Contra Rotating Propeller Drive for f3a 2m Pattern Planes
#1201
Yes they do!
I see it's Ulsamer's model so he should know a thing or two about props. What's very interesting is the pitch difference between the front and rear it looks like 22" rear and 14" or maybe 17" front.
Malcolm
I see it's Ulsamer's model so he should know a thing or two about props. What's very interesting is the pitch difference between the front and rear it looks like 22" rear and 14" or maybe 17" front.
Malcolm
#1204
Steve
#1205
Thread Starter
We have three sponsored pilots at the Worlds, Marcus Zeiner (AUSTRIA), Philip Rannetshauser (GER), and Joseph Sczur (USA).
I believe that Philip is also using a prototype Pletenburg motor as well with one of his Contras.
Brenner ...
I believe that Philip is also using a prototype Pletenburg motor as well with one of his Contras.
Brenner ...
Last edited by Brenner; 08-21-2013 at 07:33 PM.
#1208
Jim O
#1209
My Feedback: (1)
Hi,
Maybe mentioned before but Sebart has info on their homepage on new contra drive unit (I have not seen info on that before):
http://www.sebart.it/img-F3A/coaxial...ial-drive.html
/Bo
Maybe mentioned before but Sebart has info on their homepage on new contra drive unit (I have not seen info on that before):
http://www.sebart.it/img-F3A/coaxial...ial-drive.html
/Bo
#1211
Hi Doug,
Yes and no .
It depends on what props you use.
If the pitch is the same on both it's at it's worst.
With a 2" difference ,front less than rear, it changes completely.
There is still a rhythm but it is very akin to a flat four boxer engine type sound - different but quite pleasing.
Different relative diameters also play a role.
In this part of the world we all use 18" front and 20" rear - would not change the sound if you paid us.
Brian
Yes and no .
It depends on what props you use.
If the pitch is the same on both it's at it's worst.
With a 2" difference ,front less than rear, it changes completely.
There is still a rhythm but it is very akin to a flat four boxer engine type sound - different but quite pleasing.
Different relative diameters also play a role.
In this part of the world we all use 18" front and 20" rear - would not change the sound if you paid us.
Brian
#1212
My Feedback: (1)
I heard Brenners Contra drives in July this summer at a competition, one in a Wind S Pro (from Finland) with carbon props and one in an Angels Shadow (from Denmark) with APC props and it was clearly a "different" sound compared to single prop F3A planes. Not ugly sound but not pleasing sound to the ear either I would say. It was some wof-wof-wof sound in the air. Hard to describe and I have never heard any similar.
/Bo
/Bo
#1214
Thread Starter
A new piece of information;
Philip Rannetshauser flew a Contra powered Axiome to a 2nd place (junior..) finish at the Worlds in SA using our latest APC clone carbon fiber props, and Christian Rannetshauser, German team manager is reporting that Philip's setup was measuring 88 db at the official sound check before each flight. Christian says that these measurements were at maximum power, and the throttle curve wasn't ATVed back.
These props have similar diameter and pitch to the APC Contra props, except that the airfoil is thicker in the inside portion of the blade, and the blades are narrower as well. Also, they only weigh 50g each. They are also noticeably quieter in the air compared with our first generation props, and there is no syncopating rhythm sound either.
These props also perform well too. The performance is similar to a 22x22 rear with a 22x20 front, except that I think the vertical performance is actually better. However, this is with a low drag Wind S Pro. The performance will obviously change with different airframes.
Brenner ...
Philip Rannetshauser flew a Contra powered Axiome to a 2nd place (junior..) finish at the Worlds in SA using our latest APC clone carbon fiber props, and Christian Rannetshauser, German team manager is reporting that Philip's setup was measuring 88 db at the official sound check before each flight. Christian says that these measurements were at maximum power, and the throttle curve wasn't ATVed back.
These props have similar diameter and pitch to the APC Contra props, except that the airfoil is thicker in the inside portion of the blade, and the blades are narrower as well. Also, they only weigh 50g each. They are also noticeably quieter in the air compared with our first generation props, and there is no syncopating rhythm sound either.
These props also perform well too. The performance is similar to a 22x22 rear with a 22x20 front, except that I think the vertical performance is actually better. However, this is with a low drag Wind S Pro. The performance will obviously change with different airframes.
Brenner ...
Last edited by Brenner; 09-03-2013 at 06:34 PM.
#1218
My Feedback: (11)
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Tracy,
CA
Posts: 2,080
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If these are the props you flew at the nats, i was impressed with the speed and power. One thing i hadn't been fully impressed with before. Nice addition for those who do want more speed. Especially in the wind.
