retracts
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: BrisbaneQLD, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 648
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

Assuming mechanical retracts, you can use a standard high torque servo but you shouldn't. Normal servos have slightly less than 180 degrees of rotation, retract servos have slightly more. Mechanical retracts need that extra so they get full travel and lock the gear into place without the servo trying to move past its end stops. Retract servos also only have two positions, they're not proportional so they only travel from one end stop to the other and back (which is why they're also called "bang bang servos"). This works better with a radio's retract switch, since they sometimes don't have adjustable end points on that channel. Besides all that, by the time you buy a standard servo with enough torque to guarantee that the retracts won't overload the servo you might as well buy a retract one.
#7
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: minneapolis,
MN
Posts: 645
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

ORIGINAL: weldercde
I just bought my first warbird. can i use regular servos on my retracts or do i use special servos thanks
I just bought my first warbird. can i use regular servos on my retracts or do i use special servos thanks
Of my warbirds that have mechanical retracts, my Hanger9 Corsair instructions called for a single high torque retract servo and it definitely needed it especially after I added Robostruts and Robart wheels. Those rotating retracts take a lot of force to move. My World Models Zero 60 instructions called for a single standard servo to move both gear and that would have been enough to operate them because the stock gear is shorter than scale length and the the stock wheels are smaller than scale, light weight, foam. However, when I lengthened the gear to the proper scale length by adding Robostruts and adding larger wheels that were also heavier, I found that a single standard servo wouldn't retract the heavier setup. So, I used two standard servos instead (a single standard servo for each retract) and that has worked great.
#9

My Feedback: (2)

I use the JR791 on my H9 P-40 and Hellcat. Tried the hitec plastic gear hs75 and it just kept stripping the gears. Never new when it would work. The JR791 is metal geared and lots more torque. But I think in the future I will be using the eflight electrics. I have them on my H9 B-25 and they seem to hold up pretty good. Not been in the air yet but during ground run ups they hold up fine.
Edwin
Edwin
#10

Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: manchester, AE, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 1,795
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

the best retract request is a can of worms, want it simple? euorkits, never fail, cheap as chips, want the best? well, jurys out on that one, it depends on what you want to spend, if mechanicals are what you are after, then it would be favorable to fit a 2nd battery pack for the retracts servo, and modify a Y lead for them. if the legs stall going into the well, then the single battery pack will drain quicker than you can say, IVE LOST IT, there will be those that detract from this, but in 40 years experiance, i heard the detractors, and seen the same picking the bits up,
#12

My Feedback: (5)
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Little Elm,
TX
Posts: 1,728
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

The better retracts would be:
For air operated use either Spring Air or the Robarts that are air up/spring down, and use the version that takes 7/16 oleo struts directly into a hole in the retract body.
For electric use the magnum rc electric, which are now made in France I believe. These were originally the Lado electric retracts. If you can get oleos to fit them I would also get 7/16 Robart oleos.
But if you can get them to fit your plane the very best are made by Sierra Giant Scale in Ohio. They cost more but are very well made. Sierra retracts usally come with oleo struts included.
Good Luck
Ed
For air operated use either Spring Air or the Robarts that are air up/spring down, and use the version that takes 7/16 oleo struts directly into a hole in the retract body.
For electric use the magnum rc electric, which are now made in France I believe. These were originally the Lado electric retracts. If you can get oleos to fit them I would also get 7/16 Robart oleos.
But if you can get them to fit your plane the very best are made by Sierra Giant Scale in Ohio. They cost more but are very well made. Sierra retracts usally come with oleo struts included.
Good Luck
Ed
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: JeddahWestern, SAUDI ARABIA
Posts: 102
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts

Thanks guys. JR 791 should do the job for now as i am within the 60 size class. My only concern at this point is if the retracts can handle the weight of my zero? i'll be preparing her tonight for her maiden tomorrow. Thinking of shifting my battery to the firewall to level her out, rather than adding another 120 grams....
Wish me luck!
Taimoor