my commentary on flying.

GW-inactive 04-28-2003 01:04 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Good point Steve. Many variables to this stuff! More than we can explain.

mvigod 04-28-2003 02:19 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Convince the judges to rotate the field 90 degrees so there is no crosswind :)

GW-inactive 04-28-2003 02:49 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Ok, Who woke Marc up? :)

PatternFlyer 04-28-2003 05:21 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Steve's description is also correct. :p
I actually was writing that prior to my first reply to this thread, but it is not always happen and I feel that it depends on design. So, I re wrote the whole reply as basic.

Quote from my first posting. "Not all plane fly same way because of different design and wind penetration characteristics. "


GW,
Thank you very much for kind words. I try to hook more people to Pattern in my area just to have people to practice with and go to contests together. So far no success.

Just call me Ihncheol or just Park. More than half the people that I know call me "Park" because of hard pronounciation of my Korean first name. :D

Actually, I have to call you Mr. W. :)

RC Admin,
If you can convince the judges, you should also be able to convince the AMA for regulation change regarding NOT being able to fly over the pit area. ;)

With lots of cross wind, I had very little time to trim my plane correctly. :mad:

Divesplat 04-29-2003 02:49 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Hey Richard

The skills learned as a pattern pilot are very difficult to relay with the written word, without visual keys.

Rudder is one of the skills that even Advanced pilots are still battling with, and Masters pilots still make occ mistakes with.

As stated above, not every plane responds the same. My buddies Prophecy and my Olympian land completely differently in regard to rudder correction, so it is not helpful to give advice unless you can see what is happening in the air.

With all this said, call Don's Hobby Shop and order his 2 books, especially crosswind flying. This is an extremely well written book and explains many many aspects of precision flying.

A large number of pattern skills have to be mostly self-awareness kinda things. This doesn't make it hopeless. There are a number of techniques you can use.

1) First, fly level. When we look up at a plane from the ground we often times see the wings in a "canted" attitude. On a fairly calm day or with slight wind straight down the pipe make striaght level passes. At the ends smoothly pull up to vertical and see if the plane pulls to the left or right consistently. If so, then that wing tip is slightly lower than the other. This is key because it is a trick to adjust for a crosswind later. Once pulling striaght up to vertical(same is true for a loop, figure 8, immelman, etc)

2) Remember the rudder does different things when plane is right side up as opposed to inverted. First thing with rudder is does it affect the track of the plane in a bad way. Does the nose pitch up or down with rudder or does the plane try to roll with rudder. If either is true then we need to try to use a little mixing with rudder so the plane will still fly without pitch(up or down) or roll(ailerons) That is a whole nother subject. Once plane is trimmed well

3) When upright the rudder input moves the nose of the plane the same direction, just like taxiing on the ground. When inverted the rudder moves the tail of the plane the same direction. So if you need to help the plane crab to the right while right side up, to adjust for crosswind or heading adjustment, slowly add as little rudder as neeeded to get the plane to keep the line you are after. Some planes will crab on their own and actually keep a fairly straight line, others will get pushed off heading and some will need oposite rudder to keep their heading. The trick is to see the line in your mind and work to get the plane on that track.

4) to you question of an immelman, again every plane will react differently. On trick is to use ail to dip the wing slightly, that is on the wind direction side. The plane will track into the wind slightly and is very helpful to keep the same track.
If you are holding rudder to maintain a heading, the same rudder will be requred until you do a 1/2 roll. For instance, if you are holding right rudder in and you do a loop, you probably will be able to hold the right rudder throughout the entire loop. There wasn't any 1/2 roll to change the orientation of the plane so right rudder will accomplish the same thing throughout the loop, and the track before and after, assuming wings stayed perfectly level t/o the loop(difficult to do also) As the wings move from level your rudder inputs will need to be changed.

5) Try some crosswind stall turns. Once you pull vertical, you may have to give rudder to maintain a straight line up. Again some planes crab into the wind some may need opposite rudder. After the rotation of the stall, don't be afraid to use some rudder on the down line to keep the line straight. This is needed at times also. Ugly yes, but we are after the line the CG of the plane draws.

