RCU Forums - View Single Post - Official HPI Savage Flux XS thread...
View Single Post
Old 10-30-2011, 09:53 AM
  #1452  
JUSTPASSEDU
My Feedback: (20)
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Island Park, NY
Posts: 235
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Official HPI Savage Flux XS thread...


ORIGINAL: ThunderbirdJunkie


ORIGINAL: Foxy

What got me about the review was if you weigh up the good and the bad, I don't see how they can end up not liking it...

1) Steering servo...yeh, like there is an RTR in existence that has an appropriately specced steering servo...next!

2) Rocks get in hard to reach places...well, yeh, but where a rock can get in, it can also get out...sure it might be annoying, but it hardly makes or breaks an RC.

3) The tires...on the one hand they said that the tires wer bad, on the other they said they were traction rolling...er, which is it? Also, these are all purpose tires, they are not supposed to be outstanding on anything in particular, just hard wearing all surfaces...

4) Speed control...this is the big deal breaker and they played it down...wth?

On the plus side they said...

1) Fast as hell

2) Great fun

3) Cheap

4) Indestructible...

Oh, and they also had a non specific diff problem, which may or may not have been in their imaginations. Clearly traxxas anboys, so take the review for what it is with that in mind...

Jang at URC basically said similar things, that he had a bunch of non-specific problems with it, but it was fast and fun...so er, the only thing we're seeing for certain is that...

1) it is is normal RTR with everything that includes, such as a substandard servo and a dodgy ESC

2) It is very strong

3) It is competitively priced

4) It is very fast

Hm...[&:]
ThunderbirdJunkie suspects that the only reason anybody doesn't like the XS is because they have a first-run model.

Two guys at the LHS were pondering what to get, ThunderbirdJunkie recommended the XS, and he also said ''Dunno how it's gonna hold up on 3S, so don't go 3S. It's just stupid on 2S, there's no need for it anyway.''

They both bought XS's and loved them. Come to find out they both ran 3S and smoked their ESC's.

Is the truck even drivable on 3S?

Anyway, apparently one of the trucks' rear diffs wasn't shimmed properly from the get-go, and it'd barely move under its own power. BTW, R&P are the same as the Bullet's.

Other guy had no issues...until he ran 3S.

Supposedly neither ESC smells fried, it just doesn't power up when you plug it in...which suggests to ThunderbirdJunkie that it has a weak BEC.

So he totally believes that it's an MMP now[&:]

Redfisher...the big Savage Flux is an awesome truck. ThunderbirdJunkie has driven several, and he needs to get off his duff and finish his electric 1/8 Savage (just need batteries...$250 for Orion 3S packs is the big hurdle[&:])

I had a 1st run model and I still like the xs but there are just a few things I don't like about it aswell. Of course the obvious is the esc , even if hpi/castle fixes them , they should still be able to run 3s reliably if it is advertised when trying to sell the truck to consumers. The truck is a bit of a pain to work on compared to other cars and trucks out there but once you take it apart a few times youll be a pro which will most likely have to happen if yourun this truck allot. The parts on this truck are made pretty cheaply in my opinion. Drivetrain parts should not wear after only a few runs , with hop ups this can be fixed but again with a Rtr truck advertised being able to use 3s they should of made the truck tough enough to handle it. I am not talking about crashing and breaking parts bc for it's size it's tough but the wear of parts is not good at all. I like the design and it's a fun truck when it runs well , no doubt about that but it def needed some more time in research & development department before being released.