JR Tx
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: houma,
LA
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
JR Tx
I just purchased a JR XP662 used and I was wondering if I would have to send the Tx in to get the channel changed or can I just change it my self?
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Pasadena,
MD
Posts: 1,050
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JR Tx
ORIGINAL: iraiam
Yes, you should send it in for the channel change and re-tune, FCC regulations prohibit schanging crystals in 72MHZ fm transmitters.
Yes, you should send it in for the channel change and re-tune, FCC regulations prohibit schanging crystals in 72MHZ fm transmitters.
I've seen some debate about that. The FCC reg states something to the effect of changing the frequency not the channel. So there are a lot of folk that agree that as long as you stay in the 72mhz range, you can change the channel. I tend to agree, why else would they sell the crystal's freely at your LHS without any issue? I'ts a simple $10 change.
Skarn
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lakewood, CO
Posts: 152
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JR Tx
ORIGINAL: Skarn
I've seen some debate about that. The FCC reg states something to the effect of changing the frequency not the channel. So there are a lot of folk that agree that as long as you stay in the 72mhz range, you can change the channel. I tend to agree, why else would they sell the crystal's freely at your LHS without any issue? I'ts a simple $10 change.
Skarn
ORIGINAL: iraiam
Yes, you should send it in for the channel change and re-tune, FCC regulations prohibit schanging crystals in 72MHZ fm transmitters.
Yes, you should send it in for the channel change and re-tune, FCC regulations prohibit schanging crystals in 72MHZ fm transmitters.
I've seen some debate about that. The FCC reg states something to the effect of changing the frequency not the channel. So there are a lot of folk that agree that as long as you stay in the 72mhz range, you can change the channel. I tend to agree, why else would they sell the crystal's freely at your LHS without any issue? I'ts a simple $10 change.
Skarn
And yes I have seen people swap transmitter crystals without regard to the FCC rules but I'm not risking any of my models like that. besides I am a licensed radio amatuer for 20 years and I know a thing or two about TX.
If you really need to operate on different channels all the time I would reccomend getting a systhesized radio, XP7202 or comparable, it will operate on any channel and you don't have to change any crystals. or spread spectrum no worry about channels there either.
This is how it works, the board that the crystal plugs into in the back of the radio has some adjustable RF coils on it, those are adjusted to get the proper RF output levels on that frequency, when the frequency (channel) is changed, the RF power level will drop. the farther away from the "tuned" frequecy you get the more it will drop. That is why FCC regs. say that it needs to be done by an authorized technician.
the technician will change the crystal and adjust it for the proper RF output levels and bandwidth. these are narrow band TX's
Also if you look at the frequency list in the back of your manual you will see how close the channels are to each other, it's in everyones best interest to use a properly tuned TX!
Some time ago at the field there was a flyer who was on the same channel as me, he swapped out his TX and RX crystal and moved 1 channel away, I still didn't fly until that transmitter was in a case. transmitters that are not tuned properly, will not have the proper bandwidth and RF power. and I'm not flying my model while there is an out of tune narrow band TX just 1 channel away.
#6
RE: JR Tx
ORIGINAL: Skarn
I've seen some debate about that. The FCC reg states something to the effect of changing the frequency not the channel. So there are a lot of folk that agree that as long as you stay in the 72mhz range, you can change the channel. I tend to agree, why else would they sell the crystal's freely at your LHS without any issue? I'ts a simple $10 change.
Skarn
ORIGINAL: iraiam
Yes, you should send it in for the channel change and re-tune, FCC regulations prohibit schanging crystals in 72MHZ fm transmitters.
Yes, you should send it in for the channel change and re-tune, FCC regulations prohibit schanging crystals in 72MHZ fm transmitters.
I've seen some debate about that. The FCC reg states something to the effect of changing the frequency not the channel. So there are a lot of folk that agree that as long as you stay in the 72mhz range, you can change the channel. I tend to agree, why else would they sell the crystal's freely at your LHS without any issue? I'ts a simple $10 change.
Skarn
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/fb.asp?m=4804374
BAX is the Futaba rep in the US. I've seen similar comments from Danny who is the JR rep.
#7
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Pasadena,
MD
Posts: 1,050
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JR Tx
Thanks all for the enlightenment! I did know that changing a channel is actually changing the frequency, but I didn't realize it was illegal! I guess a lot of the guys at RC clubs don't realize it either!
Skarn
Skarn
#10
Senior Member
My Feedback: (16)
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Zephyrhills,
FL
Posts: 193
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JR Tx
OK, then why am I able to change my JR 9303 from a fixed frequency module to a synthesized module and change frequencies to anything I want? If what you guys say is true (technically, it probably is by law) then JR is breaking the law by selling individual TX crystals. You can't buy TX crystals from Airtronics.
I tend to think this is a bunch of government gobbldygook.
I tend to think this is a bunch of government gobbldygook.
