ORIGINAL: otrcman
ORIGINAL: Instructor
May I ask you how the pilot is controling the Fin/Rudder? If I'm not mistaken, doesn't the DR-1 have cable
controls for the Fin/Rudder and the Elevator? If so, then the pilot uses the Fin/Rudder to sideslip the DR-1 by
moving the rudder pedals or tiller bar in the cockpit the same
way he controls the pitch with the control stick hooked to the elevator by cables.....
Larry
Yes, the rudder of the DRI is cable controlled. But remember, there is no fin. Just a rudder. The plane will sideslip one way or the other all by itself and has no natural tendency to come back to center. It requires active pilot input to keep the plane anywhere near straight. That's a difficult concept to wrap your mind around if all you have flown is modern airplanes (say, 1920 or later) with actual stability.
The advent of a fixed fin on full scale airplanes was a total game changer for the pilot. Once there is a fixed fin (of sufficient size) the airplane will fly with little or no sideslip all by itself. Before fixed fins came along, maintaining zero sideslip was the pilot's job. Normally, the way the pilot sensed sideslip was to feel whether the wind was equal on both sides of his face.
In pitch, there is a big difference between an elevator that can ''float'' versus an irreversible elevator. That's why we see reference to stick-fixed versus stick-free stability in aerodynamic testing. Stick-fixed is more stable in almost all cases, because you are essentially making the fixed surface larger by locking the elevator.
In a typical light airplane, the pilot isn't maintaining the control surfaces rigidly in place at all. The surfaces are pretty much floating in the slipstream and the pilot is just applying pressure one way or the other when he exerts control. Not the same as an R/C plane where the servo keeps the surface from floating in the slipstream.
An easy way to think of the concept is this: A fixed tail surface (fin, stabilizer) is where the stability comes from. A movable tail surface (rudder, elevator) is where control comes from.
Dick
You make it sound like it took a long time for fixed area fins to be introduced. I say that it did not. The early Fokkers were really the only designs this way. All or most of the allied designs had fixed vertical area. The Fokker DVII had fixed area as well, although at the insistence of Richtofen.
No doubt fixed surface area is a good thing, but it is a bad thing when we got to supersonic flight. The stabilator solved the compressabilty issue with the jets.
Also, if you have ever had a triplane, then you would know how much fun that full flying rudder is! Many have just not gotten comfortable enough with theirs to really play with it.