Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
#127
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
ORIGINAL: sortegon
These are my downandlocked converted retracts
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFC9n...e_gdata_player
These are my downandlocked converted retracts
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFC9n...e_gdata_player
#130
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
I like having the air/electric combo, my gear is electric but the brakes, doors, canopy open and canopy lock are all air. Its the lightest way to go electric. I you did say the f-15 which has 8 or more gear doors, a speed brake and then electric canopy with locks and electric brakes the weight of all the electric motors, wiring and battery to run it would be much heavier. For something my f16 which has 3 doors I would deff go all electric if I wasn't worried about weight. Its all in what weight u have to work with and how complex your jet is.
#131
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Grande Prairie,
AB, CANADA
Posts: 630
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
I want to convert my doors on my 1/8th f16 to electric. Did I miss the links on here to be able to do this? The search engine is awful
#133
My Feedback: (9)
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Mission,
TX
Posts: 65
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
Right now having trouble with my f16 1/8 gear doors... Thinking about doing something like in previous post... Just a cord and a piano wire...
#134
My Feedback: (3)
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
ORIGINAL: sortegon
Right now having trouble with my f16 1/8 gear doors... Thinking about doing something like in previous post... Just a cord and a piano wire...
Right now having trouble with my f16 1/8 gear doors... Thinking about doing something like in previous post... Just a cord and a piano wire...
Eagerly waiting for the e-brakes which should soon be available to finally get rid of all air accessories i have around...
I have already converted 2 ESM air retracts for an 89" Spitfire and my FB F-15D retracts to electric and it is all working perfectly!!!
Rgds,
#135
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: vallentuna , SWEDEN
Posts: 133
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
There is a connection between price and quality and it´s difficult to save money and at the same time get somthing to rely on,
believe me,i tried!
Here in Europe Eurokit have started selling electric retracts at about the same price as Electron.
They look OK but I have not seen them live yet..
Buying a airset and rebuild them is not an option for me anyway..Then I end up with paying for the same function twice?
If I had a complicated gear mechanism that is hard to come by,ok,but otherwise its a big NO for me.
I liked the Electrons so much so I bought a set yesterday for the 1:10 Connie that Ivve is building,simplicity to install and
great workmanship from their part made this choise simple..
There is nothing that can ruin a good days flying like crappy undercarriage that is unreliable for me anyway.
//Bokis
believe me,i tried!
Here in Europe Eurokit have started selling electric retracts at about the same price as Electron.
They look OK but I have not seen them live yet..
Buying a airset and rebuild them is not an option for me anyway..Then I end up with paying for the same function twice?
If I had a complicated gear mechanism that is hard to come by,ok,but otherwise its a big NO for me.
I liked the Electrons so much so I bought a set yesterday for the 1:10 Connie that Ivve is building,simplicity to install and
great workmanship from their part made this choise simple..
There is nothing that can ruin a good days flying like crappy undercarriage that is unreliable for me anyway.
//Bokis
#137
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: vallentuna , SWEDEN
Posts: 133
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
Yes but there are those who buy air retracts AND THEN send them off for rebuild or buy an aftermarket electric actuator..
Not so uncommon according to what I se in different forums..[8D]
//Bokis
Not so uncommon according to what I se in different forums..[8D]
//Bokis
#138
My Feedback: (1)
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
ORIGINAL: tp777fo
Electrons all installed in my UF....work like a champ. Now just get it finished and flown.
Electrons all installed in my UF....work like a champ. Now just get it finished and flown.
Is a battery pack included with the Electron retracts?
What battery pack does it use?
Is there a separate on/off switch for the retract battery?
From the pictures on their website I see that the ECU for the retracts has an output for each one of the three retract units, two for brakes (which I assume will be available at a later date), and four other outputs (or inputs) that I cannot read the labels on. What are the other connection ports on the ECU?
Can the ECU also control door actuators?
If so, can it be programmed for different gear/door sequences?
#139
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Rome, ITALY
Posts: 165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
Here you go!
Battery is not included in the set, I use a 2S1P 5000 mah Lipo (I need weight, a 1500 mah is safe for many cycles).
The retract ECU does not have a separate switch but switches off automatically when receiver signal is off, just like most turbine ECUs.
The outputs for the brakes are actually three, just like the retracts.
Three are the inputs too: retract signal, brakes and front steering.
Then there is the output to the front steering servo. This is a clever trick as the servo is disabled directly by the ECU as soon as you hit the retracts.