#11
Senior Member
My Feedback: (3)
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Bloomington,
MN
Posts: 3,282
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JR Tx
ORIGINAL: Eplane65
OK, then why am I able to change my JR 9303 from a fixed frequency module to a synthesized module and change frequencies to anything I want?
OK, then why am I able to change my JR 9303 from a fixed frequency module to a synthesized module and change frequencies to anything I want?
I tend to think this is a bunch of government gobbldygook.
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Slough, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 1,415
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JR Tx
I do believe that the regulations state that you cannot change a frequency determining component. A crystal is a freq. determing component, however a synth unit has a FIXED reference inside and all you are adjusting is a variable division ratio. This is NOT a freq. determing component and hence you are allowed to change it.
I would imagine that the crystals being sold across there are for a 1 for 1 replacement ie if you are using a channel 63 Tx Xtal, then you can legally replace it with a channel 63 Tx Xtal ( Crystals do age and can go faulty)
I would imagine that the crystals being sold across there are for a 1 for 1 replacement ie if you are using a channel 63 Tx Xtal, then you can legally replace it with a channel 63 Tx Xtal ( Crystals do age and can go faulty)
#13
RE: JR Tx
ORIGINAL: Mac_Man_UK
I do believe that the regulations state that you cannot change a frequency determining component. A crystal is a freq. determing component, however a synth unit has a FIXED reference inside and all you are adjusting is a variable division ratio. This is NOT a freq. determing component and hence you are allowed to change it.
I would imagine that the crystals being sold across there are for a 1 for 1 replacement ie if you are using a channel 63 Tx Xtal, then you can legally replace it with a channel 63 Tx Xtal ( Crystals do age and can go faulty)
I do believe that the regulations state that you cannot change a frequency determining component. A crystal is a freq. determing component, however a synth unit has a FIXED reference inside and all you are adjusting is a variable division ratio. This is NOT a freq. determing component and hence you are allowed to change it.
I would imagine that the crystals being sold across there are for a 1 for 1 replacement ie if you are using a channel 63 Tx Xtal, then you can legally replace it with a channel 63 Tx Xtal ( Crystals do age and can go faulty)
No you can not remove a Ch 63 crystal and replace with another Ch 63 crystal. No 2 crystals are identical. These are basically just chunks of precision cut rock and there is only just so much one can do to guarantee accuracy. There is still a tolerance that must be tuned for.
The crystal are sold because the radios are sold worldwide where the same laws may not apply and also so that you may purchase the part and take it to you radio shop if you desire a change.
Please do yourself and others a favor and stop trying to find a way to avoid the laws and just follow them. (Not directed at any particular person)
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lakewood, CO
Posts: 152
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: JR Tx
ORIGINAL: Eplane65
OK, then why am I able to change my JR 9303 from a fixed frequency module to a synthesized module and change frequencies to anything I want? If what you guys say is true (technically, it probably is by law) then JR is breaking the law by selling individual TX crystals. You can't buy TX crystals from Airtronics.
I tend to think this is a bunch of government gobbldygook.
OK, then why am I able to change my JR 9303 from a fixed frequency module to a synthesized module and change frequencies to anything I want? If what you guys say is true (technically, it probably is by law) then JR is breaking the law by selling individual TX crystals. You can't buy TX crystals from Airtronics.
I tend to think this is a bunch of government gobbldygook.
government gobbldygook, maybe but...
There are commercial users between the frequencies that we use who pay big money for a licence to operate, go ahead and interfere with one of those with a improperly tuned TX and see what happens.
#15
RE: JR Tx
ORIGINAL: iraiam
Synthesized modules have no crystals, thus, no need to tune for variance in crystals. JR is not breaking the law by selling TX crystals and is just ridiculous to state they are. It's what the end user does with that crystal that makes it legal or illegal, just like any other product.
government gobbldygook, maybe but...
There are commercial users between the frequencies that we use who pay big money for a licence to operate, go ahead and interfere with one of those with a improperly tuned TX and see what happens.
ORIGINAL: Eplane65
OK, then why am I able to change my JR 9303 from a fixed frequency module to a synthesized module and change frequencies to anything I want? If what you guys say is true (technically, it probably is by law) then JR is breaking the law by selling individual TX crystals. You can't buy TX crystals from Airtronics.
I tend to think this is a bunch of government gobbldygook.
OK, then why am I able to change my JR 9303 from a fixed frequency module to a synthesized module and change frequencies to anything I want? If what you guys say is true (technically, it probably is by law) then JR is breaking the law by selling individual TX crystals. You can't buy TX crystals from Airtronics.
I tend to think this is a bunch of government gobbldygook.
government gobbldygook, maybe but...
There are commercial users between the frequencies that we use who pay big money for a licence to operate, go ahead and interfere with one of those with a improperly tuned TX and see what happens.
Gun dealers sell guns. They don't know if you are buying it to protect yourself or to rob a bank or commit murder. Don't blame the dealer - blame the end user.
Please - no comments from anti-gun nuts. I don't want to hear it.