As you can see, it is very difficult to discuss this as this is getting very long. Practice practice practice and pay very close attention to the heading and track of the plane. Keep mental notes to what worked today, yesterday etc. Go to every contest you can and talk with everyone. Volunteer to scribe as you get a different perspective of the planes flying and why the judge gave a 9 or a 3. When appropriate ask the judge questions.

Learning these things can be frustrating by yourself, but they are possible. Self-aware learning has a way of being very fulfulling. Once you see what you want the plane to do, then strive to accomplish it, there is plenty of reason to get out to the field.

Hope this helps and sorry for being so long winded. By the way, this whole exercise applies to IMAC as well.

Ed

PatternFlyer 04-29-2003 06:28 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Ed,

Great explanation above.
I am not a certified NSRCA judge, but have a question regarding the #4 dipping the wing slightly.

Yes, I've tried that.
However, isn't that going to cause degrading per the rule book?

Divesplat 04-29-2003 07:25 AM

Pattern practice help
 
If the wing dip is visible, yes there should be a deduction.

The trick is to try and mask the wing dip so as not to be detectable, or minimally detectable.

If you dip the wing as you are pulling elev. and the dip is very slight it may go totally unnoticed. If you dip the wing prior to the pull, then it will be obvious. Same notion as the downline pull on a stall turn, if the wings aren't totally level on the downline, you will encure a smaller deduction if you adjust the wings as you exit, as opposed to making the change on the downline where everyone can see it.

Also, I/m talking about very small amounts of wing changes.

In Don's book he also brings up there are better places to do this where the plane is in a better position, or more difficult to discern by the judges. The pilot has a better feel for what is going on as he/she is controlling the plane. For instance, on a loop, on the backside as the plane goes from the back side down to ending level is the best time to do this.

Another idea to maintain heading in crosswind is to try and roll with the canopy into the wind. So practice 1/2 rolls, slow rolls, 2 of 4 pt rolls and 4 pt rolls rolling both directions, left and right. It does feel different.

Ed

Jon Wold 04-29-2003 08:02 AM

Re: Pattern practice help
 

Originally posted by Richardfast
I am practicing pattern flying. I am working on just the basic turnaround maneuvers, with concentration on coming out of the maneuver with wings level, at the right altitude and right throttle setting. My problem is with crosswind correction. It is obvious what to do during the straight and level flight portion (obvious, but not easy), but it is not clear to me how to correct for crosswind during the turnaround maneuver itself ( half loops). How do you make this correction during these half loop turnarounds? Are you using just rudder throughout the maneuver, during just part of the maneuver, or are you also throwing in some roll correction? Any help would be appreciated.
I have no real answer for you, but I tried this with two different planes last week and I found that neither rudder nor ailerons did me any good. The only things I could to to make it appear straight was a lot of power, and to do the correction before the manouver. (Meaning I can't do any corrections once I've stared a 1/2 reverse cuban 8, I set it up before the roll on the 45 deg. up leg and live with the way it comes out :( ) And I found that at less than half power, the nose would weir into the wind big time.

Richardfast 04-29-2003 11:35 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Thanks to all of you for the great input. I am practicing as much as I can and I will strive to get some observer/caller help. Hope I didn't hack anyone off with the bit of sarcasm that started this going, but I just wasn't making much progress in my flying and my first contest is only a month away. I was getting a little frustrated.

AdrianM 04-29-2003 08:56 PM

Pattern practice help
 
I coach/spotter is essential. As you focus on the manuver your spotter can see things you cant pay attention to as a beginner. I am in the same boat as you...starting out at precision aerobatics. Every Saterday night I call my Pattern/IMAC clubmates and schedule things so a few of us are at the field at the same time.

FYI, Spotting for more experienced fliers is just as valuable as getting coached. Especially if they call out what they are doing.

BJM 05-07-2003 09:59 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Hey guys,

An airplane with rudder applied will not hold a heading or a line. If you hold rudder across the box, you will fly an arc.
Billy

Surfer Dude 05-08-2003 01:57 AM

Here's what I do.
 
I make sure the plane flighs straight on a calm day with no computer trim, just mechanical trim.

Now when I fly I use the both methods of using the rudder and dipping one wingtip in to the wind. When I use the aileron I use enough so that it flighs straight but not so it is noticed from the judges. I use this method in mild to heavy winds.

