You don't have this on your list, and it is a bit smaller than the planes you do have listed, but the Flyzone Tidewater is an excellent flyer and lands like it is on rails on water. I don't speak from years of experience like others here, but the Tidewater made me a fan of seaplanes.I also have the Flyzone Beaver but have only flown it from grass using the wheels, however, it is a very good flyer also. The floats are on it now, after my experience with the Tidewater, I am looking forward to trying the Beaver off of water. Jim