Chris
Chris
#1221
Thread Starter
Hey Peter,
We are shipping these props right now, but currently we are struggling a little to keep up with demand. Consequently there's about a two week lead time for delivery.
Brenner ...
We are shipping these props right now, but currently we are struggling a little to keep up with demand. Consequently there's about a two week lead time for delivery.
Brenner ...
#1222
I have to say the contra`s did great in the winds and the sound was much better in the air.
looking forward to getting the new plane done, and testing mine. If Scott lets me fly it
Bryan
looking forward to getting the new plane done, and testing mine. If Scott lets me fly it
Bryan
#1223
A new piece of information;
Philip Rannetshauser flew a Contra powered Axiome to a 2nd place (junior..) finish at the Worlds in SA using our latest APC clone carbon fiber props, and Christian Rannetshauser, German team manager is reporting that Philip's setup was measuring 88 db at the official sound check before each flight. Christian says that these measurements were at maximum power, and the throttle curve wasn't ATVed back.
These props have similar diameter and pitch to the APC Contra props, except that the airfoil is thicker in the inside portion of the blade, and the blades are narrower as well. Also, they only weigh 50g each. They are also noticeably quieter in the air compared with our first generation props, and there is no syncopating rhythm sound either.
These props also perform well too. The performance is similar to a 22x22 rear with a 22x20 front, except that I think the vertical performance is actually better. However, this is with a low drag Wind S Pro. The performance will obviously change with different airframes.
Brenner ...
Philip Rannetshauser flew a Contra powered Axiome to a 2nd place (junior..) finish at the Worlds in SA using our latest APC clone carbon fiber props, and Christian Rannetshauser, German team manager is reporting that Philip's setup was measuring 88 db at the official sound check before each flight. Christian says that these measurements were at maximum power, and the throttle curve wasn't ATVed back.
These props have similar diameter and pitch to the APC Contra props, except that the airfoil is thicker in the inside portion of the blade, and the blades are narrower as well. Also, they only weigh 50g each. They are also noticeably quieter in the air compared with our first generation props, and there is no syncopating rhythm sound either.
These props also perform well too. The performance is similar to a 22x22 rear with a 22x20 front, except that I think the vertical performance is actually better. However, this is with a low drag Wind S Pro. The performance will obviously change with different airframes.
Brenner ...
I did fly Brenner's new props and they sounded great and pulled just fine. I'll have to take a close look at the data but It looked like I was pulling 77 Amps at full throttle on the ground which should be right around 3000 Watts.
Jim O
#1224
Thread Starter
Hey Jim,
That's great to hear! I'm really glad that you're having good success with your setup.
It looks like the Axiome is another great platform for the Contra. Based on the feedback that I've received so far, pilots have reported good results with the following airframes:
Axiome,
Wind S Pro
Oxai Hera S
Oxai Citron
Valiant
Sensation
Visa
All of these planes have flown well without modifications, and I'm sure that here are others that I can't recall, and the list is still growing. Also, this is not to say that there aren't many other planes that also fly well with modifications. I think that pretty much any plane can be made to fly well with simple mods.
Brenner ...
That's great to hear! I'm really glad that you're having good success with your setup.
It looks like the Axiome is another great platform for the Contra. Based on the feedback that I've received so far, pilots have reported good results with the following airframes:
Axiome,
Wind S Pro
Oxai Hera S
Oxai Citron
Valiant
Sensation
Visa
All of these planes have flown well without modifications, and I'm sure that here are others that I can't recall, and the list is still growing. Also, this is not to say that there aren't many other planes that also fly well with modifications. I think that pretty much any plane can be made to fly well with simple mods.
Brenner ...
#1225
Hey Jim,
That's great to hear! I'm really glad that you're having good success with your setup.
It looks like the Axiome is another great platform for the Contra. Based on the feedback that I've received so far, pilots have reported good results with the following airframes:
Axiome,
Wind S Pro
Oxai Hera S
Oxai Citron
Valiant
Sensation
Visa
All of these planes have flown well without modifications, and I'm sure that here are others that I can't recall, and the list is still growing. Also, this is not to say that there aren't many other planes that also fly well with modifications. I think that pretty much any plane can be made to fly well with simple mods.
Brenner ...
That's great to hear! I'm really glad that you're having good success with your setup.
It looks like the Axiome is another great platform for the Contra. Based on the feedback that I've received so far, pilots have reported good results with the following airframes:
Axiome,
Wind S Pro
Oxai Hera S
Oxai Citron
Valiant
Sensation
Visa
All of these planes have flown well without modifications, and I'm sure that here are others that I can't recall, and the list is still growing. Also, this is not to say that there aren't many other planes that also fly well with modifications. I think that pretty much any plane can be made to fly well with simple mods.
Brenner ...
Jim O