Now when i fly with the rudder I apply just enouch to make it fly straight .The rudder method is better for light to mild winds with my airplane.

On uplines I use the rudder and depending maybe a little up or down elevator. When I do my stall turn Turn to the direction of wind. Now the real trick is adding opposite rudder right after the turn is made so that there is no heading change.
With loops I usually fly the airplane and use all four controls.

Remember the plane is supposed to fligh in a straight line meaning the plane can be headed into the wind.

One other thing that helped me was living in chicago. Every now and then on a windy day at the field, i'll look up and watch the airplanes landing in O'hare and see how the airplane acts.

I hope this clears up some things, but then again I'm only 15 and I'm right maybe once out of a thousand times. But seriously i hope this helps anyone out there.

Chris

rajul 05-08-2003 01:28 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Don Ramsey has an excellent coverage on rudder control here http://www.cox-internet.com/donramsey/FourthControl.htm You'll find a wealth of other pattern flying goodies too........

JRW 05-08-2003 04:01 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Hi Richardfast,

You are right, there is not much info on the "how" section of "flying." In fact, "how" to fly a good looking maneuver in any flight direction or with any amount of wind from any direction is nearly unexplainable. The pilot, the criteria for getting a "10" is pretty clear, but how to do it from flight to flight, or day to day is not clear. In order to do this, you need a certain skill set. The skills to perform the manuevers are the easiest to understand.

However, the MOST important skill IMHO is PERCEPTION. And, this skill takes the most time and practice to gain. It is also the first to leave you if you stop practicing. IMHO, these are the most important things to learn:

Again, PERCEPTION, PERCEPTION, PERCEPTION, PERCPTION!

1. PERCEPTION: Learn to the see the model correctly in any attitude. If you are "seeing" it deviated from what you KNOW is the proper attitude, you can LEARN to correct the error. This is an equal combination of usually WATCHING higher class flyers, practice with a coach, and practice grinding it out by yourself (and foul words if necessary). Perception of your model will also allow you to "see" mistakes before they happen. For instance, you have decided to leave a small dip in the wing prior to the start of the next maneuver. You do this so that the judges don't "see" you obviously fixing a small mistake. Thus, I "know" that to pull a radius that "looks" correct (given one wing is dipped), that I will need twice the usual oppisite rudder, and to breathe in the aileron fix 50% through the radius, simultaniously releasing some of the rudder. However, do not release all the rudder, or the tail might waggle (which creates a visual que to the judges that you have done "something" wrong they did not see before). I don't think you can write enough about how important perception is. One trick to give your vision a paradigm shift is to simply double your baseline height for a few sequences.

2. At each class, the next most important aspect of flying skill is (get ready to be bored) (drum-roll please) STRAIGHT, WINGS LEVEL FLIGHT. You absolutely cannot escape this fundamental! The winners of each class from Sportsman to FAI separate themselves not by how good the snap of one maneuver looks, but by the quality of the linking of maneuvers and the mastering of fundementals. What was once a good enough straight line to win the Advanced Nats, looks more like sport-flying at the Masters level. A honing of the fundamentals at each level will reward you tremendously!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3. The next most important skill is "entry and exit" of ANY maneuver. Entering the maneuver correctly gives you a "chance" to perform it correctly, exiting it correctly allows you to "link" the whole maneuver set together. In fact, as your PERCEPTION improves, you will continually find errors in how you enter and exit a maneuver. Once you "see" the error, you can "learn" to fix it on the spot.

Thus far:
1. Perception
2. Straight wings level flight
3. Maneuver entry and exit

Finally: As your perception improves, and you learn to get the plane to do what you want, you will start a very important transformation. You need to become "plane" centered instead of "tranmitter" centered. The judges don't care what your transmitter stick positions indicate the plane is doing. The only "que" to the judges is what your plane is doing. Thus, your "que" should be the plane as well. Release your preconcived notions, fears, or hessitations. To fly a straight line, it "might" require use of rudder, elevator, and aileron - thats OK. Flying a perfect loop with a cross wind will UNDOUBTEDLY require flying ALL THREE FLIGHT AXIS - and thats OK. The plane will not fall out of the sky or something if all of a sudden you find that you need lots of control input to get something to look nice. Transforming to a plane centered approach will allow you to be "ahead" of the plane. If you continually focus on the tranmitter, you will always be "behind" the plane.

