We used to have a moderator here that paid $100 for his at NAPA. I got my 3 jaw one at Harbor Freight and you got an every better deal on a much better puller. A sloppy 3 jaw one like mine will do the job but not as well.
Once you've used the caged type, it's hard to go back. Like I said, it's like a 3rd hand when setting up. Back the center screw all the way back & use the cage screw to get the jaws snug on what you want to pull. The puller will then be much easier to keep in place as you screw the center screw down.
I knew I was getting a "steal" as it was only a few $ more than an open type. That's one of the reasons Sears is going under. They aren't the Sears I grew up with. I used to buy my shotgun shells & hunting gear @ Sears in the south suburbs of Chicago back in the '60s. That area was a small game hunter's paradise. Cottontails, Ringneck Pheasants, doves & LOTS of waterfowl. My 1st shotgun was a Sears (High Standard) 16ga pump.