RCU Forums - View Single Post - Comp ARF BAE Hawk build thread
View Single Post
Old 10-21-2013 | 01:57 PM
  #1516  
Dave Wilshere
 
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 13,265
Received 792 Likes on 575 Posts
From: Watford, UNITED KINGDOM
Default

Originally Posted by Dieselman1220
Finally got my Navy scheme hawk in so now i can take part in the thread instead of just creeping around in it. Great service from Andy Kane before and after the sale.
A few questions now.
In the manual it states servos with a minimum of 11KG required? Thats about 388 ounces. Seems awfully excessive not so much for the stabs and rudder, but for the ailerons? However it also states that an 8411 or 8711 may be used???
Theres a big difference in strength between the 8411 advertised at 155oz and the 8711 at over 400oz?
I have some 8411s that i was planning on using for the ailerons as well as some futaba 9156s and savox 1258TG and 1256TGs..(I trust all of these equally, and they are all nearly identical in size) The only ones I was planning on having to purchase were some
8711s or 9157s for the elevators.
So why the large discrepancy in the servo torque requirement? just seems odd for as small as the ailerons are and as little movement thats required of them. Dont get me wrong though Im all about "over building" the airplane. Better to not need it and have than need it and not have it..
The 11kg servos are JR 8411! I spec'd JR 8411 and 8511/8611/8711 servos as CARF's favourite servos (mine too)

The twin servos for the stab were for holding power and backlash resistance, I was asked if one 8711/8911 would be enough and I said torque wise, but not gear train/flutter resistance enough.
So two servos of 11KG+ are OK, but many many models and the thread starter still flying with two 8711's tells me its the best set-up

Dave Wilshere
PS Welcome to the thread!