One reason the real "Master-Grasshoppers" don't post much of the "how" to fly stuff, is that the more "plane-focused" you become, the more "natural" the flying becomes, and the "less" aware they are of making the actual corrections.

Without improving your perception, the maneuvers will always be a mystery and incosistent! This is one reason that attending contests is so important to "learning" how to fly pattern. And now young pattern grasshopper, you too are ready spread your wings and fly!
Jim Woodward
(my pattern wings are still a little wet. I too would like to hear how the big guys to it)

KenChoo 05-08-2003 11:12 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Hey Jim!

Truly excellent response there, (I think it's worth a print in the K-Factor! Would you mind submitting it?). It really struck a chord with me, because I know that perception is my number 1 (and 2 and 3) problem with my pattern flying. It was easier when I had my sister as my caller/coach, as she has a good set of eyes. But now I'm on my own, in a place where I'm the only one flying pattern (come to think of it, the only one flying precision aerobatics of any kind). And I'm frustrated because I'm very comfortable with the sticks, I have no real issues with corrections, it's just SEEING the plane right to know "which/how much/when" on the inputs. And I notice, that due to our field setup (awkward) I'm usually flying further out on the left than on the right, while trying to do my center maneuvers centered. That leaves me feeling too rushed coming in from the right (regardless of which way I'm flying the sequence, wind from left or wind from right). I'll admit, I'm kinda lost, so I was wondering if you had any words of wisdom to help me train myself to see things better? Thanks Jim.

Cheers,
Ken
NSRCA 2997

Anthony-RCU 05-09-2003 03:51 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Great response Jim! Great K factor article.

One way I practiced over the winter was lots of flights of just practicing lines. Straight through the box to an immelman straight across the top. Split S then repeat. Then big square loops and 45 's through the middle then repeat all inverted. Then add lots of half rolls, change turnarounds, etc.
The key is knowing were the plane is at all attitudes and all parts of the box. I also practice the sequence above or below the class I'm flying every so often to force me to do different stuff.

Richardfast 05-09-2003 04:06 PM

Pattern practice help
 
You guys are really helping me learn to fly pattern! None of these responses from all of you are wasted. Since I started this thread I have burned through almost two gallons of fuel, practicing a lot of the suggestions that have been said here. The good news is I am improving!
There are no active pattern flyers in my area so this thread has been my school.
Perception, perception, perception.... right on! At my stage of learning, the only way I can tell whether or not the wings are perfectly level is when I pull and find out too late that the heading is going bye bye. But I am getting better at flying the airplane and not the sticks. One thing I am going to try is putting a dayglo stripe on each wing tip to better see where the wings are as the plane passes through box center.
Thanks again for all of the help. This thread is being printed out as it builds for continued study.
By the way, Hover King, last years masters champion at the Nat's was 15; so believe me, I pay attention to what you say regardless of age.

JRW 05-09-2003 04:21 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Ken, Anthony,

Thanks for the kind words - heres what you should consider:
1. Box: You NEED a box to practice pattern. From your habitual pilot station, setup some 60 degree lines, even if temorary. Place some poles or flag markers out about 25 meters along these lines and a center marker (or do it at the 150 marker is your club allows). These can be something you take home if you wanted. If you do this, and your centered maneuvers are still rushed, you are simply flying too close.

