flight packs vs. complete systems?
#1
Thread Starter

My Feedback: (3)
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,015
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pointe Claire,
QC, CANADA
OK, so I'm shopping for a flight pack, so I can have more than three planes at the feild...
And I'm baffled by marketing...
Why does a Fut. flight pack cost $179Canadian while a complete 4 channel 'Skysport' cost $199?!?!?
Is a Tx (with battery, gimbals, antenna, etc, etc etc..) really only $20?!
I guess I'll have the buddy box, and a box to rig into a flight sim soon!!
And I'm baffled by marketing...
Why does a Fut. flight pack cost $179Canadian while a complete 4 channel 'Skysport' cost $199?!?!?
Is a Tx (with battery, gimbals, antenna, etc, etc etc..) really only $20?!
I guess I'll have the buddy box, and a box to rig into a flight sim soon!!
#2
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 925
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: OKC, OK
The flight packs are more marketed toward those people that have computer radios with 6+ model memory and cost a good bit more than just a flight pack would. It is hard to convince yourself that you should buy just a flight pack when you are buying it for a radio that is only 20 bucks more, but once you have that 4/5/6 hundred (or more) dollar radio, you won't think that the flight pack is such a bad deal anymore.
#3
Thread Starter

My Feedback: (3)
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,015
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pointe Claire,
QC, CANADA
Don't get me wrong, I already have the 6XA. Only reason I bought it was for the 6 channels, the the 6 model memory, computer mixing, etc. etc... and that fact that I wouldn't need to buy new one...
But you'de figure that the complete 4 ch Tx would be the most expencive part to manufacture. So, in removing it , that would lower the price for just aflight pack conciderably...
The only realy difference between a 'Skysport' 4ch system and a typical flight pack is just that, the included Tx...
But you'de figure that the complete 4 ch Tx would be the most expencive part to manufacture. So, in removing it , that would lower the price for just aflight pack conciderably...
The only realy difference between a 'Skysport' 4ch system and a typical flight pack is just that, the included Tx...
#4
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NW of Chicago,
IL
It is also depends on servos. Usually cheaper radios comes with cheaper servos.
4 channels SkySport cost less, but you can "set" only 1 plane with this radio (trim adjustments, etc.). More expensive (computerized) radios have memory for 6 or more planes. Now, what is better - having 6 planes and 6 radios, or 6 planes and 1 radio (plus flight packs)?
6 SkySports @ $200 is $1200.
1 6XAS (with "flight pack included" ) - $230 plus 5 flight packs @ $120 each totals $830...
Not to mention "headache" (kinda) of managing 6 transmitters.
Consider also, that for 3rd or 4th plane 4 channels might be not enough...
Finally, to simplify your life try to add prices of the components for one flight pack if you buy them separately.
4 channels SkySport cost less, but you can "set" only 1 plane with this radio (trim adjustments, etc.). More expensive (computerized) radios have memory for 6 or more planes. Now, what is better - having 6 planes and 6 radios, or 6 planes and 1 radio (plus flight packs)?
6 SkySports @ $200 is $1200.
1 6XAS (with "flight pack included" ) - $230 plus 5 flight packs @ $120 each totals $830...
Not to mention "headache" (kinda) of managing 6 transmitters.
Consider also, that for 3rd or 4th plane 4 channels might be not enough...
Finally, to simplify your life try to add prices of the components for one flight pack if you buy them separately.
#5
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 993
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Washington,
DC
Is a Tx (with battery, gimbals, antenna, etc, etc etc..) really only $20?!
#6
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 245
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Montreal,
QC, CANADA
6 SkySports @ $200 is $1200.
1 6XAS (with "flight pack included" ) - $230 plus 5 flight packs @ $120 each totals $830...
1 6XAS (with "flight pack included" ) - $230 plus 5 flight packs @ $120 each totals $830...
1 6XAS + 5 flight packs = 830$, includes
1 computer radio (6 channels)
6 receivers
1 TX battery
6 RX batteries
1 sets of crystals
1 overnight charger
24 servos (bb 3004)
1 servo tray
6 switch harnesses
1 servo extension wire (6")
5 servo extension wires (9")
1 6xas + 5 skysports: = 975$, includes
1 computer radio (6 channels)
5 four-channel radios
6 receivers
6 TX batteries
6 RX batteries
6 sets of crystals
6 overnight chargers
24 servos (bb 3004)
6 servo trays
6 switch harnesses
1 servo extension wire (6")
The difference: 145$ for 5 tx batteries, 5 sets of crystals, 5 overnight, and 5 servo trays more (though you're missing 5 servo extension wires)!
I'm not considering the extra TXs, but think about this, you can sell the 5 skysports on ebay as buddy boxes for 10$ each and get back 50$.
Tell me why anyone bothers with buying Flight packs again?
Here's another even simpler way of looking at it:
Skysport = 150$
Flight Pack + Crystal set = 150$
#7