The round led push button is used for setting the ECU, very simple.
The ECU cannot drive other devices such as gear doors but sequencing is easily achived by using servo slow function as the electric retracts and electric actuators (Lado e-doors in my case) only start moving when 100% channel travel has completed.
I'm completely sold to this system, fantastic!
Mauri
Battery is not included in the set, I use a 2S1P 5000 mah Lipo (I need weight, a 1500 mah is safe for many cycles).
The retract ECU does not have a separate switch but switches off automatically when receiver signal is off, just like most turbine ECUs.
The outputs for the brakes are actually three, just like the retracts.
Three are the inputs too: retract signal, brakes and front steering.
Then there is the output to the front steering servo. This is a clever trick as the servo is disabled directly by the ECU as soon as you hit the retracts.
The round led push button is used for setting the ECU, very simple.
The ECU cannot drive other devices such as gear doors but sequencing is easily achived by using servo slow function as the electric retracts and electric actuators (Lado e-doors in my case) only start moving when 100% channel travel has completed.
I'm completely sold to this system, fantastic!
Mauri
#140
My Feedback: (1)
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
Mauri,
Thanks for the detailed answers. I am in the process of designing a new jet and since I will have to buy a new set of retracts for it anyway I have decided to use the Electron retracts from the start. Thanks for the help in making the decision.
Thanks for the detailed answers. I am in the process of designing a new jet and since I will have to buy a new set of retracts for it anyway I have decided to use the Electron retracts from the start. Thanks for the help in making the decision.
#141
My Feedback: (52)
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Salem,
MA
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
I just received the set that I ordered today. I can NOT get them to work. They just grind. I followed the directions and don't know if I'm missing a step. Do you mind going over the set up sequence. They don't seem to be that difficult I may just have gotten a defective set. i got the ER45. Thanks for your help.
Steve
Steve
#142
Thread Starter
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
Back in 2010 I posed the question "why not electric Retracts for Turbines"? Now we are seeing them everywhere -
What I see now with the advent of FEJ including electric retracts on F-16 gear is that ALL of the major jet kit manuacturers will start to offer these. My cyrstal ball tells me that once the chinese manufacturers get into these they will see the benefits of not having to deal with customer complaints about their cylinders not holding air and that the old problems they have had with air in the past will go away.
Moreover, watch out (USA companies that make them) because these will be std equipment and they will offer them for the same price as air. Better diversify...
What I see now with the advent of FEJ including electric retracts on F-16 gear is that ALL of the major jet kit manuacturers will start to offer these. My cyrstal ball tells me that once the chinese manufacturers get into these they will see the benefits of not having to deal with customer complaints about their cylinders not holding air and that the old problems they have had with air in the past will go away.
Moreover, watch out (USA companies that make them) because these will be std equipment and they will offer them for the same price as air. Better diversify...
#144
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Fort Wayne, IN
Posts: 3,759
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
Now we just need some electric door cylinders that are the same dia as the air type. I bought a set of Lado door cylinders and they are so big in dia as to be unuseable in my 1/8 scale F-16......ARGH I resorted to steel cabls that "almost" work.........They open and close, but don't close all the way.
#145
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Grande Prairie,
AB, CANADA
Posts: 630
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
Yup I had the same issue with them. They work fantastic but are simply too large for a size like 1/8th. I just couldn't make them work.
#147
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Rome, ITALY
Posts: 165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
Finished at last!
[link=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHMcBVyc7l0]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHMcBVyc7l0[/link]
Maiden soon!!!
[link=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHMcBVyc7l0]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHMcBVyc7l0[/link]
Maiden soon!!!
#149
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Rome, ITALY
Posts: 165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric Retracts - Why don't we have them for Turbines?
The 3 main doors are moved by Lado E-Door actuators (30mm stroke).
The outer doors of the mains are linked to the legs.
The small nose door is moved by a servo.
The retracts are Electron Retracts ER-50 units.
The legs and wheels are by Behotec (very heavy and sturdy).
Last weekend during final setup I cycled the gears 75 times on a 2S1P 2500 mah Lipo and I still don't need to charge!
Mauri
The outer doors of the mains are linked to the legs.
The small nose door is moved by a servo.
The retracts are Electron Retracts ER-50 units.
The legs and wheels are by Behotec (very heavy and sturdy).
Last weekend during final setup I cycled the gears 75 times on a 2S1P 2500 mah Lipo and I still don't need to charge!
Mauri