2. Fixing your Perception: Fly at a baseline height where "level" flight means you can just see the bottom of the outside wing panel. This is much easier to hit consistently than a lower baseline hieght where you only see the wing tip. Maybe 40 meters up for a quick number. Then, fly straight passes. Use the 1/2 reverse cuban 8 for a turnaround manuever. Just before starting the manuever, induce a miniscule wing dip, and then start the manuever. Do this small wing dip both directions. One side will look really BAD, one side will look BETTER. Repeat the BETTER looking angle on the next pass, and make refinements so that when you "pull" the turnaround manuever, you need little to no rudder correction. Repeat this until you can exit one turnaround maneuver, fly the straight line, and start the next turnaround mauever, with little deviation in heading or roll. Bets are that doing this at the baseline height you "see" the bottom of the outside wing will train your vision to que into the true wings level position. Making these adjustments on the turnaround manevuers is good for the visual que, because your eyes can see the wings position better at the ends of the box.
3. Centered loop: With your new found level flight position, try a gentle centered loop. In my opinion, lots of folks do not keep the "outside" wing down. In that, they sort of roll the plane so that the "see" the top of the wings too much, and make up for this with larger amount of rudder input, and the plane heads in after the loop. I think you will be surprised at how much different a loop looks if you keep the outside wing down. Further more, your rudder work through the loop will be cut in 1/2 when you keep the correct wings level position through the backside of the loop. One way to easily determine if your wing are level "through" the loop, is that upon exit, do you need to make an aileron correction? Fact is, if you need an aileron correction at the bottom of the loop, you probably needed it much earlier than you "saw". - learn to NOT need to see the top of the plane as a comforting factor.
4. TOP OF THE BOX: IMHO, flying at the top of the box, wings level, on heading is hard! How many times have you, or at least seen, huge deviations is exits and straight lines. A typical top of the box error I see (and I make), is to head in when going across the top. For instance, 1/2 square loop with 1/2 roll: At the top of this, when pushing the exit radius, make sure the plane does not head in. Typically, I see lots of people (including me) head in and decend. Try to recognize this early. Other than practice, I don't know how to help with this one.

1. Straight flight: keep baseline where you see the bottom of outside wing panel
2. entry radius: work adjusting your wings level position until you can pull into it with little to no rudder.
3. Centered maneuvers: keep outside wing down, resist urge to see top of plane.
4. Anyone else help with the top of the box stuff??????????????
Jim Woodward

GW-inactive 05-09-2003 08:32 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Jim,

Just wanted to personally thank you for your latest involvement in the pattern discussion on RCU. As a moderator of the pattern forum, I am expected to know the answers to alot of this stuff you are explaining, and often I may have a clue,often times I do not have a clue. or cannot put it to words. This is where you are excelling. I have read over your comments about trimming and you comments on practicing many times now. Your explanations were just what we have been needing for a long time in pattern and here on RCU its a welcomed addition.

There are often comments about why nobody discusses how to fly pattern, and the answer is "Its tough to tell someone how to do something that is second nature".
You have did this in a way in which the novice and mid level pilots will have a better understanding of what we are trying to accomplish with these planes. I will be trying some of your ideas this weekend. Keep up the great discussions.

rajul 05-09-2003 11:00 PM

Pattern practice help
 

Originally posted by Jim Woodward

1. Straight flight: keep baseline where you see the bottom of outside wing panel

Jim, is it possible for you to post a photo or diagram so that we can better visualize this keypoint you're making ? Thanks for the great "back to the basics" discourse !

Divesplat 05-10-2003 02:49 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Don't have diagram but beings we are standing on the ground and essentially looking up at some angle, we should be able to see the bottom of the outboard wing. If we cannot, the wings are angled to such as we look up, in other words not level.

The appearance of wings level is different, working back to the word Perception, depending on the different altitude we are flying. The higher up we are, the more visible the outboard wing should be.

If I were 10' tall(I'm not but) and the plane was being flown at 10' high, all I should see is the wing tip, but neither top nor bottom of wing as the wings are level with my eyesight. If the plane was flown at 50' up, and all I saw was the wingtip as before, the inboard wing would be lower than the outboard wing, hence not level because of the angle I would be looking up towards the 50' level.

Hope thismakes sense. Every plane presents differently, and the only way to figure it out is to fly level and do the pull and push exercises mentioned above, to learn what the correct sight is for our individual planes.

Ed

KenChoo 05-12-2003 02:12 AM

Re: Jim Woodwards' post - #28
 
Hey Jim,

I know what you mean about heading "in" at the top of the box, typically say after an immelmann. I always thought that if my heading was correct I'd have an easier time of it (i.e. heading straight before the pull up, then after it wouldn't come it). But it still happens - some days it's not so bad, some days it pretty severe. What I try to do to help myself, is sneak in a touch of rudder on the last 1/4 of the half loop (just a breath!) - always pushing the nose just a little out. That way, even if I was really heading for trouble, by the time I complete the half roll I don't require as much rudder correction as I would have w/o the sneaking in of rudder. It's much stealthier that way that correcting after the half roll. Hope it helps! (Can't tell if it will...ALL my maneuvers look pretty ugly).

