RCU Forums

RCU Forums (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/)
-   RC Radios, Transmitters, Receivers, Servos, gyros (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/rc-radios-transmitters-receivers-servos-gyros-157/)
-   -   Superior JR 11X Range Test results (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/rc-radios-transmitters-receivers-servos-gyros-157/10662324-superior-jr-11x-range-test-results.html)

Rob2160 08-09-2011 04:15 AM

Superior JR 11X Range Test results
 


Just my findings onRangetesting a JR 11X.

Please note this is not in any way a criticism of Futaba FASST or Spektrum, I have radios from both of these companies and they have all worked brilliantly and flawlessly for over 12 months and Thousands of flights..I have range tested Futaba and Spektrum equipment with great results that have inspired complete confidence in its use.. and a 100% reliability record confirms this.

But the 11X is something ELSE!...</p>

I walk range test every new TX / RX or combo.. and any new installation in a Heli or Fixed wing..</p>

Futaba FASST, Spektrum DSM2 / DSMX and JR DSMX all get well over 2000 meters clear line of sight (I don't bother checking further than that anymore..)</p>

The reason for my range tests are not to test 2.4Ghz, but simply to test that any new TX / RX are actually not faulty out of the box before I fly with them...</p>

(I picked up a faulty Spek RX this way and binned it without ever using it, thereby preventing a possible loss of a Helicopter)</p>

But I digress..</p>

Anyway, I also have a "Short version" of my range test, where I place the TX in my sunken loungeroom and walk around a large oval outside our house.</p>

At the far extreme of the oval I am approximately 500 meters from the TX which is behind 3 brick walls and about 30 trees..</p>

My Futaba FASST does not have reception at this point.. Neither does my Spektrum DX6i / DX8 with AR6200 and AR8000 combos...</p>

The JR11X on the other hand has GREAT reception at that point with an AR8000 and also with an E-Flite Ultra Micro Beast.</p>

These three videos confirm it..</p>

Vid 1 - when I first bought the radio.. -</p>

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Gl6e25m9WU</p>

Vid 2. Tonight with the UMX Beast (I only did another range test because I had opened the TX to adjust the spring tension on the sticks)</p>

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdT2lUY57Kk</p>

Vid 3 Tonight Part 2.</p>

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PcdmIvLWrig</p>

A.T. 08-09-2011 01:08 PM

RE: Superior JR 11X Range Test results
 


ORIGINAL: Rob2160 <span style="font-size: smaller">Just my findings onRangetesting a JR 11X. Please note this is not in any way a criticism of Futaba FASST or Spektrum, I have radios from both of these companies and they have all worked brilliantly and flawlessly for over 12 months and Thousands of flights..I have range tested Futaba and Spektrum equipment with great results that have inspired complete confidence in its use.. and a 100% reliability record confirms this.
But the 11X is something ELSE!.. I walk range test every new TX / RX or combo.. and any new installation in a Heli or Fixed wing.. Futaba FASST, Spektrum DSM2 / DSMX and JR DSMX all get well over 2000 meters clear line of sight (I don't bother checking further than that anymore.. The reason for my range tests are not to test 2.4Ghz, but simply to test that any new TX / RX are actually not faulty out of the box before I fly with them...(I picked up a faulty Spek RX this way and binned it without ever using it, thereby preventing a possible loss of a Helicopter)But I digress. Anyway, I also have a "Short version" of my range test, where I place the TX in my sunken loungeroom and walk around a large oval outside our house.At the far extreme of the oval I am approximately 500 meters from the TX which is behind 3 brick walls and about 30 trees. My Futaba FASST does not have reception at this point.. Neither does my Spektrum DX6i / DX8 with AR6200 and AR8000 combos.. The JR11X on the other hand has GREAT reception at that point with an AR8000 and also with an E-Flite Ultra Micro Beast. These three videos confirm it..Vid 1 - when I first bought the radio.. -Vid 2. Tonight with the UMX Beast (I only did another range test because I had opened the TX to adjust the spring tension on the sticks)Vid 3 Tonight Part 2</span>.
Transmitters are limited to the actual RF output permitted and so all generally have, within lineof sight,equal range.
The receiver is themain limiting factor, except with 2.4Ghz the type of signal generated has animpact, and during range tests, the power down RF level.
When comparing range tests, the power down output should be verified to be all 10% of full power or make allowancesaccordingly.
<span style="font-size: smaller">AFHSS by Hitec has proven to be the least effected by obstacles.

</span>Good reading:
Range Test - Comparative Range Test data on multiple systems **
note that the JR/Spektrum systems, used in this test, has twice the TXRFoutput permitted in other countries so the result must be downgraded accordingly when read by those in Uk, Europe &amp;Asia etc.
<a add_date="1282300850" last_modified="1290289614" last_visit="1290289614" href="http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showpost.php?p=15836998&amp;postcount=2">Range of Transmitter and Receiver
</a>Receiver - Operating Range
Receiver - Operating Range - Full vs ParkFlyer vs Backyard.
Range Problem
<span style="color: #000000">and especially for those still using 27&lt;75mhz.
</span>Range Problem - Transmitter Antenna cleaning
<dl> <dt><span style="font-size: x-small">1. </span><font color="#22229c">2.2KM Rx was inside the car</font>
<span style="font-size: smaller">"Today I did a car ground range test. Full power, not range check dedicated mode. Very impressed ! 2.2km ground level !!!
And must stop the test because of the field iregularities, even if we choosed a very flat area, the car passed behind a small (2-3m) hill
that blocked the signal completelly. I guess that this system can do more than 4km in the air ! I wrote system and not Aurora,
because was a module mounted on a T9C.
Did I mentioned that the Rx was inside the car, placed in the back, having direct vision to the transmitter via the rear window? "