My Feedback: (2)
I bother with flight packs because I get better ball bearing servo's. I use Hitec's HS-425 double ball bearing servo with RX3800 7 channel receiver and 600MAH battery pack and switch set. I definitely do not need more 4 channel transmitters. All this cost $99.00 US
John
John
#8

My Feedback: (11)
I also just order the rec and servos I need because I use better servos and usually can't get them with a package. If you are just getting the basics, package deals are great, but like you say, the transmitter fits in there for just a few bucks more. Get it and sell it on ebay or in a forum. Just shows how much they make on their flight packs.
#9
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 245
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Montreal,
QC, CANADA
I bother with flight packs because I get better ball bearing servo's
#10
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NW of Chicago,
IL
I did not know if this is legal to use full transmitter as a buddy box. Also, if somebody buying cheaper radio for a cheaper plane - the person would like to have set of servos, receiver and batteries too, isn't it?
#11

My Feedback: (2)
SaviCatses,
Minor point but Hitec HS-425's are dual ball bearing, while Futaba 3004 are top ball bearing only.
ekrcflyer ,
Perfectly legal to use a full transmitter as a buddy box. If using Futaba transmitters with a Futaba trainer cord the "Buddy" doesn't transmit. Same holds true if you use Jr's to Jr's etc. If using Futaba to Hitec use the Hitec cable, otherwise the Hitec will transmit. If using Hitec to Futaba use the Futaba cable. 1st mentioned transmitter is the "Master" that actually transmits. In any case you can always pull the crystal on the "Buddy".
John
Minor point but Hitec HS-425's are dual ball bearing, while Futaba 3004 are top ball bearing only.
ekrcflyer ,
Perfectly legal to use a full transmitter as a buddy box. If using Futaba transmitters with a Futaba trainer cord the "Buddy" doesn't transmit. Same holds true if you use Jr's to Jr's etc. If using Futaba to Hitec use the Hitec cable, otherwise the Hitec will transmit. If using Hitec to Futaba use the Futaba cable. 1st mentioned transmitter is the "Master" that actually transmits. In any case you can always pull the crystal on the "Buddy".
John
#12
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NW of Chicago,
IL
Thanks John.
It's a good piece of information about using full box as a buddy box, except for the fact that pulling crystal will not prevent radio from “transmitting”. "Real" buddy boxes don't have a crystal AND final transmitting module (amplifier).
It's a good piece of information about using full box as a buddy box, except for the fact that pulling crystal will not prevent radio from “transmitting”. "Real" buddy boxes don't have a crystal AND final transmitting module (amplifier).
#13

My Feedback: (2)
Pulling a crystal will prevent a transmitter from transmitting. The RF section or "Final" will not be modulated, hence no transmission.
As far as using "Real" buddy boxes, I use my 4 channel Hitec to fly my Rascal with. When my brother-in-law whom I'm training wants to fly, I use my Futaba 6XAS. The Rascal is on memory 3 and I can set the rates on low. He uses the Futaba as a low rate buddy box. Try setting low rates on your "Real" buddy box. When we are through I can then use the Futaba to fly my Four Star.
Sometimes flexibility wins. Plus I haven't spent money on a box I can only use for one purpose.
Later,
John
As far as using "Real" buddy boxes, I use my 4 channel Hitec to fly my Rascal with. When my brother-in-law whom I'm training wants to fly, I use my Futaba 6XAS. The Rascal is on memory 3 and I can set the rates on low. He uses the Futaba as a low rate buddy box. Try setting low rates on your "Real" buddy box. When we are through I can then use the Futaba to fly my Four Star.
Sometimes flexibility wins. Plus I haven't spent money on a box I can only use for one purpose.

Later,
John