Cheers,
Ken

KenChoo 05-12-2003 02:57 AM

Pattern practice help
 
Ooops, just realized what a dumb post/answer mine was, Jim. Never mind. Usually guestimate whether I need to touch in a bit of rudder. Point really is PERCEPTION again, ain't it?

Cheers,
Ken

Anthony-RCU 05-13-2003 07:43 PM

Pattern practice help
 

Originally posted by Jim Woodward
4. TOP OF THE BOX: IMHO, flying at the top of the box, wings level, on heading is hard! How many times have you, or at least seen, huge deviations is exits and straight lines. A typical top of the box error I see (and I make), is to head in when going across the top. For instance, 1/2 square loop with 1/2 roll: At the top of this, when pushing the exit radius, make sure the plane does not head in. Typically, I see lots of people (including me) head in and decend. Try to recognize this early. Other than practice, I don't know how to help with this one.

4. Anyone else help with the top of the box stuff??????????????
Jim Woodward [/B]
Hi Jim,
I remember a conversation about smaller half squares at the Nats. Can't take my own advice however. Really having problems with this one, especially sinking into the spin and speeding up and wich makes for an ugly entry. Have also been flying some reaaallly big square loops lately.
Think I need to use less power on the up line adding power only after the roll. Smaller radii would probably help too. Any other suggestions.

ilikeplanes 05-14-2003 03:01 AM

Pattern practice help
 
rajul, that link is amazing. I added it to my favorites list. It will take me weeks to absorb all that.

I'm also learning to use rudder. Funny that I have 15 years experience and never REALLY learned to use it. With all this advise, I'm going to start drilling with the sim and at the field. I have already noticed that small rudder corrections are becoming more natural and automatic (at least up right).

I would also add that it is possible to over drill. As your mind becomes fatigued, you just start burning-in bad technique. I always start a flight with a shake-out, drill several passes, fly the sequence a few time, and shake-out at the end. This helps me stay relaxed and prevents the sequence from becoming an adversary. Remember, it's supposed to be fun too.

sm00thflyer 05-15-2003 01:56 AM

Pattern practice help
 
I'm currently practicing for the US F3A Team Trials. My practice sessions consist of 3 flights in the morning and 3 flights in the late afternoon. Also, I try to have a caller as often as possible to help give me positive criticism.

There's a couple of reasons I don't go out for one long practice session. First, I get tired if I practice more than 3 or 4 flights at a time. The quality of the flights go downhill after putting forth the intense mental focus it requires to fly well. Secondly, in North Carolina right now it's humid and warm by noon. If I'm at my field at 9am, I can 'beat the heat' and get a more efficient practice session. Then in the afternoon I do something else other than flying to give myself a break and allow time to 'rest'. Around 5pm, I'll go out again when it's somewhat cooler and put in 3 more quality spent flights.

Some fields aren't always great with the sun, along with other variables, so I can understand why some people can't practice exactly how I do.

Finally, I get my dad to call for me b/c he can see the big picture when I'm flying - such as constant radii, centering, etc. I recommend getting someone to call for you as much as you can, even if they can't coach you on the technical things. If you are fortunate enough to have someone who can coach you, one on one discussions are the best for understanding 'how to fly a maneuver'. Sometimes it's hard to translate words into how to fly b/c it's such an intricate process.

I think all the replies on here have been great...keep it up everyone! Burn fuel efficiently!

JRW 05-22-2003 02:59 PM

Pattern practice help
 
Pete -
Best of luck to you this summer with the Team Trials! What planes are you taking with you?

Jim W.

sm00thflyer 05-27-2003 12:17 AM

Pattern practice help
 
thanks jim...i've got 2 fully finished partners on order from PL Prod...the first one was suppose to come april 1st and the second may 15th, but neither has come :( so i'm gonna be flying a Phenom. it's a new design from a couple of guys in winston-salem, NC...it flys very well


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:15 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.