</span><span style="font-size: x-small">2. An interesting Video of a Heli model with full telemetry, sitting in ground effect and demonstrating a range of 4/10th's of a mile
<span style="font-size: smaller">or about 2,112 feet</span>. Keep in mind this is with many large obstacles in the way! The 2.4GHz scenario has changed somewhat?
</span><font color="#22229c">Range test using Segway &amp; GPS</font>

<font color="#22229c" size="1">AFHSS - Power Down for Range Check is 1mw</font><font size="1"> - tested to at least 1/4 mile.</font>

and much more under
"Receiver Operating Range, Range Test &amp; Range Problem Solving" at
<font color="#22229c">Alan's Hobby, Model &amp; RC FAQ Web Links</font> <!an>

Alan T.
</dt></dl>

fizzwater2 08-09-2011 01:42 PM

RE: Superior JR 11X Range Test results
 
at 2000 meters I would assume one isn't using the "power down" range test mode. To the original poster - is that a correct assumption?

Does anyone have the details on just how far down the power is on each brand's range test mode?

Also - if you're doing comparisons between brands on the power down mode, don't forget that the effective range is a square root function of the power ratio- not linear. For example, 2 times the power will only give you equivalent signal strength at 1.414x the distance. It takes 4X power to double the distance.


Rob2160 08-10-2011 02:07 AM

RE: Superior JR 11X Range Test results
 


ORIGINAL: fizzwater2

at 2000 meters I would assume one isn't using the "power down" range test mode. To the original poster - is that a correct assumption?

Does anyone have the details on just how far down the power is on each brand's range test mode?

Also - if you're doing comparisons between brands on the power down mode, don't forget that the effective range is a square root function of the power ratio- not linear. For example, 2 times the power will only give you equivalent signal strength at 1.414x the distance. It takes 4X power to double the distance.


These range checks are in full power not power down mode.

I got much more than 2000 meters with 2.4Ghz when I tested to extreme ranges.. but I will never fly further than 500 meters in any conceivable situtation so if it still works at 2000 meters that is good enough for me..

Here are my very first range tests when I switched to 2.4. I was just curiious what range they would provide and was very impressed...


http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_98...tm.htm#9829320

Rob2160 08-10-2011 02:09 AM

RE: Superior JR 11X Range Test results
 


ORIGINAL: A.T.

Transmitters are limited to the actual RF output permitted and so all generally have, within lineof sight,equal range.
The receiver is themain limiting factor, except with 2.4Ghz the type of signal generated has animpact, and during range tests, the power down RF level.
When comparing range tests, the power down output should be verified to be all 10% of full power or make allowancesaccordingly.
<span style="font-size: smaller">AFHSS by Hitec has proven to be the least effected by obstacles.

</span>Good reading:
Range Test - Comparative Range Test data on multiple systems **
note that the JR/Spektrum systems, used in this test, has twice the TXRFoutput permitted in other countries so the result must be downgraded accordingly when read by those in Uk, Europe &amp;Asia etc.
<a add_date="1282300850" last_modified="1290289614" last_visit="1290289614" href="http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showpost.php?p=15836998&amp;postcount=2">Range of Transmitter and Receiver
</a>Receiver - Operating Range
Receiver - Operating Range - Full vs ParkFlyer vs Backyard.
Range Problem
<span style="color: #000000">and especially for those still using 27&lt;75mhz.
</span>Range Problem - Transmitter Antenna cleaning
<dl> <dt><span style="font-size: x-small">1. Aurora 9ch Power Down for Range Check is 1mw - tested to at least 1/4 mile.
</span><font color="#22229c">2.2KM Rx was inside the car</font>
<span style="font-size: smaller">"Today I did a car ground range test. Full power, not range check dedicated mode. Very impressed ! 2.2km ground level !!!
And must stop the test because of the field iregularities, even if we choosed a very flat area, the car passed behind a small (2-3m) hill
that blocked the signal completelly. I guess that this system can do more than 4km in the air ! I wrote system and not Aurora,
because was a module mounted on a T9C.
Did I mentioned that the Rx was inside the car, placed in the back, having direct vision to the transmitter via the rear window? "

</span><span style="font-size: x-small">2. An interesting Video of a Heli model with full telemetry, sitting in ground effect and demonstrating a range of 4/10th's of a mile
<span style="font-size: smaller">or about 2,112 feet</span>. Keep in mind this is with many large obstacles in the way! The 2.4GHz scenario has changed somewhat?
</span><font color="#22229c">Range test using Segway &amp; GPS</font>

<font color="#22229c" size="1">AFHSS - Power Down for Range Check is 1mw</font><font size="1"> - tested to at least 1/4 mile.</font>

and much more under
"Receiver Operating Range, Range Test &amp; Range Problem Solving" at
<font color="#22229c">Alan's Hobby, Model &amp; RC FAQ Web Links</font> <!an>

Alan T.
</dt></dl>
Thanks for the great info Alan, I look forward to reading those links shortly..


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:25 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.